Compulsive buying disorder

Compulsive buying disorder (CBD) is characterized by an obsession with shopping and buying behavior that causes adverse consequences. It "is experienced as a recurring, compelling and irresistible–uncontrollable urge, in acquiring goods that lack practical utility and very low cost^[1] resulting in excessive, expensive and time-consuming retail activity [that is] typically prompted by negative affectivity" and results in "gross social, personal and/or financial difficulties".^[2] Most people with CBD meet the criteria for a personality disorder. Compulsive buying can also be found among people with Parkinson's disease^[3] or frontotemporal dementia.^[4][5]

Compulsive buying-shopping disorder is classified by ICD-11 among "other specified impulse control disorders".^[5] Several authors have considered compulsive shopping rather as a variety of dependence disorder.^[6]

History

According to German physician Max Nordau, French psychiatrist Valentin Magnan coined the term oniomania in the 1892 German translation of his Psychiatric Lectures (Psychiatrische Vorlesungen).^[7] Magnan describes compulsive buying as a symptom of social degeneration.^[8] In his book Degeneration (1892), Nordau calls oniomania or "buying craze" a "stigma of degeneration".^[9] Emil Kraepelin described oniomania as of 1909,^[10] and he and Bleuler both included the syndrome in their influential early psychiatric textbooks.^[11] Kraepelin described oniomania as "a pathological desire to buy... without any actual need and in great quantities", considering it alongside kleptomania and other conditions that were thought to be related to impulsivity (of the type nowadays denoted impulse control disorders).^[5][12]

Relatively little interest seems to have been taken in collocating CBD as a distinct pathology until the 1990s.^[12][13] It has been suggested that even in the 21st century, compulsive shopping can be considered a barely recognised mental illness.^[14] Since 2019, ICD-11 (the 11th revision of the International Classification of Diseases) has classified it among "other specified impulse control disorders" (coded as 6C7Y), using the descriptor compulsive buying-shopping disorder.^[5]

Characteristics

CBD is characterized by an obsession with shopping and buying behavior that causes adverse consequences. According to Kellett and Bolton, it "is experienced as an irresistible–uncontrollable urge, resulting in excessive, expensive and time-consuming retail activity [that is] typically prompted by negative affectivity" and results in "gross social, personal and/or financial difficulties".^[2] What differentiates CBD from healthy shopping is the compulsive, destructive and chronic nature of the buying. Where shopping can be a positive route to self-expression, in excess it represents a dangerous threat.^[15]

CBD is frequently comorbid with mood, anxiety, substance abuse and eating disorders. People who score highly on compulsive-buying scales tend to understand their feelings poorly and have low tolerance for unpleasant psychological states such as negative moods.^[16] The onset of CBD occurs in the late teens and early twenties and is generally chronic. The phenomenon of compulsive buying tends to affect women rather than men. The aforementioned reports on this matter indicated that the dominance of the majority group is so great that it accounts for more than 90% of the affected demographic.^[17] Zadka and Olajossy suggest the presence of several similar tendencies between consumer-type mannerisms and pathologic consumption of psychoactive elements. These tendencies include a constant need to consume, personal dependence, and a tendency to lack a sense of self-control over behavior.^[18] Additionally, Zadka and Olajossy state that one could conclude that individuals suffering from the disorder are often in the second decade to fourth decade of their lives and exhibit mannerisms akin to neurotic personality and impulse-control disorders.^[19]

 

Compulsive buying disorder

CBD is similar to, but distinguished from, OCD hoarding and mania. Compulsive buying is not limited to people who spend beyond their means; it also includes people who spend an inordinate amount of time shopping or who chronically think about buying things but never purchase them. Promising treatments for CBD include medication such as selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs), and support groups such as Debtors Anonymous.^{[20][21][22][23]}

Research reveals that 1.8 to 8.1 percent of the general adult population have CBD and that while the usual onset is late adolescence or early adulthood, it is often recognized as a problem later in life.^[24]

