History of cataract surgery

Cataract surgery has a long history in Europe, Asia, and Africa. It is one of the most common and successful surgical procedures in worldwide use, thanks to improvements in techniques for cataract removal and developments in intraocular lens (IOL) replacement technology, in implantation techniques, and in IOL design, construction, and selection.^[1] Surgical techniques that have contributed to this success include microsurgery, viscoelastics, and phacoemulsification.^[2]

Cataract surgery, using a temporal approach phacoemulsification probe (in right hand) and "chopper" (in left hand)

Cataract surgery is the removal of the natural lens of the eye that has developed a cataract, an opaque or cloudy area.^[3] Over time, metabolic changes of the crystalline lens fibres lead to the development of a cataract, causing impairment or loss of vision. Some infants are born with congenital cataracts, and environmental factors may lead to cataract formation. Early symptoms may include strong glare from lights and small light sources at night and reduced visual acuity at low light levels.^[4][5]

Couching was the original form of cataract surgery, and was used from antiquity. It is still occasionally found in traditional medicine in parts of Africa and Asia. In 1753, Samuel Sharp performed the first-recorded surgical removal of the entire lens and lens capsule, equivalent to what became known as intracapsular cataract extraction. The lens was removed from the eye through a limbal incision.^[1] At the beginning of the 20th century, the standard surgical procedure was intracapsular cataract extraction (ICCE).^[6] In 1949, Harold Ridley introduced the concept of implantation of the intraocular lens (IOL), which made visual rehabilitation after cataract surgery a more efficient, effective, and comfortable process.^[1]

In 1967, Charles Kelman introduced phacoemulsification, which uses ultrasonic energy to emulsify the nucleus of the crystalline lens and remove cataracts by aspiration without a large incision. This method of surgery reduced the need for an extended hospital stay and made out-patient surgery the standard.^[7] In 1985, Thomas Mazzocco developed and implanted the first foldable IOL. Graham Barrett and associates pioneered the use of silicone, acrylic, and hydrogel foldable lenses, making it possible to reduce the incision width.^[6] In 1987, Blumenthal and Moisseiev described the use of a reduced incision size for ECCE.^[8] In 1989, M. McFarland introduced a self-sealing incision architecture,^[8] and in 2009, Praputsorn Kosakarn described a method for manual fragmentation of the lens, which consists in splitting the lens into three pieces for extraction, allowing a smaller, sutureless incision, and requires implantation of a foldable IOL. This technique uses less expensive instruments and is suitable for use in developing countries.^[8]

Couching

Main article: Couching (ophthalmology)

 

"Couching for cataract"; Wellcome Collection illustration of Indian doctors performing couching.

Couching is the earliest-documented form of cataract surgery, and one of the oldest surgical procedures ever performed. In this technique, the lens is dislodged and pushed aside into the vitreous cavity, but not removed from the eye, thus removing the opacity from the visual axis, but also the ability to focus.^[9] After being used regularly for centuries, couching has been mostly abandoned in favor of more effective techniques, due to its generally poor outcomes, and is currently only routinely practiced in remote areas of developing countries.^[10][11]

Cataract surgery was first mentioned in the Babylonian code of Hammurabi 1750 BCE.^[12] The earliest known depiction of cataract surgery is on a statue from the Fifth Dynasty of Egypt (2467–2457 BCE).^[12] According to Francisco J Ascaso et al, a "relief painting from tomb number TT 217 in a worker settlement in Deir el-Medina" shows "the man buried in the tomb, Ipuy ... one of the builders of royal tombs in the renowned Valley of the Kings, circa 1279–1213 BC" as he underwent cataract surgery. Although direct evidence for cataract surgery in ancient Egypt is lacking, the indirect evidence, including surgical instruments that could have been used for the procedure, show that it was possible. It is assumed that the couching technique was used.^[12][13]

