Sino-Forest Corporation

Sino-Forest Corporation (Sino-Forest) (TSX: TRE) (Chinese: 嘉汉林业; pinyin: Jiāhàn Línyè) claimed at one time to be one of the leading commercial forest plantation operators in China. In 2011, the company was accused of fraud and found itself under investigation by the Royal Canadian Mounted Police and the Ontario Securities Commission. On March 30, 2012 Sino-Forest filed for bankruptcy protection in Canada. It also announced that the company would be sold or restructured, with the proceeds going to its creditors. On July 13, 2017, the OSC released its decision finding that Sino-Forest and four individuals, including former CEO Allen Chan, committed fraud.

It is not to be confused with China Forestry Holdings Ltd.^[1] (HK:0930)^[2] or the Chinese state-owned China Forestry Group Corporation (CFGC).^[3]

History

The company was formed in 1994 and subsequently claimed that its principal businesses included the ownership and management of tree plantations and complementary manufacturing of downstream engineered-wood products. The company claimed to derive most of its revenue from the sales of wood fibre needed to produce industrial, commercial and residential wood products. Sino-Forest also held a majority interest in Omnicorp Limited, an investment holding company listed in Hong Kong (HK:0094) that in turn claimed to import wood fibre into China. Sino-Forest's common shares traded on the Toronto Stock Exchange under the symbol TRE from 1995 until they were suspended in 2011, and its corporate office were in Mississauga, Canada. Sino-Forest had a market capitalization of just over $5 billion in November 2010.

As of September 30, 2009, Sino-Forest claimed to have had approximately 757,000 hectares of trees under management and over 700,000 hectares of trees available to be acquired under six long-term master agreements. The company claimed to have plans to replant 200,000 hectares by 2012.

Management further claimed that it expected to benefit from China's economic stimulus plan, which included further infrastructure development, rebuilding after Sichuan's 2008 earthquake and building of affordable housing for rural areas.^[4]

Business segments

At the end of September 2010, Sino-Forest Corp had claimed approximately 757,000 hectares of forest plantations located in southern China. Its principal business segments include Wood Fibre Operations (i.e. the ownership and management of plantation trees, the sale of standing timber and wood logs, the trading of wood products sourced domestically and internationally) and Manufacturing and Other Operations (i.e. downstream engineered-wood flooring and panels, seedling nurseries, greenery services).

Subsidiaries

Sino-Forest Corporation owned an interest of approximately 60% of Omnicorp Limited (to be renamed Greenheart Group Limited upon shareholder approval), a Hong Kong listed company (HK:0094). In addition, Sino-Forest owned HK$212 million of convertible bonds of Omnicorp, which if fully converted would increase Sino-Forest's interest to nearly 60% of the enlarged issued share capital of Omnicorp.

The principal activities of Omnicorp's subsidiaries claimed to consist of log harvesting, lumber processing and marketing and sales of logs and lumber products to China and other countries around the world. Omnicorp claimed to own 60.4% of the harvesting and other rights in a 184,000-hectare hardwood forest concession in Suriname, South America and Sino-Forest, through its wholly owned subsidiary Sino-Capital Global Inc. owned the remaining 39.6%. Omnicorp also intended to acquire a high quality radiata pine plantation in New Zealand upon satisfaction of certain conditions as announced on November 3, 2010.

ARCPE

Sino-Forest Applied Research Centre for Pearl River Delta Environment (ARCPE) officially opened on 22 June 2009 at the Hong Kong Baptist University.^[5] The Centre remains active with Sino-Forest name.

Reported financial position as of December 31, 2010

The company's claimed assets grew significantly from 2004 to 2010. The reported assets were:

• 2004 $0.7 billion
• 2005 $0.8 billion
• 2006 $1.2 billion ^[6]
• 2007 $1.8 billion ^[7]
• 2008 $2.6 billion
• 2009 $3.9 billion
• 2010 $5.7 billion ^[8]

The December 31, 2010 audited financial statements reported Sino-Forest had:

• $5.7 billion of assets
• $2.4 billion of liabilities
• 395 million of net income ^[9]

Fraud allegations

On June 2, 2011, shares in Sino Forest plummeted following the release of a negative research report ^[10] by Carson Block of Muddy Waters Research, which made allegations that Sino-Forest had been fraudulently inflating its assets and earnings, and that the company's shares were essentially worthless. Muddy Waters claimed that Sino Forest was a "multibillion-dollar Ponzi scheme" that was "accompanied by substantial theft".^[11] Sino Forest rejected the allegations of fraud and launched an independent investigation by PricewaterhouseCoopers.^[11] Shares in Sino Forest fell by 82% following publication of the Muddy Waters report,^[12] with prominent investor John Paulson selling his entire stake in the company at a $720 million loss.^[13]

On June 30, debt rating agency Standard & Poors downgraded Sino-Forest's long-term corporate credit rating from "BB" to "B+". A second downgrade to "B" followed on August 23.^[14]

On August 15, 2011, Sino-Forest announced that the results of the PwC probe into the allegations would be delayed to the end of the year due to difficulties in gathering data from the Chinese companies involved.^[15]

Suspension of Trading of Shares

On August 26, 2011, the Ontario Securities Commission suspended trading of the shares of Sino-Forest, stating that the company had engaged in practices they "knew or should have known" perpetuated a fraud.^[16] The OSC also initially ordered that five directors of Sino-Forest resign, but rescinded this demand a few hours later as the Ontario Securities Act does not allow the commission to summarily force the resignation of a company director without a hearing.^[17]

Bankruptcy Protection

On March 30, 2012, Sino-Forest filed for bankruptcy protection in Canada under the framework laid out in the Companies' Creditors Arrangement Act.^[18][19]

