Tail-sitter

For rocket powered vertical landing vehicles, see VTVL.

A tail-sitter, or tailsitter, is a type of VTOL aircraft that takes off and lands on its tail, then tilts horizontally for forward flight.

The Convair Pogo was one tailsitter design.

Originating in the 1920s with the inventor Nikola Tesla, the first aircraft to adopt a tail-sitter configuration were developed by Nazi Germany during the Second World War. Development of such aircraft spiked during the late 1940s and 1950s, as aircraft designers and defence planners alike recognised the potential value of fixed-wing aircraft that could perform both a vertical take-off and vertical landing while also transitioning into and out of conventional flight. Inherent problems with tail-sitter aircraft were poor pilot visibility and control difficulties, especially during vertical descent and landing. Programmes to develop manned tail-sitters were typically terminated in the form of the more practical thrust vectoring approach, as used by aircraft such as the Hawker Siddeley Harrier and Yakovlev Yak-38.

Description

A tail-sitter sits vertically on its tail for takeoff and landing, then tilts the whole aircraft forward for horizontal flight. This is very different from the many other kinds of VTOL technologies, which have horizontally-oriented fuselages.

Tail-sitters change fuselage orientation after take-off. They start off with the back of the aircraft to the ground (...a vertical orientation), and then reorient to a horizontal orientation in flight.

Some tail-sitters then landed conventionally in horizontally-oriented configuration, while others had a much more ambitious goal of landing vertically with the aircraft's back to the ground, a highly hazardous procedure for many reasons, prime of which was increased fuel consumption and limited pilot visibility.

History

Early work

The concept of a tail-sitting aircraft can be attributed to originate with the inventor Nikola Tesla, who filed for an associated patent during 1928.^[1] However, no immediate attempt to implement this concept into a functional aircraft would emerge for almost two decades.

During the Second World War, Nazi Germany worked on the Focke-Wulf Triebflügel (wing-driven) fighter that incorporated the tail-sitter concept into its design. It featured three wings that were mounted radially as a rotor on a rotating section of the fuselage, these were driven by small jet engines positioned on the wingtips to propel the aircraft via this wing rotation. For takeoff and landing, it would fly vertically (akin to a helicopter) before tilting over horizontally to fly as a self-propelled wing generating both lift and thrust. The contemporary Heinkel Lerche project had an annular wing forming a duct around a conventional propeller, and in the transition from vertical to forward flight the lift would have transferred to the wing.^[2][3]

Cold War era

During the 1950s, aircraft designers around the world engaged in programmes to develop fixed-wing aircraft that could not only perform both a vertical take-off and vertical landing, but transition into and out of conventional flight as well. As observed by the aviation author Francis K. Mason, a combat aircraft that possessed such qualities would have effectively eliminate the traditional reliance on relatively vulnerable runways by taking off and landing vertically as opposed to the conventional horizontal approach.^[4] Accordingly, the development of viable vertical take-off and landing (VTOL) aircraft was particularly attractive to military planners of the early postwar era.^[5] As the thrust-to-weight ratio of turbojet engines increased sufficiently for a single engine be able to lift an aircraft, designers began to investigate ways of maintaining stability while an aircraft was flying in the VTOL stage of flight.^[6]

One company that opted to engage in VTOL research was the French engine manufacturer SNECMA who, beginning in 1956, built a series of wingless test rigs called the Atar Volant. Only the first of these was unpiloted and the second flew freely, both stabilized by gas jets on outrigger pipes The third had a tilting seat to allow the pilot to sit upright when the fuselage was level and had the lateral air intakes planned for the free flying aircraft, though it always operated attached to a movable cradle. The pilot for these experiments was Auguste Morel. However, the Atar Volant was not an end onto itself; its long term purpose was to serve as precursors to a larger fixed-wing aircraft.^[7] Independently of this work, substantial influence on the direction of development came from the Austrian design engineer Helmut von Zborowski, who had designed an innovative doughnut-shaped annular wing that could function "as power plant, airframe of a flying wing aircraft and drag-reducing housing". It was theorised that such a wing could function as a ramjet engine and propel an aircraft at supersonic speeds, suitable for an interceptor aircraft.^[5]