Couching was practiced in ancient India and subsequently introduced to other countries by Indian physician Sushruta (c. 6th century BCE),^[14] who described it in his medical text, Sushruta Samhita ("Compendium of Sushruta"); the work's Uttaratantra section^[a] describes an operation in which a curved needle was used to push the opaque "phlegmatic matter"^[b] in the eye out of the way of vision. The phlegm was then said to be blown out of the nose. The eye would later be soaked with warm, clarified butter before being bandaged.^[15] The removal of cataracts by surgery was introduced into China from India, and flourished in the Sui (581–618 CE) and Tang (618–907 CE) dynasties.^[16]

The first references to cataract and its treatment in Europe are found in 29 CE in De Medicina, a medical treatise by Latin encyclopedist Aulus Cornelius Celsus, which describes a couching operation.^[17] In 2nd century CE, Galen of Pergamon, a prominent Greek physician, surgeon, and philosopher, reportedly performed an operation to remove a cataract-affected lens using a needle-shaped instrument.^[18][19] Although many 20th-century historians have claimed that Galen believed the lens to be in the exact centre of the eye, there is evidence that he understood the crystalline lens is located in the anterior aspect of the eye.^[20]

The removal of cataracts by couching was a common surgical procedure in Djenné^[21] and many other parts of Africa.^[22] Couching continued to be used throughout the Middle Ages, and is still used to this day in some parts of Africa and in Yemen.^[23][11] However, it has been proven to be an ineffective and dangerous method of cataract therapy, which often leads to blindness or only partially restored vision.^[23] The technique has mostly been replaced by extracapsular cataract surgery, including phacoemulsification.^[24]

The lens can also be removed by suction through a hollow instrument: bronze oral-suction instruments that seem to have been used for this method of cataract extraction during the 2nd century CE have been unearthed.^[25] Such a procedure was described by the 10th-century Persian physician Muhammad ibn Zakariya al-Razi, who attributed it to Antyllus, a 2nd-century Greek physician. According to al-Razi, the procedure "required a large incision in the eye, a hollow needle, and an assistant with an extraordinary lung capacity".^[26] This suction procedure was also described by Iraqi ophthalmologist Ammar Al-Mawsili in his 10th-century medical text, Choice of Eye Diseases.^[26] He presented case histories of its usage, while claiming to have successfully performed it on a number of patients.^[26]: p318 Extracting the lens has the benefit of removing the possibility of the lens migrating back into the field of vision.^[27] According to oculist Al-Shādhili, a later variant of the cataract needle in 14th-century Egypt used a screw to grip the lens. It is not clear how often, if ever, this method was used; other writers, including Abu al-Qasim al-Zahrawi and Al-Shadhili, appear to have been unfamiliar with this procedure, or claimed it was ineffective.^[26]: p319

Eighteenth and nineteenth centuries

 

Beer-type cataract knife and needle, cased, Paris, 1820-1866

 

A cataract surgery. Dictionnaire Universel de Médecine (1746–1748)

On Sep. 18, 1750, Jacques Daviel performed the first documented planned primary cataract extraction on a cleric in Cologne.^[28] In 1753, Samuel Sharp performed the first-recorded surgical removal of the entire lens and lens capsule: the lens was removed from the eye through a limbal incision.^[1] In America, cataract couching may have been performed in 1611,^[29] while cataract extraction was most likely performed by 1776.^[30] Cataract extraction by aspiration of lens material through a tube using suction was performed by Philadelphia-based surgeon Philip Syng Physick in 1815.^[31]

King Serfoji II, Bhonsle of Thanjavur, India, reportedly performed cataract surgeries in the early 1800s, according to manuscripts stored in the Saraswathi Mahal Library.^[32]

In 1884, Karl Koller became the first surgeon to apply a cocaine solution to the cornea as a local anaesthetic; the news of his discovery spread rapidly, but was not without controversy.^[33][34]

