Augusta Declaration

The Augusta Declaration, or the Memorial of Augusta County Committee, May 10, 1776, was a statement presented to the Fifth Virginia Convention in Williamsburg, Virginia on May 10, 1776. The Declaration announced the necessity of the Thirteen Colonies to form a permanent and independent union of states and national government separate from Great Britain, with whom the Colonies were at war.

Augusta Declaration
Created	Before May 10, 1776
Presented	May 10, 1776
Location	Unknown (presumed lost)
Author(s)	Thomas Lewis, Sampson Mathews, Samuel McDowell, et al.
Purpose	To create a permanent and independent union of states and national government separate from Great Britain

When the Fifth Virginia Convention assembled on May 6, 1776, independence was a leading issue. Several of the delegates had already been instructed by their counties to pursue independence, and others had come with resolutions for independence in hand. The Augusta Declaration was the first official statement on the subject, being introduced by Thomas Lewis, on behalf of the Augusta County, Virginia Committee of Safety on May 10. Five days later, on May 15, the Convention declared Virginia wholly independent of Great Britain, and called for state papers (a declaration of rights and constitution), foreign alliances, and a confederation of the colonies. These resolutions were forwarded to the Second Continental Congress and introduced as the Lee Resolution, which initiated the drafting of the United States Declaration of Independence, the Model Treaty (foreign policy), and the Articles of Confederation (the first U.S. constitution), respectively.

While legislation from various American counties and colonies had called for or emboldened independence from Great Britain, none had done so while proposing either a formal union of the colonies as states or a national government. The Augusta Declaration called for both, which the colonies would go on to adopt in the creation of the United States of America under the Articles and, ultimately, the United States Constitution. Virginia history scholar Hugh Blair Grigsby states the Augusta Declaration "deserves to be stereotyped as the Magna Charta of the West" for its precedent in calling for this governmental mode.^[1]

The document is presumed to be a lost work, with only an abstract surviving in the notations of the official journal of the Fifth Virginia Convention.

The Augusta Declaration

On May 10, 1776, Thomas Lewis introduced the Augusta Declaration to the Fifth Virginia Convention on behalf of the Augusta County, Virginia Committee of Safety. Specifics of the declaration are unknown, as it is currently lost.^[2] The abstract of the document was recorded in the journal of the Convention as such:

A representation from the committee of the county of Augusta was presented to the Convention, and read: setting forth the present unhappy situation of the country, and, from the ministerial measures of vengeance now pursuing, representing the necessity of making the confederacy of the United Colonies the most perfect, independent, and lasting; and of framing an equal, free, and liberal government, that may bear the test of all future ages.

This was the first official proposal for the creation of a permanent and independent union of states and national government from any of the Thirteen Colonies.^[3][4][5]

Fifth Virginia Convention

Main article: Fifth Virginia Convention

The Fifth Virginia Convention convened on May 6, 1776. There were three parties present. The first was mainly made up of wealthy planters, who sought to continue their hold on local government as it had grown up during colonial Virginia's history. These included Robert Carter Nicholas Sr. who opposed the Declaration of Independence from King George. This party, which saw little to gain and much to lose from a separation from Great Britain, dominated the convention by a malapportionment that lent an advantage to the slaveholding east.^[6] The second party was made up of the intellectuals of the Enlightenment: lawyers, physicians and "aspiring young men". These included the older generation of George Mason, George Wythe, and Edmund Pendleton, and the younger Thomas Jefferson and James Madison.^[7] The third, "radical party," was a minority of young men mainly from western Virginia, some of whom had supported independence earlier than 1775.^[8] The Augustans were from this party, with Thomas Lewis and Samuel McDowell serving as delegates.

When the convention began, three counties (Cumberland, Charlotte, and James City)^[9][10][11] had already drafted resolutions for independence. Delegates from several others had come to Williamsburg with prepared statements on the issue, while most others had come knowing the question would be addressed.^[12] Over the first several sessions, the Convention dealt with matters largely related to the ongoing war effort.^[13] On May 10, the fifth session of the Convention, Thomas Lewis introduced the Augusta Declaration on behalf of the Augusta County Committee of Safety. This was the first statement on the issue of independence during this Convention, and would influence final resolution on the subject.^[14][15] On May 14, the Convention resolved itself into a committee to debate the question of independence in full.^[16] The following day, May 15, the committee came to a unanimously agreement "to propose to Congress to declare the United Colonies free and independent States, absolved from all allegiance to, or dependence upon, the Crown or Parliament of Great Britain".

