Peaceful transition of power

A peaceful transition or transfer of power is a concept important to democratic governments in which the leadership of a government peacefully hands over control of government to a newly-elected leadership. This may be after elections or during the transition from a different kind of political regime, such as the postcommunist period after the fall of the Soviet Union.^[1]

In scholarship examining democratization and emerging democracies, study of the successful transitions of power is used to understand the transition to constitutional democracy and the relative stability of that government.^[2][3][4][5] A 2014 study concluded that 68 countries had never had a peaceful transition of power due to an election since 1788.^[6][1]

Democratization studies

President-elect Ronald Reagan is sworn in as president of the United States in a symbolic peaceful transfer of power in 1981.

In scholarship examining democratization and emerging democracies, study of the successful transitions of power is used to understand the transition to constitutional democracy and the relative stability of that government (democratic consolidation).^[2][3][4][5]

A 2014 study by Adam Przeworski of 3,000 elections from 1788 to 2008, published in the journal Comparative Political Studies concluded that 68 countries (including Russia and China) had never had a peaceful transition of power between parties following an election, making it a "rare and a recent practice."^[6][1] The same study found that once a country has an initial peaceful transfer of power (an "alternation"), it is very likely to keep doing so, making the peaceful transition of power a habit-forming activity.^[6][1] In a stable institutionalized democracy, a peaceful transition is the expected outcome of an election.^[6][1]

Peaceful transitions require a number of strong democratic institutions and norms to exist, such as the willingness of opposition parties to serve as a loyal opposition. Transitions by election put power holders in vulnerable positions, as not only do they risk potential changes in policy and practice and thus their means of power, but they also risk political retribution or retaliation.^[7]

By region

The first peaceful transition of power in a country is often treated as an important stage in a government transition towards democracy such as seen in elections in the Democratic Republic of the Congo.^[8] Successful transitions during tense political moments such as the Velvet Revolution in Armenia in 2018 are interpreted as signs of improved governance within the country, an important milestone in democratization and functioning civil society.^[9] Alternately, the lack of peaceful transfers of power, such as in elections in Georgia from 1995 to 2008 in which the only transition between presidents was via the 2003 Rose Revolution, may harm the international reputation of the country as a "democracy".^[10]

Africa

Since achieving independence from European colonial powers, Africa has had a mixed record in achieving peaceful transitions of power, with variations among nations.^[11]

The first peaceful transition of power between civilians in Nigeria took place in 2007, although the outgoing and incoming presidents were of the same party and the preceding election was characterized by widespread irregularities.^[12] In 2018, Liberia had its first electoral transfer of power since 1944.^[13] The first peaceful transition of power in the Democratic Republic of the Congo took place in 2019, with outgoing president Joseph Kabila yielding power to opposition leader Felix Tshisekedi.^[14] The first transition of power from one democratically elected leader to another in Niger took place in 2021, overcoming the nation's history of four coups d'etat.^[15]

Asia

Indonesia

Symbolism

The symbol of peaceful transition of power is when the outgoing president and/or vice president, after their respective successors recite the oath of office, switch chairs, so that the incumbent president is on the furthest left side of the altar at the People's Consultative Assembly main session's room, and the sitting vice president is immediately on the right side of the speaker and deputies speaker's desk. As of 2022^[update], starting in 1978, the vice presidents always did this symbolic transfer when there was no vacancy in the office except in 2004, when Hamzah Haz did not attend the ceremony, and in 2009, when Jusuf Kalla was already seated on the furthest right side so no switch was needed. For presidents, as of 2022^[update], this symbol of peaceful transition happened only twice, in 1999 during the inauguration of Abdurrahman Wahid, and in 2014 for the first inauguration of Joko Widodo.

Europe

Belarus

Main articles: National Anti-Crisis Management and United Transitional Cabinet

During the 2020 Belarusian protests that followed the disputed results of the Belarusian presidential election in August 2020, Belarusians created a Coordination Council and a shadow government, the National Anti-Crisis Management (NAM), aiming for a peaceful transfer of power to a freely and fairly elected president.^[16][17][18] NAM proposed a "constitutional" option for power transfer, in which the presumed presidential election winner, Sviatlana Tsikhanouskaya, would become Prime Minister and the powers of the de facto president Alexander Lukashenko would be legally transferred to the Prime Minister's position, followed by elections for a new president organised by a newly created electoral commission; and a "legal sovereignty" option, in which Tsikhanouskaya would become President and organise presidential elections within 40–70 days.^[19]

Georgia

The transfer of power resulting from the 2012 Georgian parliamentary election was considered an important case of peaceful transfer of power in the post-Soviet political development of Georgia, which, since the Soviet period, had earlier gone through changes such as the Rose Revolution in 2003.^[10]

