User interface management system

A User Interface Management System (UIMS) is a mechanism for cleanly separating process or business logic from Graphical user interface (GUI) code in a computer program.^[1] UIMS are designed to support N-tier architectures by strictly defining and enforcing the boundary between the business logic and the GUI. A fairly rigid Software architecture is nearly always implied by the UIMS, and most often only one paradigm of separation is supported in a single UIMS. A UIMS may also have libraries and systems such as graphical tools for the creation of user interface resources or data stores.

Generally, you cannot easily use multiple UIMS systems at the same time, so choosing the correct model for your UIMS is a critical design decision in any project. The choice of system is dependent upon the system(s) you wish to create user interfaces for, and the general style of your application. For example, if you want to create a web based front end, or just a standalone application or both that would be an important factor in choosing. If you want to deploy to the Macintosh, Windows and Linux, that would further influence your choice of a UIMS system.

There are many UIMS approaches described in research papers. However, there are not very many systems available commercially or through open source.

Models

In a frequently cited body of work, Foley and Wallace describe a "linguistic model" for user interface management consisting of a Presentation Layer, a Dialog Control layer and an Application layer. These layers correspond to the lexical, syntactic and semantic layers from formal language theory. While Foley's model is theoretically enlightening, it does not propose a specific practical system for separating code. There are also many interesting border cases that don't fall cleanly into one of these layers.

A more directly applicable theory of user interface management is the model–view–controller design pattern, which is described in detail in its own article. A recent variant of MVC is the model–view–presenter model which is similar to MVC, but has some interesting insights into the problem.

Implementations

A functional based system approaches all user interface actions as interfaces for functions. Dialogs exist solely to collect parameters for functions that are called when the dialog is closing. Menu Trees are one family of model implementations that follow this pattern.

Grammar based UIMS provide a specialized language for describing the user interface. Usually, this is a special language designed specifically for the presentation of user interface elements.

The Editing Model is a specialization of grammar based UIMS. They present all interaction as direct presentations of underlying presentation objects. Essentially, using the grammar of the programming language as the grammar for the GUI. A scroll bar may present an integer, a check box may present a boolean, a function is presented as a button or menu item. A dialog box or a menu is a presentation of a complex object containing properties and functions. A controller layer automatically synchronizes the object with the presentation and vice versa through a two way connection provided by an Observer pattern. Enable/disable and validation present special challenges under the editing model, but they can be dealt with. A commercial program, ViewSoft Internet, was briefly available in the 1990s that implemented a general purpose GUI builder based upon the Editing Model.

Transition Networks present the user interface logic as a kind of intelligent flowchart. In an Event Language model, the computer language is designed around the handling of events. This is essentially the approach taken in Microsoft's .Net languages C# and Visual Basic.Net with their delegate and event language structures.

Other models include Hypertalk, Production Systems and Declarative Languages.

Examples of UIMS and models

• Tiger
• MenuLay
• HyperCard
• ViewSoft Internet
• Sassafras
• ALGEA
• Squeak
• Model–view–controller (MVC)
• Model–view–presenter (MVP)
• Linguistic model
• Seeheim model
• Higgins UIMS
• Arch model
• Picasso-3
• ProcSee
• Common Lisp Interface Manager

Top researchers

Important research in this field has been done by Brad Myers, Dan Olsen, Scott Hudson and James D. Foley.

References

1. Olsen, Dan (1991). User Interface Management Systems: Models and Algorithms. Morgan Kaufmann Publishers. ISBN 1-55860-220-8.

External links

• Model View Presenter
• A UIMS Course Outline
• ProcSee UIMS
• User Interface Management Systems: Models and Algorithms