Stigmata

For other senses of this word, see Stigma and stigmata (disambiguation).

Not to be confused with Stigmatism.

Stigmata (Ancient Greek: στίγματα, plural of στίγμα stigma, 'mark, spot, brand'), in Roman Catholicism, are bodily wounds, scars and pain which appear in locations corresponding to the crucifixion wounds of Jesus Christ: the hands, wrists, and feet.^[1]

Hands with stigmata, depicted on a Franciscan church in Lienz, Austria

St Catherine fainting from the stigmata by Il Sodoma, Church of Saint Pantaleon, Alsace, France

Stigmata are exclusively associated with Roman Catholicism. Many reported stigmatics are members of Catholic religious orders.^[2] St. Francis of Assisi was the first recorded stigmatic. For over fifty years, St. Padre Pio of Pietrelcina of the Order of Friars Minor Capuchin reported stigmata which were studied by several 20th-century physicians. Stigmata are foreign to the Eastern Orthodox Church, which professes no official view on them; the only stigmatics have been Catholics who lived after the Great Schism of 1054.^[3]

A high percentage (perhaps over 80%) of all stigmatics are women.^[4] In his book Stigmata: A Medieval Phenomenon in a Modern Age, Ted Harrison suggests that there is no single mechanism whereby the marks of stigmata were produced. What is important is that the marks are recognised by others as of religious significance.^[5] Some cases of stigmata have been results of trickery.^[6][7] Some cases have also included reportings of a mysterious chalice in visions being given to stigmatics to drink from or the feeling of a sharp sword being driven into one's chest.^[8]

Description

 

Saint Francis of Assisi contemplating the wounds of stigmata as part of the Imitation of Christ^[9][10]

An individual bearing the wounds of stigmata is a stigmatist or a stigmatic. In Galatians 6:17, Saint Paul says:

Τοῦ λοιποῦ κόπους μοι μηδεὶς παρεχέτω· ἐγὼ γὰρ τὰ στίγματα τοῦ Ἰησοῦ ἐν τῷ σώματί μου βαστάζω.

From henceforth let no man trouble me: for I bear in my body the marks of the Lord Jesus.

A stígma (στίγμα) is a mark on the skin.^[11]

Reported cases of stigmata take various forms. Many show some or all Five Sacred Wounds that were, according to the Bible, inflicted on Jesus during his crucifixion: wounds in the wrists and feet, from nails; and in the side, from a lance. Some stigmatics display wounds to the forehead similar to those caused by the crown of thorns.^[4] Stigmata as crown of thorns appearing in the 20th century, e.g. on Marie Rose Ferron, have been repeatedly photographed.^[12][13][14] Other reported forms include tears of blood or sweating blood, and wounds to the back as from scourging.

Many stigmata show recurring bleeding that stops and then starts, at times after receiving Holy Communion; a significant proportion of stigmatics have shown a strong desire to receive Holy Communion frequently.^[4] A relatively high percentage of stigmatics also exhibit inedia, claiming to live with minimal (or no) food or water for long periods of time, except for the Holy Eucharist. Some exhibit weight loss, and closer investigation often reveals evidence of fakery.^[4]

Some stigmatics claim to feel the pain of wounds with no external marks; these are referred to as "invisible stigmata".^[4] Some stigmatics' wounds do not appear to clot, and seem to stay fresh and uninfected. The blood from the wounds is said, in some cases, to have a pleasant, perfumed odor, known as the Odour of Sanctity.

Individuals who have obtained the stigmata are many times described as ecstatics, overwhelmed with emotions upon receiving the stigmata. No case of stigmata is known to have occurred before the thirteenth century.^[15]

In his paper Hospitality and Pain, Christian theologian Ivan Illich states: "Compassion with Christ ... is faith so strong and so deeply incarnate that it leads to the individual embodiment of the contemplated pain." His thesis is that stigmata result from exceptional poignancy of religious faith and desire to associate oneself with the suffering Messiah.

