Broad arrow

For the ghost town, see Broad Arrow, Western Australia. For the messenger pigeon, see Broad Arrow (pigeon). For the arrangement of cylinders of an engine, see W engine.

A broad arrow, of which a pheon is a variant, is a stylised representation of a metal arrowhead, comprising a tang and two barbs meeting at a point. It is a symbol used traditionally in heraldry, most notably in England, and later by the British government to mark government property. It became particularly associated with the Board of Ordnance, and later the War Department and the Ministry of Defence. It was exported to other parts of the British Empire, where it was used in similar official contexts.

A stylised broad arrow

Heraldic broad arrow with plain barbs

In heraldry, the arrowhead generally points downwards, whereas in other contexts it more usually points upwards.

In heraldry

 

Pheon in the arms of the Sidney family of Penshurst: Or, a pheon azure

The broad arrow as a heraldic device comprises a socket tang with two converging blades, or barbs. When these barbs are engrailed on their inner edges, the device may be termed a pheon. Woodward's Treatise on Heraldry: British and Foreign with English and French Glossaries (1892), makes the following distinction: "A BROAD ARROW and a PHEON are represented similarly, except that the Pheon has its inner edges jagged, or engrailed."^[1] Parker's Glossary of Terms Used in Heraldry (1894) likewise states, "A broad arrow differs somewhat ... and resembles a pheon, except in the omission of the jagged edge on the inside of the barbs."^[2] However, A. C. Fox-Davies, in his Complete Guide to Heraldry (1909), comments: "This is not a distinction very stringently adhered to."^[3]

The pheon features prominently in the arms of the Sidney family of Penshurst, and thence in the arms of Sidney Sussex College, Cambridge, and of Hampden–Sydney College, Virginia. Sidney Sussex's newsletter for alumni is titled Pheon.^[4]

Use for British Government property

 

Ammunition box or coal container dated 1831, displaying Board of Ordnance coat of arms, initials and broad arrow

 

British convicts in uniforms bearing broad arrows: a late 19th-century print

 

A broad arrow on a Marconi TF1041B valve voltmeter, indicating Ministry of Defence ownership

The broad arrow was used in England (and later Britain), apparently from the early 14th century, and more widely from the 16th century, to mark objects purchased from the monarch's money, or to indicate government property. It became particularly associated with the Office or Board of Ordnance, the principal duty of which was to supply guns, ammunition, stores and equipment to the King's Navy.

Origins

The origins of the broad arrow device used by the Board of Ordnance are debated. The symbol is widely supposed to have been derived from the pheon in the arms of the Sidney family, through the influence either of Sir Philip Sidney, who served as Joint Master-General of the Ordnance in 1585–6; or that of his great-nephew, Henry Sydney, 1st Earl of Romney, who served as Master-General from 1693 to 1702.^[5][6][7] However, as noted by the Oxford English Dictionary, "this is not supported by the evidence", as the use of the device predates the association of either Sidney with the Board.^[8]

The earliest known use of the symbol in what seems to be an official capacity is in 1330, on the seal used by Richard de la Pole as butler to King Edward III.^[9][10] In 1383, it is recorded that a member of the butlery staff, having selected a pipe of wine for the King's use, "signo regio capiti sagitte consimili signavit" ("marked it with the royal sign like an arrowhead").^[9] In 1386, Thomas Stokes was condemned to stand in the pillory by the Court of Aldermen of London for the offence of having impersonated an officer of the royal household, in which role he had commandeered several barrels of ale from brewers, marking them with a symbol referred to as an "arewehead".^[11] The device was also used in the 15th and 16th centuries as an assay mark for pewter and tin.^[9]

An alternative theory is that the device used on naval stores and property was in its origins a simplified and corrupted version of an anchor symbol.^[12] Thus, a set of "Instructions for marking of Timber for His Majesty's Navy" issued in 1609 commands:

