Gille Críst, 4th Earl of Angus had by his first wife, Marjorie of Huntingdon (youngest daughter of Henry of Scotland, Earl of Huntingdon and his wife, Ada de Warenne), the following son and daughter:
Donnchadh (or Donnchad), 5th Earl of Angus who succeeded him before 1206.
^Graham, William, LL.D., Genealogical & Historical Diagrams, Illustrative of the History of Scotland, England, France, and Germany from the Ninth Century to the Present Time, (Edinburgh, 1862) p.13: (author states in the Genealogical and Historical Map of Scotland, No.1, "Henry, Prince of Scotland and Earl of Huntingdon, d. 1152, -- dau. Marjory=Earl of Angus.").
^Lord Lindsay. Lives of the Lindsays; or a Memoir of the Houses of Crawford and Balcarres, 2nd ed., vol. 1, (London, 1858) pp. 23-24: (author states, “By William's wife, Marjory, daughter of Henry Prince of Scotland, and sister of King William the Lion and David Earl of Huntingdon, § he left a son and heir, Sir David, Lord of Crawford, and two younger sons, Sir Walter and William, of whom Sir Walter became the ancestor of the House of Lamberton, and William of the Lindsays of Luffness, who ultimately succeeded to the male representation of the Lindsays.”), (author also states, “§ Robert de Pinkeney claimed the Scottish throne in 1291 as descendant and representative of Marjory, mother of his grandmother Alice de Lindsay, the heiress of this original House of Crawford. See his ' Peticio,' Rymer's Foed., torn. ii. p. 576. The mother of Alice having been Aleonora de Limesay, as shewn hereafter, Marjory must have been the wife, not of David, Alice's father, but of William, her grandfather, the William spoken of in the text - one generation more remote.”But is should be noted that the mother of Alice was Margerie, not Aleonora de Limesay who was the wife of Sir William, her grandfather. Lord Lindsay (1849) swapped the two wives in error. An English document (CDS, i, no. 1614) dated 1243 shows that Alice's brother Gerard, Lord of Crawford, is named as "the son of Margerie of Lindsey").
^According to Beryl Platts, Scottish Hazzards, vols. 1, 2, 4 & 5 (the Procter Press, 1985); the author states that Sir William de Lindsay born about 1148 who married, firstly, Aleanora de Limesay (daughter of Gerard, Lord of Limesay and Amicia de Bidun) about 1174 by whom he had three sons, also married, secondly, Margaret of Huntingdon (daughter of Henry of Huntingdon, Earl of Huntingdon and Ada de Warenne). [Beryl Platts disagrees with the statement made by Lord Lindsay that Marjorie of Huntingdon had three sons with Sir William de Lindsay (died c. 1200).].
Bibliography
Sir James Balfour Paul. The Scots Peerage: founded on Wood's edition of Sir Robert Douglas's, The Peerage of Scotland, (Edinburgh, Scotland: David Douglas, 1904), vol. 1, pp. 4, 5, 12, 13, & 160-165.
Cokayne, G.E., The Complete Peerage. New ed., vol. 1, (London, 1910), p. 146.
Roberts, John L., Lost Kingdoms: Celtic Scotland in the Middle Ages, (Edinburgh, 1997), pp. 53–54
Weir, Alison. Britain's Royal Families: The Complete Genealogy (London, U.K.: The Bodley Head, 1999), p. 196.
Richardson, Douglas. Royal Ancestry: A Study in Colonial and Medieval Families, vol. 4, (2013), pp. 582–583: [author states, "They had three sons, ... , and four daughters. Children of Henry of Scotland, by Ada de Warenne: i. Malcolm IV of Scotland, ii. William the lion, King of Scots, iii. David of Scotland, iv. Maud of Scotland, v. Margaret of Scotland, vi. Ada of Scotland, vii. ______ of Scotland (daughter)."].