Distinctions

Unlike normal consumers and hoarders, who derive excitement and focus on the items purchased, compulsive buyers gain excitement and focus on the acquisition process itself and not the item purchased^[25]

Compulsive buying disorder is tightly associated with excessive or poorly managed urges related to the purchase of the items and spending of currency in any form; digital, mobile, credit or cash.^[26]

Four phases have been identified in compulsive buying: anticipation, preparation, shopping, and spending. The first phase involves a preoccupation with purchasing a specific item or with shopping in general. The second phase the individual plans the shopping excursion. The third phase is the actual shopping event; while the fourth phase is completed by the feelings of excitement connected to spending money on their desired items.^[27]

The terms compulsive shopping, compulsive buying, and compulsive spending are often used interchangeably, but the behaviors they represent are in fact distinct.^[28] One may buy without shopping, and certainly shop without buying: of compulsive shoppers, some 30 percent described the act of buying itself as providing a buzz, irrespective of the goods purchased.^[29]

Causes

Compulsive buying can be found among people with Parkinson's disease^[3] or frontotemporal dementia.^[4][5]

CBD often has roots in early experience. Perfectionism, general impulsiveness and compulsiveness, dishonesty, insecurity, and the need to gain control have also been linked to the disorder.^[30][31] From a medical perspective, it can be concluded that impulse-control disorders are attributed to the desire for positive stimuli.^[19] The normal method of operation in a healthy brain is that the frontal cortex regulation handles the activity of reward. However, in individuals with behavioral disorders, this particular system malfunctions. Scientists have reported that compulsive buyers have significantly different activity in this area of the brain.^[19]

Compulsive buying seems to represent a search for self in people whose identity is neither firmly felt nor dependable, as indicated by the way purchases often provide social or personal identity-markers.^[32] Those with associated disorders such as PTSD/CPTSD,^[33] anxiety, depression and poor impulse control are particularly likely to attempt to treat symptoms of low self-esteem through compulsive shopping.^[34]

Others, however, object, stating that such psychological explanations for compulsive buying do not apply to all people with CBD.^[35]

Social conditions also play an important role in CBD, the rise of consumer culture contributing to the view of compulsive buying as a specifically postmodern addiction, particularly with regard to internet buying platforms.^[36]

Readily available credit cards enable casual spending beyond one's means, and some would suggest that the compulsive buyer should lock up or destroy credit cards altogether.^[37] Online shopping also facilitates CBD, with online auction addiction, used to escape feelings of depression or guilt, becoming a recognizable problem.^[38]

Materialism and image-seeking

A social psychological perspective suggests that compulsive buying may be seen as an exaggerated form of a more normal search for validation through purchasing.^[39] Also, pressures from the spread of materialist values and consumer culture over the recent decades can drive people into compulsive shopping.^[40]

Companies have adopted aggressive neuromarketing by associating the identification of a high social status with the purchasing of items. They strive to bring out such an individual as a sort of folk hero for having the ability to buy several items. As a result, according to Zadka and Olajossy, the act of shopping is then associated with the feeling of holding a higher social status or of climbing the social ranks. Zadka holds that these companies take advantage of the frailties of peoples' egos in an attempt to get them to spend their money.^[19]

Symptoms and course

Diagnostic criteria for compulsive buying have been proposed:

1. Over-preoccupation with buying.
2. Distress or impairment as a result of the activity.
3. Compulsive buying is not limited to hypomanic or manic episodes.^[41]
4. Constant obsessing with buying as well as being dissatisfied all the time.