SNECMA's design team decided to integrate this radical annual wing design into their VTOL efforts. Accordingly, from this decision emerged the basic configuration of the C.450 Coléoptère.^[5] In December 1958, the Coléoptère first left the ground under its own power, albeit while attached to a gantry.^[6] Several challenging flight characteristics were observed, such as the tendency for the aircraft to slowly spin on its axis while in a vertical hover; its pilot also noted that the vertical speed indicator was unrealistic and that the controls were incapable of steering the aircraft with precision while performing the critical landing phase. Dead-stick landings were deemed to be an impossibility.^[5] One of aircraft's flights involved a public display of its hover performance before an assembled audience.^[8] The eye-catching design of the Coléoptère rapidly made waves in the public conscious, even internationally; author Jeremy Davis observed that the aircraft had even influenced international efforts, having allegedly motivated the United States Navy to contract American helicopter manufacturer Kaman Aircraft to design its own annular-wing vehicle, nicknamed the Flying Barrel.^[5]

Accordingly, the United States experimented with its own tail-sitters, typically involving propeller-driven design configurations with relatively conventional fixed wings. The Convair XFY Pogo was one such aircraft, featuring a delta wing with cruciform tail configuration; initial test flights were conducted inside of a naval airship hangar at Moffett Field in Mountain View, California.^[9] The XFY successfully demonstrated the full transition between flight modes on 5 November 1954.^[10] A somewhat similar aircraft was the Lockheed XFV Salmon, which paired a straight wing with an X tail; however, the XFV never achieved the crucial flight transition.^[11] However, it became evident during flight testing that such VTOL aircraft would be flown only by the most experienced pilots, even if all technical problems were disregarded; thus, it was not feasible to place VTOL fighters—as previously hoped for—on every ship. Also, whereas jet-engined fighters had top speeds that approached Mach 2, the turboprop VTOL fighter was at a disadvantage due to its maximum speed being below Mach 1. As a result of these circumstances, work on the XFY was halted.^[12] During 1955, the United States commenced flight testing of a jet-powered design, the Ryan X-13 Vertijet. Two prototypes were constructed, both of which flew, made successful transitions to and from horizontal flight, and landed. The X-13's final test flight was conducted near Washington DC during 1957.^[13]

An inherent problem with all these tail-sitter designs was poor pilot visibility, especially of the ground, during vertical descent and landing. Ultimately, most work on applying the concept towards manned aircraft were abandoned upon the arrival of more practical form of VTOL appeared, in the form of thrust vectoring, as used by production aircraft such as the Hawker Siddeley Harrier and Yakovlev Yak-38.^[14][15][16] An unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) does not suffer the problem of pilot attitude. The Dornier Aerodyne is of ducted-fan configuration similar to a coleopter, and a test UAV flew successfully in hover mode in 1972, before development was discontinued.^[17] Another contemporary UAV project was the NSRDC BQM-108 that was developed by the United States Navy; although work was discontinued almost immediately after its single successful test flight.^[18]

During the 1970s, several studies and wind tunnel models were made of a tail-sitting version of the General Dynamics F-16 Fighting Falcon that was intended for use on board ships; however, it was decided not to pursue further development of the concept due to the large thrust requirement involved, as well as the need for extensive apparatus to handle take-off and landing.^[19]

In the present

At present, most of the tail sitter projects or proposals fall under the category of unmanned aircraft such as Bell Apt or Northrop Grumman Tern.

List of tail-sitters

Type	Country	Date	Role	Status	Description
AeroVironment SkyTote	USA	2010	UAV	Prototype	None
Bachem Ba 349	Germany	1944	Interceptor	Prototype	Launched up a vertical tower, landed using parachutes.
Bell Apt	USA	2019	UAV	Prototype	Planned for delivering^[20]
Bolköw P 110.1	West Germany	1950s	VTOL Fighter	Project	None ^[21]
Sukhoi Shkval	USSR	1960	Interceptor	Development ceased,partial Mockup	equipped with a conventional Landing gear.side-by-side afterburner engines.
CDADI VD200	China	2014	UAV	Project	None
Convair XFY-1 Pogo	USA	1954	Fighter	Prototype	None
Dornier Aerodyne	Germany	1972	UAV	Prototype	None
Focke-Wulf Triebflügel	Germany	1944	Interceptor	Project	Rotor wing around middle of fuselage. In-flight transition never resolved.
Focke Wulf Fw 860	West Germany	1950s	VTOL Fighter	Project	None ^[21]
Heinkel Lerche	Germany	1944	Fighter	Project	None
Heinkel He 231	West Germany	1950s	VTOL Fighter	Project	None
Lockheed Martin Cormorant	USA	2008	UAV	Prototype	None
Lockheed XFV-1	USA	1954	Fighter	Prototype	None
Messerschmitt Me X1-21	West Germany	1950s	VTOL Fighter	Project	None ^[21]
NASA Puffin	USA	2010	Private	Project	None ^[22]
Northrop Grumman Tern	USA	2018	UCAV	Prototype	None
NSRDC BQM-108	USA	1976	UAV	None	None
Rotary Rocket Roton ATV	USA	1999	Experimental	Prototype	Rotorcraft test vehicle for proposed SSO space launcher.
Ryan X-13 Vertijet	USA	1955	Experimental	Prototype	None
SNECMA Coléoptère	France	1959	Experimental	Prototype	Never achieved transition. Had one cylindrical wing.