gille, críst, earl, angus, ruled, until, 1206, mormaer, angus, gille, brigte, angus, younger, brother, adam, angus, almost, nothing, known, except, that, married, marjorie, huntingdon, daughter, henry, scotland, warenne, that, succeeded, donnchad, before, 1206. Gille Crist Earl of Angus ruled until 1206 as Mormaer of Angus He was a son of Gille Brigte of Angus and younger brother of Adam of Angus Almost nothing is known of him except that he married Marjorie of Huntingdon the daughter of Henry of Scotland and Ada de Warenne and that he was succeeded by his son Donnchad before 1206 His daughter Bethoc Beatrix was married to Walter Stewart 3rd High Steward of Scotland and was mother to Alexander Stewart 4th High Steward of Scotland It is claimed that Marjorie of Huntingdon married secondly as his second wife Sir William de Lindsay of Luffness and Crawford born c 1148 died c 1200 but such a marriage did not occur Gille Crist Earl of Angus and Marjorie of Huntingdon were ancestors of Robert I known as Robert the Bruce King of Scots b 11 July 1274 d 7 June 1329 1 2 3 Gille Crist 4th Earl of Angus had by his first wife Marjorie of Huntingdon youngest daughter of Henry of Scotland Earl of Huntingdon and his wife Ada de Warenne the following son and daughter Donnchadh or Donnchad 5th Earl of Angus who succeeded him before 1206 Bethoc or Beatrix who was married to Walter Stewart 3rd High Steward of Scotland and mother to Alexander Stewart 4th High Steward of Scotland Gille Crist 4th Earl of Angus had by his second wife Ingibiorg Ericsdottir of Caithness daughter of Eric Thorliotsson the following son Magnus II Earl of Orkney and CaithnessSee also EditSir Robert de Pinkeney Baron of Pinkeney d 1296 13th century English noble and a competitor for the Crown of Scotland References Edit Graham William LL D Genealogical amp Historical Diagrams Illustrative of the History of Scotland England France and Germany from the Ninth Century to the Present Time Edinburgh 1862 p 13 author states in the Genealogical and Historical Map of Scotland No 1 Henry Prince of Scotland and Earl of Huntingdon d 1152 dau Marjory Earl of Angus Lord Lindsay Lives of the Lindsays or a Memoir of the Houses of Crawford and Balcarres 2nd ed vol 1 London 1858 pp 23 24 author states By William s wife Marjory daughter of Henry Prince of Scotland and sister of King William the Lion and David Earl of Huntingdon he left a son and heir Sir David Lord of Crawford and two younger sons Sir Walter and William of whom Sir Walter became the ancestor of the House of Lamberton and William of the Lindsays of Luffness who ultimately succeeded to the male representation of the Lindsays author also states Robert de Pinkeney claimed the Scottish throne in 1291 as descendant and representative of Marjory mother of his grandmother Alice de Lindsay the heiress of this original House of Crawford See his Peticio Rymer s Foed torn ii p 576 The mother of Alice having been Aleonora de Limesay as shewn hereafter Marjory must have been the wife not of David Alice s father but of William her grandfather the William spoken of in the text one generation more remote But is should be noted that the mother of Alice was Margerie not Aleonora de Limesay who was the wife of Sir William her grandfather Lord Lindsay 1849 swapped the two wives in error An English document CDS i no 1614 dated 1243 shows that Alice s brother Gerard Lord of Crawford is named as the son of Margerie of Lindsey According to Beryl Platts Scottish Hazzards vols 1 2 4 amp 5 the Procter Press 1985 the author states that Sir William de Lindsay born about 1148 who married firstly Aleanora de Limesay daughter of Gerard Lord of Limesay and Amicia de Bidun about 1174 by whom he had three sons also married secondly Margaret of Huntingdon daughter of Henry of Huntingdon Earl of Huntingdon and Ada de Warenne Beryl Platts disagrees with the statement made by Lord Lindsay that Marjorie of Huntingdon had three sons with Sir William de Lindsay died c 1200 Bibliography EditSir James Balfour Paul The Scots Peerage founded on Wood s edition of Sir Robert Douglas s The Peerage of Scotland Edinburgh Scotland David Douglas 1904 vol 1 pp 4 5 12 13 amp 160 165 Cokayne G E The Complete Peerage New ed vol 1 London 1910 p 146 Roberts John L Lost Kingdoms Celtic Scotland in the Middle Ages Edinburgh 1997 pp 53 54 Weir Alison Britain s Royal Families The Complete Genealogy London U K The Bodley Head 1999 p 196 Richardson Douglas Royal Ancestry A Study in Colonial and Medieval Families vol 4 2013 pp 582 583 author states They had three sons and four daughters Children of Henry of Scotland by Ada de Warenne i Malcolm IV of Scotland ii William the lion King of Scots iii David of Scotland iv Maud of Scotland v Margaret of Scotland vi Ada of Scotland vii of Scotland daughter Preceded byAdam Mormaer of Angus 1206 Succeeded byDonnchadh Retrieved from https en wikipedia org w index php title Gille Crist Earl of Angus amp oldid 1088474803, wikipedia, wiki, book, books, library,
