Working Commission to Investigate the Use of Psychiatry for Political Purposes
October 20, 2023
The Working Commission to Investigate the Use of Psychiatry for Political Purposes (Russian: Рабо́чая коми́ссия по рассле́дованию испо́льзования психиатри́и в полити́ческих це́лях) was an offshoot of the Moscow Helsinki Group[1][2] and a key source of information on psychiatric repression in the Soviet Union.[3]
The Working Commission to Investigate the Use of Psychiatry for Political Purposes
Рабочая комиссия по расследованию использования психиатрии в политических целях
The commission was established on 5 January 1977 on the initiative of Alexandr Podrabinek[4] along with a 47-year-old self-educated worker Feliks Serebrov, a 30-year-old computer programmer Vyacheslav Bakhmin and Irina Kuplun[5]: 148 and was composed of five open members and several anonymous ones, including a few psychiatrists who, at great danger to themselves, conducted their own independent examinations of cases of alleged psychiatric abuse.[6] The leader of the commission was Alexandr Podrabinek who published a book Punitive Medicine[6] containing a ‘white list’ of two hundred of prisoners of conscience in Soviet mental hospitals and a ‘black list’ of over one hundred medical staff and doctors who took part in committing people to psychiatric facilities for political reasons.[7]: 15 The psychiatric consultants to the Commission were Dr Alexander Voloshanovich and Dr Anatoly Koryagin.[8]: 153
Investigating activitiesEdit
The task stated by the Commission was not primarily to diagnose persons or to declare people who sought help mentally ill or mentally healthy.[5]: 150 [9]: 26 However, in some instances individuals who came for help to the Commission were examined by a psychiatrist who provided help to the Commission and made a precise diagnosis of their mental condition.[5]: 150 [9]: 26 At first it was psychiatrist Aleksandr Voloshanovich from the Moscow suburb of Dolgoprudny, who made these diagnoses.[5]: 150 But when he had been compelled to emigrate on 7 February 1980,[10] his work was continued by the Kharkov psychiatrist Anatoly Koryagin.[5]: 150 Koryagin's contribution was to examine former and potential victims of political abuse of psychiatry by writing psychiatric diagnoses in which he deduced that the individual was not suffering from any mental disease.[5]: 179 Those reports were employed as a means of defense: if the individual was picked up again and committed to mental hospital, the Commission had vindication that the hospitalization served non-medical purposes.[5]: 179 Also some foreign psychiatrists including the Swedish psychiatrist Harald Blomberg and British psychiatrist Gery Low-Beer helped in examining former or potential victims of psychiatric abuse.[5]: 150 The Commission used those reports in its work and publicly referred to them when it was essential.[5]: 150
The commission gathered as much information as possible of victims of psychiatric terror in the Soviet Union and published this information in their Information Bulletins.[11]: 45 For the four years of its existence, the Commission published more than 1,500 pages of documentation including 22 Information Bulletins in which over 400 cases of the political abuse of psychiatry were documented in great detail.[5]: 148 Summaries of the Information Bulletins were published in the key samizdat publication, A Chronicle of Current Events.[5]: 148 The Information Bulletins were sent to the Soviet officials, with request to verify the data and notify the Commission if mistakes were found, and to the West, where human rights defenders used them in the course of their campaigns.[5]: 148 The Information Bulletins were also used to provide the dissident movement with information about Western protests against the political abuse.[5]: 148 The Working Commission also gathered information about relevant international events and published reports on the Honolulu Congress of the World Psychiatric Association, including the texts of the key resolutions, and printed translations of long letters by Professor Peter Berner about the course of establishing the Review Committee on abuse.[12]: 81
Foreign reactionsEdit
