Torreón massacre

The Torreón massacre (Spanish: Matanza de chinos de Torreón; Chinese: 菜苑慘案) was a racially motivated massacre that took place on 13–15 May 1911 in the Mexican city of Torreón, Coahuila. Over 300 Asian Mexicans were killed by a local mob and the revolutionary forces of Francisco I. Madero, mostly Chinese Mexicans and some Japanese Mexicans. A large number of Chinese homes and shops were looted and destroyed.

Torreón massacre
Part of the Mexican Revolution
Mexican forces outside the Casino de la Laguna
Location	Torreón, Coahuila
Coordinates	25°32′22″N 103°26′55″W / 25.53944°N 103.44861°W / 25.53944; -103.44861
Date	13–15 May 1911
Target	Asian Mexicans
Attack type	Massacre
Deaths	303 (see Casualties, below)
Perpetrators	Maderistas
No. of participants	4,500
Motive	Ethnic hatred, Sinophobia, Anti-Japanese sentiment

Torreón was the last major city to be taken by the Maderistas during the Mexican Revolution. When the government forces withdrew, the rebels entered the city in the early morning and, along with the local population, began a ten-hour massacre of the Chinese community. The event touched off a diplomatic crisis between Qing China and Mexico, with the former demanding 30 million pesos in reparation. At one point it was rumored that Qing China had even dispatched a warship to Mexican waters (the cruiser Hai Chi, which was anchored in Cuba at the time). An investigation into the massacre concluded that it was an unprovoked act of racism.

Background

Chinese immigration to Mexico began as early as the 17th century, with a number settling in Mexico City, most of whom originated from Taishan, Guangdong, Qing China. Immigration increased when Mexican president Porfirio Díaz attempted to encourage foreign investment and tourism to boost the country's economy. The two countries signed a Treaty of Amity and Commerce in 1899;^[1][2] over time, the Chinese expatriates began to establish profitable businesses such as wholesale and retail groceries. By 1910, there were 13,200 Chinese immigrants in the country, many living in Baja California, Chihuahua, Coahuila, Sinaloa, Sonora, and Yucatán.^[2]

Torreón was an attractive destination for immigrants at the turn of the nineteenth century. It was located at the intersection of two major railroads (the Mexican Central Railway and the Mexican International Railroad) and was proximate to the Nazas River, which irrigated the surrounding area, making it a suitable location for growing cotton.^[3] The Chinese probably began to arrive in Torreón during the 1880s or 1890s, at the same time that other immigrants were first recorded as coming to the city.^[4] By about 1900, 500 of the city's 14,000 residents were Chinese. The Chinese community was easily the largest and most notable group of immigrants in the city.^[5] By 1903, it had formed the largest branch of the Baohuanghui (Protect the Emperor Society) in Mexico.^[6]

On October 17, 1903, President Porfirio Diaz set up a commission to look at the impact of Chinese immigration to Mexico. The final 121-page report—published in 1911, written by José María Romero—established that Chinese immigration, whether at an individual or group level, was not to the greater benefit of Mexico.^[7]

 

A portrait of Kang Youwei from 1906 or earlier

Mexico was one of the countries visited by Kang Youwei after his failed Hundred Days' Reform in Qing China. He had recently founded the China Reform Association to restore the Guangxu Emperor to power, and was visiting Chinatowns worldwide to fund the Association.^[4][8] He arrived in 1906, and purchased a few blocks of real estate in Torreón for 1,700 pesos,^[8][9] later reselling it to Chinese immigrants for a profit of 3,400 pesos.^[9] This investment spurred Kang to have the Association establish a bank in Torreón, which began selling stock and real estate to Chinese businessmen. The bank also built the city's first tram line.^[8][9] Kang visited Torreón again in 1907.^[8][9] It has been suggested that the city served as a test case for Chinese immigration to Mexico and Brazil, which Kang believed might solve overpopulation problems in the Pearl River Delta, Guangdong.^[10] Soon there were 600 Chinese living in the city.^[1][11]

In 1907, a number of Mexican businessman gathered to form a chamber of commerce to protect their businesses from the foreigners. Instead of targeting Chinese specifically, they wrote:

We cannot compete against the foreigners in commercial ventures. The sad and lamentable fact is that the prostration of our national commerce has created a situation in which Mexicans are replaced by foreign individuals and companies, which monopolize our commerce and behave in the manner of conquerors in a conquered land.