North America

United States

See also: Attempts to overturn the 2020 United States presidential election

A peaceful transition of power has historically been the norm in United States presidential transitions. The transition from John Adams to Thomas Jefferson in 1801 was considered an important milestone for the United States fledgling democracy. From then until 2020, the losing party in every presidential election "willingly and peacefully" relinquished power to the opposition.^[20][21] The transition is institutionalized through symbolic acts like the presidential inaugurations.^[22][23] Outgoing U.S. presidents traditionally attend the inaugurations of their successors, a symbol of the peaceful passage of power from one administration to the next.^[24]

During the 2020 presidential elections, experts described a risk of democratic backsliding in the U.S.,^[25][26] as President Donald Trump publicly refused to commit to a peaceful transfer of power if he lost his election bid.^[27] In September 2020, after Trump's statements, the U.S. Senate unanimously passed a resolution committing to a peaceful transition of power and opposing any attempt "by the President or any person in power to overturn the will of the people of the United States"; many senators cited the peaceful transition of power's centrality to U.S. democracy.^[28] Business leaders also made statements calling for a peaceful transfer.^[29]

Trump was defeated in the 2020 election by Joe Biden in both the popular vote and the electoral vote, but refused to accept defeat. Trump falsely claimed election fraud, initiated a seven-part plan to overturn the election, and engaged in an aggressive and unprecedented^[30] campaign to remain in power.^[31][32] Trump's fellow Republicans had varied reactions to Trump's false election-fraud claims.^{[33][34][35][36]} Trump stated on 15 October 2020 that he would accept a peaceful transfer (after a long period of ambiguous answers to the question) while still falsely alleging fraud and waging a legal battle to attempt to overturn the election results.^[37]

On January 6, 2021, a pro-Trump mob, inflamed by false claims, attacked the Capitol in Washington, D.C. in a failed attempt to keep Trump in power. The mob disrupted the counting of the electoral votes by a joint session of Congress for several hours.^[38][39][40] Five people were killed either shortly before, during, or following the attack.^[41] Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell noted that "if this election were overturned by mere allegations from the losing side, our democracy would enter a death spiral."^[42] On 7 January 2021, Trump condemned the riots and committed to the peaceful transition of power,^[43] although since leaving office he has continued to routinely repeat election lies and defend the riots.^[44]

South America

In Venezuela, the Puntofijo Pact allowed a political agreement to respect the election results,^[45] allowing for a peaceful transition of power after the ouster of dictator Marcos Pérez Jiménez and during the country's democratic period.^[46]