While initially triggered by a perhaps mild need to feel special, the failure of compulsive shopping to actually meet such needs may lead to a vicious cycle of escalation,^[42] with them experiencing the highs and lows associated with other addictions.^[43] The 'high' of the purchasing may be followed by a sense of disappointment, and of guilt,^[44] precipitating a further cycle of impulse buying.^[45][46] With the now addicted person increasingly feeling negative emotions like anger and stress, they may attempt to self-medicate through further purchases,^[47] followed again by regret or depression once they return home,^[48] leading to an urge for buying more. The aforementioned symptoms are aggravated further by the availability of money through access to credit cards and easy bank loans.^[49]

As debt grows, the compulsive shopping may become a more secretive act.^[43] At the point where bought goods are hidden or destroyed, because the person concerned feels so ashamed of their addiction, the price of the addiction in mental, financial and emotional terms becomes even higher.^[50]

Individuals who can be considered addicted to shopping are observed to exhibit repetitive and obsessive urges to go buy items, especially when in the vicinity of an environment that supports this venture, such as a mall. In such locations, they mostly purchase things that are cheap and of low value mainly just to satisfy the urge to spend. Normally, these items end up being returned to the shop or disposed of entirely after a while. However, according to Zadka and Olajossy, this rarely works as these individuals are known to have low self-esteem.^[19]

Consequences

The consequences of compulsive buying, which may persist long after a spree, can be devastating, with marriages, long-term relationships, and jobs all feeling the strain.^[51] Further problems can include ruined credit history, theft or defalcation of money, defaulted loans, general financial trouble and in some cases bankruptcy or extreme debt, as well as anxiety and a sense of life spiraling out of control.^[52] The resulting stress can lead to physical health problems and ruined relationships, or even suicide.^[53]

Treatment

Treatment involves becoming conscious of the addiction through studying, therapy and group work. Research done by Michel Lejoyeux and Aviv Weinstein suggests that the best possible treatment for CBD is cognitive behavioral therapy. They suggest that a patient first be "evaluated for psychiatric comorbidity, especially with depression, so that appropriate pharmacological treatment can be instituted." Their research indicates that patients who received cognitive behavioral therapy over 10 weeks had reduced episodes of compulsive buying and spent less time shopping as opposed to patients who did not receive this treatment (251).

Lejoyeux and Weinstein also write about pharmacological treatment and studies that question the use of drugs on CBD. They declare "few controlled studies have assessed the effects of pharmacological treatment on compulsive buying, and none have shown any medication to be effective." (252) The most effective treatment is to attend therapy and group work in order to prevent continuation of this addiction.^[54][55]

Hague et al. reports that group therapy rendered the highest results as far as treatment of compulsive buying disorder is concerned. He states that group therapy contributed to about 72.8% in positive change in the reduction of urges of compulsive spending. Additionally, he notes that psychotherapy may not be the treatment of choice for all compulsive buying disorder patients since the suitability of the treatment method to the patient is also an important consideration. He holds that the treatments of the disorder are required to provide a certain reflection of the context in which this phenomenon manifests.^[56]

Selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors such as fluvoxamine and citalopram may be useful in the treatment of CBD, although current evidence is mixed.^[57][58] Opioid antagonists such as naltrexone and nalmefene are promising potential treatments for CBD.^[57] A review concluded that evidence is limited and insufficient to support their use at present, however.^[59] Naltrexone and nalmefene have also shown effectiveness in the treatment of gambling addiction, an associated disorder.^[59][60]

Historical examples

• Mary Todd Lincoln (1818–1882), wife of US president Abraham Lincoln, was addicted to shopping, running up (and concealing) large bills on credit, feeling manic glee at spending sprees, followed by depressive reactions in the face of the results.^[61]

See also

• Shopping addiction
• Money disorders
• Shopaholic (novels)
• Confessions of a Shopaholic (film)

