Violence against prostitutes

Violence against prostitutes include violent and harmful acts, both physical or psychological, against individuals engaging in prostitution. It occurs worldwide, with the victims of such acts of violence being predominantly women. In extreme cases, violent acts have led to their murder while in their workplace.

Prevalence

Women working in prostitution experience higher levels of violence against them than the general population of women.^[1] A long-term study published in 2004 estimated the homicide rate for active female prostitutes who had worked in Colorado Springs from 1967 through 1999 to be 204 per 100,000 person-years.^[2] The overwhelming majority of the 1,969 women in the study were street prostitutes. Only 126 worked in massage parlors, and most of these women were also prostituted on the streets.^[2]

Although the Colorado Springs prostitutes appeared to be representative of all US prostitutes in terms of prevalence and number of sexual partners, and while they worked as prostitutes (and died) in many parts of the country, prostitutes elsewhere might have different mortality rates and profiles.^[2] This homicide figure is considerably higher than that for the next riskiest occupations in the United States during the 1980s (4 per 100,000 for female liquor store workers and 29 per 100,000 for male taxicab drivers).^[3] The prevalence of violence against prostitutes varies by location. A study of prostituted women and girls in Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada over the age of 14 who used illicit drugs other than marijuana found that 57% of prostitutes experienced some form of sex-based violence over an 18-month period.^[4] A study of 1,000 female (both cisgender and transgender) prostitutes in Phnom Penh, Cambodia, found 93% of women surveyed had been the victim of rape in the past year.^[5]

Types of violence

Physical

Physical violence is defined by World Health Organization as "the intentional use of physical force or power, threatened or actual, against oneself, another person, or against a group or community, which either results in or has a high likelihood of resulting in injury, death, psychological harm, maldevelopment, or deprivation".^[6] Physical violence is more commonly experienced by outdoor prostitutes with 47% of prostitutes working outdoors reporting being kicked, punched, or slapped in one study.^[7] In a study of prostitutes working in San Francisco, 82% of participants reported having experienced some type of physical violence since entering prostitution, with 55% of these assaults being committed by a client.^[8] A different study found a slightly lower rate with 74% of sex-workers reported experiencing some form of physical abuse in their lifetime.^[9] The general consensus among most studies regarding violence against prostitutes is that rates of physical violence against prostitutes is extremely high, particularly among women who experience higher rates of physical violence than their male counterparts.^[8]

Psychological

Psychological abuse, also referred to as mental abuse or emotional abuse is characterized by a person subjecting or exposing another to behavior that may result in psychological trauma, including anxiety, chronic depression, or post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).^[10][11][12] The United Nations Population Fund says that this type of violence "includes, but is not limited to, being insulted (e.g. called derogatory names) or made to feel bad about oneself; being humiliated or belittled in front of other people; being threatened with loss of custody of one's children; being confined or isolated from family or friends; being threatened with harm to oneself or someone one cares about; repeated shouting, inducing fear through intimidating words or gestures; controlling behavior; and the destruction of possessions."^[13]

There are certain types of psychological or emotional abuse that sex workers are more prone to such as denial of basic needs, forced drug or alcohol consumption, and being arrested for carrying condoms to name a few.^[13] Women working in prostitution are especially vulnerable to psychological abuse, particularly verbal abuse, because many customers and other members of society view them as "whores" or as generally undesirable women. Often verbal abuse will occur either while the service is being given, or after it has been given and the customer is not satisfied. In both these cases, verbal abuse can be a precursor to sexual violence from the client.^[1] In one study, 78% of sex-workers reported having experienced emotional or psychological abuse in their lifetime.^[9]

