Annie MacDonald Langstaff

Annie MacDonald Langstaff (6 June 1887 – 29 June 1975) was a Canadian law student, legal activist, supporter of women's suffrage and an early woman aviator. Born in Ontario in 1887, she graduated from Prescott High School and then married in 1904. Her husband quickly abandoned her, leaving her a single mother. Moving to Montreal in 1906, she began working as a stenographer in the law office of Samuel William Jacobs, who encouraged her to study law. Finding no barriers to her admission, Langstaff enrolled at McGill University in 1911, graduating three years later as a Bachelor of Civil Law. On applying to the Bar of Montreal to practice, she was refused the right to take the examination.

Annie MacDonald Langstaff
from Maclean's Magazine, 1922
Born	Annie MacDonald (1887-06-06)6 June 1887 Alexandria, Glengarry Township, Ontario, Canada
Died	29 June 1975(1975-06-29) (aged 88) Montreal, Quebec, Canada
Nationality	Canadian
Other names	Annie Langstaff, A. MacDonald Langstaff, Annie McDonald Langstaff
Education	Bachelor of Civil Law
Alma mater	McGill University
Occupation(s)	Paralegal, women's rights activist, aviator
Years active	1906–1965

When Langstaff petitioned the Superior Court for a Writ Of Mandamus to compel the bar to admit her as she met all statutory requirements, the court upheld the bar's decision based upon the fact that she neither had her husband's permission to attend law school, nor to become a lawyer. As her husband had abandoned her and her child and she did not know where he was, she was unable to obtain his permission. The refusal led to feminists in support of women's suffrage embracing Langstaff and her cause. She became active in the fight for enfranchisement of women in Quebec, while continuing her fight to become a barrister. In 1915 she filed an appeal with the Court of King's Bench, which also ruled against her, claiming that her recourse was to petition the legislature, since they had enacted the statute defining who could become a lawyer.

Langstaff was supported in her quest by her employer, with whom she would work for 60 years. Preparing an amendment to the Bar Act, Jacobs argued for the admission of women to the bar before the National Assembly of Quebec in 1915. Numerous attempts were made to change the law, without success. She wrote Canada's first French-English/English-French law dictionary in 1937. In 1940, when women in Quebec won the right to vote, the decision was used as leverage to change the law excluding women from practicing law. The next year, joined by Leona Bell and Elizabeth C. Monk, Langstaff pleaded with the Quebec Bar Association to support their right to practice. The bar agreed to allow women to enter the profession, if the legislature approved, which they did on 29 April 1941. Because of a prerequisite for lawyers admitted to the bar to have obtained a Bachelor of Arts degree, Langstaff was not admitted to the bar in her lifetime. She was posthumously admitted to the Montreal Bar in 2006.

Early life

Annie MacDonald was born on 6 June 1887 in Alexandria, Glengarry Township, Ontario, to Clara Angela (née McPhaul) and Archibald B. MacDonald. Her father was a teacher, later an insurance agent, and both of her parents were Catholic.^[1][2] Annie was the oldest sibling in a family of five other children: John, Alice Phyllis Muriel "Phyllis", Mary Jane, Pearl and Eileen.^[3] By 1891, the family was living in Prescott,^[4] where MacDonald attended Catholic grammar schools and graduated from Prescott High School.^[5][6] On 21 November 1904 in Prescott, MacDonald married Gilbert Samuel Langstaff, a carpenter,^[7] with whom she had a daughter, Mary Andrea Langstaff, on 28 April 1906.^[8][9] Soon after their marriage, Langstaff and her husband separated,^[10] as he left her.^[11] Her husband migrated to New York City in 1905 with another woman whom he claimed to have married in 1904.^[12][13]

Career

Law school and bar case (1906–1915)

 