See also

 

Look up tailsitter in Wiktionary, the free dictionary.

• Thrust vectoring
• Tiltrotor
• Tiltjet
• Tiltwing
• Coleopter
• PTOL
• VTOL

References

Citations

1. "Nikola Tesla U.S. Patent 1,655,114 - Apparatus for Aerial Transportation". 1 March 2015. Retrieved 7 July 2016., Tesla Universe.
2. Sharp, Dan. Luftwaffe: Secret Weapons of the Third Reich. Mortons, 2015. pp. 98-101.
3. Ford, Roger (2013). Germany's Secret Weapons of World War II. London, United Kingdom: Amber Books. p. 224. ISBN 9781909160569.
4. Mason 1967, p. 3.
5. Davis, Jeremy (July 2012). "Cancelled: Vertical Flyer". Air & Space Magazine.
6. Gaillard 1990, p. 200.
7. Gaillard 1990, p. 180.
8. Haimes, Brian J. (15 November 2006). "The Coleopter - a revolutionary experimental aircraft". New Scientist.
9. Taylor 1977, p. 63.
10. "Convair XFY." Flight, 12 November 1954, p. 696.
11. Winchester 2005, p. 135.
12. Allen 2007, p. 20.
13. Darling, Jeff (13 June 2011). . Diseno. Archived from the original on 28 January 2014. Retrieved 9 February 2014.
14. Wilson 2000, p. 145.
15. "Yak-36 Forger—interim V/Stol." Flight International, 2 May 1981.
16. Brown 1970, p. 81.
17. "Eine Dokumentation zur Geschichte des Hauses Dornier." Dornier GmbH, 1983. p. 214.
18. Eilertson 1977.
19. Newsom, William A.; Anglin, Ernie L. (September 1975). "FREE-FLIGHT MODEL INVESTIGATION OF A VERTICAL-ATTITUDE VTOL FIGHTER" (PDF). National Aeronautics and Space Administration. Retrieved October 16, 2016.
20. "Bell APT". Bell Flight. Retrieved 14 October 2019.
21. Hirschberg, Mike (1 November 2000). "V/STOL Fighter Programs in Germany: 1956-1975" (PDF). robertcmason.com.
22. Choi, Charles Q. (19 January 2010). "Electric Icarus: NASA Designs a One-Man Stealth Plane". Scientific American. Retrieved 27 February 2010.

Bibliography

• Allen, Francis J. "Bolt Upright: Convair's and Lockheed's VTOL fighters". Air Enthusiast (Key Publishing) Volume 127, January/February 2007, pp. 13–20. ISSN 0143-5450.
• Brown, Kevin. "The Plane That Makes Airfields Obsolete." Popular Mechanics, 133(6), June 1970, pp. 80–83.
• Eilertson, W.H. (1977). The XBQM-108A Vertical Attitude Takeoff and Landing Vehicle. Washington, DC: Defense Technical Information Center. ASIN B00073EVPK.
• Gaillard, Pierre (1990). Les Avions Francais de 1944 à 1964. Paris: Éditions EPA. ISBN 2-85120-350-9.
• Taylor, John W. R. & Michael J. H. Jane's Pocket Book of Research and Experimental Aircraft. Collier Books: New York, 1977 ISBN 0-356-08405-1.
• Wilson, Stewart. Combat Aircraft since 1945. Fyshwick, Australia: Aerospace Publications, 2000. ISBN 1-875671-50-1.
• Winchester, Jim. "Lockheed XFV-1 Salmon." Concept Aircraft: Prototypes, X-Planes and Experimental Aircraft. Kent, UK: Grange Books plc., 2005. ISBN 978-1-84013-809-2.