Over fifty victims examined by psychiatrists of the Moscow Working Commission between 1977 and 1981 and the files smuggled to the West by Vladimir Bukovsky in 1971 were the material which convinced most psychiatric associations that there was distinctly something wrong in the USSR.[11]: 245 Peter Reddaway said that after he had studied official documents in the Soviet archives, including minutes from meetings of the Politburo of the Central Committee of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union, it became evident to him that Soviet officials at high levels paid close attention to foreign responses to these cases, and if someone was discharged, all dissidents felt the pressure had played a significant part and the more foreign pressure the better.[13] In the autumn of 1978, the British Royal College of Psychiatrists carried a resolution in which it reiterated its concern over the abuse of psychiatry for the suppression of dissent in the USSR and applauded the Soviet citizens, who had taken an open stance against such abuse, by expressing its admiration and support especially for Semyon Gluzman, Alexander Podrabinek, Alexander Voloshanovich, and Vladimir Moskalkov.[14]
Forcing shutdownEdit
Members of the Working Commission have been stifled through exile and imprisonment.[15] All of its members were arrested or forced to emigrate.[16] The Working Commission ceased to exist on 21 July 1981 when its last member Feliks Serebrov was sentenced to 5 years of camps and 5 years of exile.[17] Prior to that, members of the Working Commission were arrested and sentenced to various terms of imprisonment and exile: Alexander Podrabinek was sentenced to 3 years of imprisonment (convicted for the second time), Vyacheslav Bakhmin was sentenced to 3 years of imprisonment, Leonard Ternovsky was sentenced to 3 years of imprisonment, Irina Grivnina was sentenced to 5 years of exile, and Anatoly Koryagin was sentenced to particularly severe punishment under Part 1 of Article of 70 the RSFSR Criminal Code, 7 years in prison camps and 5 years of subsequent exile.[17] The charge was anti-Soviet activities for having corresponded with the British medical journal The Lancet, which published an article by Koryagin critical of the Soviet government's use of involuntary psychiatric confinement for political reasons.[18] On 5 April 1981, the Moscow Helsinki Group members Yelena Bonner, Sofiya Kalistratova, Ivan Kovalyov, Naum Meiman issued document No. 162 "The Arrest of Anatoly Koryagin" which stated,[19][20]
The arrest of Koryagin puts a definite end to the humane and legal activity of the Working Commission to Investigate the Use of Psychiatry for Political Purposes, and gives rise to the fear that the authorities intend to increase their use of psychiatric persecution for political reasons.
^Burns, John (26 July 1981). "Moscow silencing psychiatry critics". The New York Times.
^Алексеева, Людмила (2013) [1979]. "Путеводитель по аду психиатрических тюрем" [The guidebook to the hell of psychiatric prisons]. Kontinent (in Russian) (152).
^Miku, Natalya; Molkin, Alexey (2015). Консультант правозащитной ассоциации "Рабочей комиссии по расследованию использования психиатрии в политических целях"—врач-психиатр А.А. Волошанович [The consultant of human rights association "The Working Commission on Investigation of Use of Psychiatry in Political Goals "—Psychiatrist A.A. Voloshanovich]. Современные научные исследования и инновации [Modern Scientific Studies and Innovations] (in Russian) (3).
^ abcdefghijklmVoren, Robert van (2010). Cold War in psychiatry: human factors, secret actors. Amsterdam—New York: Rodopi. ISBN978-90-420-3046-6.
^ ab"The spread of Soviet suppression". New Scientist. 78 (1104): 493. 25 May 1978.
^Brintlinger, Angela; Vinitsky, Ilya (2007). Madness and the mad in Russian culture. University of Toronto Press. ISBN978-0-8020-9140-6.
^Medicine betrayed: the participation of doctors in human rights abuses. Zed Books. 1992. p. 153. ISBN1-85649-104-8.
^"Dr Alexander Voloshanovich: A critic of the political misuse of psychiatry in the USSR". Psychiatric Bulletin. 4 (5): 70–71. 1 May 1980. doi:10.1192/pb.4.5.70.
^ abVoren, Robert van (2009). On dissidents and madness: from the Soviet Union of Leonid Brezhnev to the "Soviet Union" of Vladimir Putin. Amsterdam—New York: Rodopi. ISBN978-90-420-2585-1.
^Bloch, Sidney; Reddaway, Peter (1985). Soviet psychiatric abuse: the shadow over world psychiatry. Westview Press. p. 81. ISBN0-8133-0209-9.
^Moran, Mark (19 November 2010). "Former Soviet dissidents believed APA pressure forced change". Psychiatric News. 45 (22): 11. doi:10.1176/pn.45.22.psychnews_45_22_023.