Sexual

Sexual violence is any sexual act or attempt to obtain a sexual act by violence or coercion, unwanted sexual comments or advances, acts to traffic a person or acts directed against a person's sexuality, regardless of the relationship to the victim.^[14][15][16] The risks of sexual abuse are overall lower than the risks of physical abuse, with the exception of indoor prostitutes who report a higher rate of rape or attempted rape than any one type of physical violence.^[7] In one study, 44% of sex-workers reported having experienced sexual abuse in their lifetime.^[7] Rates of sexual assault and rape are higher among women (including transgender women) than among men, though the overall rate is high with one study finding that 68% of respondents had been raped since entering prostitution.^[8] These high levels of sexual violence suffered by sex workers have very traumatic effects on the men and women working as prostitutes. High levels of rape and other forms of sexual violence while working as a prostitute have been linked to higher levels of PTSD.^[8]

Contributing factors

Studies have shown that younger prostitutes tend to experience more client violence than their older colleagues.^[7] Furthermore, cisgender and transgender female sex workers are also more likely to experience violence committed by a client than their male prostitute counterparts.^[1]

Social stigmas: transgender sex workers

As represented through a study on transgender sex workers, trans women, especially those of color, tend to endure higher rates of violence than that of cisgender women due to discriminations and intersectional factors.^[17] There are a variety of contributing factors, including the social stigmas surrounding transgender women that push them into sex work as a means of survival; this includes high unemployment rates typically due to legalized discriminations, a lack of education or career opportunities, and mental health issues resulting from transphobic experiences from adolescence through adulthood.^[18]  It is shown in one study that transgender women chose to remain in sex work despite the risks of violence and HIV contraction as a means to gain the social and economic support that society typically fails to provide.^[17][19] This is specifically seen with black transgender women who are paid less for sex work, and are therefore pushed to see more clients, increasing their chances of exposure to violence.^[19]

Although transgender sex workers are able to attain their own sense of community, they are still faced with discrimination which often represents itself in violence on the streets. On top of the typical risk of rape and robbery that prostitutes face by their clients, transgender prostitutes face the additional burden of transphobic acts of violence and harassment. One study includes 48 transgender women of color from San Francisco who share their experiences with violence during sex work—one participant recalls: "The police see you on the sidewalk, they will snatch your hair off your head, if you have on a wig and they will call you 'boy', loud, so everybody can hear over the speaker phone" [p. 774].^[17]  Another participant describes being forced into performing oral sex on an officer in order to escape the threat of arrest.^[17] This transphobic violence is also perpetuated by clients, as shown through another participant who describes the death of her friend, who was killed and dismembered by a client who originally believed she was a cisgender woman.^[17]

Legal vs. illegal sex work

Laws prohibiting prostitution can make it difficult for the men and women engaging in prostitution to report any violence they may experience while on the "job".^[20] Often transactions or arrangements to meet up with clients must be made in secret in places where prostitution is illegal.^[21] The decriminalization of sex work in New Zealand has shown that violence is reduced when sex workers are not forced to work alone, or in isolated places. Sex work was always legal in New Zealand but decriminalization removed laws that increased danger.^[22]

 

"The Paris" brothel in Chicago c. 1911

Indoor vs. outdoor working environment

There are substantial differences in rates of victimization between street prostitutes and indoor sex workers who work as call girls, or in brothels and massage parlors.^[23][24] Women who work legally in licensed brothels are much less likely to be victimized, as are indoor workers in countries where sex work is legal.^[25] A 1999 study of 240 prostitutes found that half of sex-workers working outside faced some type of violence in the past six months, compared to a quarter of those working indoors.^[7]

Experiences of client violence by prostitutes working indoors or outdoors. Values are numbers (percentages) of prostitutes unless stated otherwise^[7]

Experiences with Violence	Outdoors (n=115)	Indoors (n=125)
Ever experienced client violence	93 (81)	60 (48)
Experienced violence in past six months	58 (50)	32 (26)
Types of Violence Ever Experienced:
Slapped, kicked, punched	54 (47)	17 (14)
Threatened with physical violence	45 (39)	18 (14)
Robbery	42 (37)	12 (10)
Attempted robbery	30 (26)	6 (5)
Beaten	31 (27)	1 (1)
Threatened with a weapon	28 (24)	8 (6)
Held against will	29 (25)	19 (15)
Attempted rape (vaginal or anal)	32 (28)	21 (17)
Strangulation	23 (20)	7 (6)
Kidnapped	23 (20)	3 (2)
Forced to give a client oral sex	20 (17)	4 (3)
Raped (vaginal)	25 (22)	2 (2)
Attempted kidnap	14 (12)	1 (1)
Slashed or stabbed	8 (7)	----
Raped (anal)	6 (5)	8 (6)
Reported at least one incident of client violence to police	41/93 (44)	11/60 (18)

