Stuttering therapy

Stuttering therapy is any of the various treatment methods that attempt to reduce stuttering to some degree in an individual.^[1] Stuttering can be seen as a challenge to treat because there is a lack of consensus about therapy.^[2]

Before beginning therapy treatment, an assessment is needed, as diagnosing stuttering requires the skills of a certified speech–language pathologist (SLP).^[3] Some of the available treatments focus on learning strategies to minimize stuttering through speed reduction, breathing regulation, and gradual progression from single-syllable responses to longer words, and eventually more complex sentences. Furthermore, some stuttering therapies help to address the anxiety that is often caused by stuttering, and consequently worsens stuttering symptoms.^[4] This method of treatment is referred to as a comprehensive approach, in which the main emphasis of treatment is directed toward improving the speaker's attitudes toward communication and minimizing the negative impact stuttering can have on the speaker's life.^[5] Treatment from a qualified S-LP can benefit stutterers of any age.^[6]

In addition, people may learn to start saying words in a slightly slower and less physically tense manner. They may also learn to control or monitor their breathing. When learning to control speech rate, people often begin by practising smooth, fluent speech at rates that are much slower than typical speech, using short phrases and sentences. Over time, people learn to produce smooth speech at faster rates, in longer sentences, and in more challenging situations until speech sounds both fluent and natural. When treating stuttering in children, some researchers recommend that an evaluation be conducted every three months in order to determine whether or not the selected treatment option is working effectively. "Follow-up" or "maintenance" sessions are often necessary after completion of formal intervention to prevent relapse.^[7]

Approaches

There are different approaches to stuttering therapy. There is no cure for the condition.^[8]

Depending the child or adult, therapy is generally a management of speech comfort, and/or teaching techniques to speak in a controlled way.

Therapy for children

Treatment of stuttering in children younger than six years of age focuses on the prevention or elimination of stuttering. Families play an important role in the management of stuttering in children: therapy is usually characterized providing an environment that encourages slow speech, affording the child time to talk, and modeling slowed and relaxed speech.

The Lidcombe Program

Lidcombe therapy has involves a parent or some significant person in the child's life being trained and delivering treatment in the child's everyday environment.^[9] In the program, family members are to provide an environment in which the child receives praise for fluent speech in the child's daily speaking and negative correction of stuttering. Some of the most effective preschool intervention programs call for direct acknowledgment of stuttering in the form of contingencies such as "that was bumpy" or "that was smooth".

Fluency shaping

Fluency shaping therapy focuses on changing all of the speech of the person who stutters. This type of therapy involves teaching the stutterer to use a speaking style that requires careful and prominent self-monitoring; examples of such therapy include one in which the stutterer slows his speech down or speaks in a controlled tone. This type of approach can reduce stuttering, although in children its effectiveness decreases if stuttering persists after eight years of age.

People who stutter are trained to reduce their speaking rate by stretching vowels and consonants, and using other disfluency-reducing techniques such as continuous airflow and soft speech contacts. The result is very slow, monotonic, but fluent speech, used only in the speech clinic. After the person who stutters masters these skills, the speaking rate and intonation are increased gradually. This more normal-sounding, fluent speech is then transferred to daily life outside the speech clinic, though lack of speech naturalness at the end of treatment remains a frequent criticism. Fluency shaping approaches are often taught in intensive group therapy programs, which may take two to three weeks to complete.

Modifying Phonation Intervals (MPI)

The Modifying Phonation Intervals (MPI) Stuttering Treatment Program is designed to be a computer-aided, bio-feedback program that requires appropriate software (MPI smartphone app) and hardware (a throat microphone headset) which records the phonation intervals, or PIs, from the surface of the speaker's throat.

The app records all PIs as well as speaker-rated speech performance measures.