Differently from the Five Holy Wounds of Christ, some mystics like Francis of Assisi and father Pio of Petralcina reported a spontaneous regression and closure of their stigmata in the days following their death.^{[16][clarification needed]} Both of them claimed to have received the divine stigmata in their hands as well as in their feet.^[17]

Specific cases

Saint Francis of Assisi

 

Saint Francis Receiving the Stigmata by Giotto

 

St. Francis of Assisi, by El Greco

St. Francis of Assisi is the first recorded stigmatic in Christian history.^[18] In 1224,^[19] two years before his death, he embarked on a journey to Mount La Verna for a forty-day fast. The legend states that one morning, near the feast of the Exaltation of the Cross, a six-winged angel appeared to Francis while he prayed. As the angel approached, Francis could see that the angel was crucified. He was humbled by the sight, and his heart was filled with elation joined by pain and suffering. When the angel departed, Francis was left with wounds in his hands, feet, and side as if caused by the same lance that pierced Christ’s side. The image of nails immediately appeared in his hands and feet, and the wound in his side often seeped blood.^[20] Pope Alexander IV and other witnesses declared that they had seen these marks both before and after his death.^[19] In traditional artistic depictions of the incident, Francis is accompanied by a Franciscan brother.^[21]

St. Francis' first biographer, Thomas of Celano, reports the event in his 1230 First Life of St. Francis:

When the blessed servant of God saw these things he was filled with wonder, but he did not know what the vision meant. He rejoiced greatly in the benign and gracious expression with which he saw himself regarded by the seraph, whose beauty was indescribable; yet he was alarmed by the fact that the seraph was affixed to the cross and was suffering terribly. Thus Francis rose, one might say, sad and happy, joy and grief alternating in him. He wondered anxiously what this vision could mean, and his soul was uneasy as it searched for understanding. And as his understanding sought in vain for an explanation and his heart was filled with perplexity at the great novelty of this vision, the marks of nails began to appear in his hands and feet, just as he had seen them slightly earlier in the crucified man above him.

His wrists and feet seemed to be pierced by nails, with the heads of the nails appearing on his wrists and on the upper sides of his feet, the points appearing on the other side. The marks were round on the palm of each hand but elongated on the other side, and small pieces of flesh jutting out from the rest took on the appearance of the nail-ends, bent and driven back. In the same way the marks of nails were impressed on his feet and projected beyond the rest of the flesh. Moreover, his right side had a large wound as if it had been pierced with a spear, and it often bled so that his tunic and trousers were soaked with his sacred blood.^[22]

From the records of St. Francis' physical ailments and symptoms, Edward Frederick Hartung concluded in 1935 that he knew what health problems plagued St. Francis. Hartung believed that he had an eye ailment known as trachoma and quartan malaria.^[23]

Quartan malaria infects the liver, spleen, and stomach, causing the victim intense pain. One complication of quartan malaria occasionally seen around Francis' time is known as purpura, a purple hemorrhage of blood into the skin. According to Hartung "If this were the case of St. Francis, he would have been afflicted by ecchymoses, an exceedingly large purpura. The purple spots of blood may have been punctured while in the wilderness and there appear as an open wound like that of Christ."^[23][24]

A later medical hypothesis was proposed in 1987 to explain the wounds, it claimed that St. Francis may have contracted leprosy.^[25]

Saint Padre Pio of Pietrelcina

 

A young Padre Pio showing the stigmata

For over fifty years, Padre Pio of Pietrelcina reported stigmata which were studied by several 20th-century physicians, whose independence from the Church is not known.^[26][27][28] The observations were reportedly inexplicable and the wounds never became infected.^[26][27][29] His wounds healed once, but reappeared.^[30] The wounds were examined by Luigi Romanelli, chief physician of the City Hospital of Barletta, for about one year. The physician Angelo Maria Merla noted that the wounds were not tubercular in origin but could not make an official diagnosis without further tests.^[31] The surgeon Giorgio Festa, a private practitioner, also examined them in 1920 and 1925.^[31] Professor Giuseppe Bastianelli, physician to Pope Benedict XV, examined the wounds, but no report of his examinations was made. Pathologist Amico Bignami of the University of Rome also observed the wounds, describing them as shallow. Festa, who had originally agreed with Bignami, later described the wounds as superficial when covered with a scab.^[31] Giorgio Festa noted that "at the edges of the lesions, the skin is perfectly normal and does not show any sign of edema, of penetration, or of redness, even when examined with a good magnifying glass".^[31] Alberto Caserta took X-rays of the hands in 1954 and found no abnormality in the bone structure.^[31] Giuseppe Sala who worked as a physician for Pio between 1956 and 1968 commented that tests revealed his blood had no signs of abnormality.^[31]