References

1. Lejoyeux, Michel; Weinstein, Aviv (2010-08-01). "Compulsive Buying". The American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse. 36 (5): 248–253. doi:10.3109/00952990.2010.493590. ISSN 0095-2990. PMID 20560822. S2CID 207428225.
2. Kellett S., Bolton J. V. (2009). "Compulsive buying : A cognitive-behavioural model". Clinical Psychology and Psychotherapy. 16 (2): 83–99. doi:10.1002/cpp.585. PMID 19229837.
3. Bhattacharjee S (2018). "Impulse control disorders in Parkinson's disease: Review of pathophysiology, epidemiology, clinical features, management, and future challenges". Neurology India. 66 (4): 967–975. doi:10.4103/0028-3886.237019. PMID 30038082. S2CID 51712597.
4. Javor A, Koller M, Lee N, Chamberlain L, Ransmayr G (2013). "Neuromarketing and consumer neuroscience: contributions to neurology". BMC Neurology. 13: 13. doi:10.1186/1471-2377-13-13. PMC 3626833. PMID 23383650.
5. Müller A, Laskowski NM, Trotzke P, et al. (2021). "Proposed diagnostic criteria for compulsive buying-shopping disorder: A Delphi expert consensus study". Journal of Behavioral Addictions. 10 (2): 208–222. doi:10.1556/2006.2021.00013. PMC 8996806. PMID 33852420.
6. Croissant B, Croissant D (2007). "[Compulsive shopping--current considerations on classification and therapy]". Nervenarzt. 78 (5): 575–9. doi:10.1007/s00115-006-2214-8. PMID 17123121.
7. Max Nordau [1892]: Entartung, Herausgegeben, kommentiert und mit einem Nachwort versehen von Karin Tebben, Berlin u.a.: De Gruyter 2013, p. 38.
8. Valentin Magnan: Psychiatrische Vorlesungen, Bd. 2/3: Über die Geistesstörungen von Entarteten, transl. Otto Möbius, Leipzig: Thieme, p. 12 f.
9. Nordau, Max Simon: Degeneration, 1895, p. 27, Internet Archive.
10. Emil Kraepelin: Psychiatrie. Ein Lehrbuch für Studierende und Ärzte, Leipzig: Barth, S. 408 f.
11. R. J. Frances et al., Clinical Textbook of Addictive Disorders (2005) p. 315
12. Edman J, Berndt J (2018). "Oniomaniacs: the popular framing of consumption as a disease" (PDF). Addiction Research & Theory. 26 (6): 431–438. doi:10.1080/16066359.2017.1396585. S2CID 148591979.
13. BLACK, DONALD W (1 February 2007). "A review of compulsive buying disorder". World Psychiatry. 6 (1): 14–18. PMC 1805733. PMID 17342214.
14. Jon E. Grant/S. W. Kim, Stop Me Because I Can't Stop Myself (2004) p. 16
15. April Lane Benson and Marie Gengler, "Treating Compulsive Buying", in Coombs, p. 452
16. Rose, Paul; Segrist, Daniel J (June 2012). "Difficulty Identifying Feelings, Distress Tolerance and Compulsive Buying: Analyzing the Associations to Inform Therapeutic Strategies". International Journal of Mental Health and Addiction. 11 (1): 65–68. doi:10.1007/s11469-012-9389-y. ISSN 1557-1874. S2CID 8232261.
17. "PsycNET". psycnet.apa.org. Retrieved 2019-06-22.
18. "PsycNET". psycnet.apa.org. Retrieved 2019-06-22.
19. Zadka, Łukasz; Olajossy, Marcin (2016). "Compulsive buying in outline". Psychiatria Polska. 50 (1): 153–164. doi:10.12740/PP/44010. ISSN 0033-2674. PMID 27086335.
20. Hartston, Heidi J.; Koran, Lorrin M (June 2002). "Impulsive behavior in a consumer culture". International Journal of Psychiatry in Clinical Practice. 6 (2): 65–68. doi:10.1080/136515002753724045. ISSN 1471-1788. PMID 24931930. S2CID 21247136.
21. Black, Donald W. (2001). "Compulsive Buying Disorder: Definition, Assessment, Epidemiology, and Clinical Management". CNS Drugs. 15 (1): 17–27. doi:10.2165/00023210-200115010-00003. ISSN 1172-7047. OCLC 30488303. PMID 11465011. S2CID 21073559.
22. Black, Donald W. (February 2007). "A review of compulsive buying disorder". World Psychiatry. 6 (1): 14–18. ISSN 1723-8617. OCLC 55586799. PMC 1805733. PMID 17342214.
23. Vyse, Stuart (2008). Going broke: why Americans can't hold on to their money. Oxford; New York: Oxford University Press. p. 28. ISBN 978-0-19-530699-6. OCLC 153773333.
24. Abramowitz, Jonathan S.; Houts, Arthur C. (2006). Concepts and Controversies in Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder. New York: Springer Science+Business Media. p. 185. ISBN 038723280X.