... the sayde Commissioners to marke the same [selected trees] with an axe bearing His Maj[esty's] letters and an anker to distinguishe them from the rest as appropriated to His Majestys Navye lest in the general sale they should bee soulde away.^[13]

Later use

A letter sent by Thomas Gresham to the Privy Council in 1554, relating to the shipment of 50 cases of Spanish reals (coins) from Seville to England, explained that each case was "marked with the broad arrow and numbered from 1 to 50".^[14]

A proclamation of Charles I issued in 1627 ordered that tobacco imported to England from non-English plantations should be sealed with "a seale engraven with a broad Arrow and a Portcullice".^[15]

A proclamation issued by Charles II in 1661 ran:

And His Majesty doth further command, That on all other Stores, Where it may be done without prejudice to the said Stores, or Charge to His Majesty, as Nails, Spikes, and other the like Stores, that the broad Arrow be put on some part of the same, whether by Stamp, Brand, or other way, as shall be particularly directed by the principal Officers and Commissioners of His Majesties Navy, to whom the care thereof is committed.^[16]

An Order in Council of 1664, relating to the requisitioning of merchant ships for naval use, similarly authorised the Commissioners of the Navy "to put the broad arrow on any ship in the River they had a mind to hire, and fit them out for sea";^[16] while the Embezzlement of Public Stores Act 1697 (9 Will. 3, c. 41) sought to prevent the theft of military and naval property by prohibiting anyone other than official contractors from marking "any Stores of War or Naval Stores whatsoever, with the Marks usually used to and marked upon His Majesties said Warlike and Naval or Ordnance Stores; ... [including] any other Stores with the Broad Arrow by Stamp Brand or otherwise".^[16]

 

An Ordnance Survey benchmark in the UK

From the eighteenth to twentieth centuries, the broad arrow regularly appeared on military boxes and equipment such as canteens, bayonets and rifles. The prisons built by the Admiralty for the French Revolutionary Wars were equipped with mattresses and other items bearing the broad arrow: at Norman Cross Prison, Huntingdonshire, this was proven effective, when a local tradesman found in possession of items bearing the marks was convicted and sentenced to stand in the pillory and two years in a house of correction.^[17] The broad arrow was routinely used on British prison uniforms from about the 1830s onwards.^[18] An instance of the Admiralty using the mark in a salvage case occurred at Wisbech, Isle of Ely in 1860: "The barque Angelo C, laden with barley, from Sulina, lying at Mr Morton's granary, has been marked with the 'broad arrow', a writ at Admiralty having been issued at the instance of Peter Pilkington, one of the pilots of this port, who claims £400 for salvage services alleged to have been rendered to the vessel during the great gale of the 28th ult."^[19]

Topped with a horizontal line, the broad arrow was widely used on Ordnance Survey benchmarks.^[20] Broad arrow marks were also used by Commonwealth countries on their ordnance.

The Board of Ordnance was absorbed into the War Department in 1855, but the broad arrow continued to be used by its successor bodies: the War Department 1855–57, the War Office 1857–1964, and by the Ministry of Defence from 1964 onwards, before being phased out in the 1980s.

It is currently a criminal offence in the United Kingdom to reproduce the broad arrow without authority (in the same way as it is an offence to reproduce hallmarks). Section 4 of the Public Stores Act 1875 makes it illegal to use the "broad arrow" on any goods without permission.^[21][22]

 

War Department Ordnance Survey marker, Bermuda

In Journals

A newspaper THE BROAD ARROW described as 'A PAPER FOR THE SERVICES' (and also with the 'Broad Arrow' mark in its header) was published from 1833. It later extended its title to include The Naval and Military Gazette. It was published during WW1 by which time it was printed by WH Smith and son. It later became THE ARMY, NAVY AND AIR FORCE GAZETTE : INCORPORATING "THE BROAD ARROW" AND "NAVAL AND MILITARY GAZETTE In 1936 The Army, Navy and Air Force Gazette amalgamated with the Naval and Military Record to form United Services Review.^[23]

