Margarete Mauthner

Margarete Mauthner (born Margarete Alexander on July 7, 1863, in Berlin; died April 24, 1947, in Johannesburg) was a German art collector, patron, translator and author, persecuted by Nazis because of her Jewish origins. Her works were published by Bruno Cassirer.^[1]

van Gogh's Chapel of Saint Remy was part of Mauthner's collection

Personal life

Coming from an upper-middle-class family, she was educated first by a governess, then in a secondary school. She was married twice. With her first husband she had a daughter who died in 1946. Her second husband was Edmund Mauthner (1868-1909).^[2]

Work as translator

Mautner translated monographs published by Bruno Cassirer as well as articles for Karl Scheffler's art magazine Kunst und Künstler. In 1917 she wrote her two-volume autobiography Rückblick, in which she traced the developments of the 19th century (the March Revolution, the founding of the Reich, the Gründerzeit, the crisis, the rise of the Jewish bourgeoisie).

The Alexander/Mauthner family lived at Matthäikirchstraße 1 in a house built in 1840, which was destroyed in World War II and is now the site of the Philharmonic Hall. Robert Musil called the building The Enchanted House. Mauthner's manuscript of her autobiography, Rückblick, was rediscovered by Musil biographer Karl Corino, and published in 2004 under the title Das verzauberte Haus.^[3] It describes the interconnections between Mauthner, her brother, her cousin, Paul Cassirer (like his brother Bruno a publisher), and Musil. Das verzauberte Haus also plays a significant role in Musil (Die Versuchung der stillen Veronika, Die Schwärmer) and was also the title of a 1908 Musil work.^[4]

Mauthner was instrumental in making Vincent van Gogh's art known in Germany, translating his letters.^[5]

Among Mauthner's many translations since 1904 is The Artful Art of Making Enemies by the Anglo-American painter James McNeill Whistler, which deals with the libel trial of the art critic John Ruskin, which significantly shaped today's views on defamation and (in)freedoms of (art) criticism.

Nazi persecution and emigration

During the Nazi era, Mauthner helped family members to escape by providing financial support for their emigration. She fled Germany in 1939, leaving her possessions behind.^[6] She emigrated to South Africa, where she died in 1947.

Lawsuits for the restitution of artworks from the Mauthner collection

Mauthner's heirs filed lawsuits to attempt to recover Van Gogh paintings that Mauthner had owned before the Nazis came to power. In 2003 they filed a claim, Orkin v. Taylor, against the Hollywood movie star Elizabeth Taylor for Van Gogh's View of the Hospice and the Chapel of Saint-Remy.^[7][8] Elizabeth Taylor's father, Francis Lenn Taylor, who was an art dealer in partnership with dealer Howard Young of Young Galleries. Francis Taylor had acquired the painting in 1963.^[9][10] The case was dismissed because the court held that California's statute of limitations had expired.^[11] Taylor later sold View of the Hospice and the Chapel of Saint-Remy at auction for 12.2 million euros.^[12][13]

Mauthner's heirs also filed a claim for the restitution of Van Gogh's drawing, View of Les Saintes-Maries-de-la-Mer, in the Oskar Reinhart collection "Am Römerholz", which is under the control of the Federal Office of Culture.^[14] They argued that Mauthner had sold under pressure of the threat she faced from Nazis.^[15] The Swiss government disagreed, saying that Reinhart had bought the work at a fair market price.^[16]

Literary works^[17]

• Rückblick. 1917, 2 Bände, unveröffentlicht
• Das verzauberte Haus. Hrsg. und mit einem Nachwort von Karl Corino. Mit einem Vorwort der Urenkel von Margarete Mauthner. Transit, Berlin 2004, ISBN 978-3-88747-197-2.

As translator

• Briefe, Vincent van Gogh, Berlin, Cassirer, 1906, 144 S., 8. Auflage 1920^[18]
• Die artige Kunst sich Feinde zu machen mit einigen unterhaltenden Beispielen, wie ich die Ernsthaften dieser Erde zuerst mit Vorbedacht zur Raserei und dann in ihrem falschen Rechtsbewusstsein zu Unanständigkeit und Torheit gebracht habe, James McNeill Whistler
  • Berlin, Cassirer, 1909, 284 S.
  • Leipzig, Weimar, Kiepenheuer, 1984
  • Hanau/Main, Müller, 1984, 255 S., ISBN 3-7833-6402-7
  • Amsterdam (= Fundus Bücher 140), Dresden, Verlag der Kunst 1996, ISBN 90-5705-020-X, 288 S.
• Volpone, Ben Jonson, Initialen, Titelblatt und Deckel von Aubrey Beardsley, W. Drugulin, Leipzig, Berlin, Bruno Cassirer, 1910, Frontispiz, 163 S., Heliogravuren
• Der Sturz des Sejanus. Volpone oder der Fuchs. Der Bartholomäusmarkt, Ben Jonson, Berlin, Cassirer, 1912, 406 S.
• Édouard Manet: Erinnerungen, Antonin Proust, Veröff. von A. Barthélemy. Berlin, Bruno Cassirer, 1917, 133 S., 24 Abbildungen, 2. Auflage 1928
• Die Frau Konnetable (La Connestable), Honoré de Balzac, Lithographien von Lovis Corinth, Berlin, Bruno Cassirer, 1922, 22 S.
• Degas: Ambroise Vollard, Berlin, B. Cassirer, 1925, 111 S., 32 Lichtdrucktafeln
• Vom Blockhaus zum Wolkenkratzer: Eine Studie über amerikanische Architektur und Zivilisation (Sticks and Stones), Lewis Mumford, Berlin, Bruno Cassirer, 1925, 292 S., 25 Abbildungen

