Lumpy Gravy

Lumpy Gravy is the debut solo album by Frank Zappa, written by Zappa and performed by a group of session players he dubbed the Abnuceals Emuukha Electric Symphony Orchestra. Zappa conducted the orchestra but did not perform on the album. It is his third album overall: his previous releases had been under the name of his group, the Mothers of Invention.

Lumpy Gravy
Original LP cover
Studio album by Frank Zappa and the Abnuceals Emuukha Electric Symphony Orchestra
Released	August 7, 1967 (original) May 13, 1968 (official)
Recorded	February 1967
Genre	Sound collage^[1]^[2]^[3] orchestral^[4] musique concrète^[5]^[6]
Length	22:37 (original) 31:45 (official)
Label	Capitol, Verve
Producer	Nick Venet
Frank Zappa chronology
Absolutely Free (1967) Lumpy Gravy (1967) We're Only in It for the Money (1968)
Frank Zappa solo chronology
Lumpy Gravy (1967) Hot Rats (1969)
1968 reissue cover

It was commissioned and briefly released, on August 7, 1967, by Capitol Records in the 4-track Stereo-Pak format only and then withdrawn due to a lawsuit from MGM Records. MGM claimed that the album violated Zappa's contract with their subsidiary, Verve Records. In 1968 it was reedited and released by MGM's Verve Records on May 13, 1968. The final version of the album consisted of two musique concrète pieces that combined elements from the original orchestral performance with elements of surf music and the spoken word. It was praised for its music and editing.

Produced simultaneously with We're Only in It for the Money, Zappa saw Lumpy Gravy as the second part of a conceptual continuity that later included his final album, Civilization Phaze III.

Recording

 

In 1966, Frank Zappa was commissioned to compose Lumpy Gravy for Capitol Records.

Following the release of Freak Out!, the debut album of the rock band the Mothers of Invention, Capitol Records A&R representative Nick Venet commissioned an album of orchestral music composed by the Mothers of Invention's leader, Frank Zappa, a self-taught composer. Venet spent $40,000 on the album.^[7][8] Because Zappa's contract with Verve and MGM Records did not allow for him to perform on albums recorded for any other label, he could not play any instrument on the proposed album, and instead served as the conductor of an orchestra consisting of session musicians hired for the recording. Zappa stated that "my contract [with MGM] did not preclude me from doing that. I wasn't signed as a conductor."^[7]

Lumpy Gravy was conceived as a short oratorio, written in eleven days.^[8] Zappa named the group assembled for the sessions the "Abnuceals Emuukha Electric Symphony Orchestra".^[8]

Percussionist Emil Richards recalled that he did not know who Zappa was and did not take him seriously as the recording sessions began, believing that Zappa was merely the guitarist for a rock band. However, upon meeting them, Zappa handed the musicians the scores for the pieces, which were dense, complex and varied in time signatures.^[7] Richards' close friend, guitarist Tommy Tedesco, was another member of the recording sessions. Tedesco mocked Zappa, believing that Zappa did not know what he was doing.^[7] The bassoonist and bass clarinetist hired for the sessions refused to perform their parts, declaring them impossible to play. Zappa responded, "If I play your part, will you at least try it?" Zappa then used his guitar to demonstrate the parts for the musicians, who then agreed to perform their assigned parts.^[7] By the end of the recording sessions, Richards and Tedesco became convinced of Zappa's talent, and became friends with the composer. Richards later performed on sessions which appeared on Zappa's album Orchestral Favorites.^[7]

Release, lawsuit and reediting

Capitol released Lumpy Gravy on August 7, 1967, only on the 4-track cartridge format, apparently in limited numbers. This version of the album is markedly different from the Lumpy Gravy that would become an official entry in Zappa's catalog. Capitol also intended to release a single consisting of the pieces "Gypsy Airs" and "Sink Trap" to promote its release.^[8] In response to the album's release, MGM threatened a lawsuit, claiming that its release violated Zappa's contract.^[8]

During the litigation, Zappa expanded and significantly edited the album, adding spoken word and musique concrète interludes, as well as some pieces of music from his pre-Mothers archives. The original Lumpy Gravy was not re-released until 2009, with the Zappa Records triple-CD release, The Lumpy Money Project/Object.

Lumpy Gravy is edited together out of hundreds, maybe thousands of tiny pieces of tape which took a long time to collect. First of all you have to find just the right little noise and things that are going to go in there, and then you have to manually cut these pieces of tape together with a razor blade.