In the American colonies

The broad arrow was used by the British to mark trees (one species of which was the eastern white pine) intended for ship building use in North America during colonial times. Three axe strikes, resembling an arrowhead and shaft, were marked on large mast-grade trees.^[24] Use of the broad arrow mark commenced in earnest in 1691 with the Massachusetts Charter, which contained a Mast Preservation Clause specifying, in part:^[25]

... for better providing and furnishing of Masts for our Royal Navy wee do hereby reserve to us ... ALL trees of the diameter of 24 inches and upward at 12 inches from the ground, growing upon any soils or tracts of land within our said Province or Territory not heretofore granted to any private person. We...forbid all persons whatsoever from felling, cutting or destroying any such trees without the royal license from us.

Initially England imported its mast trees from the Baltic states, but it was an expensive, lengthy and politically treacherous proposition. Much of British naval policy at the time revolved around keeping the trade route to the Baltics open. With Baltic timber becoming less appealing to use, the Admiralty's eye turned towards the Colonies. Colonists paid little attention to the Charter's Mast Preservation Clause, and tree harvesting increased with disregard for broad arrow protected trees. However, as Baltic imports decreased, the British timber trade increasingly depended on North American trees, and enforcement of broad arrow policies increased.^[26] Persons appointed to the position of Surveyor-General of His Majesty's Woods were responsible for selecting, marking and recording trees as well as policing and enforcing the unlicensed cutting of protected trees. This process was open to abuse, and the British monopoly was very unpopular with colonists. Part of the reason was that many protected trees were on either town-owned or privately owned lands.

Colonists could only sell mast trees to the British, but were substantially underpaid for the lumber. Even though it was illegal for the colonists to sell to enemies of the crown, both the French and the Spanish were in the market for mast trees as well and would pay a much better price. Acts of Parliament in 1711, 1722 and 1772 (Timber for the Navy Act 1772) extended protection finally to 12-inch-diameter (300 mm) trees and resulted in the Pine Tree Riot that same year. This was one of the first acts of rebellion by the American colonists leading to the American Revolution in 1775, and a flag bearing a white pine is said^{[by whom?]} to have been flown at the Battle of Bunker Hill.

In Australia

 

Benchmark of c.1829 on the line of the Great North Road, Sydney, Australia

The broad arrow was used to denote government property in the Australian colonies^[27] from the earliest times of settlement^[28] until well after federation.^[29] William Oswald Hodgkinson's government-sponsored North-West Expedition in Queensland used the broad arrow to mark trees along the expedition's route.^[30] The broad arrow mark was also used on survey markers.^[31] It can still be seen on some Australian military property. The broad arrow brand is also still used to mark trees as the property of the Crown, and is protected against unauthorised use.

In Victoria, Australia for example, Part 4 of the Forests (Licences and Permits) Regulations 2009 states that "an authorised officer may use the broad arrow brand ... to mark trees in a timber harvesting area which are not to be felled; or to indicate forest produce which has been seized under the Act; or to indicate that forest produce lawfully cut or obtained is not to be removed until the brand is obliterated with the crown brand by any authorised officer."^[32] The broad arrow is used currently by the Australian Army to denote property owned by the Department of Defence.^[33]

The mark was not widely used for convict clothing in Australia during the early period of transportation, as government-issued uniforms were rare.^[34] The Board of Ordnance took over supply in the 1820s, and uniforms from this period onwards were generally marked with the broad arrow,^[35] including so-called "magpie" uniforms.^[36] In an account published in 1827, Peter Miller Cunningham described Australian convicts as wearing "white woollen Paramatta frocks and trowsers, or grey and yellow jackets with duck overalls, (the different styles of dress denoting the oldness or newness of their arrival,) all daubed over with broad arrows, P.B.s, C.B.s, and various numerals in black, white, and red".^[37] In 1859, Caroline Leakey, writing under the pen-name "Oliné Keese", published a fictionalised account of the convict experience entitled The Broad Arrow: Being Passages from the History of Maida Gwynnham, a Lifer.

