fbpx
Wikipedia

Section 51(xxvi) of the Constitution of Australia

April 05, 2024

Section 51(xxvi) of the Constitution of Australia,[1] commonly called "the race power", is the subsection of Section 51 of the Constitution of Australia granting the Australian Commonwealth the power to make special laws for people of any race.

As initially written, s 51(xxvi) empowered the Federal Parliament to make laws with respect to: "The people of any race, other than the aboriginal race in any State, for whom it is deemed necessary to make special laws". The Australian people voting at the 1967 referendum deleted the words in italics, moving and centralising the existing State Parliaments' race power to the Federal government.

Edmund Barton had argued in the 1898 Constitutional Convention that s 51(xxvi) was necessary to enable the Commonwealth to "regulate the affairs of the people of coloured or inferior races who are in the Commonwealth".[2][3][4] The section was intended to enable the Commonwealth to pass laws restricting such migrant labourers as the Chinese and Kanakas. Quick and Garran observed in 1901 that "It enables the Parliament to deal with the people of any alien race after they have entered the Commonwealth; to localise them within defined areas, to restrict their migration, to confine them to certain occupations, or to give them special protection and secure their return after a certain period to the country whence they came."[5]

There were delegates, however, at the 1898 Convention who argued against the use of legislative power to deal specifically with alien races, accepting that people might be excluded from Australia based on race, but arguing that once people were admitted to the country they should be treated in the same way as other citizens.[6]

The scope of s 51(xxvi) is, subject to the Constitution itself, unfettered in keeping with s 51 granting plenary powers to the Commonwealth.[7] Section 51(xxvi) supports the rejection of legal equality requirements when considering legislation otherwise validly enacted under the Constitution.[8] Thus legislation empowered by other constitutional powers, such as in the Northern Territory National Emergency Response,[9] which was empowered by section 122,[10] may be racially discriminatory.

The second question in the 1967 referendum amended this section, removing the prohibition on the Commonwealth making laws in regards to "the Aboriginal race". At the time this was largely seen as a positive change for Aboriginal peoples' welfare, as the Commonwealth was seen as being more positive towards them than the states collectively were.

In the 1998 case Kartinyeri v Commonwealth, the High Court was split on whether s 51(xxvi) could be used to enact legislation that adversely discriminated on the basis of race. Justices Gummow and Hayne held that the use of race as the basis of parliamentary power was inherently discriminatory and that benefits to the people of one race may be detrimental to people of another.[11] Justice Kirby disagreed, holding that the race power did not permit the enactment of laws to the detriment of the people of any race.[12] Justice Gaudron held that it was difficult to conceive of circumstances in which a law to the disadvantage of a racial minority would be valid.[13]

The Northern Territory National Emergency Response of 2007–2011, and its continuation as the Stronger Futures policy would have required the use of this section had the Commonwealth implemented it in any of the states. However, as it was implemented only in a territory, this was not the case.

A federal government commissioned report from the "Expert Panel on Constitutional Recognition of Indigenous Australians" on 19 January 2012, recommended that a referendum be held for the repeal of s 51(xxvi), replacing it with new sections s 51A (which would empower the Commonwealth to make laws for Indigenous Australians, but also recognises Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders as Australia's first peoples) and s 116A (which would prohibit racially discriminatory legislation or the making of laws under s51A that are not for the benefit of Indigenous peoples).[14]

In 2017, the Referendum Council (with the same initial co-chairs as 2012's Expert Panel) made recommendations echoing those made by that Panel, although not formally including the repeal of section 25 as per the Expert Panel recommendations (2012) and the Joint Select Committee on Constitutional Recognition of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples (2015).[15][16][17]

