Isabel de Clare, 4th Countess of Pembroke

Isabel de Clare, suo jure 4th Countess of Pembroke and Striguil (c. 1172 – 11 March 1220), was an Anglo-Norman and Irish noblewoman descended from Aoife Macmurrough and Richard de Clare and one of the wealthiest heiresses in Wales and Ireland.^[1] She was the wife of William Marshal, 1st Earl of Pembroke, who served three successive kings as Marshal of England. Her marriage had been arranged by King Richard I.

Isabel de Clare
suo jure Countess of Pembroke and Striguil
Born	c. 1172 Leinster
Died	11 March 1220 Chepstow, Wales
Noble family	De Clare
Spouse(s)	William Marshal, 1st Earl of Pembroke ​ ​ (m. 1189; died 1219)​
Issue	William Marshal, 2nd Earl of Pembroke Richard Marshal, 3rd Earl of Pembroke Maud Marshal Gilbert Marshal, 4th Earl of Pembroke Walter Marshal, 5th Earl of Pembroke Anselm Marshal, 6th Earl of Pembroke Isabel Marshal Sibyl Marshal Joan Marshal Eva Marshal
Father	Richard de Clare, 2nd Earl of Pembroke
Mother	Aoife of Leinster

Family inheritance

 

Daniel Maclise's painting of the marriage of Isabel's parents, Richard de Clare, 2nd Earl of Pembroke, and his wife Aoife of Leinster in August 1170, the day after the capture of Waterford.

Isabel was one of two known legitimate children of Earl Richard "Strongbow". Isabel may have been older than her brother Gilbert, who was born in 1173 but died a teenager soon after 1185, at which point Isabel became the heir to her parents' great estates in England, Wales and Leinster. Her mother was the daughter of Diarmait Mac Murchada, the deposed King of Leinster and Mór_Ní_Tuathail. The latter was a daughter of Muirchertach Ua Tuathail and Cacht ingen Loigsig. The marriage of Strongbow and Aoife took place in August 1170, the day after the capture of Waterford by the Cambro-Norman forces led by Strongbow.^[2]

Isabel's paternal grandparents were Gilbert de Clare, 1st Earl of Pembroke, and his wife Isabel de Beaumont. Deprived of his father Gilbert's estate of Pembrokeshire by the king in 1153 when he succeeded as a child, Richard Strongbow continued to assert he was an earl, but took his title as Striguil (the Welsh name for the lordship of Chepstow, the centre of his estates in the southern March of Wales).^[3] The earldom of Pembroke was not forgotten, however, and in 1199 it was recreated and awarded to Isabel's husband, William Marshal, undoubtedly on the basis of Isabel's hereditary claim to it. In this way, Isabel could be said to be the successor in the earldom of Pembroke to her grandfather Gilbert, the first earl, especially as her husband before 1199 was meticulous in referring to her as 'Countess Isabel'.^[4]

Isabel was described as having been "the good, the fair, the wise, the courteous lady of high degree".^[5] She allegedly spoke French, Irish and Latin.^[6] After her brother Gilbert's death, Isabel became one of the wealthiest heiresses in the kingdom, owning besides the titles of Pembroke and Striguil, much land in Wales and Ireland.^[1] She also had a hereditary claim on the numerous castles on the inlet of Milford Haven, guarding the St George's Channel, including Pembroke Castle.^[1] She was a ward of King Henry II, who carefully watched over her inheritance, and who we find in 1189 had confided her to the keeping of Ranulf de Glanville chief justiciar of England.^[7]

Marriage

The new King Richard I arranged her marriage in August 1189 to William Marshal, regarded by many as the greatest knight and soldier in the realm. Henry II had promised Marshal he would be given Isabel as his bride, and his son and successor Richard upheld the promise one month after his accession to the throne. At the time of her marriage, Isabel was residing in the Tower of London in the protective custody of the Justiciar of England, Ranulf de Glanville.^[5] Following the wedding, which was celebrated in London "with due pomp and ceremony",^[5] they spent their honeymoon at Stoke d'Abernon in Surrey which belonged to Enguerrand d'Abernon.^[8]

Marriage to Isabel elevated William Marshal from the status of military captain and knight into one of the richest men in the kingdom. He would serve as Lord Marshal of England, four kings in all: Henry II, Richard I, John, and Henry III. Although Marshal did not become Earl of Pembroke until 1199—a revival of the title by King John as an act of favour—he nevertheless assumed overlordship of Leinster in Ireland and the Marcher lordships of Chepstow and Usk with Isabel's many other estates in several English counties, which belonged to her father's and her own earldom of Striguil.

