What Hurts the Most

"What Hurts the Most" is a song written by American songwriter Jeffrey Steele and English songwriter Steve Robson. Originally recorded by country music artist Mark Wills in 2003 on his album And the Crowd Goes Wild, it was covered by Bellefire a year later. The first version to be released as a single was by pop singer Jo O'Meara in 2005, from the album Relentless. Later that year, country band Rascal Flatts covered the song as well, releasing it as the first single from the 2006 album Me and My Gang, topping the U.S. country and adult contemporary charts with it. German band Cascada later had international chart success with the song in 2007. It was also covered by Eden in 2008.

"What Hurts the Most"
Song by Mark Wills
from the album And the Crowd Goes Wild
Released	October 21, 2003
Genre	Country pop
Length	3:47
Label	Mercury Nashville
Songwriter(s)	Jeffrey Steele, Steve Robson
Producer(s)	Chris Lindsey, Mark Wills

Content

Jeffrey Steele co-wrote the song with Steve Robson, with whom he also co-wrote Rascal Flatts' 2002 single "These Days". Robson presented Steele with an unfinished track, and Steele decided to come up with lyrics to finish the track. Originally, he had wanted to write a song about the loss of his father, but instead went with a more universal theme of lost love.^[1] After singing the lyrics, he decided that he liked how sad the song sounded, when Robson suggested that it be recorded in a higher key to sound more emotional.^[1]

Mark Wills was the first artist to record the song,^[1] doing so on his 2003 album And the Crowd Goes Wild. Jo O'Meara, a pop singer, released the song in 2005 and had chart success with it in the United Kingdom. Faith Hill had also intended to include the song on her 2005 album Fireflies, and although she had recorded the song, her version did not make the final cut.^[1] Rascal Flatts then recorded the song as well, and per producer Dann Huff's suggestion, it made their album Me and My Gang.^[1] Wills' rendition of the song, though never a single, peaked at number 51 on the U.S. Hot Digital Songs charts in 2006 in the wake of Rascal Flatts' success with it.

Jo O'Meara version

"What Hurts the Most"
Single by Jo O'Meara
from the album Relentless
B-side	"The First Time" "Never Meant to Break Your Heart" "Let's Love"
Released	September 26, 2005
Recorded	2005
Genre	Pop
Length	3:29
Label	Sanctuary
Songwriter(s)	Jeffrey Steele, Steve Robson
Producer(s)	Brian Rawling
Jo O'Meara singles chronology
"What Hurts the Most" (2005) "On The Surface" (2021)
Music video
"What Hurts The Most" on YouTube

British singer Jo O'Meara, who was originally the leader of the pop music band S Club 7, released the song in 2005 as her first solo single, becoming the first artist to release it as a single. It was the lead single from her debut album Relentless. O'Meara's version peaked at number 13 in the UK Singles Chart.

Track listings

CD 1

1. "What Hurts the Most" – 3:21
2. "The First Time" – 4:11

CD 2

1. "What Hurts the Most" – 3:21
2. "Never Meant to Break Your Heart" – 4:28
3. "Let's Love" (Metro Mix) – 5:40
4. "What Hurts the Most" (CD-ROM Video)

Charts

Weekly charts Chart (2005) Peak position Ireland (IRMA)^[2] 26 Scotland (OCC)^[3] 11 UK Singles (OCC)^[4] 13

Year-end charts Chart (2005) Position UK Singles (OCC)^[5] 236

Rascal Flatts version

"What Hurts the Most"
Single by Rascal Flatts
from the album Me and My Gang
Released	January 9, 2006
Recorded	2005
Genre	Country, country pop
Length	3:34
Label	Lyric Street
Songwriter(s)	Jeffrey Steele, Steve Robson
Producer(s)	Dann Huff, Rascal Flatts
Rascal Flatts singles chronology
"Skin (Sarabeth)" (2005) "What Hurts the Most" (2006) "Me and My Gang" (2006)
Music video
"What Hurts The Most" on YouTube

In 2006, country music trio Rascal Flatts released a cover of this song as a single from their album Me and My Gang, and it became their fifth number-one single on the Billboard Hot Country Songs chart. It also peaked at number six on the all-genre Billboard Hot 100, becoming the band's first top 10 pop hit. In addition, the song reached number one on the Adult Contemporary charts. Rascal Flatts also performed the song live with Kelly Clarkson at the Academy of Country Music Awards in 2006.

Rascal Flatts' recording earned two nominations for the 49th Annual Grammy Awards, in the categories of Best Country Performance by a Duo or Group with Vocals, and Best Country Song.