Samuel William Jacobs, in 1918

In 1906, Langstaff moved to Montreal, Quebec, to work for the law firm of Jacobs, Hall and Garneau,^[5][14] as a stenographer for the head partner Samuel William Jacobs, KC.^[6] Her family also moved to Quebec, where her father worked as a customs collector in Saint-Hyacinthe.^[8][15] Langstaff had an affinity for the law and within a few years was performing much of the company incorporation work for Jacobs.^[5] With his encouragement, she wrote to McGill University's faculty of law, in 1911, inquiring if she could be admitted. Frederick P. Walton, dean of the faculty, responded that no woman had ever asked for admission before, and while he was unsure of whether his colleagues would approve, she ought to begin attending lectures.^[14] Langstaff graduated in 1914 with a Bachelor of Civil Law,^[5][16] first in her class in criminal and company law,^[5] and fourth overall with first-class honours.^[14] That year, she became the first woman to serve as a court stenographer in the June Special Session of the Montreal Criminal Court.^[6]

Langstaff applied to sit for the preliminary bar examination but was refused by the Bar of Montreal despite her law degree.^[17] The preliminary examination was open to male students before they began their studies, but anticipating that she might encounter difficulty, Langstaff had not applied until after she had already received her degree.^[6] In January 1915, she petitioned the Superior Court for a Writ Of Mandamus.^[10] With Jacobs acting as her counsellor, she asked the court to grant her the right to take the examination, as she met all the statutory qualifications.^[6][17] At issue were two questions: whether a woman was admissible at all, and whether as a married woman, Langstaff was admissible as either a law student or lawyer, since her husband had not given his consent.^[5] A good deal of the court proceedings focused on the fact that Langstaff was raising her daughter as a single mother and did not know the whereabouts of her husband. In his ruling, Justice Henri-Césaire Saint-Pierre denied her request, stating that to allow her to practice law without her husband's consent would be a "direct infringement upon public order and a manifest violation of the law of good morals and public decency".^[17]

 

Justice Henri-Césaire Saint-Pierre

After Saint-Pierre's comments had been widely publicized in newspapers throughout the United States and Canada, the issue became a cause célèbre for those involved in the struggle for women's suffrage. Professor Carrie Derick and the Montreal Local Council of Women [fr] (French: Conseil local des femmes de Montréal) staged demonstrations protesting the decision.^[6][17] Langstaff was invited regularly to speak at suffragist rallies, where she stressed that equal opportunity was her goal^[17] and filed an appeal with the Court of King's Bench.^[6][18] At the September 1915 hearing, the court's focus was again turned to the facts that she was not living with her husband, that he had not agreed to her attending law school, and that she was raising her daughter without his support.^[17] In a 4 to 1 decision, issued on 2 November with Justice Joseph Lavergne as Langstaff's sole supporter, her appeal was denied.^[6][19][20] The basis of the ruling was that the intent of the law in Quebec was to exclude women from the legal profession because hearing cases which involved crimes of a sexual nature or obscenities "would bring into contempt her honor as a spouse or as a mother and to revile herself in the eyes of her husband, her children, and the male sex generally".^[10] The judge also noted that the courts were not the appropriate venue for such a decision and that it should be reviewed by the legislature^[21] since the law forbade women practicing.^[22] On 31 December 1915, her only brother was killed in action while fighting on the front lines in World War I.^[15]

Continuing activism, paralegal work, and legal scholarship (1916–1965)

Langstaff began to plan for introducing an amendment to the Bar Act at the next legislative session of the National Assembly of Quebec,^[23] which would convene on 12 January 1916.^[24] Langstaff's supporters, including Jacobs, prepared a bill^[17] and Lucien Cannon sponsored it.^[25] Jacobs, using arguments supporting Langstaff's application written by Justice Lavergne, spoke to the committee along with feminists Grace Ritchie England and Marie Lacoste Gérin-Lajoie.^[26] The bill did not make it out of committee,^[17] nor did a similar attempt made after the 1916 General Election of Quebec.^[26] Langstaff continued to work as a legal assistant at Jacobs, Hall, Couture and Fitch,^[6] (later Jacobs & Phillips (1920)^[25][27] and still later Phillips & Vineberg (1945)).^[6][27] During World War I, further action on admitting women to the bar in Quebec was suspended, but in 1920 another unsuccessful attempt at legislation was made.^[26] Becoming the assistant to the other senior partner, Senator Lazarus Phillips,^[25] Langstaff served as his secretary, a bookkeeper for the firm, and as a paralegal.^[17][28]

