Anti-Oriental riots (Vancouver)

The Vancouver riots occurred September 7–9, 1907, in Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada. At about the same time there were similar anti-Asian riots in Bellingham, Washington, San Francisco, and other West Coast cities. They were not coordinated but instead reflected common underlying anti-immigration attitudes.^[2] Agitation for direct action was led by labour unions and small business.^[3]: 163 Damage to Asian-owned property was extensive.

Anti-Oriental Riots
Part of the Pacific Coast race riots of 1907
Location	Chinatown and Japantown Vancouver, British Columbia
Casualties
Death(s)	none confirmed
Injuries	unknown
Arrested	At least 19^[1]

Causes of riots

In the early years of the twentieth century race relations on the Pacific Coast of Canada were strained. There were an estimated 16,000 Chinese immigrants in the province at the 1901 census, an increase from the prior 1881 (4,350) and 1891 (8,910) counts.^[4]: 7–8 There were also 8,000 Japanese and around 5,000 South Asians. The Chinese had come to Canada to build the railways; the Japanese to fish; and Indians to farm and log.

 

Japanese immigrants arriving from Kumeric, 1907

At this time, other ships with more migrants were arriving, including the Suian Maru [83 Japanese, 1906],^[5][6][7] SS Kumeric [1,177 Japanese, 1907],^[8][9][10] SS Tartar [514 Indians, 1907],^[11] and the SS Monteagle [901 Indians, further 100 in 1908].^[12][13] Meanwhile, the Panic of 1907, caused by the failure of Augustus Heinze's brother's bank in New York, exacerbated the difficult labour market and brought racial tensions to the fore.

White people perceived Asians as taking "their" jobs. Australia had enacted the Immigration Restriction Act 1901 which promulgated the White Australia policy and eliminated Asian immigration shortly after federation. The Asian Exclusion League in Canada lobbied for Canada to do the same.

The riots that broke out on September 7, 1907 were the accumulation of growing enmity toward the Asian immigrants that were coming to the United States and parts of Canada.^[14]: 68 "By the end of October 1907, new arrivals totaled 11,440. Of these immigrants the Japanese accounted for 8,125, the Chinese 1,266, and the Punjabi Sikhs 2,049".^[3]: 163 As the numbers of Asian immigrants continued to grow, anti-Asian activist began to feel threatened that the Japanese could "ultimately control [Vancouver] part of Canada".^[14]: 66 The riots represented the voices and feelings of anti-Asian activists, in attempt to "convince federal authorities of the seriousness of anti-Japanese sentiment in British Columbia".^[3]: 163

Events

The 1907 Vancouver riot was the second act of anti-Asian violence in the history of Vancouver; the first incident took place in the area of Coal Harbour, in 1887.^[15]: 172 A riot targeting East Indian lumber workers in Bellingham in 1907 started the events.^[16] Shortly thereafter, tensions flared in the north and angry mobs stormed through Powell Street in Vancouver's Chinatown, breaking windows and assaulting Chinese people in the streets. The riot lasted three days in September 1907; finally the Vancouver police closed the streets and calm slowly returned. Many windows were broken and the population was terrified. The second day of the riot turned against the Japanese community. There were similar actions in Steveston in Richmond against the Japanese.

Immediate lead-up

Early in 1907 the Grand Trunk Pacific Railway lobbied Ottawa to let it import 10,000 Japanese workers to build its line in Northern BC [this figure is often misquoted as 50,000]. Attorney-General (later Premier) Bowser did not like such large numbers and opposed such a large Asian influx. On August 12, 1907, members of the Asiatic Exclusion League met and developed a resolution. The document asked the Canadian government to "enforce the Immigration Act passed by the provincial legislature in the Spring of 1907",^[15]: 176 but the Canadian Government refused to endorse the proposed act.