In India

 

Registration plate of an Indian military vehicle

The device was used in Colonial India, and continues to be used in modern India on military vehicle registration plates, although the symbol now employed is a standard typographical upward-pointing arrow rather than a true broad arrow.^[38]

In characterisation of internal combustion engines

Main article: W engine

Multi-cylinder internal combustion engines have their cylinder banks arranged in different ways. If there are just two, they may be in-line, opposed or at an angle, the latter often described as a Vee (or V) arrangement. When there are more than two cylinders, they are either arranged radially, in-line or in in-line groups. Thus a V-6 engine has two banks of three cylinders at an angle driving a common crankshaft, a V-12 two groups of six in-line.

Broad arrow or W engines have three groups, one vertical and the two others symmetrically angled at less than 90° on either side. Both the air-cooled Anzani 3-cylinder fan engines of the "pioneer era" of aviation, and the later, "Golden Age of Aviation"-era British Napier Lion 12-cylinder, triple-bank liquid-cooled inline aviation engine could be said to have this layout when seen from a "nose-on" view.

See also

• Tiwaz (rune)

Notes

1. Woodward & Burnett (1969), p. 350
2. Parker & Gough (1966), p. 23
3. Fox-Davies, A. C. (1969) [1909]. Brooke-Little, J. P. (ed.). A Complete Guide to Heraldry. London: Nelson. p. 213.
4. "Alumni - Publications". Sidney Sussex College.
5. Sidney, Philip (1901). The Sidneys of Penshurst. London: S. H. Bousfield. p. 262. ... [Henry Sydney] caused his arms, a pheon, or double broad-arrow, to be cut on all Crown property, a practice that has survived to this day ...
6. Spence, Keith (1999) [1973]. The Companion Guide to Kent and Sussex (3rd ed.). Woodbridge: Companion Guides. p. 204. ISBN 1900639262. ... perhaps [Henry Sydney's] greatest claim to fame lies in the fact that, as Master of the Ordnance, he adopted the broad arrow or "pheon" of the Sidneys as the mark of government property.
7. Army Ordnance, Volume 14, American Ordnance Association, 1933, p. 162
8. "broad arrow, n.". Oxford English Dictionary (Online ed.). Oxford University Press. (Subscription or participating institution membership required.)
9. London (1956–58), p. 93
10. Ailes, Adrian (2019). "Medieval armorial seals in The National Archives (UK)". In Whatley, Laura (ed.). A Companion to Seals in the Middle Ages. Leiden: Brill. p. 163. ISBN 978-90-04-38064-6.
11. London 1954–55, p. 93; citing Riley, Henry Thomas, ed. (1868). Memorials of London and London Life, in the XIIIth, XIVth, and XVth Centuries. London: Longmans, Green & Co. pp. 489–490.
12. Fairbrother (1914), p. 481
13. Quoted in Fairbrother (1914), p. 481.
14. Turnbull, William B., ed. (1861). Calendar of State Papers, Foreign Series, of the Reign of Mary, 1553–1558: preserved in the Public Record Office. London: Longman & Co. p. 141. (text calendared and modernised).
15. Larkin, James F., ed. (1983). Stuart Royal Proclamations. Vol. 2. Oxford: Clarendon Press. p. 133. ISBN 0198224664.
16. Quoted in Fairbrother (1914), p. 482.
17. Monger, Garry (2021). "Fort in the Fens". The Fens. 31. Natasha Shiels: 20–21.
18. Fairbrother (1914), p. 482: "The Prison Commissioners ... wrote, on 2 March last: 'It [the broad arrow] is referred to in the Public Stores Acts in 1875, but was in use many years before that date. It has been used in Convict Prisons and Hulks for more than 80 years, and was also used in Australia.'"
19. "Wisbech". Stamford Mercury. 15 June 1860. p. 4.
20. "Ordnance Survey". www.ordnancesurvey.co.uk. Retrieved 30 March 2021.
21. Hayes (1837), p. 273
22. Section 4: Marks in schedule appropriated for public stores.