Perpetrators

Violent clients, pimps and police officers

Perpetrators may include violent clients and pimps. Clients often attempt to maintain a power balance that favors them over the prostitutes. This is often done through different methods of violence such as sexual, emotional, and physical.^[21] Though pimps may be perpetrators of violence against sex workers with 53% of sex workers in one study reporting that violence at the hands of pimps is a major problem, 33% of subjects interviewed in that same study reported that the main benefit to having a pimp is the protection from potential assault.^[26]

Because of the illegality of sex work in many parts of the world, sex workers often have to service clients in discreet and isolated spaces where they are less likely to get caught by the police. Because of this isolation, sex workers are made more vulnerable to attacks by their clients. According to a study conducted on one hundred and thirty people working in San Francisco as street sex workers, 82% had been physically assaulted, 83% had been threatened with a weapon and 68% had been raped while working as prostitutes.^[27]

In countries such as the United States sex work is illegal, and so sex workers are not able to report violence done against them in fear of being arrested themselves. In certain states anti-prostitution mandates carry a minimum sentence and can increase to felony charge after multiple arrests, which leads to difficulty finding housing and employment, and disqualification for welfare benefits.^[28] Additionally sex workers may be registered as sex offenders, or face deportation if they have precarious migratory or citizenship status.^[29]

Because of the stigma that exists around sex work, police are less likely to investigate attacks on sex workers.^[30] As one sex worker in South Africa reports, "to gather evidence of a crime against a sex worker, they have to first take it seriously"; “If we go to the police to report abuse, we’re made fun of, we’re told ‘you deserve it.’ They chase you away,” notes another sex worker.^[31]

Police officers themselves are common perpetrators of violence against prostitutes. A study of sex-workers in Phnom Penh, Cambodia found that half of the women had been beaten by police and about a third had been gang-raped by police.^[5] "In South Africa, where sex work has been illegal since the former apartheid regime criminalized it in 1957, police officers often fine sex workers inordinate sums of money and pocket the cash, resulting in a pattern of economic extortion of sex workers by state agents."^[32]

Serial killers

 

Jack the Ripper's victims (The Illustrated Police News, 1888)

Sex workers (particularly those engaging in street prostitution) are also sometimes targeted by serial killers, who may consider them easy targets and less likely to be missed, or who use the religious and social stigma associated with sex workers as justification for their murder.

The unidentified serial killer known as Jack the Ripper killed at least five sex workers in London in 1888. Due to the frequent murders of prostitutes at that time and place, however, it is difficult to be certain of the number killed by Jack the Ripper. These particular murders are distinguished from other murders of sex workers during the same time period due to the post-mortem mutilations that occurred, and it is for that reason that other murders of prostitutes are not usually attributed to the Ripper, or are disputed.

Peter Sutcliffe (aka the Yorkshire Ripper) murdered 13 women, some of whom were sex workers, from 1975 to 1980 in Northern England.

Gary Ridgway (aka the Green River Killer) confessed to killing 48 sex workers from 1982 to 1998, making him one of the most prolific serial killers in U.S. history.^[33]

Robert Hansen murdered between 15 and 21 sex workers, near Anchorage, Alaska, between 1980 and 1983.

Joel Rifkin confessed to killing 17 sex workers in the New York area between 1989 and 1993, without there having been a missing persons report filed on any of the women during that time.

Robert Pickton, a Canadian who lived near Vancouver, made headlines after the remains of numerous missing sex workers were found on his family farm. He has now been convicted of the murders of six women who went missing from Vancouver's Downtown Eastside, and is suspected by police of killing at least twenty more (though no charges have been filed in relation to their deaths). In December 2007 he was sentenced to life in prison, with no possibility of parole for 25 years.

