Rail transport in Wales

Rail transport in Wales began in the early 19th century initially used for industrial purposes and shortly began to be used for commercial purposes. The Beeching cuts had a significant impact on rail transport in Wales, closing a large number of railway stations. Since then some stations have reopened in Wales and following Welsh devolution, the Wales and Borders passenger rail franchise was established in 2001 and the operator was taken into public ownership by the Welsh Government in 2021.

Rail transport in Wales
Cardiff Central railway station
Operation
Infrastructure company	Network Rail
Major operators	Transport for Wales Rail
Features
No. stations	223
Map Existing rail network of Wales

Rail services are generally managed by the Welsh Government whilst rail infrastructure is generally the responsibility of the UK Government. Rail in Wales is mostly operated by Transport for Wales Rail. Current developments include the North Wales Metro, South Wales Metro and Swansea Bay and West Wales Metro.

History

Early history

The world's oldest known iron railway bridge, Pont-y-Cafnau was designed and built in 1793. On 21 February 1804 the first recorded steam-hauled journey on rails took place in Merthyr Tydfil from Penydarren to the Glamorganshire Canal.^[1][2]

Swansea and Mumbles Railway was opened in 1807, becoming the first fare-paying passenger rail service in the world.^[3]

In 1832 Ffestiniog Railway opened and is the world's oldest surviving railway company.^[3]

Trains between South Wales, Bristol and London crossed the River Severn at Gloucester. The Severn Railway Bridge was opened in 1879, and continued to operate until it collapsed in 1960. In 1873, a Severn Estuary tunnel began construction including permanent water pumps which remain operational. The first trains passed through the tunnel in 1886 and for a century remained the longest underwater tunnel in the world.^[3]

Beeching report

In 1963, the Beeching report aimed to reduce the debt of the nationalised British Rail and led to 189 stations in Wales intended for closure with lines and tracks removed over the next decade across Wales. This list for closure was in addition to another 166 Welsh stations and halt-stops that were proposed for closure prior to Beeching's report.^[4]

Some stations with particular industry works were saved. Larry Davies, an Arriva Trains Wales' community manager in 2013 said, "Although there were a lot of local protest from people as one would expect, I think the traffic that came from the power station saved the Conwy Valley line".^[4] Since the Beeching cuts and as of 2013, 32 stations have re-opened in Wales.^[4]

Wales and Borders franchise

In March 2000, the UK government announced its proposal to form the new Wales and Borders rail franchise, following long-standing calls for this by the Select Committee on Welsh Affairs.^[5] The Wales & Borders Train Company was formed on 14 October 2001 and ran by National Express.^[6]

In 2016, Transport for Wales was established, and would oversee the procurement of the next operator of the franchise, then operated by Arriva Trains Wales, as well as Metro services on the Valley Lines.^[7][8]

In 2018, KeolisAmey Wales was appointed to operate the Wales and Borders franchise on behalf of Transport for Wales, replacing Arriva Trains Wales as the operator of the Wales and Borders franchise, and would be operating as a "partnership" between KeolisAmey and Transport for Wales while being branded as the latter. It commenced operations in October 2018.^[7][8] The introduction of a new operator was accompanied with a £5 billion investment into rail by the Welsh Government, during the 15-year franchise.^[9]

In 2020, Transport for Wales took ownership of Core Valley Lines from Network Rail, which runs from Cardiff to Aberdare, Merthyr Tydfil, Treherbert, Rhymney and Coryton.^[7]

Transition to public-owned operation

In February 2021, the Wales and Borders franchise was brought into public ownership by the Welsh government under the subsidiary Transport for Wales Rail.^[10] In the same year, a new app was launched and Bow Street railway station became the first Transport for Wales built station.^[7]

As of 2023^[update], there are 223 rail stations in Wales.^[11]

Network

 

Rail network of Wales

Geography

The Welsh railway system is split into three detached parts: The South Wales network, consisting of the South Wales Main Line, the West Wales lines and their complex network of associated branches, including the Valley Lines, the Cambrian Line serving mid-Wales, and in North Wales, the North Wales Coast Line and its associated branches. The three parts are linked together by the Welsh Marches Line and Shrewsbury–Chester line which both run partly through Wales and partly through England.