Marshal and Isabel did not sail to Ireland till 1200, after taking possession of Pembroke. He left her behind him on his return to England.^[9] She may have ruled Leinster in his absence till as late as 1203, with as her seneschal a Wiltshire knight, Geoffrey fitz Robert, who was married to Isabel's aunt, Basilia de Clare, a sister of Strongbow.^[10] Isabel is credited with playing a major part at this time in the foundation of the borough known as New Ross.^[11] Isabel was again left to rule Leinster in 1207-8 during her husband's house arrest at the court of King John when, though pregnant, she successfully led the campaign which defeated the rebel barons of the province.^[12]

The marriage was happy, despite the difference in age between them. William Marshal and Isabel produced a total of five sons and five daughters.^[1]

Widowhood

Isabel lived as a widow for only ten months after the death of William Marshal, though it was by no means an uneventful period, which has left a good deal of evidence as to how a great heiress such as she was, managed her affairs when she came into full control of her inheritance. She wrote within days to the papal legate and the justiciar of England asking for the prompt delivery of her lands, and on 18 June 1219, the justiciar issued writs ordering local officers to hand over, to her, control of her inheritance in four English counties and in Ireland. Pembroke is not mentioned, which hints that her eldest son may have directly inherited the earldom as it may have been treated as a royal grant to his father, not as part of his mother's inheritance. The marcher lordship of Striguil also came to her. In July she was in France, where she successfully negotiated with King Philip Augustus the possession of her Norman inheritance. While there, she and her son opened negotiations with the king for the marriage of the younger William Marshal with his first cousin, a ploy which caused panic at the English court and a counter-offer of marriage to King Henry III's youngest sister Eleanor.^[13] There is evidence that she made good use of her eldest son as her agent in managing the great estates that were hers to dispose of in the months she had them, both of them stonewalling her late husband's executors to avoid paying the debts he left. In February 1220 she was mortally ill at Chepstow, and on 2 March her son is found at Cirencester en route to Wales to attend her deathbed. Tintern Abbey sources give her death as 11 March 1220.^[14] She was buried in the north choir aisle of the family abbey of Tintern, next to her mother Aoife.^[15]

Issue

• William Marshal, 2nd Earl of Pembroke (1190 – 6 April 1231). Chief Justiciar of Ireland. He married firstly, Alice de Bethune, and secondly, Eleanor Plantagenet, daughter of King John.
• Richard Marshal, 3rd Earl of Pembroke (1191 – 1 April 1234 Kilkenny Castle, Ireland), married Gervase le Dinant. He died childless.
• Maud Marshal (1192 – 27 March 1248). She married firstly, Hugh Bigod, 3rd Earl of Norfolk, by whom she had issue; she married secondly, William de Warenne, 5th Earl of Surrey, by whom she had issue, including John de Warenne, 6th Earl of Surrey who married Alice le Brun de Lusignan; she married thirdly, Walter de Dunstanville. Five queen consorts of Henry VIII: Catherine of Aragon, Anne Boleyn, Jane Seymour, Catherine Howard and Catherine Parr were her descendants.
• Gilbert Marshal, 4th Earl of Pembroke (1194 – 27 June 1241). He married firstly, Marjorie of Scotland, daughter of King William I of Scotland; and secondly, Maud de Lanvaley. He is known to have had an illegitimate daughter while a young cleric, who he married to Maelgwyn Fychan, a prince of the royal house of Deheubarth.
• Walter Marshal, 5th Earl of Pembroke (1196 – 24 November 1245). He married Margaret de Quincy, Countess of Lincoln, widow of John de Lacy, 1st Earl of Lincoln, as her second husband. The marriage was childless.
• Anselm Marshal, 6th Earl of Pembroke (1198 – 22 December 1245). He married Maud de Bohun. He died childless.
• Isabel Marshal (9 October 1200 – 17 January 1240). She married firstly, Gilbert de Clare, 4th Earl of Hertford; and secondly, Richard, 1st Earl of Cornwall. She had issue by both marriages. King Robert I of Scotland and Queen consorts Anne Boleyn, Jane Seymour, Catherine Howard and Catherine Parr were descendants.
• Sibyl Marshal (1201 – before 1238), married William de Ferrers, 5th Earl of Derby, by whom she had issue. Queen consort Catherine Parr was a descendant.
• Joan Marshall (1202–1234), married Warin de Munchensi, Lord of Swanscombe, by whom she had issue. Both queen consorts Jane Seymour and Catherine Parr were descendants. Had Joan Marshal.
• Eva Marshal (1203–1246), married William de Braose (died 1230). Queen consorts Anne Boleyn, Jane Seymour, Catherine Howard, and Catherine Parr were her descendants.

