Tlahuelilpan pipeline explosion

On 18 January 2019, a pipeline transporting gasoline exploded in the town of Tlahuelilpan, in the Mexican state of Hidalgo. The blast killed at least 137 people and injured dozens more. Mexican authorities blamed fuel thieves, who had illegally tapped the pipeline. The explosion was particularly deadly because large crowds of people had gathered at the scene to steal fuel. Security forces tried to persuade people to move away from the scene, but they were outnumbered and asked not to engage with civilians for fear of causing a violent confrontation. The leak was reported at 17:04 CST (23:04 UTC), and the explosion occurred two hours later at 19:10. It took about four hours for responders to extinguish the fire.

Tlahuelilpan pipeline explosion

Date	18 January 2019
Time	17:04 CST (leak reported) / 19:10 CST (explosion)
Location	Tlahuelilpan, Hidalgo, Mexico
Coordinates	20°07′03″N 99°13′10″W / 20.11750°N 99.21944°W / 20.11750; -99.21944
Cause	Fuel-air explosion, caused by illegal tapping into the pipeline
Deaths	137^[1]
Suspects	Huachicoleros
[Interactive fullscreen map + nearby articles]

Background

Fuel theft from pipelines owned by Pemex, the state oil company, has been a long-term problem in Mexico.^[2][3] The problem worsened in the 2010s as organized crime groups in Mexico began including gasoline theft as part of their main streams of revenue. With the international soaring of fuel prices, this criminal activity became a lucrative business for thieves.^[4] Gasoline theft crime groups used bribery and violence to corrupt government officials.^[4] Investigators suspect that several officials within Pemex are involved in facilitating the operations of these criminal groups.^[5] Complicity includes activities such as employees sharing the exact time when the fuel will flow through the pipelines, the maps of the pipelines, and how to successfully perforate them.^[6]

Illegally extracting, possessing, or safeguarding petrochemicals from pipelines, vehicles, equipment, or installations is a federal crime in Mexico and is punishable with up to 20 years in prison.^[7] The gasoline thieves are known in Mexico as huachicoleros,^[2] a name derived from the slang term huachicol, or poor-quality alcohol.^[8] The gasoline they steal is often sold in public at a discounted price.^[5][9] These groups have gained support from impoverished communities because they provide low-cost gasoline and give some locals a venue for employment as fuel carriers and lookouts.^[4] Their supply of illegal fuel is believed to sustain entire communities in some parts of the states of Veracruz, Puebla and Hidalgo, where the explosion occurred.^[10]

By mid-2018, the rate of pipeline perforations had risen considerably to slightly over 40 perforations per day, compared to 28 perforations a day in 2017.^[2] In the first 10 months of 2018, 12,581 illegal perforations were reported across pipelines in Mexico.^[11] The states in Mexico with the highest illegal perforations reported between 2016 and 2018 were Hidalgo, Puebla, Guanajuato, Jalisco, Veracruz, State of Mexico, and Tamaulipas. In 2018, Hidalgo was the state with the most illegal perforations reported with 2,121. In Tlahuelilpan alone, at least 70 illegal perforations were reported from 2016 to the day of the explosion. However, Tula headed the count in the state of Hidalgo with 500 perforations reported in 2018 alone.^[12] As a result of the increase of fuel theft, the federal government has spent approximately US$3 billion a year on pipeline repairs and maintenance, as well as compensation to buyers for whom the product was intended.^[13][14]

When President Andrés Manuel López Obrador took office in December 2018, he launched a campaign against gasoline theft gangs, and dispatched close to 5,000 troops from the Mexican Armed Forces and the Federal Police to guard pipelines across Mexico.^[15] Part of his strategy was to divert the flow of fuel from pipelines, detect leaks when they occurred, and transport the fuel by trucks.^[16] Most of the thieves operate in remote areas, and drill at the pipelines during the night to avoid detection. These measures were intended to stop the thieves from illegally tapping fuel pipes. When implemented, however, the measures led to logistical problems, resulting in fuel shortages and long lines at gas stations nationwide in January 2019.^[4]

