It was mentioned by Norman Tindale in his classic ethnographic map of Australian tribes. The status of Jadira in the sense defined by Tindale has been recently questioned by Paul Burke.
Tindale described the tribal boundaries of some 3,600 square miles (9,300 km2) of land belonging to a "Jadira" people, in the following terms.3,600 sq. The Jadira occupied the areas about the middle sections of the Cane and Robe rivers, running south of Mount Minnie, and as far north as the Fortescue River. Their eastern frontier putatively fell short of the western scarp of the higher plateau of the Hamersley Ranges.[1]
Tindale also added a list of alternative names for these Jadira:
Kawarindjari, Kawarandjari
Kawarandari
Kawarindjara
Kauarind'arri, Kauarndhari
Garindjari
These terms represented Ngarlumaexonyma applied to the Jadira, and bore the sense of "belonging to the west".[1]
The only other information available to Tindale led him to suggest that some of the Jadira, a non-circumcising tribe, with the onset of European colonization, shifted eastwards to Ashburton Downs Station, while a second group moved to the mouth of the Fortescue River where they were assimilated into the Martuthinira. Traditionally, he added, their access to the coastal waters lay through Nhuwala (which Tindale spelt Noala) territory, between the Cane and Robe rivers,[1] a practice Tindale described as "trespassing".[2]
Controversyedit
Aboriginal Legal Aid lawyer and Land Council lawyer Paul Burke re-examined Tindale's papers and sources when, with regard to a native title claim, he had to work out the precise boundaries for another tribe in this area. He came to the conclusion that the Jadira people and their territory were a misnomer, a phantom category, inexplicably created by Tindale on otherwise very thin evidence.[3]
The primary source for Tindale's thesis lies in a single reference to the Kau'arndhäri[a] in a 1914 paper by Daisy Bates,[5] where Bates names it as one of four western Pilbara tribes – the others being the Ngarluma, the Kariera, and the Martuthinira – whose class system, governing marriages, is, she claimed, identical.[6][b] Bates does not mention the Jadira, but Tindale drew the conclusion that it was the endonym of the Kau'arndhäri, on the basis of a report by Carl Georg von Brandenstein, who glossed the latter term by the former.[5]
Notesedit
^Bates spells it two slightly different ways: "Kau'arndhäri", and "Kauarndhari".[4]
^Bates does however distinguish between cross-cousin marriage permitted by the Kariera and Ngarluma, but not by the Martuthinira or Kau'arndhäri, a statement which contradicts her prior remark that she did not have sufficient information on the last two regarding cross-cousin rules.[4]
Burke, Paul (December 2015). Roberts, Amy; McCaul, Kim (eds.). "Cartographic Ethnogenesis: Tindale's Invention of the Jadira Tribe in the Pilbara Region of Western Australia" (PDF). Journal of the Anthropological Society of South Australia. 39 (Special Edition: Norman B. Tindale's Research Legacy and the Cultural Heritage of Indigenous Australians): 102–126.
jadira, also, language, people, territory, pilbara, region, western, australia, mentioned, norman, tindale, classic, ethnographic, australian, tribes, status, sense, defined, tindale, been, recently, questioned, paul, burke, contents, ascribed, country, contro. See also Jadira language The Jadira are a people and territory in the Pilbara region of Western Australia It was mentioned by Norman Tindale in his classic ethnographic map of Australian tribes The status of Jadira in the sense defined by Tindale has been recently questioned by Paul Burke Contents 1 Ascribed country 2 Controversy 3 Notes 3 1 Citations 4 SourcesAscribed country editTindale described the tribal boundaries of some 3 600 square miles 9 300 km2 of land belonging to a Jadira people in the following terms 3 600 sq The Jadira occupied the areas about the middle sections of the Cane and Robe rivers running south of Mount Minnie and as far north as the Fortescue River Their eastern frontier putatively fell short of the western scarp of the higher plateau of the Hamersley Ranges 1 Tindale also added a list of alternative names for these Jadira Kawarindjari Kawarandjari Kawarandari Kawarindjara Kauarind arri Kauarndhari Garindjari These terms represented Ngarluma exonyma applied to the Jadira and bore the sense of belonging to the west 1 The only other information available to Tindale led him to suggest that some of the Jadira a non circumcising tribe with the onset of European colonization shifted eastwards to Ashburton Downs Station while a second group moved to the mouth of the Fortescue River where they were assimilated into the Martuthinira Traditionally he added their access to the coastal waters lay through Nhuwala which Tindale spelt Noala territory between the Cane and Robe rivers 1 a practice Tindale described as trespassing 2 Controversy editAboriginal Legal Aid lawyer and Land Council lawyer Paul Burke re examined Tindale s papers and sources when with regard to a native title claim he had to work out the precise boundaries for another tribe in this area He came to the conclusion that the Jadira people and their territory were a misnomer a phantom category inexplicably created by Tindale on otherwise very thin evidence 3 The primary source for Tindale s thesis lies in a single reference to the Kau arndhari a in a 1914 paper by Daisy Bates 5 where Bates names it as one of four western Pilbara tribes the others being the Ngarluma the Kariera and the Martuthinira whose class system governing marriages is she claimed identical 6 b Bates does not mention the Jadira but Tindale drew the conclusion that it was the endonym of the Kau arndhari on the basis of a report by Carl Georg von Brandenstein who glossed the latter term by the former 5 Notes edit Bates spells it two slightly different ways Kau arndhari and Kauarndhari 4 Bates does however distinguish between cross cousin marriage permitted by the Kariera and Ngarluma but not by the Martuthinira or Kau arndhari a statement which contradicts her prior remark that she did not have sufficient information on the last two regarding cross cousin rules 4 Citations edit a b c Tindale 1974 p 242 Tindale 1974 p 254 Burke 2015 pp 102 126 a b Bates 1914 pp 392 393 a b Burke 2015 p 113 Bates 1914 p 391 Sources edit AIATSIS map of Indigenous Australia AIATSIS Tindale Tribal Boundaries PDF Department of Aboriginal Affairs Western Australia September 2016 Bates D M 1914 Social Organisation of some Western Australian tribes Reports of the Australia and New Zealand Association for the Advancement of Science 14 387 400 Burke Paul December 2015 Roberts Amy McCaul Kim eds Cartographic Ethnogenesis Tindale s Invention of the Jadira Tribe in the Pilbara Region of Western Australia PDF Journal of the Anthropological Society of South Australia 39 Special Edition Norman B Tindale s Research Legacy and the Cultural Heritage of Indigenous Australians 102 126 Tindale Norman Barnett 1974 Jadira WA Aboriginal Tribes of Australia Their Terrain Environmental Controls Distribution Limits and Proper Names Australian National University Retrieved from https en wikipedia org w index php title Jadira amp oldid 1158444288, wikipedia, wiki, book, books, library,