Early-to-mid 20th century

At the beginning of the 20th century, the standard surgical procedure was intracapsular cataract extraction (ICCE). The work of Henry Smith, who first developed a safe, fast way to remove the lens within its capsule by external manipulation, was considered particularly influential; the capsule forceps, the discovery of enzymatic zonulysis by Joaquin Barraquer in 1957, and the introduction of cryoextraction of the lens by Tadeusz Krwawicz and Charles Kelman in 1961 continued the development of ICCE.^[6] Intracapsular cryoextraction was the favoured form of cataract extraction from the late 1960s to the early 1980s: it consisted in using a liquid-nitrogen-cooled probe tip to freeze the encapsulated lens to the probe. This required a large incision and the cornea to be folded back and the anterior chamber to be drained.^[9][35][36]

In 1949, Harold Ridley introduced the concept of implantation of the intraocular lens (IOL) which made visual rehabilitation after cataract surgery a more efficient, effective, and comfortable process.^[1]

Artificial IOLs, which are used to replace the eye's natural lens removed during cataract surgery, increased in popularity since the 1960s, and were first approved by the US Food and Drug Administration in 1981. The development of IOLs was considered a notable innovation, as patients previously had to wear very thick glasses, or a special type of contact lens, in order to cope with the removal of their natural lens. IOLs can be used to correct other vision problems, such as toric lenses for correcting astigmatism.^[37] IOLs can be classified as monofocal, toric, and multifocal lenses.^[38]

Ocular anaesthesia has improved since Alfred Einhorn synthesised procaine in 1905, which was used in retrobulbar anaesthesia.

Peribulbar anaesthesia was introduced in 1980 by Mandal and David. Since the turn of the millennium, sub-Tenon's anaesthesia hascome into common use, and by ising a blunt cannula to deliver local anaesthetic, the risk of accidentally puncturing the globe is reduced. The more recent tendency is to administer topical local anesthesia without use of a needle.^[9]

Also in the 1960s, the development of A-scan ultrasound biometry contributed to provide more accurate predictions of implant refractive strength.^[39]

In 1967, Charles Kelman introduced phacoemulsification, which uses ultrasonic energy to emulsify the nucleus of the crystalline lens and remove cataracts by aspiration without a large incision. This method of surgery reduced the need for an extended hospital stay and made out-patient surgery the standard. Patients who undergo cataract surgery rarely complain of pain or discomfort during the procedure, although those who have topical anaesthesia, rather than peribulbar block anaesthesia, may experience some discomfort.^[7]

Late 20th century

Ophthalmic viscosurgical devices (OVDs), which were introduced in 1972, facilitate the procedure and improve overall safety. An OVD is a viscoelastic solution, a gel-like substance used to maintain the shape of the eye at reduced pressure, as well as protect the inside structure and tissues of the eye without interfering with the operation.^[1]

In 1980, D.M. Colvard made the cataract incision in the sclera, which limited induced astigmatism.^[8] In the early 1980s, Danièle Aron-Rosa and colleagues introduced the neodymium-doped yttrium aluminum garnet laser (Nd:YAG laser) for posterior capsulotomy.^[6] In 1985, Thomas Mazzocco developed and implanted the first foldable IOL. Graham Barrett and associates pioneered the use of silicone, acrylic, and hydrogel lenses.^[6]

According to Cionni et al (2006), Kimiya Shimizu began removing cataracts using topical anaesthesia in the late 1980s,^[6] though Davis (2016) attributes the introduction of topical anaesthetics to R.A. Fischman in 1993.^[1] In 1987, Blumenthal and Moissiev described the use of a reduced incision size for ECCE. They used a 6.5 to 7 mm (0.26 to 0.28 in) straight scleral tunnel incision 2 mm (0.079 in) behind the limbus with two side ports.^[8]

In 1989, M. McFarland introduced a self-sealing incision architecture; in 1990, S.L.Pallin described a chevron-shaped incision that minimized the risk of induced astigmatism; in 1991, J.A. Singer described the frown incision, in which the ends curve away from the limbus, similarly reducing astigmatism.^[8] Toric IOLs were introduced in 1992 and are used worldwide to correct corneal astigmatism during cataract surgery;^[37][1] they have been approved by the FDA since 1998.^[40] Also in the late 1990s, optical biometry based on partial coherence infrared interferometry was introduced: this technique improves visual resolution, offers much greater precision, and is much quicker and more comfortable than ultrasound.^[39]