 

Tintern Abbey, the burial place of Isabel de Clare

Legacy

A cenotaph was discovered inside St. Mary's Church, New Ross, Ireland, whose slab bears the partial inscription "ISABEL: LAEGEN" (interpreted as 'Isabel of Leinster') and an engraved likeness said to be hers.^[16] This identification was subsequently rejected, even before modern research identified her true burial place at Tintern ^[17]

It was suggested in 1892 by Paul Meyer that Isabel might have encouraged the composition of the Song of Dermot, which narrates the exploits of her father and maternal grandfather. The Deeds of the Normans in Ireland as it is now known is dated by its latest editor to the 1190s, so Meyer's suggestion is possible.^[18] However the text makes no mention of either Isabel or her husband, and is more likely to have been sponsored within the community of barons of Leinster at a time before Isabel and William Marshal effectively exercised their lordship in Ireland in 1200.^[19]

Although her daughters had many children, Isabel's five sons, curiously, died childless, apart from Gilbert, who before he inherited the earldom had an illegitimate daughter he married off to a son of the Welsh lord Maelgwyn Fychan in 1240.^[20] This failure in heirs is supposedly attributed to a curse placed upon William Marshal by the Irish Bishop of Ferns, Albin O'Molloy.^[21] The title of marshal subsequently passed to Hugh de Bigod, husband of Isabel's eldest daughter Maud, while the title of Earl of Pembroke went to William de Valence, 1st Earl of Pembroke, the husband of Joan de Munchensi, daughter of Joan Marshal. He was the first of the de Valence line of the earls of Pembroke.

Within a few generations their descendants included much of the nobility of Europe, including all the monarchs of Scotland since Robert I (1274–1329) and all those of England, Great Britain and the United Kingdom since Henry IV (1367–1413); and Katherine of Aragon and all of the English queen consorts of Henry VIII.^{[citation needed]}

Ancestry

Ancestors of Isabel de Clare, 4th Countess of Pembroke

16. Richard FitzGilbert, Lord of Clare 8. Gilbert FitzRichard, Lord of Clare 17. Rohese Giffard 4. Gilbert de Clare, 1st Earl of Pembroke 18. Hugh I, Count of Clermont-en-Beauvaisis 9. Adeliza de Clermont-en-Beauvaisis 19. Marguerite de Montdidier-Roucy 2. Richard de Clare, 2nd Earl of Pembroke 20. Roger de Beaumont 10. Robert de Beaumont, 1st Earl of Leicester 21. Adeline of Meulan 5. Isabel de Beaumont 22. Hugues I, Count of Vermandois 11. Élisabeth de Vermandois 23. Adélaïde, Countess of Vermandois 1. Isabel de Clare, 4th Countess of Pembroke 24. Murchad, King of Leinster 12. Donnchad, King of Leinster 6. Diarmait, King of Leinster 13. Orlaith 3. Aoife MacMurrough, Princess of Leinster 28. Gilla Comgaill Ua Tuathail 14. Muirchertach Ua Tuathail 29. Sadbh Ní Domnail 7. Mór Ní Tuathail 30. Loigsig Ua Morda, King of Laois 15. Cacht Ní Morda, Princess of Laois 31. Gormlaith Ní Caellaide