Incident

Tlahuelilpan is crossed by one of the country's main fuel pipelines, connecting the port of Tuxpan, Veracruz, with the Pemex complex at Tula, Hidalgo, some 13 kilometres (8 mi) to the southwest of the town.^[17] Reports of residents collecting what appeared to be fuel in the San Primitivo district of the town started circulating on social media during the afternoon of 18 January 2019.^[18][19] A video shot earlier and later uploaded to YouTube showed local residents with buckets, jerrycans and water bottles swarming around a large petrol fountain coming from a rupture in the pipeline;^[17][20] witnesses interviewed later on local television spoke of a crowd numbering in the hundreds, "or perhaps even a thousand".^[21] Other accounts stated that some residents, including children, were jokingly throwing gasoline at each other and horseplaying near the breach zone.^[19] A 911 call to local police reported the leak at 17:04 hours, and the explosion occurred at 19:10 hours.^[22] When first informed of the leak, Pemex did not initially close the valve because they did not consider the leak "important".^[23] It took four hours to extinguish the explosion's fire.^[4][17] Residents from the surrounding areas were evacuated.^[24]

It is believed that the fountain caused fumes of the fuel to fill the air which later ignited in a huge fireball that consumed the surrounding fields which had been soaked with fuel.^[19] The pipeline at the rupture point was estimated to carry around 10,000 barrels of gasoline at 2 megapascals (290 psi).^[25] The exact cause of the fire that ignited the spill is not yet known.^[19] Investigators' first hypothesis was that the gases produced by the leak and the electricity sparks caused by the friction of people's synthetic clothes may have caused the explosion.^[26] The explosion was particularly deadly because the free gasoline attracted large numbers of people to the breach zone.^[4] Residents also stated that the shortage of gasoline in the area may have prompted many to attend the scene when they heard of the breach.^[27]

There were about 25 troops at the site, but Secretary of Defense Luis Cresencio Sandoval stated that there were not enough personnel to turn back the 600–800 residents who had reached the site in search of fuel. He stated that the Army tried to persuade villagers to not get near the breach zone, and that some became aggressive when asked to turn back.^[4] None of the residents were carrying firearms, but some were armed with sticks and stones.^[28] The soldiers did not intervene with civilians as they were outnumbered. They were also asked by their leadership not to engage with potential fuel thieves at the scene when residents started flocking to the breach, because they feared a shootout would break out and unarmed civilians would be hurt or that soldiers would be killed by an angry mob.^[25]

Reactions

The military's DN-III Plan for civilian assistance and disaster relief was activated in the evening of 18 January.^[29] Several of the wounded victims were transported via helicopter to hospitals in Hidalgo, State of Mexico, and Mexico City.^[30][31] Some of the minors were expected to be sent to Shriners Hospitals for Children in the U.S. state of Texas.^[32][33] Hidalgo Governor Omar Fayad said that the government would take care of the medical and funeral expenses. He stated that the government would not pursue legal action against the civilians who were taking the stolen gasoline from the pipeline that exploded.^[34] Fayad confirmed that the government had information booths at the cultural center in Tlahuelilpan with the lists of the victims and the hospitals where they were to receive treatment. The list was also available at the government's website.^[35]

Investigators helped recover the corpses and ordered the bodies to be sent to morgues in Tula and Mixquiahuala for their official identification.^[36] They stated that the bodies would take several months to be fully identified.^[37] Given the fact that many bodies experienced high degree burns, face-to-face recognition was deemed nearly impossible. Families were asked to identify the bodies by the belongings found at the scene. Mexican authorities asked the victim's family members to complete a DNA test to assist in the identification process.^[38] Investigators stated they would likely take the remains to institutions in the U.S. or Europe to facilitate the process.^[39] The victims' family members, however, confronted the investigators at the breach scene and asked them to not take the bodies. They criticized the investigators for wanting to take the bodies to morgues under the assumption that they were doing it for monetary gains. The families stated that traveling outside of Tlahuelilpan to recover the bodies would be difficult for them due to the shortage in gasoline and because it would prove expensive for them.^[40]