— El Nuevo Mundo^[9]

Tensions and resentment of the Chinese ran high among the Mexican populace of Torreón, stemming from the immigrants' prosperity and monopoly over the grocery trade.^[12] Nationwide resentment of the Chinese has also, conversely, been attributed to the fact that the Chinese represented a source of cheap-labor which was central to the Porfirian economic program. Therefore, opposing the Chinese was an indirect way to oppose the dictatorship.^[6]

Anti-Chinese sentiments were apparent in the Independence Day speeches and demonstrations of 16 September 1910. Over the next several weeks a number of Chinese establishments were vandalized.^[12][13]

Events

Events leading to the massacre

On 5 May 1911 (Cinco de Mayo), a revolutionary leader,^[13] a bricklayer^[14] or stonemason^[13][15] named Jesús C. Flores, made a public speech in nearby Gómez Palacio, Durango, in which he claimed that the Chinese were putting Mexican women out of jobs, had monopolized the gardening and grocery businesses, were accumulating vast amounts of money to send back to China, and were "vying for the affection and companionship of local women." He concluded by demanding that all people of Chinese origin be expelled from Mexico.^[16] One witness recalled him stating "that, therefore, it was necessary... even a patriotic duty, to finish with them."^[17]

The branch of the reform association in Torreón heard of Flores' speech, and on 12 May the society's secretary, Woo Lam Po (also the manager of the bank) circulated a letter in Chinese among the leaders of the community warning that there could be violence:

Brothers, attention! Attention! This is serious. Many unjust acts have happened during the revolution. Notice have [sic] been received that before 10 o'clock today the revolutionists will unite their forces and attack the city. It is very probable that during the battle a mob will spring up and sack the stores. For this reason, we advise all our people, when the crowds assemble, to close your door and hide yourself and under no circumstances open your places for business or go outside to see the fighting. And if any of your stores are broken into, offer no resistance but allow them to take what they please, since otherwise you might endanger your lives. THIS IS IMPORTANT. After the trouble is over we will try to arrange a settlement.^[14][17]

Siege of Torreón

 

The Maderistas enter Torreón on 13 May

On the morning of Saturday, 13 May, the forces of the Mexican Revolution led by Francisco I. Madero's brother Emilio Madero attacked the city.^[18][19] Its railroads made it a key strategic point necessary to seizing complete control of the surrounding region:^[20] it was also the last major city to be targeted by the rebels.^[21] Madero and 4,500 Maderistas surrounded the city, hemming in General Emiliano Lojero [es] and his 670 Federales.^[18][22] They overran the Chinese gardens surrounding the city, killing 112 of the people working there.^[22][23] Chinese houses were used as fortifications for the advancing rebels, and the people living there were forced to prepare them food.^[22] The fighting continued until the Federales began to run low on munitions on Sunday evening. Lojero ordered a retreat, and his forces abandoned the city under cover of darkness between two and four in the morning on Monday, 15 May, during a heavy rainstorm.^{[18][21][22][24]} The retreat was so sudden that some troops were left behind during the evacuation.^[24] Before the rebels entered the city, witnesses reported that xenophobic speeches had been made to incense the accompanying mob against foreigners.^[25] Jesús Flores was present, and made a speech calling the Chinese "dangerous competitors" and concluded "that it would be best to exterminate them."^[24]