21st century

According to surveys of members of the American Society of Cataract and Refractive Surgery, approximately 2.85 million cataract procedures were performed in the United States throughout 2004, while 2.79 million operations were executed in 2005.^[41] In 2009, Praputsorn Kosakarn described a method for manual fragmentation of the lens, called "double-nylon loop", which consists in splitting the lens into three pieces for extraction, allowing a smaller, sutureless incision of 4.0 to 5.0 mm (0.16 to 0.20 in), and requires implantation of a foldable IOL. This technique uses less expensive instruments and is suitable for use in developing countries.^[8]

As of 2013, medical staffs had access to instruments that use infrared swept-source optical coherence tomography (SS-OCT), a non-invasive, high-speed method that can penetrate dense cataracts and collects thousands of scans per second, with the ultimate goal of generating high-resolution data in 2D or 3D.^[39] As of 2021, approximately four million cataract procedures take place annually in the U.S. and nearly 28 million worldwide, a large proportion of which are performed in India; that is about 75,000 procedures per day globally.^[42]

Notes

1. chapter 17, verses 55–69
2. kapha in Sanskrit

References

1. Davis, G. (January–February 2016). "The Evolution of Cataract Surgery". Mo. Med. 113 (1). Missouri State Medical Association: 58–62. PMC 6139750. PMID 27039493.
2. "Chapter 5: Microsurgery and Extracapsular Cataract Extraction" (PDF). rajswasthya.nic.in. pp. 36–44. (PDF) from the original on 6 May 2021. Retrieved 12 February 2023.
3. "Cataracts". www.nei.nih.gov. National Eye Institute. from the original on 2 May 2019. Retrieved 27 July 2020.
4. Basic and clinical science course (2011–2012). Pediatric ophthalmology and Strabismus. American Academy of Ophthalmology. ISBN 978-1615251131.
5. "Facts About Cataract". September 2009. from the original on 24 May 2015. Retrieved 24 May 2015.
6. Cionni, Robert J.; Snyder, Michael E.; Osher, Robert H. (2006). "6: Cataract surgery". In Tasman, William (ed.). Duane's Ophthalmology. Vol. 6. Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. from the original on 20 February 2023. Retrieved 16 February 2023 – via www.oculist.net.
7. Pandey, Suresh K.; Milverton, E. John; Maloof, Anthony J. (October 2004). "A tribute to Charles David Kelman MD: ophthalmologist, inventor and pioneer of phacoemulsification surgery". Clinical & Experimental Ophthalmology. 32 (5): 529–533. doi:10.1111/j.1442-9071.2004.00887.x. ISSN 1442-6404. PMID 15498067. S2CID 25230092.
8. Singh, K.; Misbah, A.; Saluja, P.; Singh, A.K. (December 2017). "Review of manual small-incision cataract surgery". Indian J Ophthalmol. 65 (12): 1281–1288. doi:10.4103/ijo.IJO_863_17. PMC 5742955. PMID 29208807.
9. Haripriya, A.; Sonawane, H.; Thulasiraj, R.D. (2017). "Changing techniques in cataract surgery: how have patients benefited?". Community Eye Health. 30 (100): 80–81. PMC 5820631. PMID 29483751.
10. Isawumi, M.A.; Kolawole, O.U.; Hassan, M.B. (June 2013). "Couching techniques for cataract treatment in Osogbo, South west Nigeria". Ghana Medical Journal. 47 (2): 64–9. PMC 3743109. PMID 23966741.