In 1921, Langstaff took up flying.^[29] An article published on 1 July 1922 in Maclean's Magazine called her the "first Canadian woman to fly" and featured her photograph.^[30] That year, when French general Ferdinand Foch toured Montreal, she circled the city in a plane as part of the festivities.^[6] She continued to attend and speak at suffragist meetings and rallies. In 1929, she proposed that single women refuse to marry until the civil code which treated wives as chattel was revised.^[31] In 1930, the legislature was again pressed to admit women to the bar. The debate clarified that the bar no longer objected to the admission of women and would allow a judge to grant her permission in the absence of a spouse.^[32] After two days of arguments, once again, the proposed bill was defeated by a vote of 37 to 29, largely because Antonin Galipeault, the Minister of Public Works and Labour, tied it to a pending suffrage bill and the possibility that feminists would next be asking for the possibility of divorce.^[33] The following year, another bill was submitted but was defeated by two votes.^[34][35]

In 1935, when Joseph-Napoléon Francoeur introduced legislation for women to prove their need for employment before they could work,^[36] Langstaff became a vocal opponent. She argued that employment was a human right and if men could work in women's occupations, like fashion or cooking, then women should be allowed to work in whatever field they wanted. She suggested that if professional men had sufficient income without employment, perhaps they should give up their careers to unemployed men.^[37] The bill did not pass, as most Members of Parliament felt that it violated the right to work.^[36][38] In 1937, Langstaff published the French-English, English-French Law Dictionary, the first Canadian legal dictionary to provide terms found in the Civil, Criminal and Municipal Codes in English and French languages.^[16][39] She authored several articles on family law^[6] and continued her work in business law, drafting bylaws and incorporation papers for groups like the Montreal branch of the National Council of Jewish Women of Canada.^[40] In 1939, she was one of the featured aviators in an air show held in Montreal in honor of King George VI and heir presumptive, Elizabeth.^[11]

After having 13 suffrage bills defeated between 1922 and 1939, Quebec's feminists worked that year to convince Premier Adélard Godbout to keep his campaign promise to reintroduce the measure.^[41] On 9 April 1940, he personally introduced "Bill No. 18" proposing women's suffrage at the provincial level.^[42] The bill passed with a vote of 67 in favour and 9 against on the third reading on 18 April. Gaining approval on 25 April from the Legislative Council,^[43] feminists saw the vote as leverage to gain other reforms.^[44] The following year, Langstaff, Leona Bell (wife of Leslie Bell) and Elizabeth C. Monk submitted a plea asking support for women's right to practice law to the Quebec Bar Association. In a vote of 12 in favour and 11 against, the bar^[34] agreed to allow it as long as the legislature approved a bill in the sitting session.^[21] On 29 April 1941, the legislature passed the bill^[34] and in early 1942, Monk, Constance G. Short, and Marcelle Hemond were the first women admitted to the bar.^[22] Impacting Langstaff, the new law required that candidates have a Bachelor of Arts degree for admission to the bar and she was not prepared to study for another degree.^[6] Langstaff retired in 1965, having spent six decades at Phillips & Vineberg.^[6][17]

Death and legacy

Langstaff died on 29 June 1975^[17] in Montreal,^[11] after a lengthy illness, and was buried at Cornwall, Ontario.^[9] Her papers were collected by her daughter and placed in the archival holdings of the Faculty of Law at McGill University.^[11][45]

In 1988, McGill's Faculty of Law inaugurated the Annie MacDonald Langstaff Workshops in her honour to provide a forum for academics, judges, lawyers, and community activists to present scholarly research and practical insights on issues relating to women and the law. Two other named lectures, the Margot E. Halpenny Memorial Lecture and the Patricia Allen Memorial Lecture are given each year as part of the series, in addition to three or four additional presentations.^[46]