In December 2006, Steve Wright murdered five sex workers in Ipswich, England (see Ipswich serial murders).

Believed to have begun in 1996, the Long Island Serial Killer killed between 10 and 16 women in the sex work profession. The killings seemed to have stopped in 2011, and a suspect was apprehended in 2023.

Efforts to combat violence

Most efforts to advocate for prostitutes have focused on prevention of the spread of AIDS/HIV+ among the general population rather than focusing on how certain policies would benefit the prostitutes themselves.^[21] This focus has neglected many of the issues of violence facing sex workers. Recently, however, there has been an effort to eradicate violence against prostitutes from a wider perspective. The United Nations Population Fund (UNPF), in conjunction with several other organizations, recommends community empowerment, led by sex workers, as a way to combat violence against sex-workers.^[34] UNPF also advocates for changing perceptions to view sex work as work, rather than an illegal activity. One issue facing efforts to prevent violence against prostitutes is that there is a low level of reporting violence among prostitutes. A study of female sex-workers in India found that 54% of female sex-workers do not report violence committed against them, and only 36% shared their experience with NGOs or a peer or family member.^[35]

By sex workers

Because of the increased risk of violence associated with working in sex work, many prostitutes have begun adopting their own personal policies to reduce the likelihood of becoming the victims of violence. A study by Maureen A. Norton-Hawk found that "40% of sex workers have a policy of refusing to provide services in an alley, 54% refuse to provide services in a drug house, and 68% refuse to provide services in an abandoned building."^[26] Often, sex workers must rely on themselves or each other for support in ending violence as many campaigns to end violence against women ignore the needs of sex workers.^[36]

Government policy

 

Sex Workers' Rights demonstration at London SlutWalk 2011

UN Women supports the decriminalization of sex work in order to protect sex-workers from violence and abuse and encourages the criminalization of forms of violence, coercion and exploitation in sex work.^[13] Currently, however, the United States of America requires that all countries it gives aid to for AIDS/HIV+ prevention and relief agree to an "anti-prostitution pledge" that dictates that the country receiving aid must adopt policy that treats sex work and prostitution the same as sex trafficking. This policy has resulted in inadequate attention being paid to the health needs of prostitutes and limits the ability of the government to address the specific needs that sex workers have.^[37] Furthermore, in the United States, many states have mandatory minimum sentencing laws that require judges to give anyone convicted of prostitution a mandatory minimum prison sentence. This can, in turn, make it less likely that prostitutes take legal action against the perpetrators of violence against them because doing so could be risking jail time.^[37]

One possible policy option that the Netherlands has done would be to designate specific places for sex workers and clients to meet up and arrange and engage in sexual activities.^[21] This would provide a safe and secure place for sexual services to be sold without having to remain in private which can be a risk factor for violence against prostitutes. Some organizations have even suggested forming support groups composed of sex workers in the area as a way to give sex workers the support they often lack.^[6]

See also

•  Prostitution portal

• International Day to End Violence Against Sex Workers
• Sex workers' rights
• Sex Workers' Rights Movement
• Violence against women