As of the chart dated January 30, 2010, the song topped the 2 million mark in paid downloads. This makes Rascal Flatts the first country group to top the 2 million mark with two songs.^[6] By April 2011, the song sold 2.28 million in the US.^[7]

Music video

The music video starts with a young girl crying over the loss of her boyfriend. She expresses anger for her father who she blames for making her boyfriend leave, resulting in his demise in a car accident. The girl's very hurt mother watches her daughter's anger for her father and cries as she feels helpless over this unfortunate situation. Over the course of the video, there are scenes of the band playing, flashbacks of the couple, and the girl trying to go about her life. A scene in which with the girl is vomiting in her bathroom and holding her stomach implies that she became pregnant right before her lover's death. The video ends with the girl running up to the boy's wooden cross memorial on the side of the road, to kneel down and say that she saw him, answering his question asked earlier in the video "What do you see?" when they were talking about the future, while a storm is brewing. The music video was directed by Shaun Silva in early 2006.

Song information

Rascal Flatts' version of the song is set in the key of F minor, with a vocal range of E♭3-C 5. The main chord pattern is Fm-D♭-A♭-E♭.^[8]

Personnel

From Me and My Gang liner notes.^[9]

• Tim Akers – keyboards
• Jay DeMarcus – bass guitar
• Paul Franklin – steel guitar
• Dann Huff – guitars
• Charlie Judge – keyboards
• Gary LeVox – lead vocals
• Chris McHugh – drums
• Joe Don Rooney – guitars
• Jonathan Yudkin – fiddle, banjo

Charts and certifications

Weekly charts Chart (2006–2007) Peak position Canada (Canadian Hot 100)^[10] 45 Canada AC (Billboard)^[11] 2 Canada Country (Radio & Records)^[12] 1 Canada Hot AC (Billboard)^[13] 44 UK Singles (OCC) 103 US Billboard Hot 100^[14] 6 US Adult Contemporary (Billboard)^[15] 1 US Adult Top 40 (Billboard)^[16] 9 US Hot Country Songs (Billboard)^[17] 1 US Mainstream Top 40 (Billboard)^[18] 22

Year-end charts Chart (2006) Position US Billboard Hot 100^[19] 26 US Adult Contemporary (Billboard)^[20] 13 US Adult Top 40 (Billboard)^[21] 26 US Country Songs (Billboard)^[22] 4 Chart (2007) Position US Adult Contemporary (Billboard)^[23] 9

Certifications

Certifications for What Hurts the Most

Region	Certification	Certified units/sales
United States (RIAA)^[24]	5× Platinum	5,000,000^‡
^‡ Sales+streaming figures based on certification alone.

Cascada version

"What Hurts the Most"
Single by Cascada
from the album Perfect Day
Released	November 21, 2007 (2007-11-21)
Recorded	2007
Genre	Eurodance
Length	3:39
Label	Zooland
Songwriter(s)	Jeffrey Steele Steve Robson
Producer(s)	DJ Manian Yann Peifer
Cascada singles chronology
"Last Christmas" (2007) "What Hurts the Most" (2007) "What Do You Want from Me?" (2008)
Music video
"What Hurts The Most" on YouTube

Background and composition

In 2007, German Eurodance trio Cascada recorded a cover of "What Hurts the Most" for their second studio album, Perfect Day (2007). The cover was produced and recorded by band members Yanou and DJ Manian at Plazmatek Studio Cologne in Cologne, Germany. The song serves as the first single from Perfect Day (2007). It was first released in Sweden on November 21, 2007, in digital and physical formats, through Zooland Records.^[25] The song was later released in the United Kingdom as a digital single on December 3, 2007, and as a CD single a week later, through All Around the World. The releases featured remixes by several disc jockeys, including Darren Styles, Spencer & Hill and Flip & Fill.^[26] "What Hurts the Most" was solicited to mainstream radio stations on December 11, 2007, in the United States, following its digital and physical release within the two weeks before. In Germany, the cover was released as a CD and digital single on January 4, 2008, through Zeitgeist.