The MPI Stuttering Treatment Program is based on a series of experimental studies by Roger Ingham and colleagues (Gow & Ingham, 1992;^[10] Ingham, Kilgo, Ingham, Moglia, Belknap, & Sanchez, 2001;^[11] Ingham, Montgomery, & Ulliana, 1983^[12]).

The MPI Stuttering Treatment Schedule is divided into four phases: Pre-Treatment, Establishment, Transfer, and Maintenance. Each phase is designed to be managed jointly by the speaker (person who stutters) and the clinician. The Pre-Treatment phase is directed by the clinician, but the other phases are largely self-managed while also requiring regular validation by a clinician.

Stuttering modification

Stuttering modification therapy, also known as traditional stuttering therapy,^[2] was developed by Charles Van Riper between 1936 and 1958.^[13] It focuses on reducing the severity of stuttering by changing only the portions of speech in which a person stutters, to make them smoother, shorter, less tense and hard, and less penalizing. This approach attempts to reduce the severity and fear of stuttering, and strives to teach stutterers to stutter with control, and not to make the stutterer fluent. Therapy using this approach tends to recognize the fear and avoidance of stuttering.

Contemporary devices

Contemporary devices used to reduce stuttering alters the frequency of the speaker's voice to mimic the "choral effect", a phenomenon in which person's stutter decreases or ceases completely when she is speaking with a group of others, or slows the rate of speech through delayed auditory feedback.

Delayed auditory feedback devices, such as Speech Easy encourage the slowing down of speech by replaying the speaker's words into their ears. The stutterer is then forced to slow their rate of speech to prevent distortions in the speech that is heard through the device. This is not effective for all people who stutter, and is shown to wear off over time.^[14] In a 2006 review of the efficacy of stuttering treatments, none of the studies on altered auditory feedback met the criteria for experimental quality, such as the presence of control groups.^[15]

There are specialized mobile applications and PC programs for stutter treatment. The goal pursued by the applications of this kind is speech cycle restoration: I say, I hear, I build a phrase, I say, and so on, using various methods of stutter correction.^[16]

The user interacts with the application through altered auditory feedback: they say something into the headset's microphone and listen to their own voice in the headphones processed by a certain method.^[16]

The following stutter correction methods are typically used in applications:

• MAF (masking auditory feedback). It is basically masking by white noise or sinus noises of the user's own speech. Scientists believe that people who stutter can speak more smoothly when they do not hear their own speech. This method is considered old-fashioned and ineffective.^[17][18][19]
• DAF (delayed auditory feedback). This method involves sending the user's voice from a microphone to headphones with a delay of fractions of a second. The goal of this method is to teach people who stutter to prolong vowels and reduce their speech rate. After speech correction with long delays, the application is adjusted at shorter delays which increase the speech rate until it becomes normal.^[20][21]
• FAF (frequency-shifted auditory feedback). This method involves shifting the user's voice tone frequency that they are listening to compared to their own voice. The shift range can be different: from several semitones to half an octave.^[22][23][24]
• Using metronomes and tempo correctors. Rhythmic metronome strikes are used in this method. The effectiveness of the method is related to the fact that rhythm has positive effect on someone who stutters, especially when pronouncing slowly.^[25]
• Using visual feedback. This method determines the user's speech parameters (for instance, speech tempo) and their representation on screen as visual information. The principal goal of the method is allowing the user to effectively manage their voice through achieving the defined targeted parameters. It is supposed that the user sees visual representation of both current and targeted parameters (such as speech tempo) on the screen while pronouncing.^[26][27]

Medications

No medication is FDA-approved for stuttering.

The best studied medication in stuttering is olanzapine, whose effectiveness as of 2004^[28] had been established in replicated trials. Olanzapine acts as a dopamine antagonist to D2 receptors in the mesolimbic pathway, and works similarly on serotonin 5HT2A receptors in the frontal cortex.^[29] At doses between 2.5 and 5 mg, olanzapine has been shown to be more effective than placebo at reducing stuttering symptoms, and may serve as a first-line pharmacological treatment for stuttering based on the preponderance of its efficacy data.^[30] However, other medications are generally better tolerated with less weight gain and less risk of metabolic effects than olanzapine.