25. Müller, Astrid; Mitchell, James E.; de Zwaan, Martina (2013). "Compulsive buying: Compulsive Buying". The American Journal on Addictions: n/a. doi:10.1111/j.1521-0391.2013.12111.x.
26. Hague B., Hall J., Kellett S. (2016). "Treatments for compulsive buying: A systematic review of the quality, effectiveness and progression of the outcome evidence". Journal of Behavioral Addictions. 5 (3): 379–394. doi:10.1556/2006.5.2016.064. PMC 5264404. PMID 27640529.{{cite journal}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
27. Herron, Abigail J., Brennan, Tim K. eds. ASAM Essentials of Addiction Medicine, The. 3rd Edition. Two Commerce Square, 2001 Market Street, Philadelphia, PA 19103 USA:Lippincott Williams & Wilkins; 2020.
28. Nataraajan, R., & Goff, B. G. (1992). Manifestations of compulsiveness in the consumer-marketplace domain. Psychology & Marketing, 9(1), 31–44. doi:10.1002/mar.4220090105
29. Helga Dittmar, "Understanding and Diagnosing Compulsive Buying", in Robert H. Coombs, Handbook of Addictive Disorders (2004) p. 438
30. April Lane Benson, I Shop Therefore I Am (2000)
31. Donald Black, "A review of compulsive buying disorder" (2007).
32. Aboujaourde/Koran, p. 8
33. Sansone, Randy A.; Chang, Joy; Jewell, Bryan; Rock, Rachel (2013-02-01). "Childhood trauma and compulsive buying". International Journal of Psychiatry in Clinical Practice. 17 (1): 73–76. doi:10.3109/13651501.2011.653379. ISSN 1365-1501. PMID 22296513. S2CID 207523867.
34. April Lane Benson/Marie Gengler, "Treating Compulsive Buying" in Coombs, p. 451
35. Aboujaourde/Koran, p. 9
36. Dittmar, p. 417
37. Dennis Hayes, Beyond the Silicon Curtain (1989) p. 145
38. Elen Lewis, The eBay Phenomenon (2008) p. 95
39. Helga Dittmar/Emma Halliwell, Consumer Culture, Identity and Well-being (2008) pp. 95-97
40. Dittmar/Halliwell, p. 97
41. Frances, p. 315
42. Pamela Klaffke, Spree (2004) p. 185
43. Klaffke, p. 185
44. Lucy Costigan, Women and Healing (2006) p. 208
45. Helga Dittmar, "Understanding and Diagnosing Compulsive Buying", in Robert H. Coombs, Handbook of Addictive Disorders (2004) p. 442
46. Oliver James, Britain on the Couch (London 1998) p. 301
47. Dittmar, p. 426
48. Dittmar, p. 424
49. Chakraborty, S.K.; Chakraborty, D. (2006). Culture, Society, And Leadership. ICFAI University Press. p. 196. ISBN 9788131401170.
50. Catalano and Sonenberg, in Costigan, p. 208
51. Klaffke, p. 430
52. Bruno Zumo, Advances in quality of life research, 2001 (2002) p. 164
53. Grant/Kim, p. 36
54. Lejoyeux, Michel; Weinstein, Aviv (1 September 2010). "Compulsive Buying". The American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse. 36 (5): 248–253. doi:10.3109/00952990.2010.493590. PMID 20560822. S2CID 207428225.
55. Wood, Heather (2003). "In the News: Retail therapy". Nature Reviews Neuroscience. 4 (9): 700. doi:10.1038/nrn1211. S2CID 41985547.
56. Hague, B; Hall, J; Kellett, S (2016). "Treatments for compulsive buying: A systematic review of the quality, effectiveness and progression of the outcome evidence". Journal of Behavioral Addictions. 5 (3): 379–394. doi:10.1556/2006.5.2016.064. PMC 5264404. PMID 27640529.
57. Aboujaoude, Elias (2014). "Compulsive Buying Disorder: A Review and Update". Current Pharmaceutical Design. 20 (25): 4021–4025. doi:10.2174/13816128113199990618. ISSN 1381-6128. PMID 24001296.
58. Black DW (2007). "A review of compulsive buying disorder". World Psychiatry. 6 (1): 14–8. PMC 1805733. PMID 17342214.
59. Piquet-Pessôa, Marcelo; Fontenelle, Leonardo F. (2016). "Opioid Antagonists In Broadly Defined Behavioral Addictions: A Narrative Review". Expert Opinion on Pharmacotherapy. 17 (6): 1–10. doi:10.1517/14656566.2016.1145660. ISSN 1465-6566. PMID 26798982. S2CID 20831064.
60. Yip, Sarah W.; Potenza, Marc N. (2014). "Treatment of Gambling Disorders". Current Treatment Options in Psychiatry. 1 (2): 189–203. doi:10.1007/s40501-014-0014-5. ISSN 2196-3061. PMC 4041397. PMID 24904757.
61. D. K. Goodwin, Team of Rivals (2013) p. 305, 401-2 and 681-2