11. Babalola, O.E. (December 2011). "The peculiar challenges of blindness prevention in Nigeria: a review article". Afr J Med Med Sci. 40 (4): 309–19. PMID 22783680.
12. Ascaso, F.J.; Lizana, J.; Cristóbal, J.A. (March 2009). "Cataract surgery in ancient Egypt". Journal of Cataract and Refractive Surgery. 35 (3): 607–608. doi:10.1016/j.jcrs.2008.11.052. PMID 19251160.
13. Grzybowski, Andrzej; Ascaso, Francisco J. (November 2014). "Indirect evidence of cataract surgery in ancient Egypt". Journal of Cataract & Refractive Surgery. 40 (11): 1944–1945. doi:10.1016/j.jcrs.2014.09.017. PMID 25442904.
14. Meulenbeld, G.J. (1999–2002). A History of Indian Medical Literature. Groningen: Forsten.
15. Sharma, P.V. (2001). Suśruta-Saṃhitā with English translation of text and Ḍalhaṇa's commentary along with critical notes. Vol ĪI (Kalpasthāna and Uttaratantra). Varanasi, India: Chaukhambha Visvabharati Oriental. pp. 202–204.
16. Deshpande, V. (2000). "Ophthalmic surgery: a chapter in the history of Sino-Indian medical contacts". Bulletin of the School of Oriental and African Studies. 63 (3): 370–388. doi:10.1017/S0041977X00008454. S2CID 162655091. See also Deshpande, V. (1999). "Indian influences on early Chinese ophthalmology: glaucoma as a case study". Bulletin of the School of Oriental and African Studies. 62 (22): 306–322. doi:10.1017/S0041977X00016724. S2CID 162306288.
17. Aur. Cor. Celsus (1831) [1769]. "Book 7, chapter 7. On the diseases of the eyes, and those which are cured by manual operations". De Medicina [On Medicine]. De medicina.English & Latin. Vol. 2. Translated by Lee, Alex. London: E. Cox. pp. 257–261. from the original on 2023-02-28. Retrieved 2023-02-28. Translated from L.Targa's 1769 edition, includes the original Latin text.
18. Urabe, H. (September 1976). "[Classification of ringworm infections (author's transl)]". Nihon Hifuka Gakkai Zasshi. The Japanese Journal of Dermatology. 86 (10): 573–581. PMID 1034789.
19. Magner, L.N. (1992). A History of Medicine. CRC Press. p. 91.
20. Leffler, C.T.; Hadi, T.M.; Udupa, A.; Schwartz, S.G.; Schwartz, D. (2016). "A medieval fallacy: the crystalline lens in the center of the eye". Clinical Ophthalmology. 10 (10): 649–662. doi:10.2147/OPTH.S100708. PMC 4833360. PMID 27114699.
21. McKissack, P; McKissack, F. (1995). The Royal Kingdoms of Ghana, Mali, and Songhay Life in Medieval Africa. Macmillan. p. 104. ISBN 978-0-8050-4259-7.
22. Thompson, E.E. (January 1965). "Primitive African Medical Lore and Witchcraft". Bulletin of the Medical Library Association. 53 (1): 80–94. PMC 198231. PMID 14223742.
23. (PDF). EuroTimes. September 2005. p. 11. Archived from the original (PDF) on 26 July 2011. Retrieved 22 September 2009.
24. "Toric Lens Implants". odpcli.com. Pacific Cataract and Laser Institute. from the original on 2019-10-09. Retrieved 2019-10-09.
25. Bergman WC, Schulz RA, Davis DS (September 2009). "Factors influencing the genesis of neurosurgical technology". Neurosurgical Focus. 27 (3): E3. doi:10.3171/2009.6.FOCUS09117. PMID 19722817.
26. Savage-Smith, E. (August 2000). "The practice of surgery in Islamic lands: myth and reality". Social History of Medicine. 13 (2): 307–321. doi:10.1093/shm/13.2.307. PMID 14535259.
27. Finger, S. (1994). Origins of Neuroscience: A History of Explorations Into Brain Function. Oxford University Press. p. 70. ISBN 978-0-19-514694-3.