The investigational compound, ecopipam, is unique from other dopamine antagonists in that it acts on D1 receptors instead of D2, owing little, if any risk, of movement disorders. A 2019 open label study of ecopipam in adults demonstrated significantly improved stuttering symptoms with no reports of parkinsonian-like movement disorders or tardive dyskinesia which can be seen with D2 antagonists.^[31] In addition, ecopipam had no reported weight gain, but instead has been reported to lead to weight loss.^[31] In a preliminary study, it was well tolerated in subjects, effectively reduced stuttering severity, and was even associated in a short-term study with improved quality of life in persons who stutter.^[31] Further research is still warranted, but this novel mechanism is showing promise in the pharmacologic treatment of stuttering.

Diaphragmatic breathing

Several treatment initiatives use diaphragmatic breathing (or costal breathing) as a means by which stuttering can be controlled.^[32]

Psychological approach

Cognitive behavior therapy has been used to treat stuttering.^[33] Also sociological approaches has been explored regarding how social groups maintain stuttering through social norms.^[34]

Self-therapy and community groups

Community groups

Stuttering support/community groups have gained prominence and visibility and can be an important part of the process for stutterers,^[35][36] A growing number of speech–language pathologists encourage their clients to participate in support groups.^[35]

Research shows that participating in support groups and self-help sessions with others who stutter may reduce the negative attitudes associated with stuttering.^[37] Becoming part of stuttering groups may help reduce the feelings of loneliness, fear, shame and embarrassment that comes with years of stuttering.^[38] Participants of group sessions show lower internalization of stigma regarding stuttering. They have lower levels of negative feelings about themselves. Moreover, the goal of helping others who stutter in the group has been linked to better psychological well-being.^[39]

Studies in the United States involving members of support groups of the National Stuttering Association have found that 57.1% of survey respondents said that the support group had affected their self-image "very positively", with no respondents indicating that it had a negative impact.^[35]

McGuire Programme

The McGuire Programme is a stammering or stuttering treatment programme/course run for people who stammer or stutter (ages 14+) by people who stammer. There are no licensed speech therapists involved. It was founded in 1994 by American Dave McGuire in Holland.^[40]

Scottish international rugby union captain, Kelly Brown, is a graduate of the course.^[41] Singer Gareth Gates attended the programme's workshops and subsequently qualified as a speech instructor himself.^[42] Stammering awareness activist^[43] Adam Black, also a graduate of the course, received a British Empire Medal in the 2019 New Year Honours list where his work raising awareness of stammering was recognised.^{[44][45][46][47]}

Cognitive Behavioral Therapy

Cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) may be used to help people who stutter. CBT may be partially effective in helping clients reduce their secondary behaviors, anxiety, and cognitive distortion.^[48][49] Cognitive behavioral therapy is a collaborative process that requires the client and the therapist working together to explore the buried feelings of frustration, avoidance, anger, and self-doubt. Younger children who stutter are more benefited by CBT as compared to adults who stutter. Research at the Michael Palin Center has shown that CBT is a powerful tool for children who stutter.^[50]

Pharmacologic therapy

Several pharmacologic, i.e. drug-based, methods to control or alleviate stuttering events have been studied, but each has either proved ineffective or have had adverse effects. A comprehensive review of pharmacologic interventions for stuttering showed that no agent leads to valid improvement in stuttering or in secondary social and emotional consequences.

See also

• "The Monster Study", 1939 experiment condemned for its treatment of orphans.

