Craigiehall

Craigiehall is a late-17th-century country house, which until 2015 served as the Headquarters of the British Army in Scotland. It is located close to Cramond, around 9 km (5.6 mi) west of central Edinburgh, Scotland.

Craigiehall
Old view of Craigiehall, showing the house with Bruce's roof and chimneys in place, and the pediment still on Burn's extension (right)
General information
Town or city	Near Edinburgh
Country	Scotland
Construction started	c. 1695
Completed	1699
Client	William Johnstone, 2nd Earl of Annandale
Design and construction
Architect(s)	Sir William Bruce

Craigiehall was designed by Sir William Bruce, with input from James Smith,^[1] and completed in 1699 for the Earl of Annandale, who had recently acquired the Craigie estate through marriage. It is a good surviving example of one of Bruce's smaller houses, and set a pattern for such villas in the Edinburgh area for the 18th century.^[2]

It was later the home of Charles Hope-Weir, who made several improvements to the estate policies. Craigiehall was extended several times, before being sold to the Earl of Rosebery, who leased out the property. It was briefly a hotel and country club, before being requisitioned by the Army at the outbreak of the Second World War. Craigiehall continues to be used as the Army's Scottish Headquarters. The house has been protected as a category A listed building since 1971, as a substantial 17th-century classical house, worked on by several notable architects.^[3]

Early history

The estate of Craigie is recorded as belonging to one John de Craigie in the reign of David I (1124–1153). In 1387 the estate passed by marriage to John Stewart, son of Sir Robert Stewart of Durisdeer. James Stewart, Earl of Arran stayed at the house in June 1593 hoping to regain royal favour.^[4] The Stewarts sold the estate, which by this time had a tower house, in 1643 to John Fairholm, treasurer to the City of Edinburgh.^[5] In 1682 John Fairholm's granddaughter Sophia, aged only 14, married William Johnstone, 2nd Earl of Annandale, and Craigiehall changed ownership again.^[5] Only two built features on the estate date from before this time; the 17th century east sundial, and the ruined doocot, or pigeon house, dated 1672. The east sundial is one of only 25 obelisk-type sundials in Scotland, and was re-erected to the east of the house in 1965, after being found in a field to the south of the house.^[6][7]

The Bruce house

 

Sir William Bruce, architect of Craigiehall.

The couple set about planning a new house to replace the aging tower house, and in 1694 the Earl contacted Sir William Bruce, who promised to design "a convenient little house, gardings and courts".^[8] The property was surveyed by John Adair, and the old tower house was taken down.^[9] The survey took the place of a site visit by Bruce, who was at this time under virtual house arrest, due to his political leanings, and suspected Jacobite sympathies.^[10] Design submissions were also obtained from James Smith and Robert Mylne. Smith's scheme was judged too small and irregular by Bruce, who urged the Earl to agree to his own "modish and regullar designe".^[11] However, the house as built by Bruce is partially based on Smith's early design.^[12] Before work on the house commenced, a courtyard, 500 by 400 feet (150 by 120 m) across, was laid out, establishing the formal arrangement in which the house would sit.^[10] On 16 February 1698, a contract was signed between Lord Annandale and the mason Thomas Bauchop, for a house 64 by 46 feet (20 by 14 m), and 28 feet (8.5 m) high, all "according to the modell of wood and draught signed by Sir William Bruce of Kinross".^[13]

Bruce's new house was complete by 1699, and was worked on by many of the same craftsmen who were engaged by Bruce at nearby Hopetoun House, which was under construction at the same time. Craftsmen included the plasterers John McKay and Thomas Albur, cabinet maker William Scott, plumber Joseph Foster, smith Alexander Gardener, and the wright Andrew Barclay.^[14] The staircase, with its wrought-iron balustrade decorated with roses, thistles, tulips and oak leaves, bears many similarities to the one at Caroline Park, Granton,^[15] and was the work of the smiths James Storrie and James Horne.^[16]

The building comprises a compact, three-storey house, in the Dutch-classical style which was introduced into England by Sir Roger Pratt, and is typical of Bruce's work.^[15] The six-bay entrance front has a two-bay projecting central section, surmounted by a pediment topped by three pineapples, of which one remains. The tympanum is carved with the coat of arms of the Earl and his wife, with their initials (WEA and SCA for William, Earl of Annandale, and Sophia Countess of Annandale) and the date 1699. The roof behind was bell-cast, with a cupola and four tall chimneys symmetrically placed, although this was replaced in the 1950s.^[15] The centrally placed entrance is reached by steps, and surmounted by carved decorations. The garden front is similar, and is also topped by a decorated pediment.^[17] Once the house was complete, two wings connected by curved passages were added. These incorporated additional accommodation and a library, but the passages and south wing were later demolished.^[16]