Massacre

The rebel forces entered the city at six o'clock, accompanied by a mob of over 4,000 men, women, and children from Gómez Palacio Municipality, Viesca Municipality, San Pedro Municipality, Lerdo Municipality, and Matamoros Municipality.^[18][22] They were joined by citizens of Torreón and began the sacking of the business district. The mob released prisoners from jail, looted stores, and attacked people on the street. They soon moved to the Chinese district. Men on horses drove Chinese from the gardens back into town, dragging them by their queues and shooting or trampling those who fell. Men, women, and children were killed indiscriminately when they fell in the way of the mob, and their bodies were robbed and mutilated.^[18][23] It was reported that "[i]n one instance the head of a Chinaman was severed from his body and thrown from the window into the street. In another instance a soldier took a little boy by the heels and battered his brains out against a lamp post. In many instances ropes were tied to the bodies of the Chinamen and they were dragged through the streets by men on horseback. In another instance a Chinaman was pulled to pieces in the street by horses hitched to his arms and legs."^[25][26] The mob finally reached the bank, where they killed the employees and hurled their severed body parts into the streets.^[27] A contemporary newspaper reported that "heads of the murdered Chinese were rolled along the streets, and their bodies were tied to the tails of horses."^[28]

A number of residents made attempts to save the Chinese from the mob.^[29] Seventy immigrants were saved by a tailor who stood atop the roof of a building where they were hiding and misdirected the mob that was hunting for them. Eleven were saved by Hermina Almaráz, the daughter of a Maderista leader, who told soldiers who wanted to take them from her home "that they could only enter the house over her dead body." Another eight were saved by a second tailor, who stood in the rain in front of the laundry they worked at and lied to the rebels about their presence.^[30]

Ten hours after the massacre had begun, at around four o'clock, Emilio Madero arrived in Torreón on horseback and issued a proclamation decreeing the death penalty for anyone who killed a Chinese. This ended the massacre.^[27]

After the massacre

Madero collected the surviving Chinese in a building and posted a hand-picked group of soldiers to protect them.^[29] Dead Mexicans were buried in the city's cemetery, but the bodies of the slain Chinese were stripped naked and buried together in a trench.^[29]

The same day as the massacre, Madero convened a military tribunal to hear testimony about the killings. The tribunal came to the conclusion that the Maderistas had "committed atrocities", but the soldiers defended themselves by asserting that the Chinese had been armed and the massacre was an act of self-defense.^[31]

Both the United States Consulate and the local Relief Committee began collecting donations from locals to support the Chinese. Between 17 May and 1 June, Dr. J. Lim and the Relief Committee collected more than $6,000, which they distributed at a rate of $30 per day to provide food and shelter for the survivors.^[29]

Aftermath

Events following the massacre

After the massacre, large numbers of Chinese fled Torreón, with El Imparcial, a daily newspaper in Mexico City, reporting that over 1,000 people were on the move. Chinese began to arrive in Guadalajara seeking passage back to China.^[29]

Property stolen from Torreón continued to appear on the black market in San Pedro for several months following the massacre and looting.^[32]

Casualties

 

A cart carrying bodies in the aftermath of the slaughter

308 Asians were killed in the massacre; 303 Chinese and 5 Japanese.^[33][34] According to the British Vice Consul in Gómez Palacio, the Japanese were killed "owing to the similarity of features" with the Chinese.^[23][27] It is estimated that the dead made up nearly one-half of the Chinese population.^[26][33]

Among the dead were 50 employees of Sam Wah, both from his estate and his restaurant; Wong Foon Chuck lost 45 employees: 32 from his estate, nine from a railroad hotel that he operated, and four from his laundry; and Ma Due lost 38 out of the 40 workers from his gardens.^[35] 25 employees of the bank were also killed.^[28]

Rebels, Federales, and bystanders were also killed;^[32] according to contemporary reports, these included 25 Federales, 34 bystanders (including 12 Spaniards and a German),^[36] and 26 Maderistas.^[37] Among the dead was Jesús Flores,^[32] apparently killed while attempting to free a machine gun abandoned by the government forces.^[37]