References

1. Costain 1962, p. 267.
2. M.T. Flanagan, 'Negotiating across Legal and Cultural Borders; Aífe, daughter of Diarmait Mac Murchada, king of Leinster, and Marriage, Motherhood and Widowhood in Twelfth-century Ireland and England', Peritia 30 (2019) 71–95. at pp. 72, 85–6, 91
3. Flanagan, 'Negotiating across Legal and Cultural Borders,' pp. 85–6.
4. D. Crouch, William Marshal, 3rd edn (Abingdon: Routledge, 2016), 83–4, 101–2
5. Painter 1933, p. 76.
6. Turtle Bunbury (2000). History, Heroes and Villains, William Marshall, Earl of Pembroke, 1147–1219 – Crusader, Templar, Kingmaker. An article. Retrieved 2010-10-29.
7. Crouch, William Marshal, 79.
8. Painter 1933, pp. 76–77.
9. Crouch, William Marshal, 102-5
10. Crouch, William Marshal, 252
11. 'C. Ó Drisceoil, 'New Ross, a town of William Marshal' in, William Marshal and Ireland ed. J. Bradley and others (Dublin: Four Courts, 2017), 278–80.
12. Crouch William Marshal, 125-31.
13. D. Crouch, 'Testament and Inheritance: the lessons of the brief widowhood of Isabel, countess of Pembroke' in, Law and Society in Later Medieval and England and Ireland, ed. Travis R. Baker (Abingdon: Routledge, 2018), pp. 25–50, at pp, 31–5.
14. Crouch, 'Testament and Inheritance' pp. 35–6
15. Flanagan, 'Negotiating across Legal and Cultural Borders,' p. 22 and notes 73, 74.
16. JSTOR: The Journal of the Royal Society of Antiquaries of Ireland, Vol.78, No (July 1948), p.65. Retrieved 2010-10-29.
17. J. Hunt, Irish Medieval Figure Sculpture, 2 vols (Dublin, 1974), no. 264
18. Mullally, Evelyn, ed. (2002). The Deeds of the Normans in Ireland. Dublin: Four Courts Press. pp. 21–35. ISBN 1851826432.
19. Crouch, William Marshal, 102-5, 122–4
20. The Acts and Letters of the Marshal Family: Marshals of England and Earls of Pembroke, 1145–1248, ed. D. Crouch, Camden Society, 47 (Cambridge, 2015), p. 27.
21. Costain 1951, pp. 114–115.

Sources

• Costain, Thomas (1962). The conquering family. Garden City, N.Y: Doubleday. ISBN 978-0-385-04088-4. OCLC 965113.
• Costain, Thomas (1951). The Magnificent Century: The Pageant of England. Doubleday and Company, Inc.
• Crouch, David (2016). William Marshal (3rd ed.). Abingdon: Routledge. ISBN 9781138939325.
• Painter, Sidney (1933). William Marshal, Knight-errant, Baron, and Regent of England. Johns Hopkins historical publications. Johns Hopkins Press. Retrieved 14 November 2018.
• Gillian Kenny. "The Wife's Tale: Isabel Marshal and Ireland", William Marshal and Ireland, ed. J. Bradley and others (Dublin: Four Courts, 2017), pp. 315–24.
• Linda E. Mitchell, "The Most Perfect Knight's Countess, Isabella de Clare, her daughters and women's exercise of power", Medieval Elite Women and the Exercise of Power, 1100–1400, ed. H. Tanner (Palgrave Macmillan, 2019), pp. 45–65.

Peerage of England
Preceded by Gilbert de Clare, 3rd Earl of Pembroke	Countess of Pembroke 1185–1220	Succeeded by William Marshal, 2nd Earl of Pembroke