Cultural geography

Cultural geography is a subfield within human geography. Though the first traces of the study of different nations and cultures on Earth can be dated back to ancient geographers such as Ptolemy or Strabo, cultural geography as academic study firstly emerged as an alternative to the environmental determinist theories of the early 20th century, which had believed that people and societies are controlled by the environment in which they develop.^[1] Rather than studying pre-determined regions based upon environmental classifications, cultural geography became interested in cultural landscapes.^[1] This was led by the "father of cultural geography" Carl O. Sauer of the University of California, Berkeley. As a result, cultural geography was long dominated by American writers.

A world map illustrating cultural areas.

Geographers drawing on this tradition see cultures and societies as developing out of their local landscapes but also shaping those landscapes.^[2] This interaction between the natural landscape and humans creates the cultural landscape. This understanding is a foundation of cultural geography but has been augmented over the past forty years with more nuanced and complex concepts of culture, drawn from a wide range of disciplines including anthropology, sociology, literary theory, and feminism. No single definition of culture dominates within cultural geography. Regardless of their particular interpretation of culture, however, geographers wholeheartedly reject theories that treat culture as if it took place "on the head of a pin".^[3]

Overview

Some of the topics within the field of study are globalization has been theorised as an explanation for cultural convergence.

This geography studies the geography of culture

• Theories of cultural hegemony or cultural assimilation via cultural imperialism
• Cultural areal differentiation, as a study of differences in way of life encompassing ideas, attitudes, languages, practices, institutions and structures of power and whole range of cultural practices in geographical areas.^[4]
• Study of cultural landscapes^[5][6] and cultural ecology.
• Other topics include sense of place, colonialism, post-colonialism, internationalism, immigration, emigration and ecotourism.

History

 

Charles Booth in the 19th century produced a series of books, Life and Labour of the People in London, with various maps highlighting poverty in the city

Though the first traces of the study of different nations and cultures on Earth can be dated back to ancient geographers such as Ptolemy or Strabo, cultural geography as academic study firstly emerged as an alternative to the environmental determinist theories of the early Twentieth century, which had believed that people and societies are controlled by the environment in which they develop.^[1] Rather than studying pre-determined regions based upon environmental classifications, cultural geography became interested in cultural landscapes.^[1] This was led by Carl O. Sauer (called the father of cultural geography), at the University of California, Berkeley. As a result, cultural geography was long dominated by American writers.

Sauer defined the landscape as the defining unit of geographic study. He saw that cultures and societies both developed out of their landscape, but also shaped them too.^[2] This interaction between the natural landscape and humans creates the cultural landscape.^[2] Sauer's work was highly qualitative and descriptive and was challenged in the 1930s by the regional geography of Richard Hartshorne. Hartshorne called for systematic analysis of the elements that varied from place to place, a project taken up by the quantitative revolution. Cultural geography was sidelined by the positivist tendencies of this effort to make geography into a hard science although writers such as David Lowenthal continued to write about the more subjective, qualitative aspects of landscape.^[7]

In the 1970s, new kind of critique of positivism in geography directly challenged the deterministic and abstract ideas of quantitative geography. A revitalized cultural geography manifested itself in the engagement of geographers such as Yi-Fu Tuan and Edward Relph and Anne Buttimer with humanism, phenomenology, and hermeneutics. This break initiated a strong trend in human geography toward Post-positivism that developed under the label "new cultural geography" while deriving methods of systematic social and cultural critique from critical geography.^[8][9]

Ongoing evolution of cultural geography

 

Cultural map of the world based on work by political scientists Ronald Inglehart and Christian Welzel in 2004

 

Regional map of Gamelan, Kulintang, and Piphat music culture in Southeast Asia

Since the 1980s, a "new cultural geography" has emerged, drawing on a diverse set of theoretical traditions, including Marxist political-economic models, feminist theory, post-colonial theory, post-structuralism and psychoanalysis.

Drawing particularly from the theories of Michel Foucault and performativity in western academia, and the more diverse influences of postcolonial theory, there has been a concerted effort to deconstruct the cultural in order to reveal that power relations are fundamental to spatial processes and sense of place. Particular areas of interest are how identity politics are organized in space and the construction of subjectivity in particular places.