Inside, Bruce planned two apartments: a state apartment, comprising dining room, drawing room, bedroom and dressing room, with a second smaller apartment to the south.^[15] Bruce's panelling survives in part of the south apartment, which was later turned into a single room. The chimneypiece and wood carving in the "Blue Room" is also 17th century.^[18] The centrally placed stairwell, lighted from above, would be developed more fully by Bruce in his design for Hopetoun House.^[1]

The walled garden to the north-east was built in 1708 by Alexander McGill, to designs by the Earl of Mar, who also designed the gate piers and garden buildings, and supplied statuary.^[16] The garden may have been balanced by a similar walled garden to the south-east of the house. No trace is now visible, but a second garden is shown on 18th century maps of the area, and would have been consistent with Bruce's symmetrical layout.^[19]

Charles Hope-Weir's improvements

 

Ruins of the grotto and bath house, by the River Almond

In 1741, the 2nd Marquis of Annandale left Craigiehall to his nephew, Charles Hope-Weir (1710–1791), second son of Charles Hope, 1st Earl of Hopetoun. Hope-Weir travelled to Europe on the grand tour in 1754-55, taking with him the young architect Robert Adam, and was inspired to improve the Craigiehall policies on his return. A walled forecourt and the formal gardens in front of the house were removed.^[16][18] He also planted numerous trees across the estate, laid out avenues, and had several garden buildings constructed. A lake was excavated, and a new bridge over the River Almond was constructed to link the neighbouring estate of Lennie, which Hope-Weir had bought in 1750.

Bridge, grotto and bath house

The rustic arched Grotto Bridge is dated 1757. It bears Hope-Weir's initials, with the inscription UTILI DULCI, taken from Horace, and translatable as "the useful with the sweet". It was built to a design by "J. Adam", either John or James, Robert's brothers.^[20] The bridge spans a particularly picturesque section of the Almond, with rapids flowing under the single span.

Upstream from the bridge is a grotto and bath house, built in a similar rustic style and presumably by the same architect. The bath house is a square vaulted chamber, with a plunge pool fed by river water. The upper chamber comprises a circular saloon with windows, although this is now roofless and in poor condition. The original roof was a conical thatched structure, and a niche on the exterior wall may have housed a statue.^[20][21]

Craigiehall Temple

An avenue of oak trees runs up Lennie Hill from the Grotto Bridge. At the summit, Hope-Weir had an ornamental temple built in 1759, commanding wide views of the expanded estate and beyond.^[22] Craigiehall Temple was a circular two-storey structure, with a stair tower at the rear and a pedimented portico on the front. The segmental pediment bears the arms of the 1st Marquess of Annandale, and so predates the temple. In The Buildings of Scotland: Edinburgh, it is suggested that this portico may have formed part of a gate to the forecourt of the house. If so, it may have been made by Alexander McGill, to a design by the Earl of Mar.^[18] It was incorporated into the temple, which was again to the design of one of the Adam brothers. A Latin inscription on the temple, again from Horace, can be translated as "live happy while you can among joyful things". The structure was burned by vandals in the early 1970s, and in 1977 the upper storey was removed as a hazard to aviation, following the development of a new longer runway at nearby Edinburgh Airport.^[22] The remaining storey was renovated, and now forms part of a private house.^[22]

Extensions and additions

In 1818 Hope-Weir's grandson James Joseph Hope-Vere FRSE (1785–1843), who had inherited the estate in 1811, asked the Edinburgh architect Thomas Brown to provide designs for an attic extension, although this was never carried out.^[23] Ten years later, William Burn was commissioned by James Joseph to design a new north wing, incorporating a dining room, with new kitchens below and bedrooms above.^[23] The front of this extension was topped by a pediment matching Bruce's original, complete with pineapples, although this too was removed in the 1950s. The rear is bowed, with a curved stair led down to the garden at the rear. Plans for a matching wing to the south were never carried out.^[23] Burn also remodelled the interior, creating a large drawing room from the rooms of the south apartment.^[18]

James' son William Edward Hope-Vere (1824–1872) commissioned David Bryce to design a further northern extension in 1853, forming a servant's range, and to remodel some of the interiors.^[23] William also rebuilt the 18th century stable court and clock tower between 1843 and 1872.^[24] It was William's son Colonel James Hope-Vere (1858–1933) who sold the estate, having inherited the estate on his father's death in 1916, selling to the Earl of Rosebery for £85,000.^[25]

 

Archibald Primrose, 5th Earl of Rosebery, purchased Craigiehall for his son Neil in 1916.