References edit

  1. ^ Constitution (Cth) s 51(xxvi).
  2. ^ "Official Record of the Debates of the National Australasian Convention". Melbourne. 27 January 1898. pp. 228–9.
  3. ^ French, Robert (2003). "The Race Power: A Constitutional Chimera". In H.P. Lee and George Winterton (ed.). Australian Constitutional Landmarks. Cambridge UK: Cambridge University Press. pp. 180–212. ISBN 0-521-83158-X.
  4. ^ George Williams (9 October 2023). "Racial divide has always been part of our Constitution". The Australian. Retrieved 10 October 2023.
  5. ^ Quick, J; Garran, R (1901). The Annotated Constitution of the Australian Commonwealth. p. 622.
  6. ^ "Official Record of the Debates of the National Australasian Convention". Melbourne. 28 January 1898. Charles Kingston at pp. 244-7, John Quick at pp, 245–6 and Josiah Symon at p. 250.
  7. ^ Kartinyeri v Commonwealth [1998] HCA 22, (1998) 195 CLR 337 at p. 355, High Court (Australia).
  8. ^ Kruger v Commonwealth [1997] HCA 27, (1997) 190 CLR 1 at pp. 44-5 per Brennan CJ.
  9. ^ Northern Territory National Emergency Response Act (Cth).
  10. ^ Constitution (Cth) s 122.
  11. ^ Kartinyeri v Commonwealth [1998] HCA 22, (1998) 195 CLR 337 at [81]-[85] per Gummow and Hayne JJ, High Court (Australia).
  12. ^ Kartinyeri v Commonwealth [1998] HCA 22, (1998) 195 CLR 337 at [152] per Kirby J, High Court (Australia).
  13. ^ Kartinyeri v Commonwealth [1998] HCA 22, (1998) 195 CLR 337 at [44] per Gaudron J, High Court (Australia).
  14. ^ Expert Panel on Recognising Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples in the Constitution (January 2012), Recognising Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples in the Constitution: Report of the Expert Panel (PDF), ISBN 978-1-921975-29-5, (PDF) from the original on 16 March 2015
  15. ^ "Final report". Parliament of Australia. 2018. Retrieved 10 April 2021.
  16. ^ "Report of the expert panel on recognising Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples in the Constitution". ANTaR. 2012. Retrieved 20 April 2021.
  17. ^ "Other proposals for constitutional change". Parliament of Australia. 2021. Retrieved 10 March 2021.

Further reading edit

  • Everett, Sean (2010). "The Australian Constitution & Section 51(xxvi): The 'Race Power' - Beneficial Power of Government or Colonial Anachronism?".
  • Williams, George. "Removing racism from Australia's constitutional DNA". (2012) 37(3) Alternative Law Journal 151.

