Jenin, Jenin
Jenin, Jenin is a film directed by Mohammed Bakri, a prominent Palestinian actor and Israeli citizen, in order to portray what Bakri calls "the Palestinian truth" about the "Battle of Jenin",[2][3] a clash between the Israeli army and Palestinians in April 2002.
| Jenin, Jenin | |
|---|---|
| Directed by | Mohammed Bakri |
| Written by | Mohammed Bakri |
| Produced by | Iyad Tahar Samoudi[1] |
| Edited by | Leandro Pantanella |
Release date |
|
Running time | 54 min |
| Country | Palestinian territories |
| Language | Arabic |
Background
A month after 18 Israelis had been killed in two separate attacks, and a few days after a suicide bombing in Netanya killed 30 and injured 140,[4] the Israeli Defense Forces called up 30,000 reserve soldiers and launched Operation Defensive Shield.
During Operation Defensive Shield in April 2002, the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) invaded a Palestinian refugee camp in Jenin. The Israeli military refused to allow journalists and human rights organizations into the camp for "safety reasons" during the fighting, leading to a rapid cycle of rumors that a massacre had occurred. Jenin remained sealed for days after the invasion. Stories of civilians being buried alive in their homes as they were demolished, and of smoldering buildings covering crushed bodies, spread throughout the Arab world. Various casualty figures circulated, a senior Palestinian official accused Israel of massacring more than 500 people in the camp. UN fact-finding mission was not allowed by Israeli to enter Jenin.[5]
Bakri participated in a nonviolent demonstration at a checkpoint during Israel's 2002 invasion of Jenin and was shocked when Israeli soldiers shot at the crowd, wounding a fellow actor standing next to him. He tells audiences that this experience inspired him to sneak into Jenin with a camera and ask residents, “What happened?”[6] The result was the documentary Jenin Jenin, featuring a range of testimonies which suggested that a massacre had indeed occurred. Bakri gave voice to the perspective of Palestinians which would not reach the media due to the sealing of the city; as a result he chose not to interview Israeli officials for the film.
Human Rights Watch investigations found "no evidence to sustain claims of massacres or large-scale extrajudicial executions by the IDF in Jenin refugee camp" although they reported that "Israeli forces committed serious violations of international humanitarian law, some amounting prima facie to war crimes".[7] The accusation of war crimes was repeated by Amnesty International.[8] During the fighting in Jenin, Palestinian spokesmen, human rights organizations and foreign journalists accused Israel of conducting a civilian massacre.[9] Israeli figures state that between 53 and 56 Palestinians were killed during the Israeli offensive, and apparently over half of them suspected to be armed combatants."[9] Israel concurs that around 50 Palestinian died, but describes the event as a battle and blames civilian deaths on the close proximity of fighters and civilians. Twenty-three Israeli soldiers died.
The film title referenced Palestinian taxi drivers calling "Ramallah, Ramallah, Ramallah", or "Jenin! Jenin!" to Palestinian workers and travellers moving through Israeli checkpoints. Bakri dedicated the film to its producer, Iyad Samoudi, who was killed by Israeli soldiers, at al-Yamun in the Jenin Governorate of the West Bank, shortly after filming ended. The IDF said that Samoudi was an armed member of the al-Aqsa Martyrs' Brigades.[10]
Film content
The film has no narrator or guide and consists only of interviews with the inhabitants of Jenin edited by the producer.[11][12]
Controversy
Official positions
After a few screenings, the film was banned by the Israeli Film Ratings Board on the premise that it was libelous and might offend the public. In response Bakri contested the screening of a counter-response documentary The Road to Jenin, made by Pierre Rehov.[13][14] The court rejected his request under the statement that regardless of the claim about the connection between the films, there is no legal basis to deny the screening of The Road to Jenin.[15] The Tel Aviv and Jerusalem Cinematheques in Israel showed Bakri's film despite the ban.[10]
Bakri took the ban to court and the Supreme Court of Israel overturned the decision. According to Supreme Court Judge Dalia Dorner: "The fact that the film includes lies is not enough to justify a ban,";[16] she implied that it is up to viewers to interpret what they see, citing the Maimonides quotation: "And with intellect shall distinguish the man, between the truth and the false."[17] On appeal, the Supreme Court's ruling was stayed, but in August 2004 the Supreme Court reaffirmed the overturning of the ban, stating that the film board does not have "a monopoly over truth".[18] Although the Supreme Court described the film as a "propagandistic lie," the ruling affirmed that choosing not to show 'both sides' of a story is not grounds for censorship.