The Convention adopted resolutions calling for:

• state papers (a declaration of rights and constitution)
• foreign alliances
• a confederation of the colonies

With this, Virginia became the first colony to instruct its delegates in Congress to introduce both a resolution for independence and a federal union of the colonies.^[17] The last resolution, specifically, was responsive to the Augusta Declaration.^[18]

On to Congress

These resolutions were forwarded to Richard Henry Lee, the Virginia representative to the Continental Congress, who introduced them to that body on June 7, almost verbatim:

Resolved, That these United Colonies are, and of right ought to be, free and independent States, that they are absolved from all allegiance to the British Crown, and that all political connection between them and the State of Great Britain is, and ought to be, totally dissolved.

That it is expedient forthwith to take the most effectual measures for forming foreign Alliances.

That a plan of confederation be prepared and transmitted to the respective Colonies for their consideration and approbation.^[19]

The Congress organized into groups to draft statements for each resolution. These efforts resulted in the creation of the United States Declaration of Independence, July 4, 1776; the Model Treaty (foreign policy), September 17, 1776; and the Articles of Confederation (first U.S. constitution), March 1, 1781. ^[20]

Augusta County Committee of Safety

Background

After Parliament closed the ports of Boston and passed the Intolerable Acts to punish Massachusetts for the Boston Tea Party, the Virginia House of Burgesses organized a protest as a show of solidarity with Boston. In response, Virginia royal governor Lord Dunmore dissolved the House of Burgesses. The burgesses then formed the extralegal Virginia Conventions in place of the dissolved House, scheduling the first session for August 1.^[21] Augusta County's elected delegates for this session, Samuel McDowell and George Mathews, did not attend the first of these Conventions, likely due to the recent end of Dunmore's War in which the Augusta County militia was heavily involved.^[22][23] For the remaining conventions, Augusta County sent Thomas Lewis and Samuel McDowell as their delegates.

In October, 1774, the First Continental Congress directed that a committee of safety be appointed in "every county, city, and town" for the primary reason of monitoring imports and exports to ensure compliance with a boycott of British goods.^[24] Over the next year the roles of the county committees expanded to include the raising of militia units, providing local government, and implementing and upholding new policy from the Continental Congress.^[25]

The Augusta Resolves

Main article: Augusta Resolves

The first recorded action of the Augusta County Committee of Safety was a patriotic meeting taking place on February 22, 1775 in Staunton, Virginia, which resulted in the drafting of the Augusta Resolves. These resolves stated the intent of the Augustans to support the Continental Congress, to pledge 'life and fortune' in preservation of their natural liberties, and to ally with "all British America" in securing these liberties.^[26] The Augusta Resolves, along with the resolutions of nearby Fincastle, Botetourt, and Pittsylvania counties, were the most significant of the second of two broad waves of resolutions passed by nearly every Virginia county from summer 1774 through winter 1775, and were unique in demonstrating a national scope that previous resolutions had not.^[27] The Augusta County committee's revolutionary activity continued throughout the next year, organizing militia and functioning as an extralegal local government. The Virginia committees of safety were replaced with standard courts when Virginia created its own permanent government.^[28][29]

Members

While the committee's declaration of May 10, 1776 is presumed lost, at least one memorial (petition) from the committee survives with its signatories intact. This memorial, dated November 9, 1776, and which relates to religion and taxation, is signed by the following:

• Thomas Lewis
• Sampson Mathews
• Samuel McDowell
• N. Thompson
• Michael Bowyer
• Alexander Sinclair
• William Bowyer
• Ja's Tate
• William McPheeters
• John Gilmore
• William Stephenson
• William Lewis
• John Cyle Jr.
• James Steel
• Abraham Smith^[30]

Contemporary references

Several contemporary references to the Augusta Declaration exist outside of the journal of the Fifth Virginia Convention. Among them:

• Gabriel Jones, Clerk of Hampshire County, referenced the declaration in an irascible letter to George Washington, on June 6, 1777, in which he expresses contempt for the people of Augusta: "These wretches, I mean inhabitants, of Augusta have forgot when they petitioned the Assembly for abolishing the established church and to declare independancy [sic] how they promised their lives and fortunes should be spent in supporting the Cause if their humble prayer should be granted . . ."^[31]
• James Madison, in a 1827 manuscript, copied the abstract of the Augusta Declaration verbatim as found in the journal of the Fifth Virginia Convention, with queries as to the date and location of the document. An editor for U.S. National Archives notes, "Clearly pertinent to [Madison's] subject, [the Augusta Declaration] must have attracted his special interest . . ."^[32]

Legacy

"It [the Augusta Declaration] is the first deliberate expression of the policy of establishing an independent state government and a permanent confederation of the States which our parliamentary journals contain; for, although several counties had expressed a resolution to sustain the Conventions in all measures which should be deemed necessary for the public weal, and had shown a spirit equal to every emergency, none had made so direct and so explicit a representation of the mode of redress which the crisis required . . . "