In 2006, more than 90 years after she had first been refused admission to the bar, Langstaff was posthumously admitted to the Barreau de Montréal and awarded the bar's rarely-given Medal of Honour.^[25] As by that time, her daughter, who had become a nun in the Sisters of Holy Cross,^[11][25] had already died, the medal was accepted by Davies Ward Phillips & Vineberg, the successor firm to her former employer. It later went on display at McGill University Faculty of Law.^[25]

References

Citations

1. Ontario Births 1887, p. 291.
2. Ontario Marriages 1886, p. 577.
3. Canada Census 1901, p. 4.
4. Ontario Births 1891, p. 272.
5. The Windsor Star 1914, p. 8.
6. Kochkina 2015.
7. Ontario Marriages 1904, p. 171.
8. Canada Census 1911, p. 1.
9. The Gazette 1975, p. 61.
10. Bergeron 2017.
11. Latour 2015.
12. U.S. Census 1910, p. 5B.
13. Naturalization Records 1917, p. 288.
14. Pilarczyk 1999, p. 58.
15. The Gazette 1916, p. 3.
16. The Gazette 1937, p. 20.
17. Pilarczyk 1999, p. 59.
18. The StarPhoenix 1915, p. 4.
19. Mossman 2006, pp. 105–106.
20. The Nanaimo Daily News 1915, p. 3.
21. The Gazette 1941, p. 1.
22. The Gazette 1942b, p. 11.
23. The Province 1915, p. 9.
24. House of Commons 1916, p. 13.
25. Leger 2006, p. 29.
26. Mossman 2006, p. 106.
27. Hopkins 1975, p. ii.
28. Baker 2013.
29. The Gazette 1921, p. 3.
30. Pringle 1922, p. 62.
31. The Gazette 1929, p. 9.
32. Vineberg 1930a, pp. 1, 5.
33. Vineberg 1930b, pp. 1, 5.
34. Cleverdon 1974, p. 262.
35. The Gazette 1941, p. 11.
36. Baillargeon & Wilson 2014, p. 107.
37. The Gazette 1935, p. 9.
38. Baillargeon & Roth 2019, p. 106.
39. Ukušová 2018, p. 87.
40. The Gazette 1942a, p. 5.
41. Kalbfleisch 2012.
42. Cleverdon 1974, p. 258.
43. Cleverdon 1974, p. 259.
44. Cleverdon 1974, p. 260.
45. Mossman 2006, p. 86.
46. McGill Faculty of Law 2020.