— Frank Zappa (1987)^[9]

The dialogue segments were recorded at Apostolic Studios in New York City after Zappa discovered that the strings of the studio's grand piano would resonate if a person spoke near those strings. The "piano people" experiment involved Zappa having various speakers improvise dialogue using topics offered by Zappa. Most of the dialogue on the reedited Lumpy Gravy, recorded simultaneously with We're Only in It for the Money,^[10] was spoken by a small group which included Motorhead Sherwood, Roy Estrada, Spider Barbour, All-Night John (the manager of the studio) and Louis Cuneo, who was noted for his laugh, which sounded like a "psychotic turkey".^[8] The concept of the reedited album derived from Zappa's "big note" theory, which states that the universe consists of a single element, and that atoms are vibrations of that element, a "big note".^[11]

The revised album proved to be very difficult to make, as the orchestral master tapes recovered from Capitol featured many poor splices.^[11] The reedited version also incorporated additional musical content not on the original release of the album, including previously recorded surf music^[11] and a 1963 Zappa-produced demo recording of a tune that later appeared in a 1967 recording under the title "Take Your Clothes Off When You Dance" on We're Only in It for the Money. Some of the editing was done in Zappa's living room.^[12] On the 1967 and 1968 releases of the album, Zappa was credited as "Francis Vincent Zappa", as Zappa had believed that this was his real name. He later learned that his birth name was Frank Vincent Zappa, and this mistake was subsequently corrected in reissues of the album.^[12]

Reception and legacy

Professional ratings

Review scores
Source	Rating
AllMusic	^[13]
Encyclopedia of Popular Music	^[14]
The Great Rock Discography	6/10^[15]
The Rolling Stone Album Guide	^[16]
Uncut	7/10^[17]

The reedited Lumpy Gravy was well received by critics, and Zappa called it one of his favorite albums out of his own work, stating that it contains his favorite music.^[18] Barry Miles, writing in International Times, described the album as fusing John Cage's Fontana Mix (1958) and John Carisi's "Moon Taj" (1962) with Zappa's distinctive style of "lyricism and cynicism", and praised Zappa's editing of the "loaded" conversation snippets, deeming them "masterpieces of editing".^[19] In a mixed review, Jim Miller of Rolling Stone called it Zappa's "most curious" album to date, finding it to represent the extreme of his "fragmented musical approach", but believed it to be overall "rather inert" and criticised the spoken sections for seeming forced. However, they deemed it an important album, concluding: "It might be said that Zappa makes mistakes other rock composers would be proud to call their own best music; Lumpy Gravy is an idiosyncratic musical faux pas that is worth listening to for that reason alone."^[20]

Retrospectively, AllMusic writer François Couture wrote, "The starting point of Zappa's 'serious music,' Lumpy Gravy suffers from a lack of coherence, but it remains historically important and contains many conceptual continuity clues for the fan."^[13] David Cavanagh of Uncut wrote that the "collage-style concept album" features "some of his most avant-garde music as well as some of his most bizarre encounters with his fellow Mothers."^[21] Ian Stonehouse of The Rough Guide to Rock wrote that the album shows Zappa at his "most original", noting its cut-up blend of musique concrète, R&B, jazz and "mumblings from inside a grand piano", and deemed it a "masterpiece that anticipated sampling technology".^[22] Miles, writing for The History of Rock, wrote that the record "owed far more to Varèse and Stravinsky than to rock'n'roll."^[23]

Edwin Pouncey of The Wire writes that the album is "[t]he culmination of Zappa's commitment to contemporary classical and electronic music", and deemed it crucial for combining "classically motivated interludes, electronic abstractions and rambling spoken word compositions within a basic rock structure. Whereas other 'rock stars' frequently toyed with vague notions of musique concrète and experimental music, Zappa incorporated them into a medium that extended his musical repertoire and pushed the prowess of The Mothers Of Invention to new heights of skill and endurance."^[4] Ultimate Classic Rock writer Ryan Reed describes it as an "avant-garde masterpiece" which has become overlooked in Zappa's discography for being one of his more unorthodox recordings, "branching from musique concrete to gorgeous jazz-fusion to proto-electronic hysteria to pitch-shifted rock grooves". They write that it has had "a sizable influence on both rock and avant-garde artists over the years".^[24]

In 1984, the second version of Lumpy Gravy was remixed by Zappa, with new overdubs by bassist Arthur Barrow and drummer Chad Wackerman.^[7] This third version of the album was not released in full at the time; an excerpt appeared in a The Old Masters sampler sent to radio stations.^[25] Additional dialogue from the "piano people" sessions was included on Zappa's later album Frank Zappa Meets the Mothers of Prevention,^[26] and his final album, Civilization Phaze III in 1993.^[27] In 2009, the box set Lumpy Money was released, containing the 1967 and 1984 versions of Lumpy Gravy, and audio documentary material derived from the sessions that produced the original 1967 orchestral sessions, dialogue which appeared in the 1968 release of Lumpy Gravy, and the album We're Only in It for the Money.^[28] On April 18, 2018, the original 1967 edit of the album was released on limited edition vinyl as a Record Store Day exclusive under the title Lumpy Gravy (Primordial).^[29] Zappa remastered the album in 1985 and again in 1993.