In contrast to the original version, Cascada's cover of "What Hurts the Most" deviates from the country sound and replaces it with Europop electronic beats and elements typical of DJ Manian and Yanou productions.^[27] However, the song opens with an acoustic guitar playing and Horler's vocals being reverbed by electropop synths.^[27] Sharon Mawer of AllMusic noted that despite the heavy electronic beats, lead singer Natalie Horler's vocals are never dominated by the music.^[27] According to the digital music sheet published at Musicnotes.com by BPJ Administration, the song is composed in a key of F♯ minor while carrying a tempo of 144 beats per minute. Horler's vocals range between a high register of A₃ to a low register of C♯₅.^[28]

Critical reception

Alex Fletcher of Digital Spy gave the song a three-star rating, saying that "it's not as good as previous single 'Everytime We Touch' for sure, but its teasing, lucid intro, which bursts into the hand-clap-inducing, hip-swiveling chorus after a flurry of robotic drum beats is certainly a good giggle."^[29] Kurt Kirton of About.com named it one of the album's standout tracks.^[30] Chuck Taylor of Billboard gave "What Hurts the Most" a positive review, writing that "this track is remixed into a frothy uptempo anthem, complete with requisite percussive thump and an exulted vocal (with 12 mixes in all) that leaves the lyric's potential heartbreak in the dust." Taylor ended his review, asking "Wouldn't it be wondrous if American programmers renewed their vow in 2008 to put variety on the airwaves—or do we really need a fifth entry in the top 10 from T-Pain?"^[31]

Chart performance

In Sweden, Cascada's cover of "What Hurts the Most" debuted on the Swedish Singles Chart on November 22, 2007, at number five, where it peaked.^[32] The song fell to number eight the next week, where it stalled on the chart for three weeks.^[32] On December 13, 2007, the song debuted and peaked on the Irish Singles Chart at number six.^[2] In the United Kingdom, the song debuted on the UK Singles Chart at number 16 on December 9, 2007.^[33] In the following week, the song reached a peak of number 10.^[33] It exited the chart at nineteen weeks, logging its last week at number 85.^[33] On March 22, 2008, the cover debuted and peaked on the French Singles Chart at number two. The song fell to number four in the following weeks and eventually fell off of the chart after twenty-seven weeks.

On January 26, 2008, the band's cover of "What Hurts the Most" entered the Billboard Hot 100 at number 95.^[34] The song rose to number 80 in the following week.^[35] On March 22, 2008, the cover peaked at number 52.^[36] The song serves as Cascada's lowest-charting single on the Hot 100 as well as their lowest-charting lead single.^[36] Aside from charting on the Hot 100, the song managed to peak at the top of Billboard Hot Dance Club Songs and at number 28 on the US Billboard Pop Songs.^[37] Despite its low peak on the Hot 100, the song managed to sell more than 500,000 downloads, earning a Gold certification by the Recording Industry Association of America in October 2009.^[38] In Canada, the song managed to peak at number 54 and lasted on the chart for eleven weeks.^[39]

Music video

The music video for "What Hurts the Most" was filmed in Los Angeles was released on January 24, 2008, to the US digital markets.

International version

The video opens with Horler sitting in a studio apartment living room holding a note saying "I can't sorry". It moves to a scene, that is intercut throughout the video, where Horler is seen performing in front of a lit up brick wall. When the first verse begins, Horler leaves the room to open the door, allowing her friends to enter. One friend sees the note and tears it up in disgust. More friends came into the apartment and soon began partying. After the chorus ends, the video moves to a tattoo parlor, where Horler receives a tattoo. As the second chorus commences, she is against a wall, appearing heartbroken, while her former love interest gestures toward the wall, attempting to try to reach out to her. Scenes of the house party continue to play throughout the rest of the video. Near the end of the second chorus, Horler is sitting against a white brick, with mascara running from her eyes, telling that she was crying. On the wall is a window in which the love interest appears to be frustrated. As the song approaches the last chorus, the house party ends with the guests exiting Horler's apartment. The video ends with Horler opening the door to see her former lover, who exchanges a smile with her, and shutting the door on him, leaving with a smile on her face.

US version

The video opens with Horler sitting in a studio apartment living room holding a note saying "I can't sorry". It moves to a scene, that is intercut throughout the video, where Horler is seen performing in front of a lit up brick wall. The first minute of the video features Horler singing in the living room. As the song approaches the chorus, Horler leaves the room and moves to a secluded room where she is seen crying. In that scene, there is also an opening that shows an image of the protagonist's former lover staring into the opening. After the chorus ends, Horler sits at a tattoo parlor while the artists gives her a tattoo. She is then seen sitting against a wall while the love interest gestures to the other side, attempting to reach out to her. As the video nears the final chorus, Horler is at a house party with her friends, appearing lonely and heartbroken.