Railway lines

• Mid Wales lines^[11]
  • Heart of Wales line^[11][12]
  • Cambrian Main line^[11]
  • Cambrian Coast Line^[11]
• North Wales lines^[11]
  • North Wales Coast Line^[11][13]
  • Conwy Valley line^[11]
  • Borderlands line^[11]
  • Wrexham to Chirk^[11]
• South Wales lines^[11]
  • South Wales Main Line^[11]
  • Newport to Chepstow line^[11]
  • Newport to Abergavenny Line^[11]
  • Swanline^[11]

• Valley Lines^[11]
  • Butetown Line^[11]
  • City Line^[11]
  • Vale of Glamorgan Line^[11]
  • Merthyr line^[11]
  • Aberdare line (Merthyr line branch to Aberdare)^[11]
  • Rhondda line^[11]
  • Rhymney line^[11]
  • Maesteg Line^[11]
  • Ebbw Valley Line^[11]
• West Wales lines^[11]
  • Swansea to Pembroke Dock^[11]
  • Swansea to Milford Haven and Fishguard^[11]

Heritage railways

Main articles: List of British heritage and private railways § Wales, and Great Little Trains of Wales

Various heritage railways are present in Wales.^[14] Some are part of the Great Little Trains of Wales initiative.^[15]

• Bala Lake Railway^[14][16]
• Brecon Mountain Railway^[14][16]
• Corris Railway^[15]
• Fairbourne Railway^[14]
• Ffestiniog Railway^[14][16]
• Llanberis Lake Railway^[14][16]
• Pontypool and Blaenavon Railway^[16]
• Rhyl Miniature Railway^[14][16]
• Snowdon Mountain Railway^[14][16]
• Talyllyn Railway - in 1951, this became the first preserved railway in the world.^[17][16]
• Vale of Rheidol Railway^[14][16]
• Welsh Highland Railway – Longest heritage railway in the UK.^[18][16]
• Welshpool and Llanfair Light Railway^[14][16]

Electrification

Currently the only stretch of line to be electrified in Wales is the South Wales Main Line between the Severn Tunnel and Cardiff Central railway station, which was electrified as part of the Great Western Main Line upgrade, and was completed in 2020.^[19] Plans to extend the electrification from Cardiff to Swansea were scrapped in 2017.^[20]

Management

See also: Wales Route Utilisation Strategy

Responsibility for agreements with rail operators and the procurement of the specific Welsh rail franchise rests with the Welsh government, whilst rail infrastructure and overall franchising powers are held by the UK government.^[21] Rail infrastructure in Wales is managed by Network Rail and is part of the Wales & Western region, including some parts of England along the England–Wales border, and parts of South West England.^[22]

Powers

Wales' railway network is not devolved to the Welsh Government and Senedd, with there being limitations. The Welsh Government has been devolved some executive functions in relation to rail transport. These are primarily on the issues of funding, passenger rail franchising, discontinuing or closing railway services or some railway assets, under the Railways Act 2005 and The Welsh Ministers (Transfer of Functions) (Railways) Order 2018. The Welsh Government has the power to make TWA orders in relation to the construction and operation of railways, tramways, trolley vehicles, and other guided transport systems, where the order authorises the acquisition or use of land rights, and the charging of tolls and penalty fares. However, any application determined to be classed as "England and Wales", for example a railway line crossing the England–Wales border, then that is the responsibility of the UK Government's Secretary of State for Transport.^[23]