Bibliography

• Baillargeon, Denyse; Roth, Käthe (translator) (2019). To Be Equals in Our Own Country: Women and the Vote in Quebec. Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada: University of British Columbia Press. ISBN 978-0-7748-3851-1. {{cite book}}: |first2= has generic name (help)
• Baillargeon, Denyse; Wilson, W. Donald (translator) (2014). A Brief History of Women in Quebec. Waterloo, Ontario, Canada: Wilfrid Laurier University Press. ISBN 978-1-55458-951-7. {{cite book}}: |first2= has generic name (help)
• Baker, G. Blaine (16 December 2013). . The Canadian Encyclopedia. Toronto, Canada: Historica Canada. Archived from the original on 8 June 2019. Retrieved 26 September 2019.
• Bergeron, Dominique (10 May 2017). [Annie MacDonald Langstaff – Courage and Determination]. Instantanés (in French). Montreal, Canada: Bibliothèque et Archives nationales du Québec. Archived from the original on 20 December 2018. Retrieved 23 September 2019.
• Cleverdon, Catherine Lyle (1974). Bliss, Michael (ed.). The Woman Suffrage Movement in Canada. The Social History of Canada. Vol. 18 (2nd ed.). Toronto, Canada: University of Toronto Press. ISBN 0-8020-2108-5.
• House of Commons (1916). Canada: House of Commons Debates—Official Report – Revised Edition (Report). Ottawa, Canada: J. de L. Taché.
• Hopkins, Mark (1975). (PDF). National Ethnic Archives. Ottawa, Ontario: Library and Archives Canada. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2 April 2020. Retrieved 2 April 2020.
• Kalbfleisch, John (9 July 2012). . Montreal Gazette. Montreal, Quebec, Canada. Archived from the original on 18 March 2019. Retrieved 26 September 2019.
• Kochkina, Svetlana (17 April 2015). . McGill University Library. Montreal, Canada: Nahum Gelber Law Library. Archived from the original on 29 August 2017. Retrieved 23 September 2019.
• Latour, Julie (9 March 2015). [Annie Macdonald Langstaff, Pioneer of Law in Quebec]. Sisyphe (in French). Montreal, Quebec, Canada. Archived from the original on 3 April 2017. Retrieved 26 September 2019.
• Leger, Kathryn (15 September 2006). "Woman's Struggle Recognized". The Gazette. Montreal, Quebec, Canada. p. 29. Retrieved 25 September 2019 – via Newspapers.com.
• Mossman, Mary Jane (2006). The First Women Lawyers: A Comparative Study of Gender, Law and the Legal Professions. Portland, Oregon: Hart Publishing. ISBN 978-1-84731-095-8.
• Pilarczyk, Ian C. (1999). "III. What a Lonely Business It Was To Be the Only Woman" (PDF). 'A Noble Roster': One Hundred and Fifty Years of Law at McGill. Montreal, Canada: McGill University Faculty of Law. pp. 58–68. ISBN 978-0-771-70545-8.
• Pringle, Gertrude E. S. (1 July 1922). "The Girl Who Goes to Business". Maclean's. Vol. 35, no. 13. Toronto, Canada: MacLean Publishing Company. pp. 60–62. ISSN 0024-9262. Retrieved 25 September 2019.
• Ukušová, Jana (2018). . The Annals of Ovidius University of Constanța. Seria Filologie. XXIX (2). Constanța, Romania: Ovidius University Press: 83–89. ISSN 1224-1768. Archived from the original on 26 September 2019. Retrieved 26 September 2019.
• Vineberg, Abel (19 February 1930a). "No Vote Taken on Admitting Women to Bar (pt. 1)". The Gazette. Montreal, Quebec, Canada. p. 1. Retrieved 25 September 2019 – via Newspapers.com. and Vineberg, Abel (19 February 1930). "No Vote Taken on Admitting Women to Bar (pt. 2)". The Gazette. Montreal, Quebec, Canada. p. 5. Retrieved 25 September 2019 – via Newspapers.com.
• Vineberg, Abel (20 February 1930b). "Quebec Women Denied Right to Practice Law (pt. 1)". The Gazette. Montreal, Quebec, Canada. p. 1. Retrieved 25 September 2019 – via Newspapers.com. and Vineberg, Abel (20 February 1930b). "Quebec Women Denied Right to Practice Law (pt. 2)". The Gazette. Montreal, Quebec, Canada. p. 5. Retrieved 25 September 2019 – via Newspapers.com.
• "1901 Canada Census, Grenville (south/sud), Ontario, Canada". FamilySearch. Ottawa, Canada: Library and Archives of Canada. 1901. p. 4. Retrieved 23 September 2019. and "1901 Canada Census, Grenville (south/sud), Ontario, Canada". FamilySearch. Ottawa, Canada: Library and Archives of Canada. 1901. p. 4. Retrieved 23 September 2019.