^White, Sarah (5 May 1983). "Carry on protesting for Soviet refusniks! Sarah White on academic boycotts and human rights in the USSR". New Scientist. 98 (1356): 321–322. ISSN 0262-4079.
^ abBonner, Yelena; Kalistratova, Sofiya; Kovalyov, Ivan (29 July 1981). Документ № 176. Осуждение последнего члена Рабочей Комиссии по расследованию использования психиатрии в политических целях Феликса Сереброва [Document Nr 176. The conviction of Feliks Serebrov, the last member of the Working Commission to Investigate the Use of Psychiatry for Political Purposes] (in Russian). Moscow Helsinki Group.
^Wynn, Alan (22 January 1983). "Imprisonment of Dr. Anatoly Koryagin". British Medical Journal. 286 (6361): 309. doi:10.1136/bmj.286.6361.309-a. PMC1546518. PMID 6402080.
^Bonner, Yelena; Kalistratova, Sofiya; Kovalyov, Ivan; Meiman, Naum (5 April 1981). Документ № 162: Арест Анатолия Корягина [Document Nr 162. The Arrest of Anatoly Koryagin] (in Russian). Moscow Helsinki Group. from the original on 2 June 2010.
"Persecution of the Working Commission (on Psychiatric Abuse)" (PDF). A Chronicle of Current Events. London: Amnesty International Publications (59, 60, 61): 131–139. 1982. (PDF) from the original on 4 July 2015.
working, commission, investigate, psychiatry, political, purposes, russian, Рабо, чая, коми, ссия, по, рассле, дованию, испо, льзования, психиатри, полити, ческих, це, лях, offshoot, moscow, helsinki, group, source, information, psychiatric, repression, soviet. The Working Commission to Investigate the Use of Psychiatry for Political Purposes Russian Rabo chaya komi ssiya po rassle dovaniyu ispo lzovaniya psihiatri i v politi cheskih ce lyah was an offshoot of the Moscow Helsinki Group 1 2 and a key source of information on psychiatric repression in the Soviet Union 3 The Working Commission to Investigate the Use of Psychiatry for Political PurposesRabochaya komissiya po rassledovaniyu ispolzovaniya psihiatrii v politicheskih celyahFormation5 January 1977 1977 01 05 FounderAlexandr PodrabinekDissolved21 July 1981 42 years ago 1981 07 21 TypeNon profitNGOHeadquartersMoscow RussiaFieldsPsychiatryLeaderAlexandr PodrabinekPublicationInformation Bulletin A Chronicle of Current EventsParent organizationMoscow Helsinki GroupAnatoly Koryagin b 1938 a psychiatrist expert of the Working Commission Contents 1 Private staff 2 Investigating activities 3 Foreign reactions 4 Forcing shutdown 5 References 6 Further readingPrivate staff EditThe commission was established on 5 January 1977 on the initiative of Alexandr Podrabinek 4 along with a 47 year old self educated worker Feliks Serebrov a 30 year old computer programmer Vyacheslav Bakhmin and Irina Kuplun 5 148 and was composed of five open members and several anonymous ones including a few psychiatrists who at great danger to themselves conducted their own independent examinations of cases of alleged psychiatric abuse 6 The leader of the commission was Alexandr Podrabinek who published a book Punitive Medicine 6 containing a white list of two hundred of prisoners of conscience in Soviet mental hospitals and a black list of over one hundred medical staff and doctors who took part in committing people to psychiatric facilities for political reasons 7 15 The psychiatric consultants to the Commission were Dr Alexander Voloshanovich and Dr Anatoly Koryagin 8 153 Investigating activities EditThe task stated by the Commission was not primarily to diagnose persons or to declare people who sought help mentally ill or mentally healthy 5 150 9 26 However in some instances individuals who came for help to the Commission were examined by a psychiatrist who provided help to the Commission and made a precise diagnosis of their mental condition 5 150 9 26 At first it was psychiatrist Aleksandr Voloshanovich from the Moscow suburb of Dolgoprudny who made these diagnoses 5 150 But when he had been compelled to emigrate on 7 February 1980 10 his work was continued by the Kharkov psychiatrist Anatoly Koryagin 5 150 Koryagin s contribution was to examine former and potential victims of political abuse of psychiatry by writing psychiatric diagnoses in which he deduced that the individual was not