Property damage

One estimate put the total damage at around US$1,000,000 (equivalent to $31,407,143 in 2022).^[25] Chinese properties were dealt US$849,928.69 ($26,693,832) in damage.^[13] Among the businesses destroyed were the bank, the Chinese Club, 40 groceries, five restaurants, four laundries, 10 vegetable stands and 23 other food stands.^[27] Almost 100 Chinese homes and businesses were destroyed in total.^[38] Also destroyed were a number of the Chinese-owned gardens outside of town.^[27] In addition to businesses and commercial establishments, an unknown number of residential buildings were robbed and destroyed.^[39] An American consular agent named G. C. Carothers described the destruction in a June 7 report on the massacre:

Next we went to the Chinese Laundry were four had been killed, and the laundry practically demolished. Bombs had been thrown on the roof, the windows and doors either destroyed or stolen, the machinery broken to pieces and everything that could be carted away, stolen.... The Puerto de Shanghai building was next visited. All of the doors and windows of the building were destroyed. The Chinese Bank, which had been moved into this building a few months before, was demolished, safes blown open and contents taken, furniture destroyed, all papers and valuables stolen.^[26]

American, Arabian, German, Spanish, and Turkish establishments were also damaged and destroyed,^[27] but in contrast to the Chinese, U.S. properties were only dealt US$22,000 ($690,957 today) in damage.^[32]

Other properties destroyed included a casino, the city courthouse,^[32] the jail, the police headquarters, the Inferior Court, the Court of Letters, and the Municipal Treasury.^[22]

Response

 

Lebbeus R. Wilfley

A month afterward, the Qing China hired American attorney Lebbeus Wilfley to conduct an investigation into the massacre. Wilfley owned a law firm in Mexico City, and had previously served as the Judge of the United States Court in China. In June he dispatched his partner, Arthur Bassett, to carry out the investigation.^[31]

The same month, Qing China demanded reparation from Mexico, seeking a payment 100,000 pesos (in 1911 money) for each Chinese killed during the massacre, a total of over thirty million.^[40] Qing China also demanded an official apology from the Mexican government.^[28]

 

The Hai Chi in 1911

This was followed by a diplomatic crisis, when a rumor began to circulate that Qing China had dispatched a warship carrying investigators to Mexican waters.^[28][38][41] The U.S. Ambassador to Mexico, Henry Lane Wilson, sent a telegram to Philander C. Knox, the Secretary of State, claiming that the Chinese gunboat Korea was en route for Mexico. Yuan Kwai, a Counselor at the Chinese embassy in the U.S., sought the support of the United States Department of State. He was told that the U.S. would not approve the act, but would not make an attempt to halt it, either. Failing to get support from the U.S., China announced that the rumor was false. Yuan Kwai stated that the cruiser Hai Chi might dock in Mexico after attending the coronation of George V in London. In the event, the Hai Chi docked in Cuba after visiting the United States and halted there while the diplomatic crisis played out, and did not go on to Mexico.^[41]

In July, U.S. consul George Carothers reported that a number of foreigners in Torreón had received letters telling them to leave the city.^[42]

Madero had ordered that the soldiers culpable for the killings be arrested and put on trial, and by 9 July, 20 of the 35 under suspicion of connection with the massacre had been captured.^[43]

Arthur Bassett made his report to Chang Yin Tang, the Chinese Minister to Mexico, on 13 July, after conducting interviews with a number of Chinese and Mexican witnesses to the massacre. He concluded that the Maderistas' claims (that they had been fired on by the Chinese) were false, citing the 12 May circular by the reform society. He also dismissed the claim that the immigrants had been armed by General Lojero and his retreating Federales, pointing out that the reason for the evacuation was a dearth of ammunition. Furthermore, no witnesses reported any form of resistance by the Chinese. In his report, he called the incident "an unprovoked massacre... conceived in malice and race hatred" and concluded that it was a clear violation of the 1899 treaty between the two countries.^[44]