See also

• Nonviolent revolution
• Peaceful Revolution
• Puntofijo Pact

References

1. "Peaceful transitions of power have been rare in modern states, but once the habit has been acquired it sticks". EUROPP. 26 November 2014. from the original on 9 October 2020. Retrieved 25 September 2020.
2. Graham, Emmanuel (July 2017). "The Third Peaceful Transfer of Power and Democratic Consolidation in Ghana" (PDF). Africology: The Journal of Pan African Studies. 10 (5): 99–127. Retrieved 25 September 2020.}
3. Tamarkin, M. (1979). "From Kenyatta to Moi: The Anatomy of a Peaceful Transition of Power". Africa Today. 26 (3): 21–37. ISSN 0001-9887. JSTOR 4185874. from the original on 6 May 2021. Retrieved 25 September 2020.
4. Mangu, Andre Mbata B. (1 June 2004). "DR Congo : the long road from war to peace and challenges for peaceful transition and national reconstruction". Africa Insight. 34 (2_3): 31–38. ISSN 0256-2804. from the original on 9 October 2020. Retrieved 25 September 2020.
5. Ahmed, Jasem Mohamad (2012). "Democracy and the problem of peaceful transfer of power". Journal of Al-Frahedis Arts. 04 (10). from the original on 9 October 2020. Retrieved 25 September 2020.
6. Przeworski, Adam (1 January 2015). "Acquiring the Habit of Changing Governments Through Elections". Comparative Political Studies. 48 (1): 101–129. doi:10.1177/0010414014543614. ISSN 0010-4140. S2CID 154441890. from the original on 9 October 2020. Retrieved 25 September 2020.
7. Sutter, Daniel (1995). "Settling Old Scores: Potholes along the Transition from Authoritarian Rule". The Journal of Conflict Resolution. 39 (1): 110–128. doi:10.1177/0022002795039001005. ISSN 0022-0027. JSTOR 174324. S2CID 145445935. Retrieved 25 September 2020.
8. "First peaceful transfer of power possible in the DRC: regional focus - East Africa". Africa Conflict Monitor. 2017 (Feb 2017): 35–39. 1 February 2017. ISSN 2311-6943. from the original on 9 October 2020. Retrieved 25 September 2020.
9. Yayloyan, Diana (28 February 2019). "A Peaceful Transition of Power and Public's Expectations in Armenia". Economic Policy Research Foundation of Turkey. from the original on 9 October 2020. Retrieved 25 September 2020 – via Think-Asia.
10. "Peaceful transfer of political power and its characteristics in Georgia. The Georgian parliamentary elections of 2012". ibn.idsi.md. from the original on 9 October 2020. Retrieved 25 September 2020.
11. "Power transitions in Africa". Brookings. Retrieved 10 August 2023.
12. "A First in Nigeria: A Peaceful Succession of Power (Published 2007)". 30 May 2007. Retrieved 10 August 2023.
13. Tomas F. Husted, Liberia: Background and U.S. Relations, Congressional Research Service (February 14, 2020), p. 5.
14. "New Congo president marks first peaceful transfer of power". Christian Science Monitor. ISSN 0882-7729. Retrieved 10 August 2023.
15. Dalatou Mamane, Niger inaugurates president in 1st democratic power transfer, Associated Press (April 2, 2021).
16. "Pavel Latushko Announces Establishment Of People's Anti-Crisis Administration". Belarus Feed. 29 October 2020. Archived from the original on 16 November 2020. Retrieved 16 November 2020.
17. Grekowicz, Nikita (15 November 2020). "Białoruś ponownie zawrzała po skatowaniu Ramana Bandarenki. Trwają protesty [relacja z Mińska]" [Belarus again in shock at the assault on Raman Bandarenka. Protests continue [report from Minsk]]. OKO.press (in Polish). Archived from the original on 16 November 2020. Retrieved 16 November 2020.
18. Sadouskaya–Komlach, Maryia (6 November 2020). "An Exiled Belarusian Opposition Faces A Credibility Test". Center for European Policy Analysis. Archived from the original on 16 November 2020. Retrieved 16 November 2020.
19. "National Anti-Crisis Management: Two power transition options have been developed". National Anti-crisis Management. 17 November 2020. Archived from the original on 17 November 2020. Retrieved 18 November 2020.
20. Pruitt, Sarah. "How the Peaceful Transfer of Power Began With John Adams". HISTORY. from the original on 14 January 2021. Retrieved 7 January 2021.
21. "All 10 living former defense secretaries: Involving the military in election disputes would cross into dangerous territory". The Washington Post. 3 January 2021. from the original on 6 January 2021. Retrieved 6 January 2021.
22. "Peaceful Transition of Power". National Archives. 18 November 2016. from the original on 9 October 2020. Retrieved 25 September 2020.
23. Jacey Fortin (19 January 2021). "Trump Is Not the First President to Snub an Inauguration". New York Times.
24. "A president hasn't refused to attend the inauguration of his successor in 152 years. Donald Trump will change that". USA TODAY. Retrieved 10 August 2023.
25. "Is the U.S. at Risk of Mirroring Hungary's Democratic Backsliding?". www.worldpoliticsreview.com. 19 October 2020. from the original on 14 January 2021. Retrieved 15 November 2020.
26. Bauer, Michael W; Becker, Stefan (2 March 2020). "Democratic Backsliding, Populism, and Public Administration". Perspectives on Public Management and Governance. 3 (1): 19–31. doi:10.1093/ppmgov/gvz026. ISSN 2398-4910. from the original on 14 January 2021. Retrieved 15 November 2020.
27. Breuninger, Kevin (23 September 2020). "Trump won't commit to peaceful transfer of power if he loses the election". CNBC. from the original on 9 October 2020. Retrieved 25 September 2020.