There were both religious and non-religious critics who accused Padre Pio of faking his stigmata, saying he used carbolic acid to make the wounds. The historian Sergio Luzzatto recounted that in 1919, according to one document in the Vatican's archive, Pio had requested carbolic acid from a pharmacist. She said it was for sterilizing syringes used for vaccination.^[32]

Amico Bignami in a report wrote that the wounds were caused by "neurotic necrosis". He suggested they had been inflicted unconsciously by suggestion and artificially maintained by iodine that Pio had used as a disinfectant.^[31] In 1922, physician Agostino Gemelli wrote that Pio was an hysteric and his stigmata were self-induced, not of supernatural origin.^[33] Gemelli also speculated that his wounds were kept open with carbolic acid.^[33] Giorgio Festa, who examined the stigmata of the friar on October 28, 1919, wrote in his report that they "are not the product of a trauma of external origin, nor are they due to the application of potently irritating chemicals".^[34]

Throughout his life, Pio had hidden his wounds by wearing fingerless gloves. At death there were no wounds, only "unblemished skin".^[35]

Mariam Thresia Chiramel

The first saint from India with stigmata was nun Mariam Thresia Chiramel.^[36] She was canonised on 13 October 2019 by Pope Francis.^[37]

Stigmata and gender

In the late nineteenth century, a French physician named Dr. A Imbert-Goubeyre began compiling a census of known stigmatics from the thirteenth century to his own time. This census includes 280 female and 41 male stigmatics, meaning women comprise a little over 87% of the list.^[38] Additionally, the University of Antwerp released a database of information on 244 stigmatics in April 2019. 92% of the stigmatics in the database are female.^[39] In some cases, convent sisters have attempted to shield stigmatic women from public scrutiny, often out of fear of how their condition would affect the convent's reputation.^[39] So, the amount of women stigmatics may be even higher than historical record shows.

Despite the high number of women stigmatics throughout history, the best-known and least contested stigmatics, such as Francis of Assisi and Padre Pio, have been men.^[38]

Scientific research

 

Stigmatization of St Catherine of Siena

Many stigmatics have been exposed for using trickery.^[6][7] Magdalena de la Cruz for example confessed before she died that her stigmata was deliberate deception.^[40]

Early neurologist Désiré-Magloire Bourneville published works which stated that saints claiming to produce miracles or stigmata, and those claiming to be possessed, were actually suffering from epilepsy or hysteria.^[41][42] Some modern research has indicated stigmata are of hysterical origin or linked to dissociative identity disorder.^{[43][44][45][46]}

There is a link between dietary constriction by self-starvation, dissociative mental states and self-mutilation, in the context of a religious belief.^[47] Anorexia nervosa cases often display self-mutilation similar to stigmata as part of a ritualistic, obsessive–compulsive disorder. A relationship between starvation and self-mutilation has been reported amongst prisoners of war and during famines.^[48][49][50]

The psychologist Leonard Zusne in his book Anomalistic Psychology: A Study of Magical Thinking (1989) has written:

Cases of stigmatism fall into two categories: self-inflicted wounds, which may be either cases of fraud or of unconscious self-infliction, and those that are caused by emotional states ... Self-induced (through autosuggestion) itching and subsequent scratching of which the individual is unaware is likely to occur in suggestible persons if the stimulus is a mental or actual picture of the Crucifixion used during meditation and if the main motive is to receive the stigmata. The motive behind that may be unconscious conflict and a desire to escape from an intolerable situation into invalidism where one's needs are taken care of. It then becomes a case of hysterical conversion reaction. Many cases of stigmatism can be explained as fraud or unconsciously self-inflicted wounds.^[51]