Defamation lawsuit
Five Israeli reserve soldiers who served in Jenin filed suit in 2002 against Bakri for defamation arguing that the movie had sullied their good names.[11] The plaintiffs were not mentioned in the film. The judge dismissed the case, ruling that while the film did in fact slander Israeli soldiers, the five Israeli soldiers were not personally slandered and thus had no standing to sue. The judge said in her verdict that Bakri had not shown "good faith", had brought no witnesses, and had not proved his claim that his charges were backed up by reports from human rights groups.[19]
Public critics
Dr. David Zangen, who was the chief medical officer for the IDF in Jenin during Operation Defensive Shield (Head of Pediatric Endocrinology at Hadassah University Hospital in Jerusalem[20]) issued a public statement titled Seven Lies About Jenin,[21] giving his personal accounts about his visit to a private premiere[citation needed] screening of the film at the Jerusalem Cinematheque. In his statement, he cited 7 discrepancies he had hoped to raise in front of the viewers who denied him the possibility to get past the second point. He claimed Bakri has 'skillfully made a crude, albeit well-done, manipulation' that it is difficult not to be drawn into the created distorted picture; and that he was amazed that the audience was not willing to hear his own accounts, a person who had 'physically' been there.[22][23] The version distributed in the English language is modified from the original movie, and some of the problematic scenes Zangen pointed out were omitted.[citation needed]
Defense
The Mohammad Bakri Defense Committee argues that "the importance of this case reaches beyond Bakri as an individual," amounting to repression of Palestinian self-expression.[24] At a screening of his latest film in New York, a disturbed audience member confronted Bakri with accusations that Jenin, Jenin exaggerated the atrocities of the invasion presented a one-sided view, and Bakri responded that he had "seen hundreds of films that deny and ignore what happened to Palestinians, yet never complained or tried to ban any film."[6]
The main line of defense for Bakri and his film is that, as the Supreme Court found, choosing not to show 'both sides' of a story is not grounds for censorship. Bakri is being represented by attorney Avigdor Feldman, who told Haaretz, "Bakri doesn't say anything in this film. The people who talk are those he filmed. So the residents of the refugee camp say things which sometimes are true and sometimes not. It's a movie. It reflects the subjective understanding of the speakers. Sometimes they say things that are harsher [than they actually were] because that is how he experienced it."[9]
The Mohammad Bakri Defense Committee adds: "For his artistic integrity and his focus on the experiences and narratives of his fellow Palestinians, Mohammad Bakri faces the potential of financial ruin in the face of spurious legal charges and dubious claims of defamation." A major component of the argument for the defense in the most recent allegations is that none of the plaintiffs, Ofer Ben-Natan, Doron Keidar, Nir Oshri, Adam Arbiv and Yonatan Van-Kaspel, are mentioned by name or shown in the film.[24]
Second defamation lawsuit and ban
In November 2016, Israeli army reserve officer Nissim Magnagi sued Bakri for defamation over the film in the Lod District Court. While the previous defamation suit had been dismissed on account of the plaintiffs not being specifically identified in the film, Magnagi was found to have had a legal basis for a defamation suit as he had appeared in the film. In January 2021, the court accepted Magnagi's defamation claim and restored the ban on the film. Bakri was ordered to pay NIS 175,000 in compensation to Magnagi as well as NIS 50,000 in legal expenses.[25][26]
Awards and nominations
Jenin, Jenin was awarded Best Film at the 2002 Carthage International Film Festival in Tunis, and the 2003 International Prize for Mediterranean Documentary Filmmaking & Reporting[clarification needed].[27][28][29][30]
Notes
- ^ a b , Haaretz, September 17, 2003.
- ^ ynet 5 לוחמי ג'נין תובעים את מוחמד בכרי - תרבות ובידור 2007-09-30 at the Wayback Machine. Ynet.co.il (1995-06-20). Retrieved on 2010-11-20.
- ^ . Archived from the original on 2007-11-28. Retrieved 2007-07-05.
