McCrae's Battalion

McCrae's Battalion was the affectionate name given by the people of Edinburgh to the 16th (Service) Battalion of the Royal Scots in World War I, raised from volunteers in 1914 as part of the New Armies called to the Colours by Lord Kitchener. The unit was named after its charismatic colonel, former Liberal MP for Edinburgh East, Sir George McCrae.

Background

Largely composed of professional and amateur sportsmen, "McCrae's" was the first of the so-called 'footballers' Pals battalions to be raised during the war and was the main inspiration behind the creation of the 17th Battalion, Middlesex Regiment in 1915.^[1][2]

16 players from Heart of Midlothian F.C. ("Hearts") enlisted, along with 500 supporters and ticket-holders.^[1] Hearts were leading the Scottish League at the time the battalion was raised in November 1914.^[3] In addition to the Hearts contingent, players and 150 followers of Hibernian, seven Raith Rovers players and a number of professional footballers from Falkirk, Dunfermline Athletic, East Fife and St Bernard's also enlisted.^[1][4][5] Fans were encouraged to follow in their heroes' footsteps and fight alongside the men they cheered on every Saturday afternoon.^[1] Rugby players, athletes and a variety of other sportsmen also joined the battalion.^{[1][6][7][8][9][10][11]}

The contemporary Hearts manager John McCartney authored two booklets documenting Scottish footballers in the Great War and those from Hearts who perished.^[12][13]

The unit was named after its charismatic colonel, Sir George McCrae, a former Liberal MP for Edinburgh East. It was the subject of a detailed historical account published in 2003 by Jack Alexander.^[14] Shortly after the publication of this book, a memorial cairn was constructed in the village of Contalmaison on the Somme. Designed by Alexander, the McCrae's Battalion Great War Memorial cairn now attracts hundreds of visitors every year to the village.^[15][16]

In October 2014, the battalion was inducted to the Scottish Football Hall of Fame.^[17]

Gallery

•  

  Hearts war memorial at Haymarket, Edinburgh

•  

  detail of Contalmaison cairn (1)

•  

  detail of Contalmaison cairn (2)