As it is not devolved, the Welsh Block Grant (determined by the Barnett formula)^[24] does not include funding for rail infrastructure to the Welsh Government, although the Welsh Government can still invest in rail, including for rail infrastructure and railway stations using its existing funding, but the responsibility of rail infrastructure and funding for Network Rail lies with the UK Secretary of State for Transport. This differs from Scotland, where such powers are devolved. In relation to building new railway stations in Wales, while the Welsh Government can invest, Network Rail is the asset owner and rail network operator of rail infrastructure in England and Wales, with the UK Secretary of State being responsible for the specifications of any enhancements and the funding provided for such enhancements. The UK Government's New Stations Fund is an example of a funding source for many of the proposed railway stations in Wales made by the Welsh Government, although other proposals such as Cardiff Parkway can be funded privately with support from the Welsh Government or by gaining funding from European Structural and Investment Funds. To assess its proposals, the Welsh Government conducts a three-stage assessment process for proposed station in Wales, with the business case of a station prioritised as a greater chance to secure UK Government funding, while limiting expenses and construction time are also prioritised.^[25]

The UK Secretary of State produces a High Level Output Specification (HLOS) and Statement of Funds Available (SoFA) to set out the priorities of Network Rail. This later develops into a Control Period, a five-year long rail plan for rail infrastructure in England and Wales.^[25]

Devolution of more powers

Further information: Proposed further Welsh devolution § Rail infrastructure

In 2005, the UK Government offered to devolve rail infrastructure to Wales. The Welsh Assembly Government of the time refused, citing concerns around funding, the weakness of the Welsh civil service and possible issues arising from the levels of integration between Wales's rail infrastructure with England's.^[26]

The 2011 Commission on Devolution in Wales had recommended that rail infrastructure be devolved to Wales. The St David's Day Agreement was created following many of the commission's recommendations, but did not include the devolution of rail infrastructure.^[8]

In 2021, the Welsh Affairs Select Committee had proposed for the establishment of a "Wales Rail Board" rather than devolving infrastructure to Wales.^[27][28]

Political concerns

Criticism of funding

A report by the Wales Governance Centre found that Wales could have utilised an additional £514 million rail infrastructure between 2011-12 and 2019-20 if rail were fully devolved, and an additional £505 million for the following five years.^[29]

In the 2020s, the Welsh Government and Welsh politicians had criticised the UK Government for the classification of some rail infrastructure schemes.

In 2020, the UK Government had classified High Speed 2 as an "England and Wales" project. This move was criticised by Welsh MPs^[30] and Welsh Government ministers, who argued such a classificiation had little justification as High Speed 2 did not pass through Wales, and they claim would not give any benefits to Wales. The classification would mean, unlike Scotland, Wales would not receive a Barnett consequential, estimated at £5 billion.^[31][32] By February 2020, the Welsh Government had received £755 million in HS2-linked funding, with the UK Government stating it was "investing record amounts in Wales' railway infrastructure" and the Welsh Government had received a "significant uplift" in Barnett-based funding due to the UK Government's increased funding of HS2,^[33] with Network Rail to invest £1.5 billion in Wales' railways between 2019 and 2024.^[34] In April 2023, all parties of the Senedd agreed to a motion introduced by Plaid Cymru that called on the UK Government to re-allocate funding to Wales that is "rightfully owed" for HS2.^[35]

In 2023, the UK Government classed Northern Powerhouse Rail, as another "England and Wales" project, which would have given Wales a Barnett consequential of £1 billion if classed as a "England" project. The decision was criticised by the Welsh Liberal Democrats.^[36]

Criticism of the state of the railways

In April 2023, Wales' transport minister, Lee Waters has described Welsh rail as having been "pretty bleak for a while" and included overcrowding and cancellations. He has accused the UK government of a "managed decline" of Welsh rail, which the UK government denies. Waters accused Network Rail's running period of 2024-2029 which shows infrastructure failures and deteriorating assets which he says will cause speed restrictions, worsened reliability, and further service failures. A spokesperson of the UK government treasury responded by saying that "we're committed to improving services for rail passengers in Wales, investing a record-breaking £2bn in Welsh railways from April 2019 to March 2024."^[37]

Future initiatives

Transport for Wales (TfW) have planned three regional metros in Wales, the South Wales Metro, Swansea Bay and West Wales Metro and the North Wales Metro.^[38]

Transport for Wales 2025

TfW say that their first phase of rail services improvement will be complete by 2025. The operating service said that there will be a "generational" change to services in the Wales and Borders franchise after 148 new trains are deployed in Wales; over 170 km (110 miles) of rail lines is electrified; new stations are built; improvements are made to tracks and signals.