This memorial was presented five days before the grand committee. . . made that report recommending a declaration of independence and a formation of a state government wholly independent of the British Crown. This memorial from Augusta . . .deserves to be stereotyped as the Magna Charta of the West."^[33]

- Hugh Blair Grigsby

Historian Pauline Maier identifies more than ninety 'declarations of independence' that were issued throughout the Thirteen Colonies from April to July 1776.^[34] Among these were the Halifax Resolves, which on April 12 authorized the North Carolina delegates to the Continental Congress to vote in favor of independence should such a vote reach the floor;^[35] and the Rhode Island Act of Renunciation, which on May 4 officially renounced that colony's allegiance to George III.^[36] In Virginia, several counties adopted resolutions in favor of independence by the end of April: Cumberland County On April 22;^[37] Charlotte County on April 23;^[38] James City on April 24.^[39]

A confederation of the colonies had also been proposed by this time. Benjamin Franklin had introduced a plan for confederation of the thirteen colonies during the July, 1775 session of the Continental Congress. This plan, which was not adopted, left open the possibility for reconciliation with Britain (aspects of his plan would be revived for the Articles of Confederation).^[40] In Virginia, Patrick Henry had been a supporter of confederation. A resolution he authored for the Fifth Virginia Convention and debated May 15 called for the independence of all thirteen colonies, which he intended to be a step toward confederation.^[41] Letters he would write to both John Adams and Richard Henry Lee on May 20 suggested the importance he placed on the issue.^[42]

Hugh Blair Grigsby, Virginia historical scholar, states that while several bodies had declared or cleared the way for a vote for independence, and while Congress had, also on May 10, instructed the colonies to form temporary governments to address the domestic needs of their people, no one in the colonies had yet laid out, as did the Committee of Safety from Augusta County, Virginia, a proposal for the creation of a permanent and independent union of states and national government for the Colonies.^[43][44] Grigsby states that this declaration is analogous to England's Magna Carta, which concerned the medieval relationship between English monarch and barons, but has come to be seen as an iconic statement of the rights of ordinary people.^[45]

A writer for an 1887 issue of The Nation states: "The distinction [to which Grigsby refers] is too technical to be of great value; at best, Augusta County was a year behind Mecklenburg, and far less outspoken than Buckingham, whose delegates to the Virginia Convention were bluntly instructed "to cause a total and final separation from Great Britain to take place as soon as possible.""^[46] Grigsby indeed notes that the Buckingham County statement, published June 14, 1776, but probably written May 13,^[47] is "the only paper which can stand near [the Augusta Declaration]."^[48] Others have noted that the Mecklenburg Resolves, while radical, left open the possibility of reconciliation with Great Britain and were not a declaration that the people of Mecklenburg County were free and independent of The Crown.^[49]