Early 20th century

Lord Rosebery had purchased Craigiehall as a home for his second son Neil Primrose MP, who was killed, the following year, in Gaza during the First World War. In 1926 Rosebery therefore decided to lease the house and policies, although the agricultural lands continue to be farmed as part of Lord Rosebery's neighbouring Dalmeny estate.^[26] The lease was taken by Mr James Morton, an Edinburgh textile manufacturer, who commissioned Robert Lorimer to make various alterations, the property having stood empty for ten years. Lorimer added the oriel window on the south front, and modernised many of Bruce's remaining interiors.^[18] A water turbine was constructed in the bath house to provide electricity.^[27]

In 1933 Craigiehall was re-let to Ernest Thompson, who turned Craigiehall into the Riverside Hotel and Country Club. Thompson operated the 25-room hotel and golf course successfully until 1939, when Craigiehall, like many other country houses, was requisitioned for the use of the armed forces.^[28]

Army Headquarters Scotland

Various regiments were stationed at Craigiehall Camp during the Second World War, including Royal Artillery, Royal Signals, and anti-aircraft units.^[29] On 12 May 1945, the surrender of German forces in Norway was negotiated and signed at Craigiehall.^[30] A rumour, related in Major Innes' book, states that Rudolf Hess was brought to Craigiehall after he flew to Scotland in 1941 to contact the Duke of Hamilton. This rumour is based on a photograph of Hess supposedly once on display at Craigiehall, although the story is not corroborated.^[31]

After the war, Ernest Thompson exercised an option of his lease allowing him to buy Craigiehall from Lord Rosebery. However, the army had still not moved out, and in 1948 offered to purchase the property from Thompson, finally completing the sale in 1951.^[32] Through the early 1950s the Army made alterations to Craigiehall. The original roof was replaced in 1953 due to woodworm, and extra rooms added in the attic. This resulted in the loss of Bruce's chimneys, and Burn's dining room pediment.^[32] Internally the house was redecorated, it being considered that there was too little of the original scheme remaining to allow restoration. Another extension was added, this time to the north-west, to house the staff of the General Officer Commanding-in-Chief (GOC) in Scotland.^[32]

 

Insignia of the 2nd Division of the British Army.

Elsewhere on the Camp, the Army began replacing the wartime Nissen huts with more permanent structures. New barracks opened in 1955, and the Headquarters of the Army in Scotland arrived the same year from Edinburgh Castle. Further land was purchased from Lord Rosebery and married quarters were built close to the river.^[33] In 1966, a purpose-built office block, by architects Bowhill Gibson and Laing, was constructed within the walled garden, and named Annandale Block in honour of the builder of Craigiehall.^[34] Craigiehall Camp was also the site of a Cold War Anti-Aircraft Operations Room, built in the 1950s.^[35] The two-storey, reinforced concrete structure was listed in 2016 as the best surviving example of its type in Scotland.^[36]

Following restructuring, the army in Scotland became part of the 2nd Division, whose headquarters moved to Craigiehall Camp from York. Craigiehall itself was formerly the HQ of the Black Watch regiment, and now serves as the Officers' Mess for the camp.^[37] In 2007, around 250 people, including civilian and military personnel, were employed at Craigiehall.^[38] In March 2007, the Ministry of Defence announced plans for a new headquarters building at Craigiehall. Under the plans, the existing Annandale Block would be demolished, and the walled garden in which it stands would be restored. The new building was to be constructed elsewhere on the grounds, and was granted planning permission in September 2007.^[38] On 14 December 2007, defence ministers from eight NATO countries met at Craigiehall to discuss the role of NATO troops involved in Afghanistan. Among the ministers attending were Des Browne from the UK, Robert Gates from the US, and Joel Fitzgibbon from Australia.^[39] A protest march was organised, attracting around 30 demonstrators.^[40]

In July 2011, following a Defence Basing Review carried out by the Ministry of Defence, it was announced that Craigiehall, along with Dreghorn Barracks and Redford Barracks also in Edinburgh, would be closing in 2014–2015. The review proposed a single UK Support Command, based at Aldershot, to replace three existing divisional headquarters including HQ 2nd Division, based at Craigiehall, which would be disbanded in 2012. Other units at Craigiehall would form part of a new multi-role brigade to be based at Kirknewton. Craigiehall Camp would be earmarked for disposal.^[41][42] Although plans to develop Kirknewton as an Army barracks were scrapped in March 2013,^[43] in early 2016, the UK Government announced that the site was one of 12 that will be sold as part of the strategy for the MOD estate. No date for the sale was given.^[44] In 2014 Army Headquarters Scotland was merged with 51st Infantry Brigade at Forthside Barracks, Stirling.^[45] The site remained home to Edinburgh Troop of 521 EOD Squadron, 11 Explosive Ordnance Disposal and Search Regiment RLC,^[46] until it closed in March 2019.^[47] The site was earmarked for disposal by 2022.^[48]