28. Leffler, CT; Hogewind, B.F. (2023). "Jacques Daviel performed the first documented planned primary cataract extraction on Sep. 18, 1750". Eye. Dec. 6, 2023 (7): 1392–1393. doi:10.1038/s41433-023-02874-5. PMC 11076578. PMID 38057561.
29. Leffler CT, Wainsztein RD (2016). "The first cataract surgeons in Latin America: 1611-1830". Clinical Ophthalmology. 10: 679–694. doi:10.2147/OPTH.S105825. PMC 4841434. PMID 27143845.
30. Leffler CT, Schwartz SG, Grzybowski A, Braich PS (2015). "The first cataract surgeons in Anglo-America". Survey of Ophthalmology. 60 (1): 86–92. doi:10.1016/j.survophthal.2014.08.002. PMC 4262555. PMID 25444521.
31. Leffler, C.T.; Letocha, C.E.; Pierson, K.; Schwartz, S.G. (2017). "Aspiration of cataract in 1815 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania". Digital Journal of Ophthalmology. 23 (4): 4–7. doi:10.5693/djo.01.2017.10.001. PMC 5791631. PMID 29403333.
32. Badrinath, S.S.; Biswas, J.; Badrinath, Vasanthi (2004-10-10). . The Hindu. Archived from the original on 2005-01-18.
33. Goerig, M.; Bacon, D; van Zundert, A. (May–June 2012). "Carl Koller, cocaine, and local anesthesia: some less known and forgotten facts". Regional Anesthesia and Pain Medicine. 37 (3): 318–24. doi:10.1097/AAP.0b013e31825051f3. PMID 22531385. S2CID 205432874.
34. Altman, A.J.; Albert, D.M.; Fournier, G.A. (January–February 1985). "Cocaine's use in ophthalmology: our 100-year heritage". Survey of Ophthalmology. 29 (4): 300–6. doi:10.1016/0039-6257(85)90154-7. PMID 3885453.
35. Toczolowski, J. (July 1993). "Thirty years of cryoophthalmology". Ann. Ophthalmol. 25 (7): 254–6. PMID 8363292.
36. Meadow, Norman B. (15 October 2005). "Cryotherapy: A fall from grace, but not a crash". Ophthalmology Times.
37. Singh, Vivek Mahendrapratap; Ramappa, Muralidhar; Murthy, Somasheila; Rostov, Audrey Talley (January 2022). "Toric intraocular lenses: Expanding indications and preoperative and surgical considerations to improve outcomes". Indian J Ophthalmol. 70 (1): 10–23. doi:10.4103/ijo.IJO_1785_21. PMC 8917572. PMID 34937203.
38. Moshirfar, Majid; Milner, Dallin; Patel, Bhupendra C. (June 21, 2022). "Cataract Surgery". www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov. National Center for Biotechnology Information. PMID 32644679. from the original on 24 February 2023. Retrieved 8 February 2023.
39. Khoramnia, R.; Auffarth, G.; Łabuz, G.; Pettit, G.; Suryakumar, R. (19 January 2022). "Refractive Outcomes after Cataract Surgery". Diagnostics. 12 (2). Basel: 243. doi:10.3390/diagnostics12020243. PMC 8870878. PMID 35204334.
40. Ramappa, Muralidhar; Singh, Vivek Mahendrapratap; Murthy, SomasheilaI; Rostov, AudreyTalley (2022). "Toric intraocular lenses: Expanding indications and preoperative and surgical considerations to improve outcomes". Indian Journal of Ophthalmology. 70 (1): 10–23. doi:10.4103/ijo.IJO_1785_21. ISSN 0301-4738. PMC 8917572. PMID 34937203.
41. "American Academy of Ophthalmology News". www.aao.org. 5 April 2006. ^{[permanent dead link]}
42. Lindstrom, Richard L. (10 February 2021). "Future of cataract surgery seems promising". occular surgery news. Healio. from the original on 16 February 2023. Retrieved 15 February 2023.