In his Stigmata: A Medieval Phenomenon in a Modern Age, Ted Harrison suggests that there is no single mechanism whereby the marks of stigmata were produced. Harrison found no evidence from a study of contemporary cases that the marks were supernatural in origin. He concluded, however, that marks of natural origin need not be hoaxes. Some stigmatics marked themselves in attempt to suffer with Christ as a form of piety. Others marked themselves accidentally and their marks were noted as stigmata by witnesses. Often marks of human origin produced profound and genuine religious responses.^[5]

Harrison also noted the male-to-female ratio of stigmatics, which for many centuries had been of the order of 7 to 1, had changed since the late 1800s to a ratio of 5 to 4. Appearance of stigmata frequently coincided with times when issues of authority loomed large in the Church. What was significant about stigmatics was not that they were predominantly men, but that they were non-ordained. Having stigmata gave them direct access to the body of Christ without requiring the permission of the Church through the Eucharist. Only in the last century have priests been stigmatised.^[5]

One suggestion is that painful bruising syndrome may explain rare cases of non self-induced stigmata.^{[46][52][53][54][55]}

Skeptical investigator Joe Nickell, who investigated recent cases of stigmata such as Katya Rivas,^[56] commented that they are indistinguishable from hoaxing.^[35]

In 2002, a psychoanalytic study of stigmatic Therese Neumann suggested her stigmata resulted from post-traumatic stress symptoms expressed in unconscious self-mutilation through abnormal autosuggestibility.^[57]

According to a study of the French theologian Joachim Bouflet, in the 21th-century there were 200 stigmatics all over the world. Most of them reached the third age without having particular health problems. The oldest stigmatic was Marie-July Jahenny who died in 1941 at the age of 91. As of 1997, the stigmatics who had been declared saints by the Roman Catholic Church were only 7.^[58]

Non-Christian stigmata

Among the Warao of the Orinoco Delta, a contemplator of tutelary spirits may mystically induce the development of "...(imagined) openings in the palms of his hands."^[59]

Buddhist "stigmata"^[60][61] are regularly indicated in Buddhist art.

Some spiritualist mediums have also produced stigmata. During the séances of German medium Maria Vollhardt, it was alleged that bleeding wounds appeared.^[62] However, Albert Moll, a psychiatrist, considered her phenomena to be fraudulent.^[63]

Notable stigmatics

• Francis of Assisi
• Marguerite Bays
• Maria Esperanza de Bianchini
• Mariam Baouardy
• Lucy Brocadelli
• Benedetta Carlini
• Rita of Cascia
• Mariam Thresia Chiramel
• Anne Catherine Emmerich
• Natuzza Evolo
• Marie Rose Ferron
• Gemma Galgani
• Veronica Giuliani
• Teresa Helena Higginson
• Marie of the Incarnation
• Marie Julie Jahenny
• Louise Lateau
• Therese Neumann
• Marcelline Pauper
• Luisa Piccarreta
• Padre Pio
• Catherine of Ricci
• Marthe Robin
• Zlatko Sudac
• Catherine of Siena
• Rhoda Wise
• Mariam Thresia Chiramel