President López Obrador canceled meetings he had in Jalisco and Guanajuato upon hearing about the explosion.^[41] He visited Tlahuelilpan on the morning of 19 January, to oversee relief operations. He also promised to step up efforts to counter cartels running fuel theft.^[4][42] Part of his promise included a commitment to continue to crack down on petrochemical theft groups, as well as finding alternatives for citizens so that they do not depend on illegal fuel.^[43] He asked the residents of Tlahuelilpan to give their testimonies of the events, and also to provide information to law enforcement on the black market in the region, including the names of those involved in the gasoline theft gangs and details of their operations.^[25]

Pemex chief executive Octavio Romero Oropeza [es] stated that pipelines in the central Mexico area had been subject to at least 10 breaches in the past three months. One of those perforations caused a fire, which took 12 hours to extinguish on 12 December 2018.^[25] Following these incidents, the pipeline was put under repair on 23 December and remained suspended until 15 January, the official confirmed.^[44][45] During its suspension, Romero Oropeza said that the pipeline was breached four times. It resumed operations on 17 January, a day before the explosion.^[45]

The mayor of Tlahuelilpan, Juan Pedro Cruz Frías, asked residents to take precautionary measures after a toxic smog was present in the town's air after the explosion.^[46] When asked about his thoughts on the incident, the mayor stated that the victims acted out of "necessity" when they learned about the fuel leak. He stated that fuel leaks were common in the area, but also said that "irresponsibility" played a role in this incident.^[47]

Investigation

Attorney General Alejandro Gertz Manero said there were indications that the incident was "deliberate".^[18] His position rested on the fact that the first incident, the leak, was intentional; however it was yet to be confirmed whether or not the explosion was deliberate.^[48] He stated that the investigation would be difficult because those involved in the incident died during the explosion.^[49] President López Obrador stated that all possibilities were being considered for the investigation, and did not discard the involvement of major criminal groups that operate in Hidalgo, like Los Zetas or the Jalisco New Generation Cartel, as well as local gasoline thieves not involved with major drug cartels.^[50]

The first hypothesis proposed by Gertz Manero's investigatory team was that the fire may have been caused by a static electricity spark product of the friction of people's synthetic clothes and the gases produced by the leak. The gasoline that was tapped into was a premium one with high octane levels, which produces lethal gases when exposed to the air.^[51] He stated that this hypothesis was not conclusive.^[52] To facilitate their investigations, the authorities stated they would step up legal proceedings to seize property involved in fuel thefts, including the land where the explosion occurred.^[53] The owners of the land said this measure was unfair and criticized the government's inability to stop fuel thieves.^[54]

On 21 January, Mexico's National Human Rights Commission (CNDH) received a complaint about the "inaction" of the Army during the events leading to the explosion. President López Obrador did not give more details to the press as to what the complaint consisted of and only confirmed it was issued.^[55] The CNDH confirmed the request and stated that they were going to question several personnel who were present during the explosion to gather more details on what exactly occurred. They clarified that this investigation did not mean the Army was at fault, and that that decision would be made after the investigation concluded and when more details on the causes of the explosion became known.^[56]

Aftermath

On May 8, 2019, an illegal gasoline truck exploded in Reforma, Chiapas.^[57] Mayor Herminio Valdez Castillo said the explosion occurred in an uninhabited area and there were no victims.^[58] In January 2020, the Secretariat of the Interior (SEGOB) announced it would build a memorial for the 137 victims of the Tlahelipan explosion. Each family had earlier been compensated with MXN 15,000 (US$800).^[59]

See also

• 1992 Guadalajara explosions
• 2010 Puebla oil pipeline explosion
• List of 21st-century explosions