References

1. Stuttering. National Institute on Deafness and Other Communication Disorders (2002–05). Retrieved on 2008-08-25.
2. Prasse, JE; Kikano, GE (1 May 2008). "Stuttering: an overview". American Family Physician. 77 (9): 1271–6. PMID 18540491.  
3. "Stuttering". Asha.org. Archived from the original on 2013-11-20. Retrieved 2014-05-12.
4. "Stuttering". Nidcd.nih.gov. from the original on 2014-04-04. Retrieved 2014-05-12.
5. (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on 2010-06-16. Retrieved 2014-05-12.
6. (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on 2010-06-16.
7. "Stuttering". Asha.org. Archived from the original on 2009-10-16. Retrieved 2014-05-12.
8. Is There a Stammering Cure? Stamma.com.
9. Manual for the Lidcombe Program of Early Stuttering Intervention 2009-07-31 at the Wayback Machine. The University of Sydney (2002). Retrieved on 2008-08-28.
10. Gow, M.L, & Ingham, R.J. (1992). The effect of modifying electroglottograph identified intervals of phonation on stuttering. Journal of Speech and Hearing Disorders, 35, 495–511. Retrieved on 2015-03-22.
11. Ingham, R.J., Kilgo, M., Ingham, J.C., Moglia, R., Belknap, H., & Sanchez, T. (2001). Evaluation of a stuttering treatment based on reduction of short phonation intervals. Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research, 44, 1229–1244. Retrieved on 2015-03-22.
12. Ingham, R.J., Montgomery, J., & Ulliana, L. (1983). The effect of manipulating phonation duration on stuttering. Journal of Speech and Hearing Research, 26, 579–587. Retrieved on 2015-03-22.
13. Kehoe, T. D. Speech-Related Fears and Anxieties 2008-07-24 at the Wayback Machine. No Miracle Cures:A Multifactoral Guide to Stuttering Therapy. Retrieved 2009-08-30.
14. review of delayed auditory feedback effectiveness for stuttering reduction. CRF de Andrade & Fabiola Staróble Juste. Evidence based Speech-Language Pathology and Audiology, May 2011.
15. Bothe, AK; Davidow, JH; Bramlett, RE; Ingham, RJ (2006). "Stuttering Treatment Research 1970–2005: I. Systematic Review Incorporating Trial Quality Assessment of Behavioral, Cognitive, and Related Approaches". American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology. 15 (4): 321–341. doi:10.1044/1058-0360(2006/031). PMID 17102144. S2CID 24775349.
16. "Electronic Devices, Software and Apps". Stuttering Foundation: A Nonprofit Organization Helping Those Who Stutter. 6 May 2011. Retrieved 2019-11-21.
17. Kalinowski, J.; Armson, J.; Roland-Mieszkowski, M.; Stuart, A.; Gracco, V. L. (1993). "Effects of alterations in auditory feedback and speech rate on stuttering frequency". Language and Speech. 36 (1): 1–16. doi:10.1177/002383099303600101. ISSN 0023-8309. PMID 8345771. S2CID 16949019.
18. Jacks, Adam; Haley, Katarina L. (2015). "Auditory Masking Effects on Speech Fluency in Apraxia of Speech and Aphasia: Comparison to Altered Auditory Feedback". Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research. 58 (6): 1670–1686. doi:10.1044/2015_JSLHR-S-14-0277. ISSN 1092-4388. PMC 4987030. PMID 26363508.
19. Burke, Bryan D. (1969-09-01). "Reduced auditory feedback and stuttering". Behaviour Research and Therapy. 7 (3): 303–308. doi:10.1016/0005-7967(69)90011-4. ISSN 0005-7967.
20. Bothe Anne K.; Finn Patrick; Bramlett Robin E. (2007-02-01). "Pseudoscience and the SpeechEasy: Reply to Kalinowski, Saltuklaroglu, Stuart, and Guntupalli (2007)". American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology. 16 (1): 77–83. doi:10.1044/1058-0360(2007/010).