Main article: Pacific Coast race riots of 1907

At about the same time there were similar anti-Asian riots in San Francisco, Bellingham, Washington, and other West Coast cities. They were not coordinated, but instead reflected common underlying anti-Asian nativism.^[2] The Vancouver riots were a direct result of the race riot in Bellingham, Washington, on September 5, 1907. Many Chinese victims of the Bellingham race riots fled to Canada,^[15]: 174 subsequently fuelling the Asiatic Exclusion League of Vancouver to take a stance against further Asian immigration.^[17]

Parade and riot

At the third meeting, members of the Asiatic Exclusion League decided to plan a parade for Saturday, September 7, which would include a band in order to draw attention.^[15]: 176 The parade would lead to Vancouver City Hall at Hastings and Main (then named Westminster), next to Chinatown, where a rally would be held to address the issues of Asian Immigration.^[15]: 176 10,000 Canadian and American citizens marched in that anti-Asian immigration parade, which resulted in a mob rioting throughout Chinese and Japanese neighbourhoods within Vancouver.^{[1][17][14]: 67 [18]}

 

Boarded windows and storefronts on Pender Street in Chinatown after the September 1907 riots

As various speakers were discussing the Bellingham riot, the sound of shattering glass caused by a rock tossed by an unruly teen, sounded the beginning of what would become a much larger riot in Vancouver. The crowd gathered at the parade turned into a rioting mob, throwing beer bottles and rocks at windows, attempting to destroy Chinese owned stores and homes. Most of the buildings attacked during the Vancouver riots were Caucasian owned.^[15]: 177

After destroying Chinese business and homes, the mob of rioters moved to Japantown. Four waves of attacks ensued, with the rioters being repulsed by the armed Japanese residents. In spite of the defenders inflicting a number of injuries upon the attacking mob, more than 50 stores and businesses in the Japanese district on Powell Street had their windows broken, resulting in thousands of dollars of damage.^[19] The Vancouver riot did not finish until 3 am on September 8; by the time dawn had broken, the city was quiet.^[14]: 67

Punjabis were initially targeted but “sent attacking white mobs fleeing” as majority of the Punjabis were former soldiers of the Sikh regiment and Punjab regiments, many of whom even after retirement and migrating to Canada, kept their service muskets and bayonets and at the minimum, daggers and swords in their households, often ceremonial religious swords which had been kept as sidearms during war.^[20][21]

The morning after the riots stopped, Ng Ah Sim, a farm worker from South Vancouver, was found hanging in a tree. His death was ruled a suicide by the coroner, but articles published in Chinese language newspapers indicated the community believed otherwise.^[22]

Aftermath

Labour Minister MacKenzie King was appointed to conduct a Royal Commission into the events. He also recompensed the damage with $26,000 to the Chinese-Canadian community and $9000 for the Japanese-Canadian community.^[23][24]

The Vancouver race riot resulted in bans on immigration for Japanese people. This ban was titled the "gentlemen's agreement" and was enacted in Canada on January 25, 1908.^[17]: 553 Within this treaty Japan agreed to "restrict the number of passports issued to make labourers and domestic servants to an annual maximum of 400".^[17]: 553 In addition to the "gentlemen's agreement", Canada also passed the continuous journey regulation, which further restricted immigration from Asia through immigration bans applied to people whose "journey" to Canada was not "continuous", that is, those whose travel from their home country included a stopover in another country; this acted as a further effective de facto restriction on immigrants from Asia.^[17]: 553

The Vancouver pogrom was talked about at length by the German Emperor Wilhelm II in his interview with the British Colonel Edward Montagu-Stuart-Wortley, that set off the Daily Telegraph Affair of 1908.^[25] In the interview, Wilhelm warned of the "Yellow Peril" that was said to be threatening Western civilization, and used the Vancouver pogrom as an example of what he called the "corruption" of British foreign policy, which he predicated would soon flounder between the contradictions of anti-Asian feelings in Canada vs. Britain's alliance with Japan.^[25] Wilhelm argued that Britain had to "protect" Canada from Asian immigration, which would mean conflict with Japan, leading him to predict disaster for the British empire.^[25]

Although spared the worst of the riots by remaining indoors and fighting back,^[26][20][21] the aftermath nevertheless affected Indians living in the province. In 1908 the British Columbia government passed a law preventing South Asian men from voting. Because eligibility for federal elections originated from provincial voting lists, they were also unable to vote in federal elections.^[27] The Canadian government also enacted a $200 head tax on Indian immigrants, and required immigrants to take a continuous journey from their country of origin to Canada; there were no boats which sailed directly from India to Canada. After 1908, yearly South Asian immigration to Canada did not exceed 80 until the 1940s. A direct result of these restrictions set the stage for one of the most infamous events in Vancouver history, the "Komagata Maru Incident" in 1914.