References

1. "Stigmata (Christian Mysticism)". Encyclopedia Britannica. Retrieved 2018-07-03.
2. Poulain, A. (1912). Mystical Stigmata. In The Catholic Encyclopedia. New York: Robert Appleton Company. Retrieved July 1, 2008 from New Advent: http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/14294b.htm
3. "Manifestations – Questions & Answers". oca.org.
4. Carroll, Michael P. (1989). Catholic Cults and Devotions: A Psychological Inquiry. McGill-Queen's University Press. pp. 80–84. ISBN 0-7735-0693-4
5. Harrison, Ted (1994). Stigmata: A Medieval Phenomenon in a Modern Age. St Martins Press. ISBN 978-0-312-11372-8.
6. Carroll, Robert Todd. (2003). The Skeptic's Dictionary: A Collection of Strange Beliefs, Amusing Deceptions, and Dangerous Delusions. Wiley. pp. 366–367. ISBN 0-471-27242-6
7. Nickell, Joe. (2004). "The Stigmata of Lilian Bernas". Skeptical Inquirer. Retrieved 12 May 2016.
8. Johann Joseph von Görres (1883). The stigmata, tr. from 'The Mystik', ed. by H. Austin.
9. Saint Francis of Assisi by Jacques Le Goff 2003 ISBN 0-415-28473-2 p. 44
10. Miles, Margaret Ruth. (2004). The Word Made Flesh: A History of Christian Thought. Wiley. pp. 160–161. ISBN 978-1-4051-0846-1
11. Henry George Liddell, Robert Scott, A Greek-English Dictionary s.v.
12. Michael Freze, 1993, They bore the wounds of Christ, OSV Publishing ISBN 0-87973-422-1 p. 125
13. A Stigmatist: Marie-Rose Ferron by Jeanne S. Bonin 1988 ISBN 2-89039-161-2 p. 153
14. Religion and American cultures: an encyclopedia of traditions, Volume 1 by Gary Laderman, Luís D. León 2003 ISBN 1-57607-238-X p. 336
15. "Catholic Encyclopedia: Mystical Stigmata". Retrieved 2008-07-02.
16. "Cent'anni fa le stimmate di Padre Pio: quando la scienza si arrende". L'Avvenire (in Italian). September 20, 2018. Poche ore dopo, alla morte erano completamente scomparse, senza lasciare segno di sé.
17. "San Francesco: le fonti che attestano le sue stimmate". October 24, 2019.
18. "What's the deal with stigmata?". The Straight Dope. 1998-02-20. Retrieved 2012-02-27.
19. Macalister, Alexander (1911). "Stigmatization" . In Chisholm, Hugh (ed.). Encyclopædia Britannica. Vol. 25 (11th ed.). Cambridge University Press. p. 918.
20. . Franciscan Friars T.O.R. Archived from the original on 2012-03-07. Retrieved 2012-02-27.
21. Francis, Henry S. (1963). "Sasseta: crucifixion with St. Francis". The Bulletin of the Cleveland Museum of Art. Cleveland Museum of Art. 50 (3): 46–49. JSTOR 25151940.
22. "Medieval Sourcebook: Thomas of Celano: Lives of St. Francis". Fordham.edu. Retrieved 2012-02-27.
23. Hartung, Edward Frederick. (1935). St. Francis and Medieval Medicine. Annals of Medical History 7: 85–91.
24. . Time. 1935-03-11. ISSN 0040-781X. Archived from the original on November 16, 2007. Retrieved 2009-09-14.
25. Schazlein, Joanne; Sulmasy, Daniel P. (1987). The Diagnosis of St. Francis: Evidence for Leprosy. Franciscan Studies 47: 181–217.
26. . Time Magazine. 19 December 1949. Archived from the original on May 1, 2008. Retrieved 2008-01-19.
27. . Time Magazine. 24 April 1964. Archived from the original on September 30, 2007. Retrieved 2008-01-19.
28. Marie osb, Dom Antoine (2000-04-24). "Letter on Blessed Pader Pio: Stigmata – Sacraments of Penance and Eucharist – Suffering". Retrieved 2006-09-27.
29. Michael Freze, 1989, They Bore the Wounds of Christ: The Mystery of the Sacred Stigmata, OSV Publishing ISBN 0-87973-422-1 pp. 283–285.
30. "Padre Pio". Britannica.com. 1968. Retrieved 2012-02-27.
31. Ruffin, Barnard. (1991). Padre Pio: The True Story. OSV Press. pp. 160–178. ISBN 0-87973-673-9
32. Quote: Maria De Vito said, "I was an admirer of Padre Pio and I met him for the first time on July 31, 1919...he gave me personally an empty bottle, and asked if I would act as a chauffeur to transport it back from Foggia to San Giovanni Rotondo with four grams of pure carbolic acid. ... He explained that the acid was for disinfecting syringes for injections. He also asked for other things, such as Valda pastilles." Moore, Malcolm (2007-10-24). "Italy's Padre Pio 'faked his stigmata with acid'". The Daily Telegraph. Rome. Retrieved 2012-04-25..
33. Higgins, Michael W. (2006). Stalking the Holy: The Pursuit of Saint Making. Anansi Press. p. 129. ISBN 0-88784-181-3
34. Gaeta, Saverio; Tornielli, Andrea (2008). Padre Pio, l'ultimo sospetto : la verità sul frate delle stimmate (in Italian). Casale Monferrato (Alessandria): Piemme.