By 2025, TfW has promised a more expansive and frequent service on its network, all trains being replaced, with 95% of journeys on 148 new trains, and a 65% increase in capacity. TfW aim to operate five new stations, and have an improved service on Sundays. They also plan to electrify part of the South Wales Valleys rail network, while also providing >600 new jobs, better Wifi services, more station car parking spaces and smarter ticketing.^[39]

Proposals

• List of proposed railway stations in Wales
• North–South Wales railway

Passenger services

Main article: Wales and Borders franchise

 

Transport for Wales' route map in May 2022

All passenger routes in Wales are operated by Transport for Wales Rail, as part of the cross-border Wales and Borders franchise, involving services throughout Wales and the routes making up the network through England.^[40] Transport for Wales operate the Premier Service, connecting Holyhead in north Wales, to Cardiff in the south.^[41]

Aside Transport for Wales Rail, Avanti West Coast operate a London Euston to Holyhead and Wrexham General service via Chester.^[42] In 2022, Grand Union was approved to operate services between Carmarthen and London Paddington, with the first services expected in 2024.^[43]

Train operating companies working in Wales include:^[44][45]

• Transport for Wales Rail – Most services in Wales & Borders
• Avanti West Coast – North Wales to English West Midlands and London Euston
• CrossCountry Trains – Cardiff/Newport to the English Midlands and North East England.
• Great Western Railway – South Wales to London

Other

 

Sign at Llanfairpwll railway station, showing a longer version of its name

• One of the stations, Llanfairpwll railway station, has the longest station name on a sign in the UK, with the sign reading Llanfairpwllgwyngyll-gogerychwyrndrobwllllantysiliogogogoch.^[1]
• The Global Centre of Rail Excellence, a proposed railway test centre, is located in South Wales.^[46]