Notes

1. Lowrey, p.6
2. Gifford, et al., pp.55-56
3. Historic Environment Scotland. "Craigiehall, excluding 1853 and 20th century additions to the north, South Queensferry (Category A Listed Building) (LB45432)". Retrieved 27 March 2019.
4. Calendar State Papers Scotland, vol. 11 (Edinburgh, 1936), p. 100.
5. Innes, p.1
6. Innes, p.53
7. "Craigiehall House, East Sundial, NMRS Number: NT17NE 30". Royal Commission on the Ancient and Historical Monuments of Scotland (RCAHMS). Retrieved 7 September 2007.
8. Sir William Bruce to Lord Annandale, 3 September 1694, quoted in Macaulay, p.19
9. Innes, p.7
10. Lowrey, p.2
11. Sir William Bruce to Lord Annandale, 14 September 1694, quoted in Lowrey, p.3
12. Lowrey, p.3
13. Contract between Lord Annandale and Thomas Bauchop, 16 February 1698, quoted in Macaulay, p.19
14. Innes, p.18
15. Gifford, et al., p.591
16. Lowrey, p.5
17. Innes, p.20
18. Gifford, et al., p.592
19. Innes, p.55
20. Innes, pp.42-43
21. "Craigiehall House, Grotto, NMRS Number: NT17NE 42". RCAHMS. Retrieved 27 September 2007.
22. Innes, pp.37-41
23. Innes, p.30
24. Innes, p.50
25. Innes, pp.35-6
26. Innes, p.61
27. Innes, p.62
28. Innes, p.64
29. Innes, himself a retired Major, gives a more comprehensive list of units, although he notes that records are vague.
30. Innes, p.78
31. Innes, p.76
32. Innes, p.65
33. Innes, p.67
34. Innes, pp.70-71
35. "Craigiehall - 3 Group, 12 Brigade AAOR". Subterranea Britannica. Retrieved 9 October 2007.
36. "Anti-Aircraft Operations Room, including radio transmission mast, Craigiehall, South Queensferry. LB52396". Historic Environment Scotland. Retrieved 21 April 2017.
37. . Archived from the original on 28 July 2006. Retrieved 5 September 2007.
38. "Army marches into future as new base gets go-ahead". The Scotsman. 13 September 2007. Retrieved 30 March 2009.
39. Garamone, Jim (14 December 2007). "U.S. to Draft Integrated Plan for Afghan Help". American Forces Press Service. Retrieved 21 December 2007.
40. ""NATO out of Afghanistan" protest". Scotland Independent Media Centre. 14 December 2007. Archived from the original on 13 July 2012. Retrieved 21 December 2007.
41. "Defence Basing Review: Headline Decisions (Standard Note SN06038)" (PDF). House of Commons Library. 19 July 2011.
42. "Local fury at plan to close all the capital's historic army bases". Edinburgh Evening News. 19 July 2011.
43. "BBC News - Army bases: Fewer than expected troops to return to Scotland". Bbc.co.uk. 5 March 2013. Retrieved 13 April 2014.
44. "Defence Minister Mark Lancaster announces release of MOD sites for development". Retrieved 18 January 2016.
45. "51st Infantry Brigade and HQ Scotland". Ministry of Defence. Retrieved 7 November 2016.
46. "A Better Defence Estate November 2016" (PDF). Ministry of Defence. p. 18. Retrieved 1 April 2021.
47. "'End Of An Era For Craigiehall': Former Army Headquarters In Scotland Closes". Forces.net. BFBS. 6 March 2019. Retrieved 12 January 2022.
48. "Disposal database: House of Commons report". Retrieved 26 November 2021.

References

• Fenwick, Hubert (1970) Architect Royal: the Life and Work of Sir William Bruce. Roundwood Press. ISBN 0-900093-12-9
• Gifford, John, McWilliam, Colin & Walker, David (1984) Edinburgh. The Buildings of Scotland. Yale. ISBN 0-300-09672-0
• Innes, C. B. (1996) Craigiehall: The story of a fine Scots country house. Army Headquarters Scotland.
• Lowrey, John (1988) "Sir William Bruce and his circle at Craigiehall 1694-1708". in Frew, John & Jones, David (eds.) Aspects of Scottish Classicism. St Andrews Studies in the history of Scottish Architecture and Design. ISBN 0-9514518-0-4
• Macaulay, James (1987) The Classical Country House in Scotland 1600-1800. Faber & Faber. ISBN 0-571-14616-3
• "Craigiehall House, NT17NE 29". CANMORE. RCAHMS. Retrieved 1 October 2007.
• Historic Environment Scotland. "Craigiehall (GDL00113)". Inventory of Gardens and Designed Landscapes. Retrieved 27 March 2019.

External links

• , British Army web site
• , Ministry of Defence web site

55°57′59″N 3°20′08″W / 55.966437°N 3.335491°W / 55.966437; -3.335491