    The marks described in the First Schedule to this Act may be applied in or on stores in order to denote Her Majesty's property in stores so marked; and it shall be lawful for any public department, and the contractors, officers, and workmen of such department, to apply those marks, or any of them, in or on any such stores; and if any person without lawful authority (proof of which authority shall lie on the party accused) applies any of those marks in or on any such stores he shall be guilty of a misdemeanor, and shall on conviction thereof be liable to be imprisoned for any term not exceeding two years.

    First Schedule: Marks appropriated for use in or on Her Majesty's Stores

    The name of Her Majesty, her predecessors, her heirs or successors, or of any public department, or any branch thereof, or the broad arrow, or a crown, or Her Majesty's arms, whether such broad arrow, crown, or arms be alone or be in combination with any such name as aforesaid, or with any letters denoting any such name.

23. "THE ARMY, NAVY AND AIR FORCE GAZETTE". www.iwm.org.uk. Retrieved 29 March 2021.
24. "The King's Broad Arrow and Eastern White Pine". NeLMA: Northeastern Lumber Manufacturers Association.
25. Malone (1979), p. 10
26. Malone (1979), p. 11
27. Australia's First Settlement 2008-07-05 at the Wayback Machine
28. Convict Cap c.1852 at NSW Migration Heritage Centre July 20, 2008, at the Wayback Machine
29. . Perth Dead Persons' Society. 2002. Broad Arrow. Archived from the original on 2008-07-06. Retrieved 2008-06-08.
30. . The State of Queensland Environmental Protection Agency. Archived from the original on 2008-08-19. Retrieved 2008-06-08.
31. 6.2.6 Old Survey Marks - Registrar General's Directions July 22, 2008, at the Wayback Machine
32. Forests (Licences and Permits) Regulations 2009 (Vic) r 16 Use of broad arrow brand.
33. "The Broad Arrow". Australian Army.
34. . Archived from the original on 2011-02-17. Retrieved 2014-01-07.
35. Maynard (1994), p. 21
36. "Convict uniforms". National Treasures. National Library of Australia. Retrieved 2008-08-04.
37. Cunningham, P. (1827). Two Years in New South Wales: a series of letters, comprising sketches of the actual state of society in that colony. Vol. 1. p. 46.
38. "number plates". www.bharat.review. Retrieved 30 March 2021.

References

• Fairbrother, E. H. (1914). "'The Broad Arrow': the King's mark". Notes and Queries. 11th ser. 9 (234): 481–483. doi:10.1093/nq/s11-IX.234.481.
• Hayes, Edmund (1837). Crimes and Punishments: Or, An Analytical Digest of The Criminal Statute Law of Ireland. Hodges and Smith.
• London, H. Stanford (1954–1955). "The broad arrow as a government badge". The Coat of Arms. 3: 135–136.
• London, H. Stanford (1956–1958). "Official badges". The Coat of Arms. 4: 93–100.
• Malone, Joseph J. (1979). Pine Trees and Politics. Ayer Publishing. ISBN 978-0-405-11380-2.
• Maynard, Margaret (1994). Fashioned from Penury: Dress as Cultural Practice in Colonial Australia. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. ISBN 978-0-521-45925-9.
• Parker, James; Gough, Henry (1966). A Glossary of Terms Used in Heraldry. London: Gale Research Company.
• Woodward, John; Burnett, George (1969) [1892]. Woodward's A Treatise on Heraldry: British and Foreign with English and French Glossaries. Rutland, VT: Charles E. Tuttle Co.

External links

•   Media related to Broad arrows in heraldry at Wikimedia Commons