Cotys I (Odrysian)

Cotys I or Kotys I (Ancient Greek: Κότυς, Kotys) was a king of the Odrysians in Thrace from 384 BC to his murder in 360 BC. He was known to have been born during the reign of Seuthes I, based on ancient sources and date of birth estimates for Cotys, his daughter who married the Athenian general Iphicrates, and her son Menestheus.^[1] According to Harpokration, he reigned for 24 years, which places his accession in 384 BC.^[2] Although his origins are actually unknown,^[3] An Athenian inscription dated to 330 BC, which honors Reboulas, brother of Cotys and son of king Seuthes. As the ordinal of Seuthes is not mentioned, it was unclear, however, which of the preceding kings named Seuthes is meant by the inscription.^[4] While scholars originally believed Seuthes II to be the father of Cotys I,^[5] now it is known that Seuthes I was his father, as Seuthes II was only 7 years old at the time of Seuthes I's abdication in 411 BC. ^[6]

Cotys I
King of Thrace
Reign	384–360 BC
Predecessor	Hebryzelmis
Successor	Cersobleptes

In 390 BC the Athenian general Iphicrates joined his colleague Thrasybulus in Thrace, helping arrange peace between the Thracian rulers Amadocus I and Seuthes II, and making both Athenian allies. Iphicrates remained for about two years, and married the daughter of Cotys in opulent circumstances.^[7] Cotys' precise standing at the time remains obscure, but he is tentatively identified as a brother of Hebryzelmis,^[8] who was the Odrysian king in Thrace in 386/385 BC, when he was honored in an Athenian decree.^[9] Shortly afterwards, in 384 BC, Cotys I became king, perhaps at first in the interior parts of Thrace.^[10] With the help of Iphicrates, Cotys succeeded in establishing himself as the heir of Hebryzelmis,^[11] and eliminating the opposition of his rivals, possibly including Amadocus II and Saratocus.^[12] Archaeological finds of items inscribed for Cotys to the north and west suggest expansion and contacts in that direction that have escaped the narrative sources.^[13] The name of Cotys (in one instance described as a son of the god Apollon) appears several times on objects from the Rogozen Treasure, although the precise manner in which it came to be buried in northwestern Bulgaria, presumably in the territory of the Triballi, remains unclear.^[14]

As Cotys tried to enlarge his kingdom, including towards the Aegean and the Chersonese, his actions led to increasing tensions with Athens. In the early 370s BC, the Second Athenian Confederacy was founded with a number of neighboring cities and islands joining the Confederacy as a safeguard against the threat from Cotys, among others.^[11]

In 375 BC Cotys probably supported Hales, leader of Triballi, a powerful Thracian tribe in northwestern Thrace, in their attack on the city of Abdera. According to Diodorus, the city was saved only after the intervention of the Athenian general, Chabrias, whose forces then garrisoned the city.^[15] In 367 BC Ariobarzanes, the Persian satrap of Phrygia, occupied Sestos. Following Ariobarzanes' revolt against the Persian king Artaxerxes II in 365 BC, Cotys apparently opposed Ariobarzanes and his ally, Athens, but his actions are ambivalent and unclear. The same year Cotys welcomed the return of his son-in-law, the dismissed Athenian general Iphicrates, and a new ally, the mercenary commander Charidemus, who married another daughter of Cotys.^[16] The Athenians under their general Timotheus were able to gain Sestos and Krithote. Soon after, in 363 or 362 BC, Cotys sent Miltokythes into the Thracian Chersonese to take Sestos. Miltokythes besieged the city and starved it into surrender, then attacked Krithote. Athenian generals sent to relieve the attacked towns were unsuccessful.^[11]

At this time, in 362 BC, however, Miltokythes rebelled against Cotys, seizing the royal treasury at Hieron Oros and, finding himself besieged there by Cotys, appealed for help to both Ariobarzanes and Athens. Cotys also appealed for help from Athens, and allied himself to the Persian satrap of Lydia Autophradates, enemy of Ariobarzanes. Athens chose to support Miltokythes, and sent a fleet to his aid, but this was defeated by Cotys with the help of his son-in-law Iphicrates. Miltokythes was forced to abandon Hieron Oros in spring 361 BC, and Cotys now besieged Sestos. Athens now allied with Sparta against Cotys. Ariobarzanes surrendered Sestos and Kritothe to the Athenian general Timotheus, and the Athenians dispatched two more commanders to aid Miltokythes against Cotys. Nevertheless, Cotys prevailed with the continued assistance of Iphicrates and Charidemus. According to Demosthenes, they bribed the Athenian military and naval commanders, and several were tried and condemned after being recalled to Athens. Despite an attempt for peace between Athens and Cotys, proclaiming him an ally, Charidemus is found besieging the last remaining Athenian fortresses in the southern Chersonese again in 360 BC.^[17]