28. "Unanimous Senate commits to peaceful transfer of power after Trump refuses". ABC News. from the original on 9 October 2020. Retrieved 25 September 2020.
29. "US business leaders call for peaceful transfer of power". www.ft.com. 7 November 2020. from the original on 14 January 2021. Retrieved 15 November 2020.
30. Multiple sources:
    • Kumar, Anita; Orr, Gabby (21 December 2020). "Inside Trump's pressure campaign to overturn the election". Politico. Trump's efforts to cling to power are unprecedented in American history. While political parties have fought over the results of presidential elections before, no incumbent president has ever made such expansive and individualized pleas to the officials who oversee certification of the election results.
    • Sanger, David E. (19 November 2020). "Trump's Attempts to Overturn the Election Are Unparalleled in U.S. History". The New York Times. President Trump's attempts to overturn the 2020 election are unprecedented in American history and an even more audacious use of brute political force to gain the White House than when Congress gave Rutherford B. Hayes the presidency during Reconstruction.
31. Multiple sources:
    • Miller, Zeke; Long, Colleen; Eggert, David (20 November 2020). "Trump tries to leverage power of office to subvert Biden win". Associated Press. from the original on 28 November 2020. Retrieved 8 December 2020.
    • Haberman, Maggie; Rutenberg, Jim; Corasaniti, Nick; Epstein, Reid J. (20 November 2020). "Trump Targets Michigan in His Ploy to Subvert the Election". The New York Times. from the original on 2 December 2020. Retrieved 8 December 2020.
    • "Trump presses Georgia governor to help subvert election". MarketWatch. Associated Press. 5 December 2020. from the original on 8 December 2020. Retrieved 8 December 2020.
    • "The Growing Backlash Against Trump's Efforts To Subvert The Election : Consider This from NPR". NPR. 20 November 2020. from the original on 2 December 2020. Retrieved 8 December 2020.
    • Raju, Manu; Herb, Jeremy (7 December 2020). "House conservatives urge Trump not to concede and press for floor fight over election loss". CNN. from the original on 8 December 2020. Retrieved 8 December 2020.
32. Multiple sources:
    • Snyder, Timothy (9 January 2021). "The American Abyss". The New York Times. Retrieved 9 February 2021.
    • Ben-Ghiat, Ruth (26 January 2021). "Opinion: Trump's big lie wouldn't have worked without his thousands of little lies". CNN.
    • Heavey, Jan Wolfe, Susan (25 January 2021). "Trump lawyer Giuliani faces $1.3 billion lawsuit over 'big lie' election fraud claims". Reuters.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
    • Block, Melissa (16 January 2021). "Can The Forces Unleashed By Trump's Big Election Lie Be Undone?". NPR.org.
    • Pilkington, Ed (24 January 2021). "Donald Trump is gone but his big lie is a rallying call for rightwing extremists". The Guardian. Retrieved 9 February 2021.
33. Parks, Miles (4 December 2020). "As Trump's Election Pressure Campaign Hits Republican Officials, Some Hit Back". NPR.org. from the original on 14 January 2021. Retrieved 7 January 2021.
34. "The uncomfortable reality: Even many Republican officials believe false election claims". Retrieved 10 August 2023.
35. "Just 27 congressional Republicans acknowledge Biden's win, Washington Post survey finds". Retrieved 10 August 2023.
36. "Trump's False Election Fraud Claims Split Republicans (Published 2020)". 6 November 2020. Retrieved 10 August 2023.
37. Alison Main (16 October 2020). "Trump says he would accept peaceful transfer of power but casts doubt on election results". CNN. from the original on 14 January 2021. Retrieved 15 November 2020.
38. Dmitriy Khavin, Haley Willis, Evan Hill, Natalie Reneau, Drew Jordan, Cora Engelbrecht, Christiaan Triebert, Stella Cooper, Malachy Browne and David Botti (30 June 2021). "Day of Rage: An In-Depth Look at How a Mob Stormed the Capitol". New York Times.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: uses authors parameter (link)
39. Colleen Long & Michael Balsamo (26 August 2021). "Capitol Police officers sue Trump, allies over insurrection". Associated Press.
40. Luke Mogelson (15 January 2021). "Capitol Police officers sue Trump, allies over insurrection". The New Yorker. The New Yorker.
41. Levenson, Eric; Vera, Amir; Kallingal, Mallika (7 January 2021). "What we know about the 5 deaths in the pro-Trump mob that stormed the Capitol". CNN. from the original on 14 January 2021. Retrieved 7 January 2021.
42. Axios (6 January 2021). "McConnell: "Our democracy would enter a death spiral" if Congress overturned election". Axios. from the original on 14 January 2021. Retrieved 7 January 2021.
43. Martin, Jeffery (7 January 2021). "Full Text of Speech in Which Donald Trump Finally Concedes Election to Biden Without Naming Him". Newsweek.
44. Dale, Daniel (12 June 2021). "Trump is doing more lying about the election than talking about any other subject". CNN. from the original on 16 June 2021..
45. Corrales, Javier (1 January 2001). "Strong Societies, Weak Parties: Regime Change in Cuba and Venezuela in the 1950s and Today". Latin American Politics and Society. 43 (2): 81–113. doi:10.2307/3176972. JSTOR 3176972.
46. Márquez, Laureano; Eduardo, Sanabria (2018). "¡Por fin, democracia!". Historieta de Venezuela: De Macuro a Maduro (1st ed.). Gráficas Pedrazas. p. 95. ISBN 978-1-7328777-1-9.