•  

  Tom Gracie, one of those who lost their lives

•  

  Raith Rovers players in McCrae's Battalion

Battalion members

See also: Heart of Midlothian F.C. and World War I

Footballers

Rank	Name	Nationality	Position	Club prior to enlistment	Battalion(s)	Wartime death date	Wartime death place	Decorations	Notes	Ref
Cpt	James Logan	Scotland	CF	Raith Rovers	16th	—	—	—		^[18]
CSM	Annan Ness	Scotland	LH	Heart of Midlothian	9th, 16th	—	—	—	^[nb 1]	^[19]
SSgt	Jimmy Frew	Scotland	LB	Heart of Midlothian	16th	—	—	—	^[nb 2]	^[19]
Sgt	Duncan Currie	Scotland	FB	Heart of Midlothian	16th	1 July 1916(1916-07-01) (aged 23)	Somme, France	—		^[20]
Sgt	George McLay	Scotland	RH	Raith Rovers	16th	22 October 1917(1917-10-22) (aged 27–28)	Passchendaele, Belgium	MM		^[21]
Cpl	Alfie Briggs	Scotland	WH	Heart of Midlothian	16th	—	—	—	^[nb 3]	^[19]
Cpl	Norman Findlay	England	GK	Heart of Midlothian	16th	—	—	—	^[nb 4]	^[19]
Cpl	Tom Gracie	Scotland	CF	Heart of Midlothian	16th	23 October 1915(1915-10-23) (aged 26)	Glasgow, Scotland	—		^[22]
LCpl	Alex Henderson	Scotland	LB	Falkirk	16th	—	—	—		^[11]
Pte	Jimmy Boyd	Scotland	GK	Heart of Midlothian	16th	3 August 1916(1916-08-03) (aged 20–21)	Somme, France	—		^[23]
Pte	Paddy Crossan	Scotland	FB	Heart of Midlothian	16th	—	—	—	^[nb 3]	^[19]
Pte	Ernest Ellis	England	RB	Heart of Midlothian	16th	1 July 1916(1916-07-01) (aged 30)	Somme, France	—		^[24]
Pte	Mick Gibbons	Scotland	IF	Falkirk	16th	—	—	—		^[11]
Pte	Bob Godfrey	Scotland	CH	Falkirk	16th	—	—	—	^[nb 3]	^[25]
Pte	Jimmy Hawthorn	Scotland	HB	Heart of Midlothian	16th	1 July 1916	Somme, France	—		^[26]
Pte	Jimmy Hazeldean	Scotland	OL	Heart of Midlothian	16th	—	—	—	^[nb 3]	^[19]
Pte	Andy Henderson	Scotland	CH	Falkirk	16th	—	—	—		^[11]
Pte	David Izatt	Scotland	HB	Dunfermline Athletic	16th	1 July 1916(1916-07-01) (aged 23–24)	Somme, France	—		^[27]
Pte	William Lavery	Scotland	RB	Raith Rovers	16th	—	—	—		^[28]
Pte	Teddy McGuire	Scotland	IR	Heart of Midlothian	16th	—	—	—	^[nb 3]	^[19]
Pte	John Morrison	Scotland	FW	Falkirk	16th	—	—	—		^[11]
Pte	Jimmy Morton	Scotland	IL	Kilmarnock	16th	1 July 1916(1916-07-01) (aged 22)	Somme, France	—		^[29]
Pte	Willie Porter	Scotland	CH	Raith Rovers	16th	—	—	—		^[28]
Pte	Bob Preston	Scotland	HB	Heart of Midlothian	16th	—	—	—	^[nb 5]	^[19]
Pte	Jock Rattray	Scotland	IF	Raith Rovers	16th	—	—	—		^[28]
Pte	Frank Reilly	Scotland	CH	Falkirk	16th	—	—	—		^[11]
Pte	James Scott	Scotland	FW	Raith Rovers	16th	1 July 1916(1916-07-01) (aged 20–21)	Somme, France	—		^[30]
Pte	Wattie Scott	Scotland	CH	Heart of Midlothian	16th	—	—	—		^[19]
Pte	Harold Sparkes	England	CF	Glossop	3rd, 11th, 16th	3 June 1917(1917-06-03) (aged 20–21)	Pas-de-Calais, France	—		^[31]
Pte	Jimmy Todd	Scotland	OF	Raith Rovers	16th	12 March 1916(1916-03-12) (aged 20–21)	Nord, France	—		^[32]
Pte	Harry Wattie	Scotland	FW	Heart of Midlothian	16th	1 July 1916(1916-07-01) (aged 23)	Somme, France	—		^[33]
Pte	Willie Wilson	Scotland	OF	Heart of Midlothian	13th, 16th	—	—	—	^[nb 6]	^[19]
Pte	Bobby Wood	Scotland	OF	Falkirk	16th	—	—	—		^[11]
n/a	Sandy Grosert	Scotland	RH	Hibernian	16th	—	—	MM	^[nb 7] ^[nb 8]	^[34]
n/a	James Low	Scotland	OF	Heart of Midlothian	16th	—	—	—	^[nb 9]	^[19]

Other sportsmen

Rank	Name	Nationality	Sport	Club prior to enlistment	Battalion(s)	Wartime death date	Wartime death place	Decorations	Notes	Ref
Lt	Arthur Flett	Scotland	Rugby union	Edinburgh Wanderers	16th	9 April 1917	Pas-de-Calais, France	—		^[35]
Cpt	Napier Armit	Scotland	Cricket	Grange CC	16th	4 August 1916	Somme, France	—		^[35]
Sgt	Finlay MacRae	Scotland	Field hockey	n/a	16th	26 August 1917 (aged 30)	Somme, France	MM and Bar		^[35]
Pte	Arthur Grant	Scotland	Golf	Le Touquet	16th	—	—	—		^[36]
Pte	Harry Harley	Scotland	Athletics	Edinburgh Northern Harriers	16th	1 July 1916	Somme, France	—		^[35]
n/a	Ned Barnie	Scotland	Swimming	—	16th	—	—	MM	^[nb 10] ^[nb 8]	^[37]
n/a	John Dallas	Scotland	Rugby union	Retired	16th	—	—	—		^[35]
n/a	Jim Davie	Scotland	Rugby union	Stewart's Melville	16th	—	—	MC		^[35]
n/a	Murdoch McLeod	Scotland	Bodybuilding	—	16th	1916	Somme, France	—		^[35]

Notes

1. Commissioned into the 9th Battalion, Royal Scots.
2. Transferred to the Royal Garrison Artillery.
3. Medically discharged.
4. Discharged to trade in September 1916.
5. Transferred to the Highland Light Infantry.
6. Transferred to the 13th Battalion, Royal Scots and later returned to the 16th Battalion.
7. Transferred to the Machine Gun Corps in 1915 and was later commissioned into the Gordon Highlanders.
8. Decoration won while serving with another unit.
9. Commissioned into the Seaforth Highlanders.
10. Transferred to the Royal Engineers.

