Newnansville, Florida

Not to be confused with Newmansville.

Newnansville, Florida was one of the first American settlements in the interior of Florida. It became the second county seat of Alachua County in 1828, and one of the central locations for activity during the Second Seminole War, during which time it was one of the largest cities in the State. In the 1850s, the Florida Railroad bypassed Newnansville, resulting in the county seat being moved to the new town of Gainesville in 1854. Consequently, Newnansville began to decline, and when a second railway bypassed the town in 1884, most of its residents relocated and formed the new City of Alachua. By 1900, Newnansville was deserted.

Newnansville Town Site
U.S. National Register of Historic Places
Entrance to the Newnansville Cemetery, one of the few surviving remains of the town
Location	Alachua County, Florida, USA
Nearest city	Alachua
Coordinates	29°48′31″N 82°28′36″W / 29.80861°N 82.47667°W / 29.80861; -82.47667
NRHP reference No.	74000608^[1]
Added to NRHP	December 4, 1974

The site is approximately 1.5 miles northeast of Alachua, on S.R. 235 off of US 441. Containing partial walls of two cemeteries, the town site was added to the National Register of Historic Places on December 4, 1974.

History

Bellamy Road

In 1824, only three years after Florida became a United States territory (and the same year that Alachua County itself was created), Congress authorized the construction of the first federal highway in the state.^[2] It would connect Pensacola to St. Augustine. The Territorial Council commissioned John Bellamy, a Monticello planter, to build it. The project took two years to complete, at a cost of $20,000. The route would become known as Bellamy Avenue. It was a major highway until the Civil War, when other roads became preferred routes. Newnansville was founded on the Bellamy Road.^{[citation needed]}

Initial settlement and peak

The Dell brothers (James, Simeon, and Maxey), who had earlier (during the Patriot War) visited the Alachua County area, came back to settle there sometime after 1814. ^[3] The exact date of first settlement is uncertain, though the period between 1814 - 1820 is determined from the date of the oldest burial in Newnansville Cemetery, infant Robert Pyles in 1820. Records also show the Dell brothers staying with Edward Wanton (one of the initial founders of the Town of Micanopy) in the Fall of 1821.^[4][5] Newnansville and Micanopy are the oldest distinctly American settlements in the State.^[3][6][7]

The Dells constructed a post office on the Bellamy Avenue in 1826 which became the nucleus of the new settlement.^[4] In 1828, it was renamed Newnansville (in honor of Daniel Newnan, who had led a raid into what is now Alachua County during the Patriot War) and was made the second county seat of Alachua County.^[8][9] In 1832, Newnansville was included as part of the newly formed Columbia County.^[8]

With the outbreak of the Second Seminole War in 1835, many residents from around the area abandoned their farms and moved to the town or nearby Fort Gilliland for refuge. Women and men both worked to fortify the town's defenses, and families doubled up in crowded spaces. Some 300 people lived in tents outside the fort.^[8]

In 1839, the legislature returned Newnansville to Alachua County, and it again became the county seat. A land office was established in 1842 to make it easier for settlers to buy public land or file claims, rather than having to go all the way to St. Augustine.^[8] Following the end of the Seminole wars, the town flourished, becoming the center for trade and plantation life in the area. The county produced mainly corn and cotton in the antebellum years. It built a new courthouse in 1850.

Decline

The Florida Railroad Company announced its plan to build a line from Fernandina to Cedar Key, passing several miles south of Newnansville. As a result, county residents voted in 1853 to move the county seat to a location along the planned route of the railroad, naming the new town Gainesville.^[10] Losing the county seat marked the beginning of decline for Newnansville as settlement moved south in the county. The town was directed to sell the courthouse in 1857, and it was used as a Masonic temple.^[8]

After the Civil War farmers developed the citrus industry in the area. Two major factors contributed to the town's continuing decline. The Live Oak, Tampa and Charlotte Harbor Railroad, said to be connecting Newnansville to Gainesville, bypassed the town in 1883, building its line to the south.^[8] In 1884 the town was bypassed again, when the Savannah, Florida, and Western Railroad constructed its line a mile and a half to the southwest. A new town, Alachua, grew up at a station stop there. In the winter of 1886, a major freeze ruined the area citrus crop. This major setback, plus the lack of railway connections, led businesses and residents to move to the growing communities of Alachua and Gainesville.

