Good conduct time allowance controversy

The good conduct time allowance (GCTA) controversy started in August 2019 involving the employees of the Bureau of Corrections (BuCor). It begins with Bureau of Corrections Director General Nicanor Faeldon and several other government officials signing the document containing the release of former Calauan, Laguna Mayor Antonio Sanchez, the prime suspect in the rape and murder of Eileen Sarmenta and her friend Allan Gomez in 1993, and the release of Josman Aznar, Ariel Balansag, Alberto Caño and James Anthony Uy, the 4 suspects in the rape and murder of sisters Marijoy and Jacqueline Chiong in 1997, citing "good conduct."

New Bilibid Prison where both Antonio Sanchez and the suspects of Chiong sisters murders are incarcerated

The aftermath of release of convicts through GCTA subsequently led to investigation regarding the GCTA and to the BuCor personnel involved in the controversy.

Background

The Good Conduct Time Allowance bill, also known as Republic Act No. 10592, was approved by the Congress and was signed by then-President Benigno Aquino III on May 29, 2013.^[1][2]

Controversies

 

Faeldon was mainly involved in the controversy

Planned release of Antonio Sanchez

Further information: Murders of Eileen Sarmenta and Allan Gomez

In August 2019, news reports stated that former Calauan, Laguna Mayor Antonio Sanchez, the suspect of raping and murdering Eileen Sarmenta and Allan Gomez in 1993, could have walked free from prison after spending 25 years in prison,^[3] according to a document bearing the signature of Bureau of Corrections director Nicanor Faeldon.^[4] The document said the release order was for one Antonio Leyza Sanchez, "who was found to have served 40 years upon retroactive application of RA No. 10592 and was certified to have no other legal cause to be further detained, shall be released from confinement." RA 10592 is the law allowing convicts an early release based on good conduct time allowance (GCTA).^[5]

On August 22, 2019, Sanchez, wearing formal outfit, is seen walking inside the prison along with the bodyguards.^[6] A social media post also claimed that Sanchez is spotted in his house in Calauan, Laguna two months ago.^[7] The impending release of Sanchez sparked nationwide outrage and condemnation. Prior to the issue, questions were raised over how could he qualify for good conduct when he was caught of seizing various items inside the prison such as P1.5 million worth of methamphetamine (shabu) hidden in a statue of the Blessed Virgin Mary in 2010 and an air-conditioning unit and flat-screen TV in 2015.^[8] Despite the outrage, BuCor Director General Nicanor Faeldon has changed tune and said Sanchez may be disqualified from the good conduct and time allowance (GCTA) rule based on several grounds.^[9]

On August 23, University of the Philippines Los Baños, the alma mater of Sarmenta and Gomez, held a rally to oppose the Sanchez's release. Among there present is the mother of Allan Gomez. Despite the Duterte administration denies the role of Sanchez release,^[10][11] Duterte's name can be seen written on their placards.^[12] The Supreme Court of the Philippines (SC), in a statement by spokesperson Brian Hosaka, denied ordering the release of Sanchez when it ruled on the retroactive application of RA 10592.^[13] Sanchez has maintained his innocence for the 1993 rape-slay of Sarmenta and the murder of Gomez and said he deserved to be freed.^[14] On August 26, President Rodrigo Duterte ordered Justice Secretary Menardo Guevarra and Bureau of Corrections chief Nicanor Faeldon not to release convicted rapist-murderer Antonio Sanchez.^[15]

Iluminada Gomez (The Mother of Allan Gomez) Said That The Gomez Family & The Sarmenta Family Has Read The Long Lost Paper That Contains The Letter of Former President Fidel Ramos That Written in August 1993 When He Was Condoling With Them Along With His Promise That The Government Would Do Anything To Give Financial Assistance to Them & Other Needs Mostly,Justice to Their Childrens & Holding Those Persons Accountable For The Double Murder of The Both 2 UP Los Baños Students in Which Mrs. Gomez Shown to The GMA News in August 2019.