21. Picoloto, Luana Altran; Cardoso, Ana Cláudia Vieira; Cerqueira, Amanda Venuti; Oliveira, Cristiane Moço Canhetti de (2017-12-07). "Effect of delayed auditory feedback on stuttering with and without central auditory processing disorders". CoDAS. 29 (6): e20170038. doi:10.1590/2317-1782/201720170038. hdl:11449/179424. ISSN 2317-1782. PMID 29236907.
22. Kalinowski, Joseph; Armson, Joy; Stuart, Andrew; Gracco, Vincent L. (1993). "Effects of Alterations in Auditory Feedback and Speech Rate on Stuttering Frequency". Language and Speech. 36 (1): 1–16. doi:10.1177/002383099303600101. ISSN 0023-8309. PMID 8345771. S2CID 16949019.
23. Zimmerman Stephen; Kalinowski Joseph; Stuart Andrew; Rastatter Michael (1997-10-01). "Effect of Altered Auditory Feedback on People Who Stutter During Scripted Telephone Conversations". Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research. 40 (5): 1130–1134. doi:10.1044/jslhr.4005.1130. PMID 9328884.
24. Howell, Peter; Davis, Stephen; Bartrip, Jon; Wormald, Laura (2004-09-01). "Effectiveness of frequency shifted feedback at reducing disfluency for linguistically easy, and difficult, sections of speech (original audio recordings included)". Stammering Research. 1 (3): 309–315. ISSN 1742-5867. PMC 2312336. PMID 18418474.
25. Brady, John Paul (1969-05-01). "Studies on the metronome effect on stuttering". Behaviour Research and Therapy. 7 (2): 197–204. doi:10.1016/0005-7967(69)90033-3. ISSN 0005-7967. PMID 5808691.
26. Hudock, Daniel; Dayalu, Vikram N.; Saltuklaroglu, Tim; Stuart, Andrew; Zhang, Jianliang; Kalinowski, Joseph (2011). "Stuttering inhibition via visual feedback at normal and fast speech rates". International Journal of Language & Communication Disorders. 46 (2): 169–178. doi:10.3109/13682822.2010.490574. ISSN 1460-6984. PMID 21401815.
27. Chesters, Jennifer; Baghai-Ravary, Ladan; Möttönen, Riikka (2015). "The effects of delayed auditory and visual feedback on speech production". The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America. 137 (2): 873–883. Bibcode:2015ASAJ..137..873C. doi:10.1121/1.4906266. ISSN 0001-4966. PMC 4477042. PMID 25698020.
28. Maguire Gerald A., Riley Glyndon D., Franklin David L., Maguire Michael E., Nguyen Charles T., Brojeni Pedram H. (2004). "Olanzapine in the treatment of developmental stuttering: a double-blind, placebo-controlled trial". Annals of Clinical Psychiatry. 16 (2): 63–67. doi:10.1080/10401230490452834. PMID 15328899.{{cite journal}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
29. Thomas, K., & Saadabadi, A. (2018). Olanzapine. In StatPearls [Internet]. StatPearls Publishing.
30. Shaygannejad V., Khatoonabadi S. A., Shafiei B., Ghasemi M., Fatehi F., Meamar R., Dehghani L. (2013). "Olanzapine versus haloperidol: which can control stuttering better?". International Journal of Preventive Medicine. 4 (Suppl 2): S270-3. PMC 3678230. PMID 23776736.{{cite journal}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
31. Maguire, G.A., Lasalle L., Hoffmeyer D., Nelson M., Lochead J.D., Davis K., Burris A., Yaruss J.S., "Ecopipam as a pharmacologic treatment of stuttering." Ann Clin Psychiatry (2019 Aug), 31(3), 164-168.
32. . American Institute for Stuttering. Archived from the original on 2010-11-15.
33. Reddy, R.P. (Spring 2017). "Cognitive Behavior Therapy for Stuttering: A Case Series". Indian Journal of Psychological Medicine. 2010 jan-jun 32(1) (1): 49–53. doi:10.4103/0253-7176.70533. PMC 3137813. PMID 21799560.
34. . Stuttering Habits. Archived from the original on 2017-04-18.