Literature

• Anna-Carolin Augustin: Biographien jüdischer Frauen: Ein großbürgerliches Frauenleben für die moderne Kunst – Der Rückblick der Berliner Kunstsammlerin Margarete Mauthner In: Medaon 9, 2015, S. 16 (Digitalisat).

References

1. "Katalog der Deutschen Nationalbibliothek". portal.dnb.de. Retrieved 2021-10-15.
2. "Margarete Mauthner". geni_family_tree. 7 July 1863. Retrieved 2021-10-15.
3. Mauthner, Margarete, Corino, Karl (2004). Das verzauberte Haus (in German). Berlin: Transit. ISBN 978-3-88747-197-2. OCLC 491826452.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
4. "Das verzauberte Haus". www.projekt-gutenberg.org. Retrieved 2021-10-15.
5. Berlins, Marcel (2004-12-07). "Elizabeth Taylor's Van Gogh painting hangs in the balance". the Guardian. Retrieved 2021-10-15.
6. M., Donnell, Nicholas (2017). A tragic fate. Law and ethics in the battle over Nazi-looted art. American Bar Association. ISBN 978-1-63425-733-6. OCLC 1007555505.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
7. "SA family fights Liz Taylor for painting". lootedart.com. Retrieved 2021-10-15.
8. "FindLaw's United States Ninth Circuit case and opinions. ndrew J. ORKIN; F. Mark Orkin; Sarah-Rose Josepha Adler; A. Heinrich Zille, Plaintiffs-Appellants, v. Elizabeth TAYLOR, Defendant-Appellee. No. 05-55364. Decided: May 18, 2007". Findlaw. Retrieved 2021-10-15.
9. "Archives Directory for the History of Collecting". research.frick.org. Retrieved 2021-10-15.
10. Neuendorf, Henri (2018-03-21). "A Prize Van Gogh Elizabeth Taylor Was Given by Her Art-Dealer Father Is Now Heading to Christie's". Artnet News. Retrieved 2021-10-15.
11. "Artelligence for March 29, 2018". Art Market Monitor. 2018-03-29. from the original on 2020-09-18. Retrieved 2021-10-15. Mauthner's heir, Andrew Orkin, sued Taylor in 2004 "asserting that has Mauthner's heir, he was the true owner of the painting. His case was dismissed because the court held that California's statute of limitations had expired. Orkin v. Taylor, 487 F.3d 734 (9th Cir. 2007). Orkin had also argued for the existence of a right to sue under the Holocaust Victims Redress Act of 1998, an argument which courts never adopted. As a result of the dismissal, the parties never litigated the factual question of the validity of the sale
12. Sullivan & Worcester LLP - Nicholas O'Donnell (2018-03-26). "What About Margarethe Mauthner? Van Gogh Once Owned by Elizabeth Taylor Heads to Auction Again with Scant Mention of its Persecuted Former Owner". Lexology. Retrieved 2021-10-15. As for Mauthner, according to the 2004 lawsuit filed by her heir Andrew Orkin against Taylor, a 1928 catalogue raisonné (a book identifying an exhaustive list of a particular artist's entire body of work), Mauthner had the painting by 1928, and a second catalogue raisonné in 1939 also listed Mauthner as the owner. Before Mauthner, the work had belonged to renowned art dealer Paul Cassirer, who acquired it in 1907. The parties to the lawsuit did not agree as to when Cassirer ceased having it.
13. magazin, manager (8 February 2012). "Versteigerung: Bilder von Liz Taylor bringen 16,5 Millionen". www.manager-magazin.de (in German). Retrieved 2021-10-15.
14. "Van Gogh's "Ansicht von Les Saintes-Maries-de-la-Mer" bleibt in der Sammlung Oskar Reinhart "Am Römerholz" in Winterthur". www.courthousenews.com. Retrieved 2021-10-15.
15. "Top U.S. court rejects appeal in van Gogh dispute". The Globe and Mail. 2007-10-30. Retrieved 2021-10-15.
16. agencies, swissinfo ch and (15 November 2013). "Ruling over Nazi-era art sale comes at a cost". SWI swissinfo.ch. Retrieved 2021-10-15.
17. "Results for 'au:Mauthner, Margarete' [WorldCat.org]". www.worldcat.org. Retrieved 2021-10-15.
18. Gogh, Vincent van; Mauthner, Margarete (1908). Briefe: Mit 12 Abb. Dt. Ausg.: M. Mauthner (in German). Berlin: Cassirer. OCLC 162907463.