See also

• Royal Commission on Chinese Immigration (1885)
• Chinese Immigration Act, 1885
• 1886 Vancouver anti-Chinese riots
• Chinese Immigration Act, 1923
• Bellingham riots
• History of Vancouver

References

1. "Wild Rioters Mob Asiatics". Los Angeles Herald. Associated Press. September 10, 1907. Retrieved 27 June 2019.
2. Lee, Erika (2007-01-01). "Hemispheric Orientalism and the 1907 Pacific Coast Race Riots". Amerasia Journal. 33 (2): 19–48. doi:10.17953/amer.33.2.y263745731125524. ISSN 0044-7471. S2CID 146563836.
3. Sugimoto, Howard H. (1973-01-01). "The Vancouver Riot and Its International Significance". The Pacific Northwest Quarterly. 64 (4): 163–174. JSTOR 40489721.
4. Report of the Royal Commission on Chinese and Japanese Immigration (Report). Ottawa: S.E. Dawson, Printer to the King's Most Excellent Majesty. 1902. Retrieved 26 June 2019.
5. Sulz, David (2008). "3 | Transitional Relations: Japanese Immigration and the Suian Maru Affair, 1900-11". In Donaghy, Greg; Roy, Patricia E. (eds.). Contradictory Impulses: Canada and Japan in the Twentieth Century. Vancouver, BC: UBC Press. pp. 46–61. ISBN 978-0-7748-1443-0. Retrieved 27 June 2019.
6. Adamski, Barbara K. (August 22, 2007). "Suian Maru Voyagers". The Canadian Encyclopedia. Retrieved 27 June 2019.
7. "Japanese Schooner Heavily Fined". Sacramento Union. November 2, 1906. Retrieved 27 June 2019.
8. Nomura, Kazuko. They Who Part the Grass: The Japanese Government and Early Nikkei Immigration to Canada, 1877–1908 (PDF) (Master of Arts thesis). University of Manitoba. Retrieved 27 June 2019.
9. "Brings Japanese". Los Angeles Herald. July 14, 1907. Retrieved 27 June 2019.
10. "Japs Crowding In from Hawaii". Los Angeles Herald. Associated Press. July 25, 1907. Retrieved 27 June 2019.
11. "Hindoos Flock to Vancouver". Mariposa Gazette. October 26, 1907. Retrieved 27 June 2019.
12. "'Ship Away Hindus' Cry". Los Angeles Herald. Associated Press. September 13, 1907. Retrieved 27 June 2019.
13. "More Hindus Arrive". Los Angeles Herald. Associated Press. December 3, 1907. Retrieved 27 June 2019.
14. Jensen, Joan M. (1988). Passage from India: Asian Indian Immigrants in North America. New Haven: Yale University Press. ISBN 9780300038460.
15. Wynne, Robert E. (1966). "American Labor Leaders and the Vancouver Anti-Oriental Riot". The Pacific Northwest Quarterly. 57 (4): 172–179. JSTOR 40488175.
16. Hallberg, Gerald. N. (1973). "Bellingham, Washington's Anti-Hindu Riot". Journal of the West. 12: 163–175.
17. Lee, Erika (2007). "The "Yellow Peril" and Asian Exclusion in the Americas". Pacific Historical Review. 76 (4): 551. doi:10.1525/phr.2007.76.4.537.
18. Englesberg, Paul (2015). . Sikh Gadar Lehar 1907-1918. Anaheim: Shri Guru Sahib Foundation: 303–337. Archived from the original on 2021-02-25. Retrieved 2019-06-27. alternative link 2016-03-04 at the Wayback Machine
19. Ito, Kazuo (1973). Issei: A History of Japanese Immigrants in North America. Seattle: Executive Committee for Publication. pp. 102–103. ASIN B000IXEZ4G.
20. Purewal, Steven (2019). Duty, honour & izzat : from golden fields to crimson - Punjab's brothers in arms in Flanders. Christopher Rawlins, Alexander Finbow. Canmore, Alberta. ISBN 978-1-988903-47-7. OCLC 1110979568.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
21. Century of Struggle and Success The Sikh Canadian Experience 13 November 2006
22. Nicol, Janet Mary (2007). "The Vancouver Race Riot of 1907". British Columbia History. 40 (2): 2–5.
23. King, William Lyon Mackenzie (1908). Report by W. L. Mackenzie King, C.M.G., Deputy Minister of Labour, Commissioner appointed to investigate into the Losses Sustained by the Chinese Population of Vancouver, B.C. on the occasion of the riots in that city in September, 1907 (Report). Ottawa: S.E. Dawson, Printer to the King's Most Excellent Majesty. Retrieved 26 June 2019.
24. King, William Lyon Mackenzie (1908). Report by W. L. Mackenzie King, C.M.G., Deputy Minister of Labour, Commissioner appointed to investigate into the Losses Sustained by the Japanese Population of Vancouver, B.C. on the occasion of the riots in that city in September, 1907 (Report). Ottawa: S.E. Dawson, Printer to the King's Most Excellent Majesty. Retrieved 26 June 2019.
25. Röhl 2013, p. 598.
26. Century of Struggle and Success The Sikh Canadian Experience 13 November 2006
27. Nayar, The Punjabis in British Columbia, page 15.