Credits and personnel

• Recorded and produced at Plazmatek Studio Cologne in Cologne, Germany
• Songwriting – Jeffrey Steele, Steve Robson
• Production – Manuel Reuter, Yann Peifer
• Vocals – Natalie Horler

Charts and certifications

Weekly charts Chart (2007–2008) Peak position Austria (Ö3 Austria Top 40)^[40] 3 Belgium (Ultratip Bubbling Under Wallonia)^[41] 5 Canada (Canadian Hot 100)^[39] 54 Czech Republic (Rádio – Top 100)^[42] 25 Europe (Eurochart Hot 100)^[43] 8 Finland (Suomen virallinen lista)^[44] 2 France (SNEP)^[45] 2 Germany (Official German Charts)^[46] 9 Hungary (Dance Top 40)^[47] 5 Ireland (IRMA)^[2] 6 Netherlands (Dutch Top 40)^[48] 23 Netherlands (Single Top 100)^[49] 35 Scotland (OCC)^[50] 4 Sweden (Sverigetopplistan)^[32] 5 Slovakia (Rádio Top 100)^[51] 85 UK Singles (OCC)^[33] 10 US Billboard Hot 100^[36] 52 US Dance Singles Sales (Billboard)^[52] 2 US Dance/Mix Show Airplay (Billboard)^[53] 1 US Mainstream Top 40 (Billboard)^[37] 28

Year-end charts Chart (2007) Position Sweden (Sverigetopplistan)^[54] 95 UK Singles (Official Charts Company)^[55] 159 Chart (2008) Position Austria (Ö3 Austria Top 40)^[56] 64 Europe (Eurochart Hot 100)^[57] 42 France (SNEP)^[58] 45 Germany (Official German Charts)^[59] 96 UK Singles (Official Charts Company)^[60] 111 Certifications Region Certification Certified units/sales United Kingdom (BPI)^[61] Silver 200,000^‡ United States (RIAA)^[62] Gold 500,000^* ^* Sales figures based on certification alone. ^‡ Sales+streaming figures based on certification alone.

Release history

Region	Date	Format(s)	Label
Sweden	November 21, 2007	CD, digital download	Bonnier
United Kingdom	December 3, 2007	Digital download	All Around the World
	December 10, 2007	CD single
United States	November 27, 2007	Digital download	Robbins
	December 4, 2007	CD single
Germany	January 3, 2008	CD, digital download	Zooland

See also

• List of Billboard Adult Contemporary number ones of 2006 and 2007 (U.S.)