Track listing

All tracks are written by Frank Zappa.

1967 version

No.	Title	Length
1.	"Sink Trap"	2:45
2.	"Gum Joy"	3:44
3.	"Up and Down"	1:52
4.	"Local Butcher"	2:36
5.	"Gypsy Airs"	1:41
6.	"Hunchy Punchy"	2:06
7.	"Foamy Soaky"	2:34
8.	"Let's Eat Out"	1:49
9.	"Teenage Grand Finale"	3:30
Total length:		22:37

1968 version, part one

No.	Title	Length
1.	"The Way I See It, Barry"	0:06
2.	"Duodenum"	1:32
3.	"Oh No"	2:03
4.	"Bit of Nostalgia"	1:35
5.	"It's from Kansas"	0:30
6.	"Bored Out 90 Over"	0:31
7.	"Almost Chinese"	0:25
8.	"Switching Girls"	0:29
9.	"Oh No Again"	1:13
10.	"At the Gas Station"	2:41
11.	"Another Pickup"	0:54
12.	"I Don't Know If I Can Go Through This Again"	3:49
Total length:		15:50

1968 version, part two

No.	Title	Length
1.	"Very Distraughtening"	1:33
2.	"White Ugliness"	2:22
3.	"Amen"	1:33
4.	"Just One More Time"	0:58
5.	"A Vicious Circle"	1:12
6.	"King Kong"	0:43
7.	"Drums Are Too Noisy"	0:58
8.	"Kangaroos"	0:57
9.	"Envelops the Bath Tub"	3:42
10.	"Take Your Clothes Off"	1:53
Total length:		15:56

Personnel

Musicians - Abnuceals Emuukha Electric Symphony Orchestra

Arnold Belnick – strings Harold Bemko – strings Chuck Berghofer – bass Jimmy Carl Black – chorus Jimmy Bond – bass Monica Boscia – chorus Dennis Budimir – guitar Frank Capp – drums Donald Christlieb – woodwind Gene Cipriano – woodwind Vincent DeRosa – french horn Joseph DiFiore – strings Jesse Ehrlich – strings Alan Estes – percussion, drums Gene Estes – percussion Louis "Louie the Turkey" Cuneo – chorus Roy Estrada – bass, chorus Larry Fanoga (Euclid James "Motorhead" Sherwood) – vocals, chorus Victor Feldman – percussion, drums

Bunk Gardner – woodwind James Getzoff – strings Philip Goldberg – strings John Guerin – drums Bruce Hampton – chorus Jimmy "Senyah" Haynes – guitar Harry Hyams – strings Jules Jacob – woodwind Pete Jolly – piano, celeste, harpsichord Harold Kelling - vocals Ray Kelly – strings Jerome Kessler – strings Alexander Koltun – strings Bernard Kundell – strings William Kurasch – strings Michael Lang – piano, celeste, harpsichord Arthur Maebe – French horn Leonard Malarsky – strings Shelly Manne – drums

Lincoln Mayorga – piano, celeste, harpsichord Ted Nash – woodwind Richard Parissi – French horn Glenn Phillips - vocals Don Randi – piano Jerome Reisler – strings Emil Richards – percussion Tony Rizzi – guitar John Rotella – percussion, woodwind Joseph Saxon – strings Ralph Schaeffer – strings Leonard Selic – strings Kenny Shroyer – trombone Paul Smith – piano, celeste, harpsichord Tommy Tedesco – guitar Al Viola – guitar Bob West – bass Tibor Zelig – strings Jimmy Zito – trumpet

Production credits

• Frank Zappa - composer, conductor
• Cal Schenkel - artwork

Charts

Album - Billboard (United States)