On April 4, 2012, Sino-Forest's auditors, Ernst and Young, resigned.^[20]

Defamation Lawsuit

On March 29, 2012, one day before filing for bankruptcy protection, Sino-Forest sued Muddy Waters in the Ontario Superior Court of Justice for defamation. Sino-Forest sought damages of $4 billion.^[21][22] In response to the lawsuit, Muddy Waters stated that Sino's bankruptcy protection filing vindicated its accusations since the company would not require bankruptcy protection if it was really generating close to $2 billion in cash flow.^[18]

Settlement of Investors' Lawsuits

In 2015, the firm's auditors Ernst and Young, a group of financial institutions (Credit Suisse Securities (Canada) Inc., TD Securities Inc., Dundee Securities Corp., Merrill Lynch Canada Inc., RBC Dominion Securities Inc., Scotia Capital Inc., CIBC World Markets Inc., Canaccord Financial Ltd. and Maison Placements Canada Inc.), and former Sino-Forest chief executive David Horsley paid $117 million, $32.5 million and $5.6 million respectively to settle investor's lawsuits.^[23]

Ontario Securities Commission Decision

On July 13, 2017, the OSC released its decision finding that "Sino-Forest, Chan, Ip, Hung and Ho engaged in deceitful or dishonest conduct related to Sino-Forest’s standing timber assets and revenue they knew constituted fraud." The OSC also found that the individual respondents violated Ontario securities law by misleading commission staff during the investigation.^[24]

Bankruptcy protection proceedings

A Plan of Compromise and Reorganization was approved by the court on 10 December 2012,^[25][26][27] which is expected to come into effect on 17 January 2013.^[28] It is now controlled by its bondholders and operating as Emerald Plantation Holdings based in Hong Kong.

See also

•  Companies portal

• China Medical Technologies
• Strategic lawsuit against public participation

The Internet Archive Wayback Machine captured the corporation's websites of www.sinoforest.com and www.sinoforestonline.com multiple times during its period of operation.^[29]

References

1. China Forestry Holdings Co. Ltd. Hong Kong website 2011-07-21 at the Wayback Machine
3. State owned China Forestry Group Corporation (CFGC) website
4. "PREVIEW-Sino-Forest seen benefiting from China's stimulus". Reuters. August 7, 2009.
5. "HKBU sets up territory's first applied research centre for Pearl River Delta environment". Hong Kong Baptist University. 23 June 2009.
6. "2009 Annual Report - Sino-Forest Corporation". www.Sedar.com. Sino-Forest Corporation. p. 23.
7. "2009 Annual Report - Sino-Forest Corporation". www.Sedar.com. Sino-Forest Corporation. p. 32.
8. "2010 Annual Report - Sino-Forest Corporation". www.Sedar.com. Sino-Forest Corporation. pp. 51, 53.
9. "2010 Annual Report - Sino-Forest Corporation". www.Sedar.com. Sino-Forest Corporation. pp. 51, 53.
10. "Muddy Waters Initiating Coverage on TRE.TO, OTC:SNOFF – Strong Sell" (PDF). Muddy Waters Research. 2 June 2011.
11. Canadian regulators order Sino-Forest executives to resign - DealBook/New York Times, 26 Aug 2011
12. Sino-Forest Shares Surge After Wellington Management Discloses 11.5% Stake - Bloomberg, 5 July 2011
13. Paulson May Deal Clients $720 Million Loss - Bloomberg, 21 June 2011
14. "Sino-Forest shares slide after S&P's 2nd downgrade". Reuters. August 23, 2011.
15. Sino-Forest Investigation Extended - Wall Street Journal, 16 Aug 2011
16. Ontario regulator accuses Sino-Forest of fraud, halts trading of its shares 2012-04-01 at the Wayback Machine - The Canadian Press, 26 Aug 2011
17. Sino-Forest Trading Halted, OSC Rescinds Order - Bloomberg, 26 Aug 2011
18. "Sino-Forest files for bankruptcy protection". BBC. 2012-03-30.
19. "Sino-Forest Corporation". FTI Consulting. Retrieved 14 January 2013.
20. "Settlement Agreement between Staff and David Horsley". www.osc.gov.on.ca. paragraph 15: Ontario Securities Commission. Retrieved 17 September 2016.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: location (link)
21. David Benoit (2012-03-30). "Sino-Forest Sues Muddy Waters for $4 Billion". Wall Street Journal.
22. "Statement of Claim - Sino-Forest vs Muddy Waters" (PDF). Wall Street Journal. Retrieved 18 September 2016.
23. "Banks to pay $32.5 million settlement in Sino-Forest lawsuit by investors". Financial Post. Retrieved 17 September 2016.
24. "OSC REASONS AND DECISION". 2017-07-13. Retrieved 2017-12-09.
25. Peter Koven (2012-12-11). "Judge approves Sino-Forest restructuring despite opposition from funds". Financial Post.
26. "Court Approves Sino-Forest's Plan of Compromise and Reorganization" (PDF). Sino-Forest Corporation. 10 December 2012. Retrieved 14 January 2013.
27. Re Sino-Forest Corporation, 2012 ONSC 7050 (12 December 2012), Superior Court of Justice (Ontario, Canada)
28. "Sino-Forest Announces Anticipated CCAA Plan Implementation Date and Reduction of Unresolved Claims Reserve" (PDF). Sino-Forest Corporation. 11 January 2013. Retrieved 14 January 2013.
29. . www.sinoforest.com. Archived from the original on 16 February 2010. Retrieved 12 January 2022.

External links

• Sinoforest.com: official Sino-Forest Corporation website