- ^ UN Report on Jenin August 7, 2009, at the Wayback Machine
- ^ "NPR : Profile : Israel's Movie Censorship Board Bans Documentary". NPR. from the original on 2005-04-27. Retrieved 2006-08-28. "Israel Bans Film about Jenin Refugee Camp"]. Morning Edition: January 1, 2003. National Public Radio.
- ^ a b Jane Adas, Filmmaker Mohammad Bakri Screens His Latest Film in New York Washington Report on Middle East Affairs, September/October 2007, p. 42
- ^ Jenin: IDF Military Operations - Summary 2016-03-05 at the Wayback Machine
- ^ JOEL GREENBERG. "Amnesty Accuses Israeli Forces of War Crimes" 2016-04-09 at the Wayback Machine. The New York Times.
- ^ a b c Izenberg, Dan (17 September 2007). "'Jenin, Jenin', now in court". The Jerusalem Post. from the original on 17 January 2021. Retrieved 17 January 2021.
- ^ a b c "T.A. cinema to screen 'Jenin, Jenin' on eve of director's libel trial" 2008-02-28 at the Wayback Machine. Haaretz.
- ^ a b 'Jenin, Jenin' director tells court film based entirely on truth - Haaretz - Israel News 2008-03-11 at the Wayback Machine
- ^ Rabble: Free speech shut down at Toronto school 2007-09-26 at the Wayback Machine
- ^ עתירה נגד שידור ”הדרך לג’נין” בערוץ 1 - וואלה! תרבות 2011-07-18 at the Wayback Machine. E.walla.co.il (2003-05-09). Retrieved on 2010-11-20.
- ^ ynet בקשה לבג"ץ: לדחות שידור "הדרך לג'נין" - תרבות ובידור 2007-09-30 at the Wayback Machine. Ynet.co.il (1995-06-20). Retrieved on 2010-11-20.
- ^ "בית המשפט התיר שידור הסרט הדרך לגנין". from the original on 2007-09-29. Retrieved 2007-07-05.
- ^ Israel court lifts Jenin film ban 2014-12-30 at the Wayback Machine, BBC News, 11 November 2003.
- ^ Israel Supreme Court 316/03 (quoting Maimonides Guide for the Perplexed: (he: מורה נבוכים), Part 1, Chapter 2)
- ^ Israel's court defeats film ban 2006-05-24 at the Wayback Machine, BBC News, 31 August 2004.
- ^ Court: 'Jenin, Jenin' untruthful, but does not slander soldiers |, Ofra Edelman, Ha'aretz 30/06/2008 2008-07-09 at the Wayback Machine
- ^ 'MEDICINE IN PEACE AND WAR/JEWISH AND ISRAELI PERSPECTIVE' with Dr. David Zangen (Google HTML version)[permanent dead link]
- ^ Commentary by Dr. David Zangen on lies concerning Jenin 2007-11-13 at the Wayback Machine
- ^ 'Seven Lies About Jenin: David Zangen views the film "Jenin, Jenin" and is horrified' (Translated from Hebrew: Ma'ariv, 8 November 2002) 24 August 2007 at the Wayback Machine
- ^ '"I Couldn't Stand the Lies"' by Asaf Haim (Translated from Hebrew: Ma'ariv, 22 April 2002) 28 September 2007 at the Wayback Machine
- ^ a b About Mohammad Bakri's case" . Archived from the original on 2008-12-02. Retrieved 2008-05-19. Mohammad Bakri Defense Committee
- ^ "Court bans screening of the documentary 'Jenin Jenin' in Israel", ynetnews.com, January 11, 2021
- ^ "'Jenin, Jenin' screenings banned in Israel as court orders damages for soldier". The Times of Israel.
- ^ Amazon.com: Jenin, Jenin
- ^ Dubai International Film Festival: Since you Left 2007-01-29 at the Wayback Machine
- ^ The Film Connection: Jenin, Jenin 2007-09-28 at the Wayback Machine
- ^ PASSIA: Personalities: Bakri, Mohammed, accessed 24 Nov. 2022.
External links
- Jenin, Jenin at IMDb
- Jenin, Jenin at AllMovie
- Jenin, Jenin, distributor's site
- Jenin, Jenin at Rotten Tomatoes