Bassett, in collaboration with Owang King (a representative for China) and Antonio Ramos Pedrueza (representing Mexican President Francisco León de la Barra), tendered a second report to Chang on 28 August, once again attempting to assess whether the Chinese themselves had prompted the massacre by resisting the Madistera troops.^[44] The editor of Diogenes, a local paper, stated that Lojero had "authorized him to deny all allegations" that he may have armed the Chinese. Upon further inquiry, the owners of local stores testified that they had not sold weapons to Chinese patrons before the massacre. The report concluded:

The contention that the Chinese offered resistance is pure fabrication, invented by the officers of the revolutionary army for the sole purpose of escaping the punishment which the commission of such a heinous crime would naturally entail upon them.^[40]

After failing to gain support from the United States, Qing China reduced the demanded indemnity from thirty million to six million. However, it continued to demand an official apology, a guarantee of the safety of Chinese citizens in Mexico, and the punishment of the soldiers responsible for the massacre.^[43]

As the 1911 Mexican Independence Day approached, the foreign community in Torreón became restless, remembering the violence that had broken out at that time the previous year. To prevent another outbreak of violence, Francisco Madero sent 1,000 troops to the city.^[31]

Qing China was overthrown in the Xinhai Revolution. Its successor, the Republic of China (ROC) came to an agreement with Mexico in November 1912, and a treaty was signed wherein Mexico granted 3,100,000 pesos in damages to ROC and extended an official apology. The deadline for payment was later extended to 15 February 1913.^[45] However, after the February 1913 assassination of Francisco Madero, Mexico entered a period of economic collapse. They proposed to pay ROC in bonds. The Dutch ambassador warned against it, believing that Mexico would be unable to obtain the foreign loans necessary for payment.^[46]

The Mexican Senate debated a number of ways to pay the indemnity through 1912 and 1913, including considering payment in silver. However, the bonds were never approved, and reparation was never made.^[46]

In 2021, 110 years later, then-president of Mexico López Obrador apologized for his country's role in massacre.^[47][48]

Further unrest

The massacre in Torreón was not the only instance of race violence against the Chinese during the revolution. In the first year alone, rebels and other Mexican citizens contributed to the deaths of some 324 Chinese. By 1919, another 129 had been killed in Mexico City, and 373 in Piedras Negras.^[25] The persecution and violence against the Chinese in Mexico finally culminated in 1931, with the expulsion of the remaining Chinese from Sonora.^[49]

See also

• Chinese Mexican
• Chinese Exclusion Act
• Anti-Chinese violence in Oregon
• Anti-Chinese violence in California
• Anti-Chinese violence in Washington
• Chinese Massacre of 1871 (Los Angeles)
• San Francisco riot of 1877
• Rock Springs massacre, 1885
• Attack on Squak Valley Chinese laborers, 1885
• Tacoma riot of 1885
• Seattle riot of 1886
• Hells Canyon massacre, 1887
• 2021 Atlanta spa shootings
• List of massacres in Mexico
• List of ethnic riots