April 05, 2024
section, xxvi, constitution, australia, commonly, called, race, power, subsection, section, constitution, australia, granting, australian, commonwealth, power, make, special, laws, people, race, initially, written, xxvi, empowered, federal, parliament, make, l. Section 51 xxvi of the Constitution of Australia 1 commonly called the race power is the subsection of Section 51 of the Constitution of Australia granting the Australian Commonwealth the power to make special laws for people of any race As initially written s 51 xxvi empowered the Federal Parliament to make laws with respect to The people of any race other than the aboriginal race in any State for whom it is deemed necessary to make special laws The Australian people voting at the 1967 referendum deleted the words in italics moving and centralising the existing State Parliaments race power to the Federal government Edmund Barton had argued in the 1898 Constitutional Convention that s 51 xxvi was necessary to enable the Commonwealth to regulate the affairs of the people of coloured or inferior races who are in the Commonwealth 2 3 4 The section was intended to enable the Commonwealth to pass laws restricting such migrant labourers as the Chinese and Kanakas Quick and Garran observed in 1901 that It enables the Parliament to deal with the people of any alien race after they have entered the Commonwealth to localise them within defined areas to restrict their migration to confine them to certain occupations or to give them special protection and secure their return after a certain period to the country whence they came 5 There were delegates however at the 1898 Convention who argued against the use of legislative power to deal specifically with alien races accepting that people might be excluded from Australia based on race but arguing that once people were admitted to the country they should be treated in the same way as other citizens 6 The scope of s 51 xxvi is subject to the Constitution itself unfettered in keeping with s 51 granting plenary powers to the Commonwealth 7 Section 51 xxvi supports the rejection of legal equality requirements when considering legislation otherwise validly enacted under the Constitution 8 Thus legislation empowered by other constitutional powers such as in the Northern Territory National Emergency Response 9 which was empowered by section 122 10 may be racially discriminatory The second question in the 1967 referendum amended this section removing the prohibition on the Commonwealth making laws in regards to the Aboriginal race At the time this was largely seen as a positive change for Aboriginal peoples welfare as the Commonwealth was seen as being more positive towards them than the states collectively were In the 1998 case Kartinyeri v Commonwealth the High Court was split on whether s 51 xxvi could be used to enact legislation that adversely discriminated on the basis of race Justices Gummow and Hayne held that the use of race as the basis of parliamentary power was inherently discriminatory and that benefits to the people of one race may be detrimental to people of another 11 Justice Kirby disagreed holding that the race power did not permit the enactment of laws to the detriment of the people of any race 12 Justice Gaudron held that it was difficult to conceive of circumstances in which a law to the disadvantage of a racial minority would be valid 13 The Northern Territory National Emergency Response of 2007 2011 and its continuation as the Stronger Futures policy would have required the use of this section had the Commonwealth implemented it in any of the states However as it was implemented only in a territory this was not the case A federal government commissioned report from the Expert Panel on Constitutional Recognition of Indigenous Australians on 19 January 2012 recommended that a referendum be held for the repeal of s 51 xxvi replacing it with new sections s 51A which would empower the Commonwealth to make laws for Indigenous Australians but also recognises Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders as Australia s first peoples and s 116A which would prohibit racially discriminatory legislation or the making of laws under s51A that are not for the benefit of Indigenous peoples 14 In 2017 the Referendum Council with the same initial co chairs as 2012 s Expert Panel made recommendations echoing those made by that Panel although not formally including the repeal of section 25 as per the Expert Panel recommendations 2012 and the Joint Select Committee on Constitutional Recognition of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples 2015 15 16 17 References edit Constitution Cth s 51 xxvi Official Record of the Debates of the National Australasian Convention Melbourne 27 January 1898 pp 228 9 French Robert 2003 The Race Power A Constitutional Chimera In H P Lee and George Winterton ed Australian Constitutional Landmarks Cambridge UK Cambridge University Press pp 180 212 ISBN 0 521 83158 X George Williams 9 October 2023 Racial divide has always been part of our Constitution The Australian Retrieved 10 October 2023 Quick J Garran R 1901 The Annotated Constitution of the Australian Commonwealth p 622 Official Record of the Debates of the National Australasian Convention Melbourne 28 January 1898 Charles Kingston at pp 244 7 John Quick at pp 245 6 and Josiah Symon at p 250 Kartinyeri v Commonwealth 1998 HCA 22 1998 195 CLR 337 at p 355 High Court Australia Kruger v Commonwealth 1997 HCA 27 1997 190 CLR 1 at pp 44 5 per Brennan CJ Northern Territory National Emergency Response Act Cth Constitution Cth s 122 Kartinyeri v Commonwealth 1998 HCA 22 1998 195 CLR 337 at 81 85 per Gummow and Hayne JJ High Court Australia Kartinyeri v Commonwealth 1998 HCA 22 1998 195 CLR 337 at 152 per Kirby J High Court Australia Kartinyeri v Commonwealth 1998 HCA 22 1998 195 CLR 337 at 44 per Gaudron J High Court Australia Expert Panel on Recognising Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples in the Constitution January 2012 Recognising Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples in the Constitution Report of the Expert Panel PDF ISBN 978 1 921975 29 5 archived PDF from the original on 16 March 2015 Final report Parliament of Australia 2018 Retrieved 10 April 2021 Report of the expert panel on recognising Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples in the Constitution ANTaR 2012 Retrieved 20 April 2021 Other proposals for constitutional change Parliament of Australia 2021 Retrieved 10 March 2021 Further reading editEverett Sean 2010 The Australian Constitution amp Section 51 xxvi The Race Power Beneficial Power of Government or Colonial Anachronism Williams George Removing racism from Australia s constitutional DNA 2012 37 3 Alternative Law Journal 151 Retrieved from https en wikipedia org w index php title Section 51 xxvi of the Constitution of Australia amp oldid 1214603330, wikipedia, wiki, book, books, library,

article

, read, download, free, free download, mp3, video, mp4, 3gp, jpg, jpeg, gif, png, picture, music, song, movie, book, game, games.