35. Yaruss, J. S., Quesal, R. W., Reeves, L., Molt, L. F., Kluetz, B., Caruso, A. J., et al. (2002). Speech treatment and support group experiences of people who participate in the National Stuttering Association. Journal of Fluency Disorders, 27(2), 115–134.
36. Yaruss, J. S., Quesal, R. W., Murphy, B. (2002). National Stuttering Association members' opinions about stuttering treatment. Journal of Fluency Disorders, 27(3), 227–242.
37. Tichenor Seth E.; Yaruss J. Scott (2019-12-18). "Group Experiences and Individual Differences in Stuttering". Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research. 62 (12): 4335–4350. doi:10.1044/2019_JSLHR-19-00138. PMID 31830852. S2CID 209340620.
38. "Why You Should Talk to Others Who Stutter". Stamurai Blog – Stuttering Information, Advice & News. 2020-10-18. Retrieved 2021-05-31.
39. Boyle, Michael P. (2013-12-01). "Psychological characteristics and perceptions of stuttering of adults who stutter with and without support group experience". Journal of Fluency Disorders. 38 (4): 368–381. doi:10.1016/j.jfludis.2013.09.001. ISSN 0094-730X. PMID 24331244.
40. Chadwick, Vince (2 February 2013). "Stutterers swear by program but speech experts unconvinced". The Sydney Morning Herald. Retrieved 13 February 2021.
41. Dirs, Ben (5 February 2014). "Scotland captain Kelly Brown tackling his stammer head on". BBC News. Retrieved 30 September 2014.
42. "Gareth Gates becomes speech coach". BBC News. 12 May 2004. Retrieved 21 December 2022.
43. Carrick, Heather (22 October 2020). "Stammering Awareness Day: Campaigner on how events are taking a different approach this year". Glasgow Times. Retrieved 29 October 2020.
44. McIver, Brian (29 August 2014). "Primary school teacher Adam Black tells how McGuire Programme helped him overcome stammer and land his dream job". Daily Record. Retrieved 29 October 2020.
45. "Adam Black doesn't want to hide his stutter anymore". BBC News. 11 July 2018. Retrieved 3 June 2019.
46. "'I thought my New Year Honours was a tax return'". BBC Newsbeat. 29 December 2018. Retrieved 3 June 2019.
47. McDonald, Sally (29 March 2016). "Man learns to control his stutter to fulfil his dream of being a teacher". Sunday Post. Retrieved 3 June 2019.
48. Reddy, R. P.; Sharma, M. P.; Shivashankar, N. (2010). "Cognitive Behavior Therapy for Stuttering: A Case Series". Indian Journal of Psychological Medicine. 32 (1): 49–53. doi:10.4103/0253-7176.70533. ISSN 0253-7176. PMC 3137813. PMID 21799560.
49. Blomgren, Michael (15 November 2010). "Stuttering Treatment for Adults: An Update on Contemporary Approaches". Seminars in Speech and Language. 31 (4): 272–282. doi:10.1055/s-0030-1265760. PMID 21080299.
50. Kelman, Elaine; Wheeler, Sarah (2015-06-30). "Cognitive Behaviour Therapy with children who stutter". Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences. 193: 165–174. doi:10.1016/j.sbspro.2015.03.256. ISSN 1877-0428.

External links

• Stammering assessment and management
• Stuttering and professional like speech language pathologist
• Stutter No More – The Fast, Simple, Proven Technique with an Astonishing Long-Term Success Rate by Dr. Martin F. Schwartz, executive director of The National Center for Stuttering (Simon & Schuster Ltd; Reprint Edition, 1992, ISBN 9780671755041, available in full for online borrowing at Internet Archive with a free account, for 14 days)
• Childhood Stuttering (1SpecialPlace Blog) – information about childhood stuttering, journal about stuttering in children
• McGuire Programme