Notes

1. Schwartz (1998) p. 59
2. Jacques (1974) p. 234
3. Lai & Chee-Beng (2010) p. 83
4. Lai & Chee-Beng (2010) p. 85
5. Lai & Chee-Beng (2010) p. 84
6. Schwartz (1998) p. 57
7. Julian Herbert (24 April 2019), "The Roots of a Forgotten Massacre", The Paris Review, retrieved 23 August 2019
8. Jacques (1974) pp. 234—236
9. Lai & Chee-Beng (2010) p. 86
10. Schwartz (1998) p. 60
11. Jacques (1974) p. 236
12. Jacques (1974) pp. 236–237
13. Romero (2010) p. 149
14. Lai & Chee-Beng (2010) p. 87
15. Young (2014) p. 201
16. Jacques (1974) p. 237
17. Romero (2010) p. 150
18. Jaques (1974) p. 238
19. Romero (2010) pp. 150–151
20. Jacques (1974) p. 233
21. Lai & Chee-Beng (2010) p. 82
22. Romero (2010) p. 151
23. Lai & Chee-Beng (2010) p. 88
24. Knight (1986) p. 207
25. Delgado (2012) p. 105
26. Romero (2010) p. 152
27. Jacques (1974) p. 239
28. "Mexico and China: The Torreon Massacre". The Sydney Morning Herald. 12 June 1911. Retrieved 2 December 2014 – via Trove.
29. Jacques (1974) p. 240
30. Romero (2010) pp. 153–154
31. Jacques (1974) p. 241
32. Knight (1986) p. 208
33. Delgado (2012) p. 104
34. Romero (2010) p. 148
35. Jacques (1947) pp. 239–240
36. "Chinese Slain By Mob In Mexico". The Spokesman-Review. Spokane, Washington. 26 May 1911. p. 6. Retrieved 4 January 2015 – via Google News Archive.
37. "Foreign Powers May Become Involved In Revolution: Massacre At Torron Cause" (PDF). East Oregonian. Vol. 24, no. 7220. Pendleton, Oregon. 23 May 1911. Retrieved 4 January 2015 – via University of Oregon.
38. "China and Mexico". The Journal of Education. 22 June 1911. p. 705. JSTOR 42818569.
39. Romero (2010) pp. 151–152
40. Jacques (1974) p. 243
41. Jacques (1974) pp. 243–244
42. Jacques (1974) pp. 240–241
43. Jacques (1974) p. 244
44. Jacques (1974) p. 242
45. Jacques (1974) pp. 244–245
46. Jacques (1974) p. 245
47. . Associated Press. 18 May 2021. Archived from the original on 17 May 2021 – via ABC News.
48. "Mexican president apologizes for 1911 massacre of Chinese". The Washington Post.
49. Reejhsinghani, Anju (Spring 2014). "Emerging Transnational Scholarship: Chinese Mexicans in China, Mexico, and the United States-Mexico Borderlands". Journal of American Ethnic History. 33 (3): 79. doi:10.5406/jamerethnhist.33.3.0077. JSTOR 10.5406/jamerethnhist.33.3.0077.

References

• Delgado, Grace Peña (2012). Making the Chinese Mexican: Global Migration, Localism, and Exclusion in the U.S.-Mexico Borderlands. Stanford, California: Stanford University Press. ISBN 978-0-8047-7814-5.
• Jacques, Leo M. Dambourges (Autumn 1974). "The Chinese Massacre in Torreon (Coahuila) in 1911". Arizona and the West. University of Arizona Press. 16 (3): 233–246. JSTOR 40168453.
• Knight, Alan (1986). The Mexican Revolution. United States: Cambridge University Press. ISBN 0-8032-7772-5.
• Lai, Walton Look; Chee-Beng, Tan, eds. (2010). The Chinese in Latin America and the Caribbean. Leiden, The Netherlands: Koninklijke Brill NV. ISBN 978-90-04-18213-4.
• Romero, Robert Chao (2010). The Chinese in Mexico, 1882–1940. Tucson, Arizona: University of Arizona Press. ISBN 978-0-8165-2772-4.
• Schwartz, Larissa N. (1998). ""The Inconveniences Resulting From Race Mixture": The Torreón Massacre of 1911". In Hom, Marlon K.; Hsu, Madeline; McCunn, Ruthanne Lum; Lai, Him Mark; Leung, Vitas; Louie, Lillian; McClain, Laurene Wu (eds.). Chinese America: History and Perspectives, 1998. Brisbane, California: Fong Brothers Printing. ISBN 1-885864-07-8.
• Young, Elliott (2014). Alien Nation: Chinese Migration in the Americas from the Coolie Era through World War II. Chapel Hill, North Carolina: University of North Carolina Press. ISBN 978-1-4696-1296-6.
• Mexico faces up to uneasy anniversary of Chinese massacre, theguardian.com, 16 May 2021

External links

 

Wikimedia Commons has media related to Torreón massacre.

• Early Documents Related To The Torreón Massacre – Original documents from the time period related to the massacre.
• Una batalla decisiva en Torreón – El Siglo de Torreón (in Spanish)