Wadley loop

The "Wadley-drift-canceling-loop", also known as a "Wadley loop", is a system of two oscillators, a frequency synthesizer, and two frequency mixers in the radio-frequency signal path. The system was designed by Dr. Trevor Wadley in the 1940s in South Africa. The circuit was first used for a stable wavemeter. (A wavemeter is used for measuring the wavelength and therefore also the frequency of a signal)

The radio receiver Yaesu FRG-7000 uses the "Wadley loop".^[1]

XCR-30

There is no regulation loop in a "Wadley-loop", which is why the term is in quotation marks. However, the circuit configuration is not known by more accurate names.^[2]

The "Wadley loop" was used in radio receivers from the 1950s to approximately 1980. The "Wadley loop" was mostly used in more expensive stationary radio receivers, but the "Wadley loop" was also used in a portable radio receiver (Barlow-Wadley XCR-30 Mark II).^[3][4]

Overview

In a traditional superheterodyne radio receiver, most oscillator drift and instability occur in the first frequency converter stage because it is tunable and operating at a high frequency.

Unlike other drift-reducing techniques (such as crystal control or frequency synthesis), the Wadley Loop does not attempt to stabilize the oscillator. Instead, it cancels the drift mathematically.

Principles of operation

 

Oscillator drift cancellation circuit - Wadley loop

The Wadley loop works by:

1. combining the first oscillator with the received signal in a frequency mixer to translate it to an intermediate frequency that is above the receiver's tuning range,
2. mixing the same oscillator with a comb of harmonics from a crystal oscillator,
3. selecting one of the results of (2) with a band-pass filter, and
4. mixing this with the IF signal from (1).

Since the high-IF of part 1 drifts in the same direction and the same amount as the "synthetic oscillator" of part 3, when they are mixed in part 4, the drift terms cancel out and the result is a crystal-stable signal at a second intermediate frequency.

However, the drift makes it impossible to use high-IF selectivity to reject undesired signals. Instead, the high IF is designed with a band-pass characteristic. Also, since the first oscillator is cancelled out, it cannot be used to tune a particular signal. Instead, it selects an entire band of signals - which one depends on which harmonic was chosen in part 3 above. The size of the band is equal to the spacing of the crystal harmonics. A conventionally tuned "back end" selects the desired signal from the band of signals presented at the second IF.

Example

An example would be picking up signals from 0 to 30 MHz. This is divided into 30 1 MHz bands, which are then translated to a band at 44-45 MHz. To convert 0-1 MHz, the first oscillator must be 45 MHz; to convert 1-2 MHz it must be 46 MHz; and so on. Meanwhile, the first oscillator is also mixed with harmonics from a 1 MHz crystal and the results pass through a 42 MHz filter. Only one harmonic gets through. When the first oscillator is 45 MHz, it is the third harmonic, because 45 - 3 = 42. At 46 MHz, it is the fourth harmonic, and so on. The oscillator does not have to be exactly 45, 46, and so on, only close enough to get through the 42 MHz band-pass filter. Let's say it is 45.1 . Then we get 42.1 from the filter, and 45.1 - 42.1 is still 3. When the high IF is mixed with the 42 MHz, the result is a band of signals from 3 MHz to 2 MHz, from which the desired signal is selected. This can potentially be accomplished with a conventional superheterodyne back-end converting 3-2 MHz to 455 kHz and finally demodulating the signal back to audio. The overall receiver drift consists of the crystal's drift plus the 3 MHz back-end. When we're listening to a 30 MHz signal, this receiver is about ten times as stable as one using a high-frequency tunable VFO.

To a new user, the feel of the first oscillator tuning control is counterintuitive. Although the knob moves in a continuous, analog fashion, its effect on the receiver operation is discrete, that is, the tuning advances in 1 MHz jumps.

An example is Yaesu's FRG-7 communications receiver,^[5] which uses the system to remove local oscillator drift. The Racal RA17 and Realistic DX-302^[6] also used the Wadley Loop in their design.

An optical implementation of a Wadley Loop has recently been proposed. This allows a compact relatively unstable laser to be used as a local oscillator. The system's stability being obtained from a master 'comb source' (usually a pulsed laser, such as a mode-locked laser), possibly common to many receivers within an exchange.^[7]

Notes

1. radiomuseum.org: Yaesu FRG-7000 Citat: "...Wadley-Loop principle (including dual superhet)..."
2. "The Wadley Loop - A Drift-cancelling Receiver Tuning Principle". February 2017. from the original on 2020-01-30. They, not its creator, call it a loop, but it is no such thing. In order for it to be a loop it must have feedback, which it does not. There is so much misinformation about the circuit I often wonder if people really understand what it is... The Wadley Loop... it's a tuning concept that cancels the drift of one oscillator in the receiver by using it twice in the conversion scheme...
3. radiomuseum.org: Barlow-Wadley XCR-30 Mark II
4. manualslib.com: Barlow-Wadley XCR-30 Mark II
5. The Wadley Drift Cancelling Loop
6. "DX-302 Owner's manual" (PDF). Retrieved 3 February 2018.
7. Lowery, Arthur James; Corcoran, Bill; Zhu, Chen (2015). "Widely-tunable low-phase-noise coherent receiver using an optical Wadley loop". Optics Express. 23 (15): 19891–20700. Bibcode:2015OExpr..2319891L. doi:10.1364/OE.23.019891. PMID 26367649.