References

1. Emmanuel Rincón (18 June 2019). "Sobreviviente de la tragedia en Tlahuelilpan regresa a Hidalgo". Excélsior (in Spanish). Retrieved 25 June 2019.
2. "Fuel theft increased by 52.6% in Mexico". El Universal. 5 July 2018. Retrieved 19 January 2019.
3. "Number of fossil fuel thefts in Mexico by state 2016 | Statistic". Statista. Retrieved 19 January 2019.
4. Villegas, Paulina; Semple, Kirk (19 January 2019). "Death Toll in Mexico Blast Rises to 66; Leader Vows to Intensify Crackdown on Fuel Theft". The New York Times.
5. "Mexico pipeline fire kills at least 21, many while gathering illegally tapped fuel". Los Angeles Times. 19 January 2019.
6. Asmann, Parker (14 January 2019). "Oil Thieves Convenient Scapegoats for Mexico's Gasoline Shortages". InSight Crime.
7. "Explosión en Tlahuelilpan, 73 muertos y 74 heridos: Minuto a minuto". Milenio (in Spanish). 19 January 2019.
8. "Mexico explosion: scores dead after burst pipeline ignites". The Guardian. 19 January 2019.
9. Sanchez, Cecilia; McDonnell, Patrick J. (4 January 2019). "Mexican president tells motorists not to panic over gasoline shortage". Los Angeles Times.
10. McDonnell, Patrick J. (12 January 2019). "Gas shortages: A self-inflicted crisis by Mexico's new president?". Los Angeles Times.
11. "Dozens killed as oil pipeline explodes in Mexico's Tlahuelilpan". Al Jazeera. 19 January 2019.
12. Jiménez, Néstor (21 January 2019). "Hidalgo, el estado con más tomas clandestinas". La Jornada (in Spanish).
13. "Mexico pipeline blast kills 66 and injures dozens more". BBC News. 19 January 2019. Retrieved 19 January 2019.
14. "At least 20 killed in Mexico pipeline explosion". CBC News. Reuters. Retrieved 19 January 2019.
15. "More Than 60 Dead, Dozens Injured In Mexican Pipeline Explosion". NPR. 19 January 2019.
16. "At least 20 killed in pipeline explosion in central Mexico". The Telegraph. 18 January 2019.
17. Imagen Noticias, Así ocurrió la explosión del ducto en Tlahuelilpan | Noticias con Ciro, retrieved 19 January 2019
18. "Suman 66 muertos y 76 heridos por explosión en Tlahuelilpan". La Jornada. 19 January 2019. Retrieved 19 January 2019.
19. ""La gente jugaba, reía y se mojaba con gasolina antes de la explosión" de ducto en Hidalgo". El Universal (in Spanish). 18 January 2019. Retrieved 19 January 2019.
20. "Mexico pipeline explosion: Death toll rises to 66". www.euronews.com. 19 January 2019. Retrieved 19 January 2019.
21. "Mexico explosion: scores dead after burst pipeline ignites". The Guardian. 19 January 2019. Retrieved 19 January 2019.
22. "Llamada al 911 alertó de fuga en ducto de Hidalgo; dos horas después explotó". El Universal. 18 January 2019. Retrieved 19 January 2019.
23. "Death toll rises in Mexico pipeline blast, amid reports leak was detected hours before explosion". CNBC. 21 January 2019. Retrieved 21 January 2019.
24. Chavez, Nicole (19 January 2019). "At least 66 people killed, dozens injured in Mexico gasoline pipeline explosion". CNN.
25. "The Latest: Mexico: 600 civilians gathered at illegal tap". The Associated Press. 19 January 2019.
26. "Alto octanaje y ropa sintética de las personas pudo generar la explosión en ducto en Tlahuelilpan". Animal Político (in Spanish). 19 January 2019.
27. Casiano, Louis (20 January 2019). "Pipeline explosion witnesses describe scene where 73 died: 'People's skin came off'". Fox News.
28. López Ponce, Jannet (19 January 2019). "Actitud del Ejército ante fuga de ducto en Hidalgo fue la correcta: AMLO". Milenio (in Spanish).
29. "Activan Plan DN-III tras explosión en ducto en Tlahuelilpan". Excélsior. 18 January 2019. Retrieved 20 January 2019.
30. Fariza, Ignacio (19 January 2019). "Al menos 67 muertos en la explosión de una toma clandestina de combustible en México". El País (in Spanish).