References

Notes

1. Martínez, Pilar Rodríguez (September 2015). "Un análisis interseccional sobre malos tratos y violencia laboral en mujeres que ejercen la prostitución" [An Intersectional Analysis of Intimate Partner Violence and Workplace Violence among Women Working in Prostitution] (PDF). Revista Española de Investigaciones Sociológicas (in Spanish). 151 (151): 123–140. doi:10.5477/cis/reis.151.123.
2. Potterat et al. 2004.
3. Castillo & Jenkins 1994.
4. Shannon, K.; Kerr, T; Strathdee, S A; Shoveller, J; Montaner, J S; Tyndall, M W (11 August 2009). "Prevalence and structural correlates of sex-based violence among a prospective cohort of prostituted women". BMJ. 339 (aug11 3): b2939. doi:10.1136/bmj.b2939. PMC 2725271. PMID 19671935.
5. "Addressing the links between sex-based violence and HIV in the Great Lakes region" (PDF). UNESCO. United Nations Educational, Scientific, and Cultural Organization. Retrieved October 29, 2015.
6. "WHO | World report on violence and health". www.who.int. Retrieved 2015-10-19.
7. Church, Stephanie; Henderson, Marion; Barnard, Marina; Hart, Graham (3 March 2001). "Violence by clients towards female prostitutes in different work settings: questionnaire survey". BMJ. 322 (7285): 524–525. doi:10.1136/bmj.322.7285.524. PMC 26557. PMID 11230067.
8. Farley, Melissa; Barkan, Howard (1998). "Prostitution, Violence, and Posttraumatic Stress Disorder". Women & Health. 27 (3): 37–49. doi:10.1300/j013v27n03_03. PMID 9698636.
9. Ulibarri, Monica D.; Semple, Shirley J.; Rao, Swati; Strathdee, Steffanie A.; Fraga-Vallejo, Miguel A.; Bucardo, Jesus; De la Torre, Adela; Salázar-Reyna, Juan; Orozovich, Prisci; Staines-Orozco, Hugo S.; Amaro, Hortensia; Magis-Rodríguez, Carlos; Patterson, Thomas L. (June 2009). "History of Abuse and Psychological Distress Symptoms Among Female Sex Workers in Two Mexico–U.S. Border Cities". Violence and Victims. 24 (3): 399–413. doi:10.1891/0886-6708.24.3.399. PMC 2777761. PMID 19634364.
10. Dutton, D. G. (1994). "Patriarchy and wife assault: The ecological fallacy". Violence and Victims. 9 (2): 125–140. doi:10.1891/0886-6708.9.2.167. PMID 7696196. S2CID 35155731.
11. O'Leary, K. Daniel; Maiuro, Roland D. (2004-01-01). Psychological Abuse in Violent Domestic Relations. Springer Publishing Company. ISBN 9780826111463.
12. Thompson, Anne E.; Kaplan, Carole A. (February 1996). "Childhood Emotional Abuse". British Journal of Psychiatry. 168 (2): 143–148. doi:10.1192/bjp.168.2.143. PMID 8837902. S2CID 8520532.
13. Addressing violence against sex workers. WHO.
14. World Health Organization., World report on violence and health (Geneva: World Health Organization, 2002), Chapter 6, pp. 149.
15. Elements of Crimes, Article 7(1)(g)-6 Crimes against humanity of sexual violence, elements 1. Accessed through [1] 2015-05-06 at the Wayback Machine
16. McDougall, Gay J. (1998). Contemporary forms of slavery: systematic rape, sexual slavery and slavery-like practices during armed conflict. Final report submitted by Ms. Jay J. McDougall, Special Rapporteur,
17. Sausa, Lydia A.; Keatley, JoAnne; Operario, Don (December 2007). "Perceived Risks and Benefits of Sex Work among Transgender Women of Color in San Francisco". Archives of Sexual Behavior. 36 (6): 768–777. doi:10.1007/s10508-007-9210-3. PMID 17674180. S2CID 40413106.
18. Nemoto, Tooru; Bödeker, Birte; Iwamoto, Mariko (October 2011). "Social Support, Exposure to Violence and Transphobia, and Correlates of Depression Among Male-to-Female Transgender Women With a History of Sex Work". American Journal of Public Health. 101 (10): 1980–1988. doi:10.2105/AJPH.2010.197285. PMC 3222349. PMID 21493940.
19. Moorman, Jessica D.; Harrison, Kristen (September 2016). "Gender, Race, and Risk: Intersectional Risk Management in the Sale of Sex Online". The Journal of Sex Research. 53 (7): 816–824. doi:10.1080/00224499.2015.1065950. PMID 26488687. S2CID 24242105.
20. Almodovar, Norma Jean (January 1, 1999). "For Their Own Good: The Results of the Prostitution Laws as Enforced by Cops, Politician and Judges". Hastings Women's Law Journal. Retrieved 23 November 2015.
21. Barnard, Marina A. (November 1993). "Violence and vulnerability: conditions of work for streetworking prostitutes". Sociology of Health and Illness. 15 (5): 683–705. doi:10.1111/1467-9566.ep11434434.
22. "New Zealand Parliament - Prostitution Law Reform in New Zealand". Parliament.nz. Retrieved 2015-07-03.
23. Weitzer 2000^{[verification needed]}
24. Weitzer 2005.
25. Sexuality Now: Embracing Diversity: Embracing Diversity - Page 527, Janell L. Carroll - 2009
26. Norton-Hawk, Maureen (February 2004). "A Comparison of Pimp- and Non-Pimp-Controlled Women". Violence Against Women. 10 (2): 189–194. doi:10.1177/1077801203260949. S2CID 73382846.
27. . Prostitutionresearch.com. Archived from the original on 2012-09-18. Retrieved 2012-08-15.
28. Grant, Melissa (21 January 2013). "The War on Sex Workers". Reason.com.
29. Wahab, Stéphanie; Panichelli, Meg (2013). "Ethical and Human Rights Issues in Coercive Interventions With Sex Workers". Journal of Women and Social Work. 28 (4): 344–49. doi:10.1177/0886109913505043.
30. Wong, Holroyd & Bingham 2011.
31. Mgbako, Chi (December 15, 2011). "Police Abuse of Sex Workers: A Global Reality, Widely Ignored". Rewire. Retrieved May 4, 2016.
32. Mgbako, Chi (15 December 2011). "Police Abuse of Sex Workers: A Global Reality, Widely Ignored". Rewire News Group.
33. "Green River Killer avoids death in plea deal - November 6, 2003". CNN.com. Retrieved 2015-07-03.
34. "Implementing comprehensive HIV/STI programmes with sex workers: Practical approaches from collaborative interventions". UNFPA - United Nations Population Fund. Retrieved 2015-10-19.
35. Mahapatra, Bidhubhusan; Battala, Madhusudana; Porwal, Akash; Saggurti, Niranjan (2014-05-20). "Non-Disclosure of Violence among Female Sex Workers: Evidence from a Large Scale Cross-Sectional Survey in India". PLOS ONE. 9 (5): e98321. Bibcode:2014PLoSO...998321M. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0098321. PMC 4028275. PMID 24846145.
36. Jacobs, Michelle S (1999). "Prostitutes, Drug Users, and Thieves: The Invisible Women in the Campaign to End Violence Against Women". Temple Political & Civil Rights Law Review. 8: 459–475.
37. Lerum, Kari."Reducing Violence against Sex Workers: What are the policy options?." Human Rights for All (2011). Accessed September 22, 2015.