Bibliography

• Hallberg, Gerald (1973). "Bellingham, Washington's Anti-Hindu Riot". Journal of the West. 12: 163–175.
• Iino, Masako (1983). "Japan's Reaction to the Vancouver Riot of 1907". BC Studies: The British Columbian Quarterly. 60: 28–47.
• Jensen, Joan M. (1988). Passage from India: Asian Indian Immigrants in North America. Yale University Press. ISBN 9780300038460.
• King, William Lyon Mackenzie (1908). Report by W. L. Mackenzie King, C.M.G., Deputy Minister of Labour, Commissioner appointed to investigate into the Losses Sustained by the Chinese Population of Vancouver, B.C. on the occasion of the riots in that city in September, 1907 (Report). Ottawa: S.E. Dawson, Printer to the King's Most Excellent Majesty. Retrieved 26 June 2019.
• King, William Lyon Mackenzie (1908). Report by W. L. Mackenzie King, C.M.G., Deputy Minister of Labour, Commissioner appointed to investigate into the Losses Sustained by the Japanese Population of Vancouver, B.C. on the occasion of the riots in that city in September, 1907 (Report). Ottawa: S.E. Dawson, Printer to the King's Most Excellent Majesty. Retrieved 26 June 2019.
• Lee, Erika (2007-11-01). "The ""Yellow Peril"" and Asian Exclusion in the Americas". Pacific Historical Review. 76 (4): 537–562. doi:10.1525/phr.2007.76.4.537. ISSN 0030-8684.
• Price, John (2007). ""Orienting" the Empire: Mackenzie King and the Aftermath of the 1907 Race Riots". BC Studies: The British Columbian Quarterly. 156 (7): 53–81.
• Röhl, John (2013). Wilhelm II Into the Abyss of War and Exile, 1900–1941. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. ISBN 9781107728967.
• Roy, Patricia E (1976). "The preservation of peace in Vancouver: The aftermath of the anti-Chinese riot of 1887". BC Studies: The British Columbian Quarterly. 31: 44–59.
• Roy, Patricia (1990). A White Man's Province: British Columbia Politicians and Chinese and Japanese Immigrants, 1858-1914. UBC Press. ISBN 9780774803731.
• Roy, Patricia. The Oriental Question: Consolidating a White Man's Province, 1914-1941 (2003)
• Sugimoto, Howard H. (1973-01-01). "The Vancouver Riot and Its International Significance". The Pacific Northwest Quarterly. 64 (4): 163–174. JSTOR 40489721.
• Wynne, Robert E. (1966-01-01). "American Labor Leaders and the Vancouver Anti-Oriental Riot". The Pacific Northwest Quarterly. 57 (4): 172–179. JSTOR 40488175.

External links

• British Columbia: From the Earliest Times to the Present, pp. 577-578, E.O.S. Scholfield & F.W. Howay, publ. 1916^{[permanent dead link]}
• The Preservation of the Peace in Vancouver: The Aftermath of the Anti-Chinese Riot of 1887, Patricia A. Roy, BC Studies