suffering from any mental disease 5 179 Those reports were employed as a means of defense if the individual was picked up again and committed to mental hospital the Commission had vindication that the hospitalization served non medical purposes 5 179 Also some foreign psychiatrists including the Swedish psychiatrist Harald Blomberg and British psychiatrist Gery Low Beer helped in examining former or potential victims of psychiatric abuse 5 150 The Commission used those reports in its work and publicly referred to them when it was essential 5 150 The commission gathered as much information as possible of victims of psychiatric terror in the Soviet Union and published this information in their Information Bulletins 11 45 For the four years of its existence the Commission published more than 1 500 pages of documentation including 22 Information Bulletins in which over 400 cases of the political abuse of psychiatry were documented in great detail 5 148 Summaries of the Information Bulletins were published in the key samizdat publication A Chronicle of Current Events 5 148 The Information Bulletins were sent to the Soviet officials with request to verify the data and notify the Commission if mistakes were found and to the West where human rights defenders used them in the course of their campaigns 5 148 The Information Bulletins were also used to provide the dissident movement with information about Western protests against the political abuse 5 148 The Working Commission also gathered information about relevant international events and published reports on the Honolulu Congress of the World Psychiatric Association including the texts of the key resolutions and printed translations of long letters by Professor Peter Berner about the course of establishing the Review Committee on abuse 12 81 Foreign reactions EditOver fifty victims examined by psychiatrists of the Moscow Working Commission between 1977 and 1981 and the files smuggled to the West by Vladimir Bukovsky in 1971 were the material which convinced most psychiatric associations that there was distinctly something wrong in the USSR 11 245 Peter Reddaway said that after he had studied official documents in the Soviet archives including minutes from meetings of the Politburo of the Central Committee of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union it became evident to him that Soviet officials at high levels paid close attention to foreign responses to these cases and if someone was discharged all dissidents felt the pressure had played a significant part and the more foreign pressure the better 13 In the autumn of 1978 the British Royal College of Psychiatrists carried a resolution in which it reiterated its concern over the abuse of psychiatry for the suppression of dissent in the USSR and applauded the Soviet citizens who had taken an open stance against such abuse by expressing its admiration and support especially for Semyon Gluzman Alexander Podrabinek Alexander Voloshanovich and Vladimir Moskalkov 14 Forcing shutdown EditMembers of the Working Commission have been stifled through exile and imprisonment 15 All of its members were arrested or forced to emigrate 16 The Working Commission ceased to exist on 21 July 1981 when its last member Feliks Serebrov was sentenced to 5 years of camps and 5 years of exile 17 Prior to that members of the Working Commission were arrested and sentenced to various terms of imprisonment and exile Alexander Podrabinek was sentenced to 3 years of imprisonment convicted for the second time Vyacheslav Bakhmin was sentenced to 3 years of imprisonment Leonard Ternovsky was sentenced to 3 years of imprisonment Irina Grivnina was sentenced to 5 years of exile and Anatoly Koryagin was sentenced to particularly severe punishment under Part 1 of Article of 70 the RSFSR Criminal Code 7 years in prison camps and 5 years of subsequent exile 17 The charge was anti Soviet activities for having corresponded with the British medical journal The Lancet which published an article by Koryagin critical of the Soviet government s use of involuntary psychiatric confinement for political reasons 18 On 5 April 1981 the Moscow Helsinki Group