On September 2, 2019, The Senate Blue Ribbon Committee holds a joint probe into the supposed early release of rape and murder convict Former Mayor Antonio Sanchez and the controversial Good Conduct Time Allowance (GCTA) Law.^[16] Bureau of Corrections chief Nicanor Faeldon confirms that George Medialdea, Rogelio Corcolon and Zoilo Ama, the three men who were convicted for the June 1993 rape and killing of Sarmenta and Gomez were already dead in jail.^[17] Senator Risa Hontiveros said that there are indications of GCTA system "is being corrupted" like the case of Sanchez.^[18]

On September 3, 2019, The family of rape and murder convict and former Calauan, Laguna Mayor Antonio Sanchez showed up at the Senate for the resumption of the probe into the controversy surrounding the possible release of their patriarch.^[19] The Sanchez family has maintain their intention that they will not pay the ₱12.6-million court-mandated damages to the families of Eileen Sarmenta and Allan Gomez who were murdered in 1993.^[20] Board of Pardons and Parole (BPP) executive director Reynaldo Bayang revealed in a Senate inquiry that Presidential spokesperson Salvador Panelo, who served as Sanchez's defense counsel in the high-profile 1993 Sarmenta-Gomez rape-slay case, wrote the BPP regarding Sanchez's application for executive clemency in a letter dated February 26.^[21] Presidential Spokesperson Salvador Panelo has confirmed a meeting with the family of his former client, convicted rapist-killer Antonio Sanchez, in Malacañang earlier this year.^[22] President Rodrigo Duterte has fired Bureau of Corrections chief Nicanor Faeldon after the latter approved the release of Sanchez.^[23][24]

The release of Chiong murders suspects

Further information: Chiong murder case

On August 30, 2019, Senator Panfilo Lacson stated that some of the convicts of the 1997 murder of the Chiong sisters are now out of prison.^[25] Faeldon has confirmed the release of Josman Aznar, Ariel Balansag, Alberto Caño and James Anthony Uy, the four persons who were convicted for the 1997 murder of the Chiong sisters.^[26] On September 4, President Rodrigo Duterte has fired Bureau of Corrections chief Nicanor Faeldon after the latter approved the release of three convicts in the murder case.^[23][24] On September 5, Chiong sisters' parents has called Duterte to return the three convicts back to prison.^[27] Eventually, the Chiong sisters' parents thanked to the President when the news of Duterte announcing that surrender of the released convicts for good conduct.^[27] The parents are also called for the investigation of Faeldon for his actions,^[27] in which Faeldon would be fired from his post by President Duterte.^[28]

On September 6, Ariel Balansag and Alberto Caño, the two of the three convicts of the Chiong sisters rape-slay case, who were released by virtue of the controversial Good Conduct Time Allowance Law, has been surrendered to the authorities.^[29][30][31] On September 18, James Anthony Uy and Josman Aznar, the last two of the four convicts of the Chiong sisters rape-slay case, has finally surrendered to the authorities.^[32]

Absolute pardon of Joseph Scott Pemberton

Further information: Killing of Jennifer Laude

The GCTA would also play a role in a different case several years later, as lawyer Rowena Garcia-Flores filed an urgent motion to the Olongapo City Regional Trial Court Branch 74 in late August 2020, requesting the release of Joseph Scott Pemberton, a US Marine convicted in the homicide of Filipino national Jennifer Laude in 2014. The grounds of the urgent motion stated that Pemberton should have been released from prison on July 31, 2020, after serving more than half of his 10-year sentence for displaying good conduct. This basis was provided by computations done by the BuCor, showing that the former US Marine has served a total sentence of eight years and ten months. In addition to this, Flores also stated that the BuCor did not give Pemberton any good conduct time allowances (GCTA) for over a year from October 22, 2014, to November 2015, stating that Pemberton did not receive any GCTA credits for the actual time he served from October 22 to December 18 in 2014, and for the months of June and July in 2020. However, the Laude family is opposed to the early release of Pemberton, stating that Pemberton was placed under solitary confinement, which does not count towards GCTA accreditation, and thus could not reasonably and justifiably claim good conduct.^[33]

Aside from the Laude family, the pardon sparked outrage in the LGBT community,^[34] as well as high-profile personalities from senators^[35] to celebrities.^[36] The hashtag #JusticeForJenniferLaude landed on the top trending spot in social media, where majority of the posts were critical of Duterte.^[37] Despite this, President Rodrigo Duterte officially gave Pemberton an absolute pardon on September 7, 2020.^[38] On September 11, 2020, several LGBT communities held a rally to protest Duterte's absolute of pardon of Joseph Scott Pemberton.^[39]