Examples of areas of study include:

• Feminist geography
• Children's geographies
• Some parts of tourism geography
• Behavioral geography
• Sexuality and space
• Some more recent developments in political geography
• Music geography

Some within the new cultural geography have turned their attention to critiquing some of its ideas, seeing its views on identity and space as static. It has followed the critiques of Foucault made by other 'poststructuralist' theorists such as Michel de Certeau and Gilles Deleuze. In this area, non-representational geography and population mobility research have dominated. Others have attempted to incorporate these and other critiques back into the new cultural geography.^[10]

Groups within the geography community have differing views on the role of culture and how to analyze it in the context of geography.^[11] It is commonly thought that physical geography simply dictates aspects of culture such as shelter, clothing and cuisine. However, systematic development of this idea is generally discredited as environmental determinism. Geographers are now more likely to understand culture as a set of symbolic resources that help people make sense of the world around them, as well as a manifestation of the power relations between various groups and the structure through which social change is constrained and enabled.^[12][13] There are many ways to look at what culture means in light of various geographical insights, but in general geographers study how cultural processes involve spatial patterns and processes while requiring the existence and maintenance of particular kinds of places.

Journals

Academic peer reviewed journals which are primarily focused on cultural geography or which contain articles that contribute to the area.

• Journal of Cultural Geography
• Antipode
• Area
• cultural geographies
• Society and Space - Environment and Planning D
• Social & Cultural Geography
• Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers

Learned societies and groups

• of the Royal Geographical Society (with the Institute of British Geographers)
• Cultural Geography Specialty Group of the Association of American Geographers
• of the Institute of Australian Geographers.

See also

• Cultural area
• Environmental determinism
• Possibilism (geography)

References

1. Peet, Richard; 1990; Modern Geographical Thought; Blackwell
2. Sauer, Carl; 1925; The Morphology of Landscape
3. Gregory, Derek; Urry, John (1985). Social Relations and Spatial Structures. London: Macmillan Education. pp. 9–19. ISBN 978-0312734848.
4. Jones, Richard C. (2006). "Cultural Diversity in a "Bi-Cultural" City: Factors in the Location of Ancestry Groups in San Antonio." Journal of Cultural Geography.
5. Sinha, Amita; 2006; Cultural Landscape of Pavagadh: The Abode of Mother Goddess Kalika; Journal of Cultural Geography
6. Kuhlken, Robert; 2002; Intensive Agricultural Landscapes of Oceania; Journal of Cultural Geography
7. Jordan-Bychkov, Terry G.; Domosh, Mona; Rowntree, Lester (1994). The human mosaic: a thematic introduction to cultural geography. New York: HarperCollins CollegePublishers. ISBN 978-0-06-500731-2.
8. Tuan, Yi-Fu (1977). Space and Place: The Perspective of Experience. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press. ISBN 978-0816638772.
9. Relph, Edward (1976). Place and Placelessness. London: Pion. ISBN 978-0850861761.
10. Whatmore, S., 2006. "Materialist returns: practising cultural geography in and for a more-than-human world". Cultural Geographies, 13(4), pp.600-609.
11. Whatmore, Sarah (2016). "Materialist returns: Practising cultural geography in and for a more-than-human world". Cultural Geographies. 13 (4): 600–609. doi:10.1191/1474474006cgj377oa.
12. Wylie, John (2016). "Timely Geographies: 'New Directions in Cultural Geography' Revisited". Area. 48 (3): 374–377. doi:10.1111/area.12289.
13. Adams, Paul C.; Hoelscher, Steven; Till, Karen E. (2001). Textures of Place: Exploring Humanist Geographies. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press. ISBN 978-0816637560.

Further reading

• Carter, George F. Man and the Land. A Cultural Geography. New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston, 1964.
• Tuan, Yi-Fu. 2004. "Centennial Forum: Cultural Geography: Glances Backward and Forward". Annals of the Association of American Geographers. 94 (4): 729–733.