By 360 BC, Cotys controlled almost all of the Chersonese peninsula, and the Athenians dispatched a new commander, Charidemus' friend Cephisodotus to the area. By the time Cephisodotus arrived in the last week of September 360 BC, Cotys had been murdered by two of Plato’s students from Aenus, Python and Heraclides. Thought previously to be close to the king, they murdered him during a feast in his palace, under the pretext that he had wronged their father. Upon their return to Athens, they were proclaimed honorary citizens and rewarded with gold wreaths. Python is said to have told the Athenians that "God did this, borrowing from me the hand that did the deed."^[18] Identifying an unnamed Thracian king met by Philip II of Macedon with Cotys, some authors had put Cotys' death in 359 BC, assuming it took place after Philip II's accession; this is still found cited in the literature, but the chronology of Cephisodotus' arrival in 360 BC is certain. Philip may have met Cotys before becoming king of Macedon and, moreover, it is not certain that the Thracian king in question should be identified with Cotys.^[19]

Cotys I was the last ruler of a relatively unified Thrace for centuries. On his death, his son and heir Cersobleptes found himself opposed by Amadocus II (son of Amadocus I and possibly already a rival to Cotys in the early 370s BC) and Berisades (son or descendant of Saratocus?), as well as Miltokythes and a certain Spokes. While Cersobleptes managed to eliminate some of these foes with the continued support of Charidemus (who captured and executed Miltokythes in 357 BC), he had to accept a partition of the kingdom with Amadocus II and Berisades.^[20] The division of Odrysian Thrace was exploited by Philip II of Macedon to impose his control over the area.

As a former ally of Athens who became a dangerous foe, Cotys I has been portrayed in a fairly negative light in our sources, depicted as irritable, intemperate, drunken, inordinately cruel, and perfidious, most notably in the polemics of Demosthenes. Plutarch provides a more nuanced depiction of Cotys' character in the following anecdote: Cotys, when one gave him a leopard, gave him a lion in return. He was naturally prone to anger, and punished the mistakes of his servants severely. When a stranger brought him some earthen vessels, thin and brittle, but delicately shaped and admirably adorned with carvings, he rewarded the stranger for them, and then broke them all into pieces, "Lest (he said) my passion should provoke me to punish those that break them excessively." ^[21]

Cotys I had several children, including a daughter who married Iphicrates probably before 387 BC, another daughter who married Charidemus probably after 365 BC,^[22] a son named Cersobleptes who succeeded his father on the throne in 360 BC, and possibly a second son named Seuthes, who may have served as Cersobleptes' deputy (hyparkhos) and may have become king as Seuthes III (these identifications are hypothetical and debated).^[23]

In popular culture

• Cotys I appears in the 2014 film Hercules portrayed by John Hurt. Here, Cotys is depicted as the main antagonist as King of Thrace during the year 361 BC. Unlike in the film, the actual Cotys I, never features in the mythology of Heracles/Hercules.