Other releases

Faeldon confirmed that at least 200 convicts have been released since June 2019.^[18] The data from BuCor showed that out of total 22,049 prisoners were freed since 2014 due to good conduct, there 1,914 prisoners who were been convicted with heinous crimes have been released.^[40][41] On September 4, 2019, Duterte ordered all 1,914 convicts to surrender themselves, giving an ultimatum of 15 days, otherwise the police will hunt them down.^[42][43] On September 10, the police reported that 180 convicts who were released based on the good conduct have been surrendered.^[44] On September 17, Duterte has offered a reward of P1 million to those who could capture the freed convicts "dead or alive".^[45]

On September 20, the DOJ ordered to stop the re-arrests of freed convicts after discovering the errors on the list submitted to the BuCor.^[46] Over 2,000 convicts have voluntarily surrendered to the government out of listed 1,914 individuals. Explaining the erroneous data, Justice Undersecretary Markk Perete said that 41 of whom "were freed with no legal obstacle" or not via GCTA.^[47] The record also shows that 354 inmates were released under the Aquino administration while 1,429 inmates under the Duterte administration.^[48]

Investigations regarding the GCTA

On September 6, an inmate's wife named Yolanda Camilon claimed that she was asked by BuCor employees a P50,000 in exchange for her husband's release from prison.^[49] On September 19, Bureau of Corrections (BuCor) Officer 3 Veronica Buño revealed that she exchanged conversation with Camilon via text messaging.^[50]

On September 9, Ombudsman Samuel Martires suspended BuCor officials for a period of six months.^[51]

Reactions

On September 4, 2019, Duterte fired Faeldon from his duty for his actions.^[52] He was replaced by former Manila jail warden Gerald Bantag.^[53] On September 18, Senator Leila de Lima said that the agency needs a real leader who can fight against corruption.^[54]