Further reading

• Benson, A. To Buy or Not to Buy: Why We Overshop and How to Stop Boston: Trumpeter Books, 2008.
• Black D.W. (2007). "A review of compulsive buying disorder". World Psychiatry. 6 (1): 14–18. PMC 1805733. PMID 17342214.
• Bleuler, E. Textbook of Psychiatry. New York: Macmillan, 1924.
• Catalano E. and Sonenberg, N. Consuming Passions: Help for Compulsive Shoppers. Oakland: New Harbinger Publications, 1993.
• DeSarbo WS, Edwards EA (1996). "Typologies of Compulsive Buying Behavior: A Constrained Cluster-Wise Regression Approach". Journal of Consumer Psychology. 5 (3): 231–252. doi:10.1207/s15327663jcp0503_02. S2CID 144637994.
• Elliott R (1994). "Addictive Consumption: Function and Fragmentation in Postmodernity". Journal of Consumer Policy. 17 (2): 159–179. doi:10.1007/bf01016361. S2CID 143240695.
• Faber R. J.; O'Guinn T. C.; Krych R. (1987). "Compulsive Consumption". Advances in Consumer Research. 14: 132–135.
• Kraepelin, E. Psychiatrie (8th ed.). Leipzig: Verlag von Johann Ambrosius Barth, 1915.
• McElroy, SL, Phillips KA, Keck PE, Jr. 1994 "Obsessive Compulsive Spectrum Disorder." Journal of Clinical Psychiatry 55(10, suppl): 33-51
• Nataraajan R., Goff B. (1992). "Manifestations of Compulsiveness in the Consumer-Marketplace Domain". Psychology and Marketing. 9 (1): 31–44. doi:10.1002/mar.4220090105.
• Ridgway NM, Kukar-Kinney M, Monroe K (2008). "An expanded conceptualization and a new measure of compulsive buying". Journal of Consumer Research. 35 (4): 350–406. doi:10.1086/591108. S2CID 3048670.
• Lam, Simon Ching; Chan, Zoe Sze-Long; Chong, Andy Chun-Yin; Wong, Wendy Wing-Chi; Ye, Jiawen (September 2018). "Adaptation and validation of Richmond Compulsive Buying Scale in Chinese population" (PDF). Journal of Behavioral Addictions. 7 (3): 760–769. doi:10.1556/2006.7.2018.94. PMC 6426376. PMID 30264602.

External links

• What is Compulsive Shopping Disorder? 2016-03-04 at the Wayback Machine