Newnansville was the site of several race-related murders in the mid-19th Century. In 1896 Harry Jordan, an African-American man suspected of the murder of Dr. J.N. Cloud, was burned to death in Newnansville. He had taken shelter in a house, defending himself in a shootout with a white mob outside. They set the house on fire, and he died.^[11] In 2021, the Alachua-Newnansville Community Remembrance Project identified eight victims of lynching from Newnansville: George Bibbon (1867), Cooley Johnson (1867), Willey Bradley (1868), Ceasar Sullivan (1868), Harry Hurl (1869), Joseph Hurl (1869), son of Harry Harold (1869), and William Rawls (1895).^[12]

Newnansville had been deserted by 1900, and all the remaining buildings were razed by the middle of the twentieth century. All that was left of Newnansville were two cemeteries and the remains of Bellamy Road, closed to traffic.^[8]

References

1. "National Register Information System". National Register of Historic Places. National Park Service. July 9, 2010.
2. Kleindienst, Linda (July 20, 2012). "Native Americans Started The Trail That Evolved Into North Florida's Transportation System". Tallahassee Magazine. Retrieved March 3, 2022.
3. "Elotchaway, East Florida, 1814". The Florida Historical Society Quarterly. 8 (3): 143–155. 1930. ISSN 0361-624X.
4. Forrester, Mary Lois. Lest We Forget, A Town, Newnansville, Florida. p. 19. OCLC 40544458.
5. Bryant, Irene, ed. (2016). Pioneers of Northwest Alachua County, Florida. Colorwise Commercial Printing. ISBN 978-0-692-79185-1.
6. Marotti, Frank (1995). "Edward M. Wanton and the Settling of Micanopy". The Florida Historical Quarterly. 73 (4): 456–477. ISSN 0015-4113.
7. "First United Methodist Church of Alachua | Our Rich History". First United Methodi. Retrieved January 3, 2023.
8. Susan Yelton, "Newnansville: A Lost Florida Settlement", The Florida Historical Quarterly, Vol. 53, No. 3 (Jan. 1975), pp. 319-331, via JSTOR; accessed March 21, 2018
9. LaCoe, Norm (1974). "The Alachua Frontier". In Opdyke, John B. (ed.). Alachua County: A Sesquicentennial Tribute. Gainesville, Florida: The Alachua County Historical Commission. p. 9.
10. Hildreth, Charles H.; Cox, Merlin G. (1981). History of Gainesville, Florida 1854-1979. Gainesville, Florida: Alachua County Historical Society. pp. 2–6, 8.
11. Dan, Nicole (September 27, 2017). "At Least 21 Lynched In Alachua County, Historical Commission Confirms". WUFT-TV. Retrieved January 9, 2018.
12. Prator, Jack. "Reconciling lynchings in Alachua, Newnansville". Gainesville Sun. Retrieved December 8, 2022.

Further reading

• Brown, George Long (2019). Denham, James M. and Keith L. Huneycutt (eds.). The Letters of George Long Brown: A Yankee Merchant on Florida's Antebellum Frontier. Gainesville, FL: University Press of Florida. ISBN 9780813056388.
• Brown, Ellen and Corinna Brown (2004). Denham, James M. and Keith L. Huneycutt (eds.). Echoes from a Distant Frontier: The Brown Sisters' Correspondence from Antebellum Florida. Columbia, SC: University of South Carolina Press. ISBN 1-57003-536-9.
• Davis, Jess G. (1969). History of Alachua County, 1824-1969. Second Edition. Gainesville, FL: The Alachua County Historical Commission.
• Mahon, John K. (1967). History of the Second Seminole War 1835-1842. Revised Edition. Gainesville, FL: University Press of Florida. ISBN 0-8130-1097-7.
• Motte, Jacob R. (1953). Sunderman, James F. (ed.). Journey into Wilderness: An Army Surgeon's Account of Life in Camp and Field during the Creek and Seminole Wars 1836-1838. Gainesville, FL: University of Florida Press.
• Opdyke, John B. (ed.) (1974). Alachua County: A Sesquicentennial Tribute. Gainesville, FL: The Alachua County Historical Commission.
• Pickard, John B. (1994). Florida's Eden: An Illustrated History of Alachua County. Gainesville, FL: Maupin House. ISBN 0-929895-12-6.
• Webber, Carl (1883). Midland Florida, the Eden of the South. Reprint. Micanopy, FL: Micanopy Publishing Company.

External links

 

Wikimedia Commons has media related to Newnansville, Florida.

• Newnansville Town Site - Explore Historic Alachua County
• Newnansville Town Site - Visit Florida
• Petition to establish East Florida Seminary at Newnansville, 1852
• Newnansville Plat, 1853
• http://www.fphsonline.com/jrnlpdf/journal08.2.pdf abandoned