See also

• Football Battalion
• Heart of Midlothian F.C. and World War I

References

1. "The Sporting Battalion". McCrae's Battalion Trust. Retrieved 9 April 2017.
2. . Archived from the original on 24 July 2018. Retrieved 24 July 2018.
3. "21 November 1914 (showing League table)". www.londonhearts.com. London Hearts Supporters' Club. Retrieved 9 April 2017.
4. "Wear These Shirts With Pride – Raith Rovers FC". raithrovers.net.
5. . The National Army Museum. Archived from the original on 6 October 2007. Retrieved 19 March 2007.
6. Purdie, Tom (2014). Hearts: The Supreme Sacrifice to Hearts at War. Amberley Publishing. ISBN 9781445633343.
7. . official website. Heart of Midlothian FC. Archived from the original on 20 March 2017. Retrieved 10 April 2017.
8. . Archived from the original on 11 October 2016. Retrieved 10 April 2017.
9. . Archived from the original on 10 April 2017. Retrieved 10 April 2017.
10. . Archived from the original on 10 April 2017. Retrieved 10 April 2017.
11. . Archived from the original on 10 April 2017. Retrieved 10 April 2017.
12. "Sport In War booklet, 1930" (PDF). ScottishSportHistory.com. Retrieved 11 April 2017.
13. "The "Hearts" and the Great War booklet, 1918" (PDF). National Library of Scotland. Retrieved 11 April 2017.
14. "How Hearts players made the supreme sacrifice". Scotsman.com. The Scotsman. 29 June 2006. Retrieved 9 April 2017.
15. "Poignant 1914 Edinburgh derby to be commemorated on French soil". Scotsman.com. The Scotsman. 12 April 2011. Retrieved 7 October 2011.
16. . Hearts News. Heart of Midlothian F.C. 26 November 2010. Archived from the original on 29 December 2010. Retrieved 7 October 2011.
17. Halliday, Stephen (27 October 2014). "McCrae's Battalion inducted into SFA Hall of Fame". The Scotsman. Retrieved 27 October 2014.
18. "Man behind the scenes at Stark's Park". Evening Telegraph. Dundee. 9 February 1932. p. 8.
19. "The Heart of Midlothian FC Players' Roll of Honour" (PDF). Retrieved 23 July 2018.
20. "Duncan Currie | Service Record | Football and the First World War". Football and the First World War. Retrieved 24 July 2018.
21. "George McLay | Service Record | Football and the First World War". Football and the First World War. Retrieved 24 July 2018.
22. "Thomas Gracie | Service Record | Football and the First World War". Football and the First World War. Retrieved 24 July 2018.
23. "James Boyd | Service Record | Football and the First World War". Football and the First World War. Retrieved 24 July 2018.
24. "Ernest Edgar Ellis | Service Record | Football and the First World War". Football and the First World War. Retrieved 24 July 2018.
25. "Robert Godfrey signs up for McCrae's Battalion 1914". www.falkirk-football-history.co.uk. Retrieved 24 July 2018.
26. "Casualty". www.cwgc.org. Retrieved 23 July 2018.
27. "David Heron Izatt | Service Record | Football and the First World War". Football and the First World War. Retrieved 24 July 2018.
28. "Wear These Shirts With Pride | Raith Rovers FC". www.raithrovers.net. Retrieved 23 July 2018.
29. "Casualty". www.cwgc.org. Retrieved 23 July 2018.
30. "James Scott | Service Record | Football and the First World War". Football and the First World War. Retrieved 24 July 2018.
31. "Harold Sparkes | Football and the First World War". Football and the First World War. Retrieved 24 July 2018.
32. "James Colin Todd | Service Record | Football and the First World War". Football and the First World War. Retrieved 24 July 2018.
33. "Henry Benzie Wattie | Service Record | Football and the First World War". Football and the First World War. Retrieved 24 July 2018.
34. "Hibernian in the Great War" (PDF). Retrieved 23 July 2018.
35. . Archived from the original on 24 July 2018. Retrieved 23 July 2018.
36. Alexander, Jack (18 March 2011). McCrae's Battalion: The Story of the 16th Royal Scots. Random House. ISBN 9781845968212.
37. "Dr William Edward Barnie | King of the Channel". www.kingofthechannel.com. Retrieved 24 July 2018.

External links

• McCrae’s Battalion Trust
• Hearts of courage – The legendary McCrae’s Own (Royal British Legion)
• Scottish Football Hall of Fame profile