Sources

• Potterat, John J.; Brewer, Devon D.; Muth, Stephen Q.; Rothenberg, Richard B.; Woodhouse, Donald E.; Muth, John B.; Stites, Heather K.; Brody, Stuart (2004). "Mortality in a Long-term Open Cohort of Prostitute Women". American Journal of Epidemiology. 159 (8): 778–85. doi:10.1093/aje/kwh110. PMID 15051587.
• Weitzer, Ronald (2005). "New directions in research on prostitution". Crime, Law and Social Change. 43 (4–5): 211–35. CiteSeerX 10.1.1.545.4191. doi:10.1007/s10611-005-1735-6. S2CID 145443565.
• Weitzer, Ronald (2006). "Moral crusade against prostitution". Society. 43 (3): 33–8. doi:10.1007/BF02687593. S2CID 144600803.
• Castillo, Dawn N.; Jenkins, E Lynn (1994). "Industries and Occupations at High Risk for Work-Related Homicide". Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine. 36 (2): 125–32. doi:10.1097/00043764-199402000-00006. PMID 8176509.
• Wong, William C.W.; Holroyd, Eleanor; Bingham, Amie (2011). "Stigma and sex work from the perspective of female sex workers in Hong Kong". Sociology of Health & Illness. 33 (1): 50–63. doi:10.1111/j.1467-9566.2010.01276.x. PMID 21226729.