References

1. "REPUBLIC ACT No. 10592". The LawPhil Project.
2. "Antonio Sanchez of 1993 UPLB rape-murder case to get out soon – DOJ". Rappler.
3. "Convicted rapist-murderer Antonio Sanchez, over 10,000 inmates set for release | ANC Highlights". ABS-CBN News. YouTube.
4. "Faeldon signed Sanchez's release order, document shows". GMA News. Retrieved 2019-09-01.
5. "SONA: Sanchez, nakatakda umanong lumaya base sa isang release order na may pirma ni Faeldon". YouTube (in Tagalog). 30 August 2019. Retrieved September 1, 2019.
6. "Love triangle 'yan: Rapist-killer Sanchez nanindigang inosente siya". ABS-CBN News. Note: At 5:20
7. "LOOK: Convicted rapist-murderer Sanchez still detained in Bilibid". ABS-CBN News.
8. "Impending release of convicted rapist-murderer Sanchez sparks outrage". ABS-CBN News.
9. Arcilla, Jan (23 August 2019). "Sanchez's release hangs". The Manila Times.
10. "Panelo denies hand in looming release of rapist-killer Sanchez". The Manila Times. Retrieved August 22, 2019.
11. "Duterte spokesman denies hand in impending release of rapist-murderer Sanchez". ABS-CBN News.
12. "DOJ, BuCor: Sanchez ineligible for release". Philippine Daily Inquirer. Retrieved August 26, 2019.
13. Putla, Benjamin (23 August 2019). "No order to free ex-mayor Sanchez: SC". Philippine News Agency.
14. "EXCLUSIVE: Rape-slay convict Sanchez claims innocence, says he deserves to be freed". ABS-CBN News. 23 August 2019.
15. Kabiling, Genalyn; Quismorio, Ellson (26 August 2019). "Don't free Sanchez — Duterte". Manila Bulletin.^{[permanent dead link]}
16. "Faeldon says all convicts benefit from GCTA law". ABS-CBN News. September 2, 2019. Retrieved September 2, 2019.
17. "3 convicts in Sarmenta-Gomez slay case already dead —Faeldon". GMA News. September 2, 2019. Retrieved September 2, 2019.
18. "Good conduct time allowance may be for sale inside Bilibid – Hontiveros". Rappler.
19. "Sanchez family shows up at Senate's GCTA law probe". Philippine Daily Inquirer. September 3, 2019. Retrieved September 3, 2019.
20. "Sanchez family admits no intention of paying damages to Sarmenta, Gomez families". GMA News. September 3, 2019. Retrieved September 3, 2019.
21. "Parole official: Panelo wrote to pardons board on ex-client Sanchez's clemency plea". ABS-CBN News. September 3, 2019. Retrieved September 3, 2019.
22. "Panelo confirms Malacañang meeting with family of ex-client rapist-killer Sanchez". ABS-CBN News. September 3, 2019. Retrieved September 3, 2019.
23. "Duterte fires BuCor chief Faeldon". ABS-CBN News. September 4, 2019. Retrieved September 4, 2019.
24. "Duterte fires Faeldon amid release of Chiong convicts, Sanchez mess". GMA News. September 4, 2019. Retrieved September 4, 2019.
25. "Lacson: Some convicts in Chiong sisters murder case now out of prison". Rappler.
26. "Faeldon confirms release of 3 convicts in Chiong sisters' rape-slay". ABS-CBN News. September 2, 2019. Retrieved September 2, 2019.
27. "Pagbalik sa Bilibid ng 3 nahatulan sa Chiong rape-slay ipinanawagan | TV Patrol". ABS-CBN News. YouTube.
28. "Duterte fires BuCor chief Faeldon". ABS-CBN News.
29. "2 of 3 convicts in Chiong sisters rape-slay case surrender to authorities". GMA News. September 7, 2019. Retrieved September 7, 2019.
30. "2 convicts in Chiong sisters' rape-slay surrender following early release". ABS-CBN News. September 7, 2019. Retrieved September 7, 2019.
31. "2 Chiong murder convicts out on GCTA surrender to authorities". Rappler. September 7, 2019. Retrieved September 7, 2019.
32. "Two more convicts in Chiong sisters' rape-slay surrender". Manila Bulletin. September 18, 2019. Retrieved September 18, 2019.^{[permanent dead link]}
33. "Pemberton counsel seeks early release —". Asian Journal News. 2020-08-29. Retrieved 2020-09-07.
34. Cabato, Regine. "Philippines' Duterte pardons U.S. Marine convicted of murdering transgender woman" – via www.washingtonpost.com.
35. "'An affront to the Filipino people': Opposition senators slam Pemberton pardon". Rappler. 7 September 2020.
36. Lalu, Gabriel Pabico (September 8, 2020). "Showbiz figures join critics in denouncing absolute pardon of Pemberton". INQUIRER.net.
37. "#JusticeForJenniferLaude: Filipinos decry pardon for US soldier Pemberton". Rappler. 7 September 2020.
38. "Duterte grants 'absolute pardon' to US soldier Pemberton". Rappler. 7 September 2020. Retrieved 2020-09-07.
39. "24 Oras Livestream: September 11, 2020 | Replay (Full Episode)". GMA News. YouTube. September 11, 2020. Retrieved September 12, 2020. Note: Go to 8:27-9:27 for the story.
40. "BuCor data show nearly 2,000 heinous crime convicts released early since 2014". ABS-CBN News.
41. "2 more Chiong murder convicts to surrender – DOJ". Rappler.
42. "Legal issues hound Duterte order for 1,914 convicts to surrender". Rappler.
43. . Philippine Daily Inquirer. Archived from the original on September 21, 2019. Retrieved September 21, 2019.{{cite news}}: CS1 maint: bot: original URL status unknown (link)
44. "PNP: 180 GCTA- freed convicts have surrendered as of September 10". UNTV News and Rescue.
45. "Duterte offers P1M bounty for capture of freed heinous crime convicts". The Philippine Star.
46. "Errors in GCTA list: DOJ orders stop to arrests of freed convicts". ABS-CBN News.
47. "BuCor list had 1,914 names, but 2,009 surrendered. What happens now?". The Philippine Star.
48. "Inmates released under GCTA from Aquino admin to Duterte presidency". Philippine Daily Inquirer.
49. "Inmate's wife says she's victim of 'GCTA for sale'". Rappler.
50. "BuCor officer admits texting 'GCTA-for-sale' witness". Philippine Daily Inquirer.
51. "Ombudsman suspends BuCor officials accused in 'GCTA for sale'". Rappler.
52. "Duterte fires Nicanor Faeldon as BuCor chief". Rappler.
53. "Duterte names ex-Manila jail warden Bantag as new BuCor chief". The Philippine Star.
54. "Ang kailangan ng BuCor ay totoong lider na kayang labanan ang korapsyon na sumira sa kanila, hindi isang mamamatay tao na walang ibang alam na pamamaraan kundi dahas. With him at the helm, we can export more senseless killings and zero progresses towards reforms. Sen. Bong Go wanted a killer at the BuCor helm, and his boss made it happen". Facebook. News5. Archived from the original on September 21, 2019.