Year	Chart	Position
1968	Billboard 200	159

References

1. Miles, Barry (2004). Zappa: A Biography. New York City, New York, US: Grove Press. p. 140. ISBN 9780802117830. Retrieved October 12, 2022.
2. Hardy, Phil; Laing, Phil (1995). "Frank Zappa". The Da Capo Companion to 20th-century Popular Music. Boston, Massachusetts, US: Da Capo Press. p. 1,035. ISBN 9780306806407. Retrieved October 12, 2022.
3. Rees, Dafydd (1991). Rock Movers & Shakers. Santa Barbara, California, US: ABC-Clio. p. 583. ISBN 0874366615. Retrieved October 12, 2022.
4. Pouncey, Edwin (July 1999). "Undercurrents #7: Fables of the Deconstruction". The Wire. Retrieved October 13, 2022.
5. Wharmby, George (October 4, 2012). "An Epic Review of Frank Zappa's first 12 albums OR Universal, what's got into ya?". Louder Than War. Retrieved October 12, 2022.
6. Wolk, Douglas (May 22, 1995). "Flashback" (PDF). CMJ New Music Monthly (428): 18. Retrieved October 12, 2022.
7. Fricke, David (2008). Lumpy Money (Media notes). Frank Zappa. Zappa Records.
8. Slaven, Neil (2009-11-17). Electric Don Quixote: The Definitive Story Of Frank Zappa. Music Sales Group. ISBN 9780857120434. Retrieved August 20, 2012.
9. Graves, Tom (December 1987). "The Rock & Roll Disc Interview: Frank Zappa". Rock & Roll Disc. Retrieved October 13, 2022.
10. Schinder, Scott (2008). Icons of Rock. Greenwood Publishing Group. p. 363. ISBN 9780313338472. Retrieved August 20, 2012.
11. Walley, David (22 Aug 1996). No Commercial Potential: The Saga of Frank Zappa. Da Capo Press. p. 240. ISBN 0306807106. Retrieved August 20, 2012.
12. Zappa, Frank with Occhiogrosso, Peter (1989). The Real Frank Zappa Book. New York: Poseidon Press. pp. 244–245. ISBN 0-671-63870-X.
13. Lumpy Gravy at AllMusic
14. Larkin, Colin (1997). "Frank Zappa". Virgin Encyclopedia of Popular Music. London: Virgin Books. p. 1293. ISBN 1-85227 745 9.
15. Strong, Martin C. (2006). "Frank Zappa". The Great Rock Discography. Edinburgh: Canongate Books. p. 1239. ISBN 1-84195-827-1.
16. Brackett, Nathan; Hoard, Christian, eds. (2004). "Frank Zappa". The New Rolling Stone Album Guide (4th ed.). Simon & Schuster. p. 902. ISBN 0-7432-0169-8.
17. Cavanagh, David (14 September 2016). "Frank Zappa/The Mothers of Invention reissues". Retrieved 25 December 2016.
18. Kart, Larry (11 Oct 2004). Jazz in Search of Itself. Yale University Press. p. 166. ISBN 0300128193. Retrieved August 20, 2012.
19. Miles, Barry (July 12, 1968). "Francis Vincent Zappa & The Abnuceals Emuukha Electric Symphony Orchestra And Chorus: Lumpy Gravy (Verve)". International Times. Retrieved October 13, 2022.
20. Miller, Jim (June 22, 1968). . Rolling Stone. Archived from the original on April 10, 2022. Retrieved October 13, 2022.
21. Cavanagh, David. "Frank Zappa/The Mothers Of Invention reissues". Uncut. Retrieved October 13, 2022.
22. Stonehouse, Ian (2003). Buckley, Peter (ed.). The Rough Guide to Rock (2nd ed.). Rough Guides. p. 1,127. ISBN 1-85828-457-0.
23. Miles, Barry (1983). "Frank Zappa: Surreal Anarchy From the Mother Superior". The History of Rock. Retrieved October 13, 2022.
24. Reed, Ryan (May 13, 2015). "How Frank Zappa Broke Every Rule with His Solo Debut 'Lumpy Gravy'". Ultimate Classic Rock. Retrieved October 13, 2022.
25. Zappa, Gail (2008). "track listing notes". Lumpy Money (Media notes). Frank Zappa. Zappa Records.
26. Rense, Rip (Jan 1986). "Flash - Mothers of Prevention". Spin. SPIN Media LLC. 1 (9): 82. Retrieved 20 August 2012.
27. Morin, Alexander J. (2002). Classical Music: The Listener's Companion. Backbeat Books. p. 1067. ISBN 9780879306380. Retrieved August 20, 2012.
28. Dolan, Casey (December 8, 2008), "The Resurrection of Frank Zappa's Soul", LA Weekly, Village Voice Media
29. ""Lumpy Gravy Primordial" Vinyl Pressing - Record Store Day 2018". 2018-03-06.