• "1910 U. S. Census, Manhattan Ward 22, New York City, New York". FamilySearch. Washington, D. C.: National Archives and Records Administration. 16 April 1910. p. 5B. NARA microfilm series T624, roll 1047, lines 92–93. Retrieved 25 September 2019.
• "1911 Canada Census, St. Hyacinthe District, Quebec, Canada". FamilySearch. Ottawa, Canada: Library and Archives of Canada. 13 June 1911. p. 1. lines 27–33. Retrieved 23 September 2019.
• "Cannot Take 'Exams'". The Windsor Star. Windsor, Ontario, Canada. 1 October 1914. p. 8. Retrieved 23 September 2019 – via Newspapers.com.
• "Defunct Measure Proves Live Topic". The Gazette. Montreal, Quebec, Canada. 10 February 1935. p. 9. Retrieved 25 September 2019 – via Newspapers.com.
• "Feminist Debaters Had No Opposition". The Gazette. Montreal, Quebec, Canada. 12 December 1929. p. 9. Retrieved 25 September 2019 – via Newspapers.com.
• "First Women Admitted to the Bar Will Appear at Court Tomorrow". The Gazette. Montreal, Quebec, Canada. 9 September 1942. p. 11. Retrieved 25 September 2019 – via Newspapers.com.
• "Growing Controls Not Dictatorship". The Gazette. Montreal, Quebec, Canada. 21 May 1942. p. 5. Retrieved 26 September 2019 – via Newspapers.com.
• "Has Not Given Up". The Province. Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada. 4 November 1915. p. 9. Retrieved 25 September 2019 – via Newspapers.com.
• "Langstaff, Annie". The Gazette. Montreal, Quebec, Canada. 3 July 1975. p. 61. Retrieved 26 September 2019 – via Newspapers.com.
• "Law Dictionary". The Gazette. Montreal, Quebec, Canada. 24 April 1937. p. 20. Retrieved 26 September 2019 – via Newspapers.com.
• "Manhattan: County Naturalization Record of Declarations of Intention, 1917: Samuel Gilbert Langstaff". FamilySearch. Manhattan, New York: New York County Clerk Office. 27 November 1917. p. 288. 168023. Retrieved 25 September 2019.
• "Mrs. A. Langstaff Had Captain H. D. Wilshire as Her Passenger". The Gazette. Montreal, Quebec, Canada. 26 December 1921. p. 3. Retrieved 25 September 2019 – via Newspapers.com.
• "Ontario Births, 1869–1912: Alexandria, Glengarry". FamilySearch. Toronto, Canada: Archives of Ontario. 6 June 1887. p. 291. No. 27 (032768). Retrieved 23 September 2019.
• "Ontario Births, 1869–1912: Prescott, Grenville". FamilySearch. Toronto, Canada: Archives of Ontario. 3 October 1891. p. 272. No. 21 (022985). Retrieved 23 September 2019.
• "Ontario Marriages, 1869–1927: Perth, Lanark — McDonald, McPhaul". FamilySearch. Toronto, Canada: Archives of Ontario. 23 August 1886. p. 577. No. 37 (006045). Retrieved 23 September 2019.
• "Ontario Marriages, 1869–1927: Prescott, Grenville — Langstaff, McDonald". FamilySearch. Toronto, Canada: Archives of Ontario. 21 November 1904. pp. 171–172. No. 011701. Retrieved 23 September 2019.
• "Quebec Bar Votes to Admit Women Council Lining Up 12–11 on Issue (pt. 1)". The Gazette. Montreal, Quebec, Canada. 3 March 1941. p. 1. Retrieved 25 September 2019 – via Newspapers.com. and "Quebec Bar Votes for Women to Join (pt. 2)". The Gazette. Montreal, Quebec, Canada. 3 March 1941. p. 11. Retrieved 25 September 2019 – via Newspapers.com.
• "Quebec Declines to License Woman Lawyer". Nanaimo Daily News. Nanaimo, British Columbia, Canada. 4 November 1915. p. 3. Retrieved 25 September 2019 – via Newspapers.com.
• . McGill University. Montreal, Quebec: McGill University Faculty of Law. 2020. Archived from the original on 28 September 2019. Retrieved 15 January 2020.
• "Was Killed in Action". The Gazette. Montreal, Quebec, Canada. 5 January 1916. p. 3. Retrieved 23 September 2019 – via Newspapers.com.
• "Women and the Bar". The StarPhoenix. Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, Canada. 20 February 1915. p. 4. Retrieved 25 September 2019 – via Newspapers.com.

External links

• "First Woman to Graduate from Law in Québec… A Prescott High School Grad"|The Past Around Us Blog