members Yelena Bonner Sofiya Kalistratova Ivan Kovalyov Naum Meiman issued document No 162 The Arrest of Anatoly Koryagin which stated 19 20 The arrest of Koryagin puts a definite end to the humane and legal activity of the Working Commission to Investigate the Use of Psychiatry for Political Purposes and gives rise to the fear that the authorities intend to increase their use of psychiatric persecution for political reasons References Edit Reddaway Peter 23 February 1978 More psychiatric terror The New York Review of Books Burns John 26 July 1981 Moscow silencing psychiatry critics The New York Times Alekseeva Lyudmila 2013 1979 Putevoditel po adu psihiatricheskih tyurem The guidebook to the hell of psychiatric prisons Kontinent in Russian 152 Miku Natalya Molkin Alexey 2015 Konsultant pravozashitnoj associacii Rabochej komissii po rassledovaniyu ispolzovaniya psihiatrii v politicheskih celyah vrach psihiatr A A Voloshanovich The consultant of human rights association The Working Commission on Investigation of Use of Psychiatry in Political Goals Psychiatrist A A Voloshanovich Sovremennye nauchnye issledovaniya i innovacii Modern Scientific Studies and Innovations in Russian 3 a b c d e f g h i j k l m Voren Robert van 2010 Cold War in psychiatry human factors secret actors Amsterdam New York Rodopi ISBN 978 90 420 3046 6 a b The spread of Soviet suppression New Scientist 78 1104 493 25 May 1978 Brintlinger Angela Vinitsky Ilya 2007 Madness and the mad in Russian culture University of Toronto Press ISBN 978 0 8020 9140 6 Medicine betrayed the participation of doctors in human rights abuses Zed Books 1992 p 153 ISBN 1 85649 104 8 a b Voren Robert van Bloch Sidney 1989 Soviet psychiatric abuse in the Gorbachev era International Association on the Political Use of Psychiatry p 26 ISBN 90 72657 01 2 Dr Alexander Voloshanovich A critic of the political misuse of psychiatry in the USSR Psychiatric Bulletin 4 5 70 71 1 May 1980 doi 10 1192 pb 4 5 70 a b Voren Robert van 2009 On dissidents and madness from the Soviet Union of Leonid Brezhnev to the Soviet Union of Vladimir Putin Amsterdam New York Rodopi ISBN 978 90 420 2585 1 Bloch Sidney Reddaway Peter 1985 Soviet psychiatric abuse the shadow over world psychiatry Westview Press p 81 ISBN 0 8133 0209 9 Moran Mark 19 November 2010 Former Soviet dissidents believed APA pressure forced change Psychiatric News 45 22 11 doi 10 1176 pn 45 22 psychnews 45 22 023 Autumn quarterly meeting 1978 Psychiatric Bulletin 3 1 5 7 1 January 1979 doi 10 1192 pb 3 1 5 White Sarah 5 May 1983 Carry on protesting for Soviet refusniks Sarah White on academic boycotts and human rights in the USSR New Scientist 98 1356 321 322 ISSN 0262 4079 Cracraft James 2014 The Soviet Union today an interpretive guide University of Chicago Press p 68 ISBN 978 0226226286 a b Bonner Yelena Kalistratova Sofiya Kovalyov Ivan 29 July 1981 Dokument 176 Osuzhdenie poslednego chlena Rabochej Komissii po rassledovaniyu ispolzovaniya psihiatrii v politicheskih celyah Feliksa Serebrova Document Nr 176 The conviction of Feliks Serebrov the last member of the Working Commission to Investigate the Use of Psychiatry for Political Purposes in Russian Moscow Helsinki Group Wynn Alan 22 January 1983 Imprisonment of Dr Anatoly Koryagin British Medical Journal 286 6361 309 doi 10 1136 bmj 286 6361 309 a PMC 1546518 PMID 6402080 Bonner Yelena Kalistratova Sofiya Kovalyov Ivan Meiman Naum 5 April 1981 Dokument 162 Arest Anatoliya Koryagina Document Nr 162 The Arrest of Anatoly Koryagin in Russian Moscow Helsinki Group Archived from the original on 2 June 2010 The trial of Koryagin PDF A Chronicle of Current Events Amnesty International Publications 62 19 26 1982 Further reading Edit Persecution of the Working Commission on Psychiatric Abuse PDF A Chronicle of Current Events London Amnesty International Publications 59 60 61 131 139 1982 Archived PDF from the original on 4 July 2015 Portals nbsp Psychiatry nbsp Soviet Union nbsp Law Retrieved from https en wikipedia org w index php title Working Commission to Investigate the Use of Psychiatry for Political Purposes amp oldid 1175447373, wikipedia, wiki, book, books, library,