References

1. Sears 2013: 65.
2. Tacheva 2006: 141–142, 146, who expresses some doubts as to the veracity or implications of this statement.
3. Tacheva 2006: 145.
4. Delev 1997: n. 21.
5. For example, Werner 1961:240; Stronk 1995: 57–58; Archibald 1998; Zahrnt 2015: 44.
6. Topalov 1994: 92–105, 137–150, 161–163, compare Topalov 2003: 204–207, and Topalov 2006: 187–188; Delev 1997: n. 24; Vulpe 1976: 31–32 allows for both possibilities.
7. Tacheva 2006: 142–144.
8. Topalov 1994: 92–105, 137–150, 161–163, compare Topalov 2003: 204–207, and Topalov 2006: 187–188.
9. Tacheva 2006: 144; Zahrnt 2015: 44.
10. Tacheva 2006: 146–147.
11. Valeva, Julia; Nankov, Emil; Graninger, Denver (2015). A Companion to Ancient Thrace. Chichester, United Kingdom: John Wiley & Sons. p. 44. ISBN 9781444351040.
12. Tacheva 2006: 146–149, sees identifies Amadocus as Amadocus I.
13. Tacheva 2006: 147–149.
14. Valeva 2015: 203–204; Dana 2015: 250–251.
15. Diodorus 15.36.1–4. Tacheva 2006: 147–149; Zahrnt 2015: 44.
16. Tacheva 2006: 154–155; she considers Charidemus' wife a granddaughter of Cotys: 158, n. 51.
17. Tacheva 2006: 152–158.
18. Plutarch, Precepts of Statecraft 20 816E (Moralia 10: 253–254), compare On Praising Oneself 11 542E (Moralia 7: 137–138); Demosthenes, 23.118–119; Tacheva 2006: 159.
19. Delev 1997: 7–8; Tacheva 2006: 158–159.
20. Delev 1997: 8–10.
21. Plutarch, Sayings of kings and commanders 15, adapted from Goodwin 1878: 189.
22. Tacheva 2006: 158, n. 51, considers her a granddaughter rather than daughter of Cotys, but nothing prevents a significant difference in age between probable half-sisters who married Iphicrates and Charidemus.
23. Manov 2019: 104; Tacheva 2006: 187 identifies Seuthes III with the former deputy Seuthes but not as a son of Cotys I; Topalov 2001: 273–238 denies any relation to the deputy Seuthes and places Seuthes III in a rival branch of the dynasty as heir of Amadocus I, Amadocus II, and Teres III; Beloch 1923: 90–91 considers the deputy Seuthes a non-reigning son of Cotys, and this Seuthes as the father of Cotys and Reboulas from the Athenian decree from 330 BC.

Βιβλιογραφία

• Demosthenes, Against Aristocrates
• Diodorus, Bibliotheca historica
• Z. Archibald, The Odrysian Kingdom of Thrace: Orpheus Unmasked, Oxford, 1998.
• K. J. Beloch, Griechische Geschichte, vol. 3/2, Berlin, 1923.
• D. Dana, Inscriptions, in: J. Valeva et al. (eds.), A Companion to Ancient Thrace, Wiley, 2015: 243–264.
• P. Delev, “Filip II i zalezăt na Goljamoto Odrisko carstvo v Trakija,” Šumenski universitet “Episkop Konstantin Preslavski,” Trudove na katedrite po istorija i bogoslovie 1 (1997) 7–40.
• W. Goodwin, Plutarch's Morals, Cambridge, 1878.
• M. Manov, "The Hellenistic Tomb with Greek Inscription from Smyadovo, Bulgaria - Reconsidered," Journal of Ancient History and Archaeology 6/3 (2019) 99–118.
• M. Sears, Athens, Thrace, and the Shaping of Athenian Leadership, Cambridge, 2013.
• J. P. Stronk, The Ten Thousand in Thrace, Amsterdam, 1995.
• M. Tacheva, The Kings of Ancient Thrace. Book One, Sofia, 2006.
• S. Topalov, The Odrysian Kingdom from the Late 5th to the Mid-4th C. B.C., Sofia, 1994.
• S. Topalov, Contributions to the Study of the Coinage and History in the Lands of Eastern Thrace from the End of the 4th C. B.C. to the end of the 3rd C. B.C., Sofia, 2001.
• S. Topalov, Ancient Thrace. Contributions to the Study of the Early Thracian Tribal Coinage and its Relations to the Coinage of the Odrysians and the Odrysian Kingdom during 6th-4th C. B.C., Sofia, 2003.
• S. Topalov, On the Political History of the Odrysian Kingdom from the End of the 6th Century B.C. to the Middle of the 4th Century B.C., Sofia, 2006.
• J. Valeva, Gold, Silver, and Bronze Vessels, in: J. Valeva et al. (eds.), A Companion to Ancient Thrace, Wiley, 2015: 197–211.
• J. Valeva et al. (eds.), A Companion to Ancient Thrace, Wiley, 2015.
• R. Vulpe, Studia Thracologica, Bucharest, 1976.
• M. Zahrnt, Early History of Thrace to the Murder of Kotys I (360 BCE), in: J. Valeva et al. (eds.), A Companion to Ancient Thrace, Wiley, 2015: 35–47.
• R. Werner, in: W.-D. von Barloewen (ed.), Abriss der Geschichte antiker Randkulturen, Munich, 1961: 83–150, 239–242.

Cotys I (Odrysian) Odrysian kingdom of Thrace Born: Unknown Died: 360 BC
Preceded by Hebryzelmis	King of Thrace 384–360 BC	Succeeded by Cersobleptes, Berisades and Amadocus II