See also

• Transport in Wales
• Rail transport in Great Britain

References

1. Gregory, Rhys (11 May 2018). "10 things you probably didn't know about the Welsh railway". Retrieved 20 April 2023.
2. "Birth of the Railway Locomotive". Museum Wales. Retrieved 20 April 2023.
3. "Landmarks in Welsh transport history". Transport For Wales News. Retrieved 27 April 2023.
4. "Fifty years since Beeching's rail cuts in Wales". BBC News. 26 March 2013. Retrieved 27 April 2023.
5. "Select Committee on Welsh Affairs Third Report".
6. "Memorandum submitted by National Express Group/Wales & Borders Train Operating Company".
7. "Our story | Transport for Wales". tfw.wales. Retrieved 7 May 2023.
8. "The Future of Railways in Wales". research.senedd.wales. Retrieved 8 May 2023.
9. "£5 billion investment to transform rail services across Wales". Transport For Wales News. Retrieved 8 May 2023.
10. "Wales' railway services now nationalised by the Welsh Government". Nation.Cymru. 8 February 2021. Retrieved 27 April 2023.
11. "Rail station usage in Wales, 2020-21" (PDF). Statistical Bulletin. Welsh Government: Statistics for Wales. 3 March 2022.
12. "Things to see and do on the Heart of Wales Line". VisitWales. Retrieved 20 April 2023.
13. "Things to do along the North Wales Coast Railway". VisitWales. Retrieved 20 April 2023.
14. "The narrow gauge and miniature steam trains of Wales". VisitWales. Retrieved 20 April 2023.
15. "Great Little Trains of Wales Limited, twelve scenic steam railways". www.greatlittletrainsofwales.co.uk. Retrieved 8 May 2023.
16. Williams, Kathryn (26 September 2020). "10 places in Wales to ride a steam train that you and your kids will love". WalesOnline. Retrieved 8 May 2023.
17. "The Talyllyn Railway - The world's first preserved railway". Visit Tywyn. Retrieved 28 April 2023.
18. "Welsh Highland Railway | VisitWales". www.visitwales.com. Retrieved 20 April 2023.
19. "London–Cardiff Electrification Fully Completed". Railway-News. 8 June 2020. Retrieved 8 May 2023.
20. "Rail electrification between Cardiff and Swansea scrapped". BBC news. 20 July 2017. Retrieved 8 May 2023.
21. "Railway Infrastructure in Wales".
22. "Wales & Western region". Network Rail. Retrieved 20 April 2023.
23. "Rail transport | Law Wales". law.gov.wales. Retrieved 20 April 2023.
24. "How is devolved Government in Wales financed? | Law Wales". law.gov.wales. Retrieved 8 May 2023.
25. "Mind the devolution gap - delivering new railway stations in Wales". research.senedd.wales. Retrieved 8 May 2023.
26. Hayward, Will (4 October 2023). "The 'biggest mistake' the Welsh Government ever made". WalesOnline. Retrieved 15 December 2023.
27. Barry, Sion (14 July 2021). "HS2 should be reclassed as an England only project says Welsh Affairs Committee". Business Live. Retrieved 8 May 2023.
28. . The National Wales. Archived from the original on 17 November 2022. Retrieved 8 May 2023.
29. "'Double whammy' on Rail funding: £500m lost to Wales since 2011 and a future funding squeeze to come, says new report". Cardiff University. Retrieved 20 April 2023.
30. "Wales is paying for HS2 but it will harm our economy - we must receive the £5 billion we are owed". Nation.Cymru. 12 February 2020. Retrieved 8 May 2023.
31. "Written Statement: The UK Budget 2023 (14 March 2023)". GOV.WALES. Retrieved 20 April 2023.
32. Barry, Sion (26 August 2020). "Wales will not get multi-billion pound HS2 consequential says Grant Shapps". Business Live. Retrieved 8 May 2023.
33. Codd, Fintan; Pickett, Lewis; Keep, Matthew (28 November 2021). Transport funding for Wales and HS2. UK Parliament (Report). Retrieved 8 May 2023.
34. "HS2: Outrageous rail project will not benefit Wales, transport expert says". BBC News. 11 February 2020. Retrieved 8 May 2023.
35. Summer, Ben (27 April 2023). "All Wales' political parties unite to call for HS2 funding for Wales". WalesOnline. Retrieved 8 May 2023.
36. "Conservatives slammed over rail funding after reports Wales is set to miss out on £1 billion". Nation.Cymru. 18 March 2023. Retrieved 20 April 2023.
37. "Trains in Wales can be awful, says transport minister Lee Waters". BBC News. 20 April 2023. Retrieved 20 April 2023.
38. "Welsh rail transformation - Industrial News". 23 August 2022. Retrieved 20 April 2023.^{[permanent dead link]}
39. "Trains: How can it take so long to fix a struggling railway?". BBC News. 6 March 2023. Retrieved 20 April 2023.
40. "Our network map | Transport for Wales". tfw.wales. Retrieved 20 April 2023.
41. "Connecting North and South Wales". Transport For Wales News. Retrieved 20 April 2023.
42. "Avanti West Coast Route Map | Avanti West Coast". www.avantiwestcoast.co.uk. Retrieved 20 April 2023.
43. "Trains: Plans for new London-west Wales services approved". BBC News. 1 December 2022. Retrieved 20 April 2023.
44. "Trains in Wales | Travel Wales by Train". Trainline. Retrieved 8 May 2023.
45. "Wales route". Network Rail. Retrieved 20 April 2023. (Note: "Wales route" includes parts in England)
46. Phillips, Lauren (18 April 2023). "World's first rail testing centre in Wales partners with Hitachi Rail". Business Live. Retrieved 20 April 2023.

External links

•   Media related to Rail transport in Wales at Wikimedia Commons