References

1. "Jeffrey Steele Reveals the Story Behind "What Hurts the Most"". Great American Country. Archived from the original on January 24, 2013. Retrieved April 15, 2009.
2. "The Irish Charts – Search Results – What Hurts the Most". Irish Singles Chart. Retrieved January 29, 2020.
3. "Official Scottish Singles Sales Chart Top 100". Official Charts Company.
4. "Official Singles Chart Top 100". Official Charts Company.
5. "2005 UK Singles Chart" (PDF). UKChartsPlus. Retrieved May 26, 2015.
6. "Week Ending Jan. 17, 2010: 21 Million Lady Gaga Fans Can't Be Wrong". Chart Watch. Retrieved August 6, 2012.
7. "Chart Watch Extra: Lady A Makes Country History". Chart Watch. Retrieved August 6, 2012.
8. "What Hurts the Most sheet music". MusicNotes.com. March 31, 2008. Retrieved September 3, 2011.
9. Me and My Gang (CD liner notes). Rascal Flatts. Lyric Street Records. 2006. 165058.{{cite AV media notes}}: CS1 maint: others in cite AV media (notes) (link)
10. "Rascal Flatts Chart History (Canadian Hot 100)". Billboard. Retrieved January 14, 2022.
11. "Rascal Flatts Chart History (Canada AC)". Billboard. Retrieved January 14, 2022.
12. "Canada Country Top 30" (PDF). Radio & Records. April 14, 2006. p. 45. Retrieved December 30, 2019.
13. "Rascal Flatts Chart History (Canada Hot AC)". Billboard. Retrieved January 14, 2022.
14. "Rascal Flatts Chart History (Hot 100)". Billboard.
15. "Rascal Flatts Chart History (Adult Contemporary)". Billboard.
16. "Rascal Flatts Chart History (Adult Pop Songs)". Billboard.
17. "Rascal Flatts Chart History (Hot Country Songs)". Billboard.
18. "Rascal Flatts Chart History (Pop Songs)". Billboard.
19. "Hot 100 Songs – Year-End 2006". Billboard. Retrieved September 20, 2019.
20. "Adult Contemporary Songs – Year-End 2006". Billboard. Retrieved September 20, 2019.
21. "Adult Pop Songs – Year-End 2006". Billboard. Retrieved September 20, 2019.
22. "Best of 2006: Country Songs". Billboard. Prometheus Global Media. 2006. Retrieved July 10, 2012.
23. "Adult Contemporary Songs – Year-End 2007". Billboard. Retrieved September 20, 2019.
24. "American single certifications – Rascal Flatts – What Hurts the Most". Recording Industry Association of America. Retrieved August 12, 2022.
25. "Cascada - What Hurts the Most". iTunes (SE). Apple. Retrieved June 19, 2012.
26. "Cascada - What Hurts the Most". iTunes (GB). Apple. Retrieved June 19, 2012.
27. Mawer, Sharon. "Perfect Day - Cascada". AllMusic. Rovi Corporation. Retrieved June 23, 2012.
28. "Cascada - What Hurts the Most Sheet Music (Digital Download)". Musicnotes.com. BPJ Administration. March 31, 2008. Retrieved June 23, 2012.
29. Fletcher, Alex (December 4, 2007). "Cascada: "What Hurts the Most" - Music Singles Review". Digital Spy. Hearst Magazines UK. Retrieved June 21, 2012.
30. Kirton, Kurt. . About.com. The New York Times Company. Archived from the original on June 18, 2008. Retrieved June 22, 2012.
31. Taylor, Chuck. . Billboard. Prometheus Global Media. Archived from the original on April 14, 2009. Retrieved June 22, 2012.
32. "Cascada – What Hurts the Most". Singles Top 100.
33. "Official Singles Chart Top 100". Official Charts Company.
34. "Hot 100 (January 26, 2008)". Billboard. Prometheus Global Media. Retrieved June 19, 2012.
35. "Hot 100 (February 2, 2008)". Billboard. Prometheus Global Media. Retrieved June 19, 2012.
36. "Cascada Chart History (Hot 100)". Billboard.
37. "Cascada Chart History (Pop Songs)". Billboard.
38. "American single certifications - Cascada - What Hurts the Most". Recording Industry Association of America. Retrieved June 19, 2012.
39. "Cascada Chart History (Canadian Hot 100)". Billboard.
40. "Cascada – What Hurts the Most" (in German). Ö3 Austria Top 40.
41. "Cascada – What Hurts the Most" (in French). Ultratip.
42. "ČNS IFPI" (in Czech). Hitparáda – Radio Top 100 Oficiální. IFPI Czech Republic. Note: Change the chart to CZ – RADIO – TOP 100 and insert 200814 into search.
43. "Hits of the World: Eurocharts". Billboard. Vol. 120, no. 14. April 5, 2008. p. 59.
44. "Cascada: What Hurts the Most" (in Finnish). Musiikkituottajat.
45. "Cascada – What Hurts the Most" (in French). Les classement single.
46. "Cascada – What Hurts the Most" (in German). GfK Entertainment charts. Retrieved August 20, 2020.
47. "Archívum – Slágerlisták – MAHASZ" (in Hungarian). Dance Top 40 lista. Magyar Hanglemezkiadók Szövetsége.
48. "Nederlandse Top 40 – week 36, 2008" (in Dutch). Dutch Top 40. Retrieved August 20, 2020.
49. "Cascada – What Hurts the Most" (in Dutch). Single Top 100. Retrieved June 23, 2012.
50. "Official Scottish Singles Sales Chart Top 100". Official Charts Company.
51. "ČNS IFPI" (in Slovak). Hitparáda – Radio Top 100 Oficiálna. IFPI Czech Republic. Note: insert 200815 into search.
52. "Cascada Chart History (Dance Singles Sales)". Billboard. Retrieved November 19, 2021.
53. "Cascada Chart History (Dance Mix/Show Airplay)". Billboard. Retrieved August 20, 2020.
54. "Årslista Singlar, 2007" (in Swedish). Sverigetopplistan. Retrieved October 30, 2019.
55. "UK Year End 2007" (PDF). UKChartsPlus. Retrieved July 9, 2023.
56. "Jahreshitparade Singles 2008" (in German). Retrieved August 20, 2020.
57. . Billboard. Archived from the original on October 4, 2012. Retrieved January 10, 2022.
58. "Tops de L'année | Top Singles 2008" (in French). SNEP. Retrieved August 20, 2020.
59. "Top 100 Singles–Jahrescharts 2008" (in German). GfK Entertainment. Retrieved August 20, 2020.
60. "UK Year End 2008" (PDF). UKChartsPlus. Retrieved July 9, 2023.
61. "British single certifications – Cascada – What Hurts the Most". British Phonographic Industry. Retrieved August 20, 2020.
62. "American single certifications – Cascada – What Hurts the Most". Recording Industry Association of America. Retrieved June 19, 2012.