35. Nickell, Joe. (2001). Real-Life X-Files: Investigating the Paranormal. University of Kentucky Press. pp. 276–288. ISBN 0-8131-2210-4
36. ^{[citation needed]}
37. "Mother Mariam Thresia Mankidiyan: From silent mystic to apostle of the family". www.vaticannews.va. October 12, 2019.
38. Wilson, Ian (1989). Stigmata: an investigation into the mysterious appearance of Christ's wounds in hundreds of people from medieval Italy to modern America. New York, NY: Harper & Row. pp. 10, 62. ISBN 0062509748.
39. Smeyers, Kristof (Autumn 2018). "Building the Archive of Stigmatic Women Religious". An Irish Quarterly Review. 107: 337–339 – via JSTOR.
40. Nickell, Joe. (2001). Real-Life X-Files: Investigating the Paranormal. University of Kentucky Press. p. 281. ISBN 0-8131-2210-4 "That many stigmatics were fakes is well established. For example, Magdalena de la Cruz, having become ill in 1543 and fearful of dying a sinner, confessed that her stigmata, inedia, and other phenomena were deliberate deceptions."
41. Porter, Dorothy; Porter, Roy (1993). Doctors, Politics and Society: Historical Essays. Rodopi. pp. 120–121. ISBN 90-5183-510-8
42. Hustvedt, Asti. (2011). Medical Muses: Hysteria in Nineteenth-Century Paris. Bloomsbury. p. 279. ISBN 978-1-4088-2235-7
43. Mazzoni, Cristina (1996). Saint Hysteria: Neurosis, Mysticism, and Gender in European Culture. Cornell University Press. pp. 24–28, 136–140. ISBN 0-8014-3229-4
44. Seidl, O. (2008). Stigmatisation and Absence of Nutrition in the Case of Therese Neumann (1898–1962). Nervenarzt 79 (7): 836–843.
45. Regal, Brian (2009). Pseudoscience: A Critical Encyclopedia. Greenwood. pp. 154–155. ISBN 978-0-313-35507-3
46. Kluger, N.; Cribier, B. (2013). Stigmata: From Saint-Francis of Assisi to Idiopathic Haematidrosis. Annales de Dermatologie et de Vénéréologie 140: 771–777.
47. Fessler, Daniel (2002). (PDF). Mind and Society: Cognitive Studies in Economics and Social Sciences. 3 (2): 81–96. Archived from the original (PDF) on February 22, 2006. Retrieved 2009-09-12.
48. Yaryura-Tobias, Jose A.; Neziroglu, Fugen A.; Kaplan, Steven (1995). "Self-mutilation, anorexia, and dysmenorrhea in obsessive compulsive disorder". International Journal of Eating Disorders. 17 (1): 33–38. doi:10.1002/1098-108X(199501)17:1<33::AID-EAT2260170104>3.0.CO;2-2. PMID 7894450.
49. Curtin, A. P. (1946). "Imprisonment under the Japanese". BMJ. 2 (4476): 585–586. doi:10.1136/bmj.2.4476.585. ISSN 0959-8138. PMC 2054516. PMID 21284113.
50. Keys, Ancel (1950). The Biology of Human Starvation. University of Minnesota Press.
51. Zusne, Leonard; Jones, Warren H. (1989). Anomalistic Psychology: A Study of Magical Thinking. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Inc. pp. 54–56. ISBN 978-0-805-80507-9
52. Early, Loretta F; Lifschutz, Joseph E. (1974). A Case of Stigmata Loretta. Arch Gen Psychiatry 30 (2):197–200.
53. Ratnoff, O. D. (1980). The psychogenic purpuras: A review of autoerythrocyte sensitization, autosensitization to DNA, "hysterical" and factitial bleeding, and the religious stigmata. Semin Hematol 17: 192–213.
54. Panconesi, E., & Hautmann, G. (1995). "Stress, Stigmatization and Psychosomatic Purpuras". International Angiology 14: 130–137.
55. Armando De Vincentiis (2011). "New insights into the phenomenon of Natuzza Evolo". Italian Committee for the Investigation of Claims on the Paranormal. Retrieved 12 May 2016.
56. "Rivas, Catalina (Katya or Catia)". The Skeptic's Dictionary.
57. Albright, M. (2002). "The Stigmata: The Psychological and Ethical Message of the Posttraumatic Sufferer". Psychoanalysis and Contemporary Thought. 25 (3): 329–358.
58. "Padre Pio: in Italy 21 stigmatized like the friar". Rome: Adnkronos. December 18, 1997.
59. Johannes Wilbert : Warao Basketry. OCCASIONAL PAPERS OF THE MUSEUM OF CULTURAL HISTORY, University of California at Los Angeles, No. 3, 1975. pp. 5–6
60. Keith Taylor & John Whitmore : Essays into Vietnamese Pasts. Southeast Asia Program, Cornell University, 1985. p. 278
61. cited in Ing-Britt Trankell & Laura Summers : Facets of Power and Its Limitations. Department of Cultural Anthropology, Uppsala University, 1998. p. 24
62. Shepard, Leslie. (1991). Encyclopedia of Occultism & Parapsychology. Gale Research Company. p. 1779
63. Wolffram, Heather (2012). "Trick, Manipulation and Farce: Albert Moll's Critique of Occultism". Medical History. 56 (2): 277–295. doi:10.1017/mdh.2011.37. PMC 3381525. PMID 23002297.