References

1. Grigsby 1890(2), p. 66
2. Grigsby 1855, p. 110
3. Grigsby 1890(2), p. 66
4. Grigsby 1855, p. 110
5. Clarke, Robert (1899). Proceedings of the Scotch Irish Congress, Volume 2. Cincinnati, Ohio: Scotch-Irish Society of America. p. 233.
6. Grigsby 1855, p. 62
7. Grigsby 1855, p.62
8. Grigsby 1855, p. 62, 110, 148
9. Van Schreeven et al., p. 433-434
10. Van Schreeven et al., p. 447-448
11. Van Schreeven et al., p. 458
12. Dunaway, Jr., W.F. (1904). "The Virginia Conventions of the Revolution". Virginia Law Register. 10 (7): 581. doi:10.2307/1100650. JSTOR 1100650.
13. Van Schreeven et al., p. 124, n. 3
14. Van Schreeven et al., p. 90, n. 8
15. White, Henry A. (1911). Southern Presbyterian leaders. New York, New York: Neale publishing Company. p. 123. OCLC 1085173085.
16. Van Schreeven et al., p. 124, n. 3
17. Colonial Williamsburg Research Dept. (January 22, 1976). "Va. Resolution for Independence" (PDF). Sixteenth Commemorative Session of the Virginia General Assembly. Williamsburg, Virginia.
18. Van Schreeven et al., p. 90, n. 8
19. Henry, William Wirt (1891). Patrick Henry; Life, Correspondence and Speeches. New York, New York: Charles Scribner's Sons. p. 401. OCLC 727087.
20. "The Model Treaty, 1776". United States Office of the Historian. United States Dept. of State.
21. Glanville, p. 71-72
22. Glanville, p. 80
23. Van Schreeven, William; Scribner, Robert; Tarter, Brent (1973). Revolutionary Virginia, the road to independence, vol. 5. Independence and the Fifth convention. Charlottesville, Virginia: University Press of Virginia. OCLC 802770.
24. Bowman, p. 325
25. Bowman, p. 336
26. Waddell, Joseph Addison (May 5, 1886). Annals of Augusta County, Virginia: With Reminiscences Illustrative of the Vicissitudes of Its Pioneer Settlers ; Biographical Sketches of Citizens Locally Prominent, and of Those who Have Founded Families in the Southern and Western States ; a Diary of the War, 1861–'5, and a Chapter on Reconstruction. Wm. Ellis Jones. p. 148 – via Internet Archive.
27. Glanville, p. 78
28. Virginia Historical Society (1887). Proceedings of the Virginia Historical Society at the Annual Meeting Held December 21-22, 1891: With Historical Papers Read on the Occasion, and Others, Volume 6. Richmond, Virginia: Virginia Historical Society. p. 110.
29. Force, Peter (1840). American archives: consisting of a collection of authentick records, state papers, debates, and letters and other notices of publick affairs, the whole forming a documentary history of the origin and progress of the North American colonies; of the causes and accomplishment of the American revolution; and of the Constitution of government for the United States, to the final ratification thereof. In six series ... Washington, DC: Virginia Historical Society. p. 939. OCLC 1039501099.
30. Bruce, Philip Alexander (1910). The Virginia Magazine of History and Biography, Volume 18. Richmond, Virginia: Virginia Historical Society. p. 148–150.
31. Jones, Gabriel (June 6, 1777). "To George Washington from Gabriel Jones, 6 June 1777". The U.S. National Archives and Records Administration.
32. Madison, James (1827). "Independence and Constitution of Virginia, [1827?]". The U.S. National Archives and Records Administration.
33. Grigsby 1890(2), p. 66
34. Maier, Pauline. American Scripture: Making the Declaration of Independence. New York: Knopf, 1997. Page 48, and Appendix A, which lists the state and local declarations.ISBN 0-679-45492-6
35. Jensen, p., 678–79.
36. "Treasures from the Archives: The Act of Renunciation". Rhode Island Department of State. Retrieved July 29, 2019. Rhode Island was the first colony to renounce allegiance to Great Britain's King George III by an official legislative act.
37. Van Schreeven et al., p. 433-434
38. Van Schreeven et al., p. 447-448
39. Van Schreeven et al., p. 458
40. Sparks, Jared (1856). The Life of Benjamin Franklin: Containing the Autobiography, with Notes and a Continuation. Boston: Whittemore, Niles and Hall. pp. 397–398.
41. Henry, William Wirt (1891). Patrick Henry; Life, Correspondence and Speeches. New York, New York: Charles Scribner's Sons. p. 397. OCLC 727087.
42. Henry, p. 397
43. Grigsby 1855, p. 110
44. Grigsby 1890(2), p. 66
45. Grigsby 1890(2), p. 66
46. "New York, Thursday, August 11, 1887: The Week". The Nation: A Weekly Journal Devoted to Politics, Literature, Science, and Art. 45: 121. July 1, 1887. Retrieved July 25, 2019.
47. Maier, American Scripture, Appendix A.
48. Grigsby 1890(1), p. 338
49. "Mecklenburg Resolutions Reject the Power of the British in North Carolina". History Channel: This Day in History. A&E Television Networks, LLC. Retrieved January 27, 2013.

Bibliography

• Grigsby, Hugh Blair (1890). The History of the Virginia Federal Convention of 1788: with some account of some eminent Virginians of that era who were members of the body. Richmond, Virginia: Virginia Historical Society. Retrieved April 23, 2020.
• Grigsby, Hugh Blair (1855). The Virginia Convention of 1776. Richmond : J.W. Randolph. OCLC 3886825. Retrieved April 23, 2020.
• Grigsby, Hugh Blair (1890). Washington and Lee University (1890). Historical Papers, Volumes 1-2. Lexington, Virginia: The New York Public Library. p. 88. Retrieved April 23, 2020.
• Jensen, Merrill. The Founding of a Nation: A History of the American Revolution, 1763–1776. New York: Oxford University Press, 1968.
• Van Schreeven, William; Scribner, Robert; Tarter, Brent (1973). Revolutionary Virginia, the road to independence, vol. 7. Independence and the Fifth convention. Charlottesville, Virginia: University Press of Virginia. OCLC 802770.
• Virginia House of Delegates (1776). The Proceedings of the Convention of Delegates Held at the Capital, in the City of Williamsburg, in the Colony of Virginia, on the 6th of May, 1776. Richmond, Virginia: Virginia House of Delegates. Retrieved April 23, 2020.

Further reading

• Gutzman, Kevin R.C. (2007). Virginia's American Revolution: From Dominion to Republic, 1776–1840. Lexington Books. p. 22. ISBN 978-0-7391-2131-3.