31. "Esta es la lista de heridos tras explosión en Hidalgo y los hospitales donde son atendidos". Animal Político (in Spanish). 19 January 2019.
32. López Ponce, Jannet (19 January 2019). "Trasladan a menor herido en explosión a hospital de Texas". Milenio (in Spanish).
33. "Tlahuelilpan, día 3: Suman 85 muertos por explosión; aún hay 58 hospitalizados". Milenio (in Spanish). 20 January 2019.
34. Mejía, Lizett Ximena (19 January 2019). "Gobierno pagará gastos de los heridos por explosión en Hidalgo". Excélsior (in Spanish).
35. "Instalan módulo de información en Centro Cultural de Tlahuelilpan". Excélsior (in Spanish). 19 January 2019.
36. Ángeles, Verónica (19 January 2019). "Peritos realizan levantamiento de cuerpos en zona de explosión del ducto en Tlahuelilpan". El Sol de Hidalgo (in Spanish).
37. Ángeles, Verónica (19 January 2019). "Tardarían meses en identificar cuerpos tras explosión de ducto en Tlahuelilpan: PGJEH". El Sol de Hidalgo (in Spanish).
38. McDonnell, Patrick J.; Sanchez, Cecilia (20 January 2019). "Mexico struggles to identify the victims of a gas pipeline explosion that killed at least 85". Los Angeles Times.
39. "Sube a 91 cifra de muertos por explosión en Tlahuelilpan". Milenio (in Spanish). 21 January 2019.
40. "Familiares se enfrentan con peritos en Tlahuelilpan". El Sol de México (in Spanish). 19 January 2019.
41. Santos, Javier (19 January 2019). "Cancela AMLO gira a Jalisco y Guanajuato". La Jornada (in Spanish).
42. "AMLO llega a Hidalgo tras explosión". El Universal. 19 January 2019. Retrieved 19 January 2019.
43. "Estrategia contra 'huachicol' no cambiará tras la explosión: AMLO". Milenio (in Spanish). 19 January 2019.
44. López Ponce, Jannet (19 January 2019). "Ducto que explotó en Hidalgo, estaba suspendido desde diciembre". Milenio (in Spanish).
45. Carrillo, Emmanuel (19 January 2019). "El ducto Tuxpan-Tula era abastecido al momento de explosión: Pemex". Proceso (in Spanish).
46. Montoya, Juan Ricardo (19 January 2019). "Se forma nube tóxica por explosión en Tlahuelilpan". La Jornada (in Spanish).
47. "Hubo irresponsabilidad por parte de pobladores: Alcalde de Tlahuelilpan". El Universal (in Spanish). 19 January 2019.
48. "Explosión en Tlahuelilpan, Hidalgo 'fue intencional': Alejandro Gertz". La Vanguardia (in Spanish). 19 January 2019.
49. Politi, Daniel (19 January 2019). "Pipeline Explosion Kills at Least 66 in Mexico". Slate.
50. Esposito, Anthony (20 January 2019). "Death toll raised to 79 in Mexico pipeline blast; new focus on fuel theft". Reuters.
51. López, Jannet (20 January 2019). "Gertz: multitud, gases y chispa apuntan a origen de explosión". Milenio (in Spanish).
52. López Ponce, Jannet (19 January 2019). "Fricción de ropa con gases de combustible pudo causar explosión: Gertz Manero". Milenio (in Spanish).
53. Venegas, Daniel (20 January 2019). "Fiscalía va por extinción de dominio de predios vinculados con huachicoleo". Milenio (in Spanish).
54. Trejo, Amparo (22 January 2019). "Dueños de terrenos de Tlahuelilpan temen extinción de dominio; nos intimidan huachicoleros, dicen". Proceso (in Spanish).
55. López Ponce, Jannet (21 January 2019). "Ejército recibe queja de CNDH por inacción en Tlahuelilpan". Milenio (in Spanish).
56. López, Jannet (22 January 2019). "Investiga ya CNDH la explosión; ascienden a 91 los fallecidos". Milenio (in Spanish).
57. Explotó ducto de Pemex en Chiapas: reportan varios muertos Infobae, 9 May 2019 Explota ducto de Pemex en Chiapas durante robo de combustible Diario de México, 9 Jan 2019
58. "Estalla ducto de Pemex en Chiapas; señalan a huachicoleros" [Pemex pipeline explodes in Chiapas; point to huachicoleros]. Forbes México (in Spanish). 9 May 2019. Retrieved 2 February 2020.
59. Construirán memorial de víctimas de explosión en Tlahuelilpan