Further reading

• Biot, René. (1962). The Enigma of the Stigmata. Hawthorn Books.
• Carroll, Robert Todd. (2003). Stigmata. In The Skeptic's Dictionary. Wiley. ISBN 978-0-471-27242-7
• Harrison, Ted. (1994). Stigmata: A Medieval Phenomenon in a Modern Age. St Martins Press. ISBN 0-312-11372-2
• Mazzoni, Cristina. (1996). Saint Hysteria: Neurosis, Mysticism, and Gender in European Culture. Cornell University Press. ISBN 0-8014-3229-4
• Nickell, Joe. (1993). Looking for a Miracle: Weeping Icons, Relics, Stigmata, Visions & Healing Cures. Prometheus Books. ISBN 1-57392-680-9
• Radford, Benjamin. (2014). What is Stigmata?. LiveScience. Retrieved 12 May 2016.
• Wilson, Ian. (1988). The Bleeding Mind: An Investigation into the Mysterious Phenomena of Stigmata. Weidenfeld & Nicolson. ISBN 0-297-79099-4
• Yarom, Nitza. (1992). Body, Blood, and Sexuality: A Psychoanalytic Study of St. Francis' Stigmata and Their Historical Context. Peter Lang Publisher.
• Van Osselaer, Tina; Graus, Andrea; Rossi, Leonardo; Smeyers, Kristof. The Devotion and Promotion of Stigmatics in Europe c. 1800-1950, between Saints and Celebrities (PDF). Numen Book Series-Studies in the History of Religions. Vol. 167. Leiden, Boston: Brill. p. 487. ISBN 978-90-04-43935-1. ISSN 0169-8834. LCCN 2020031449. (PDF) from the original on September 9, 2021.

External links

•   Media related to Stigmata at Wikimedia Commons