Forrester single (locomotive)

Swiftsure was first of eight or more similar locomotives with a single pair of driving wheels built by George Forrester and Company (Forresters) from 1834. The tank variant was the first passenger tank engine to enter service in the world.

Swiftsure/Vauxhall type
Vauxhall (1834)
Type and origin Power type Steam Builder George Forrester and Company Build date 1834 Rebuilder D&KR
Specifications Configuration: ​  • Whyte 2-2-0 Leading dia. 3 ft 0 in (0.91 m) Driver dia. 4 ft 8+1⁄2 in (1.435 m) Boiler pressure 50 lbf/in^2 (0.34 MPa) Cylinders 2 (horizontal) Cylinder size 11 in × 16 in (279 mm × 406 mm)
Career Nicknames Boxers First run 1834
Details refer to D&KR locomotives as built.^[1]

They have been claimed to be the first locomotives to use outside horizontal cylinders^[a] and also the first to use 4 eccentric cranks. The use of outside cylinders on a short wheelbases with no wheel balances resulted in an oscillating movement at speed, resulting in a nickname of "Boxers" and most being rebuilt from 2-2-0 to incorporate trailing axle becoming configured as 2-2-2.

Locomotives were supplied to the Liverpool and Manchester Railway (L&MR), Dublin and Kingstown (D&KR), London and Greenwich (L&GR), Birmingham and Gloucester (B&GR), and a few other minor railways.

History

George Forrester's Vauxhall Foundry had been established in Liverpool by 1827, taking over a disused cotton mill. The location was about 1.5 miles (2.4 km) from the L&MR's Edge Hill Workshops and was also convenient to the docks. The L&MR had started operating in 1830, becoming the first example of successfully operating railway in the world and the model upon which the next generation of railways used as a study example for their own projects. While most L&MR locomotives in the early 1830s were supplied by Robert Stephenson and Company of Newcastle that company was unable to supply demand and other suppliers were entering the market.^{[citation needed]} Forrester's had first become with the proposal to construct locomotives in response to a tender invitation by the L&MR in May 1831 but pulled out following a misunderstanding with the L&MR's secretary Henry Booth, the tender being satisfied by Bee and Liver from Edward Bury and Experiment from Robert Sharp.^[2] Forresters, along with other firms, did however perform some locomotive component construction or repair work for the L&MR in the early 1830s.^[3]

Origins

The D&KR had started their procurement for tendering for locomotives in August 1833 approaching nine firms with a requirement for six locomotives to be delivered in perfect working order by 1 May 1834; the seven who replied all commenting on the short timescale.^[4] The D&KR engaged John Urpeth Rastrick as consultant to visit the prospective builders and he returned with a specification which matched an improved Experiment locomotive from Sharp Brothers of Manchester.^[4] D&KR engineers Vignoles and Bergin has concerns over the vertical cylinders and other aspects of 'Experiment and Sharp Brothers design and the D&KR board of directors asked the locomotive manufacturers to submit their own proposals; Liverpools's Edward Bury, favoured by some of the D&KR's Quaker board, being eliminated at his stage over insistence of use of an inside-cylinder design with a crank axle which was not favoured by D&KR engineers.^[4]

 

Valve Gear of Forrester's Swiftsure locomotive (built 1834)

In December 1833, with time running short to get locomotives built for their planned start of operations the D&KR board finally placed based an order for three locomotives from Sharp Brothers that were to become the Hibernia type, and three from George Forrester. They would have originally preferred to have placed all six with one manufacturer for parts commonality however ability to complete the build in the needed timescale had become a priority and degrees of uncertainty about both designs may have been a factor.^[5] Forrester had not built any locomotive prior to the D&KR order,^[6] so winning the order may seem unexpected. Forrester did have some advantages: Liverpool base at convenient to the L&MR and their workshops; Good communications with regular steam packet to Dublin; previous component build work for the L&MR; amiable relations with the customer; and a reputation for good workmanship, though that may have gained later.^{[citation needed]} The design may have been evolved with the collaboration of or intention to satisfy Vignoles and Bergin. Snell claims Vignoles obtained a set of drawings from Dodds, albeit Snell also claims Dodds influence was not present until later D&KR engines. While seemingly not involved in the design the employment of Alexander Allan from Stephenson's would have been a help. It is also the case Forrester was given the Stephenson locomotive Milo by the L&MR in 1834 with a view to a repair quote; the L&MR eventually accepting Milo was uneconomic to repair leaving Forrester to scrap Milo and with the L&MR proving Swiftsure as a replacement early in 1834 — the precise dates are unclear and it was possibly too late in the year to reverse engineer any of Milo's features into the Forrester design.^{[citation needed]}

D&KR officials often did spot visits to Forresters during their locomotives' construction and were generally well received by Forresters, their spot checks at Sharps sometimes gave indication of staff problems and absenteeism.^[7]

The company first began to produce railway locomotives in 1834.^[6] The locomotives constructed in that year were Swiftsure for the L&MR; with Vauxhall, Dublin and Kingstown for the D&KR which was to begin operations in December of that year. Swiftsure was a locomotive built by Forresters of the Vauxhall Foundry in Liverpool which entered service for the L&MR in 1834 as No. 36.^[8]

Stretton claims Swiftsure to be the first locomotive built by the company, though others have stated that this might not be the case.^[9][10][11] However information from Mr Alexander Allan (engineer at Forresters) published in 1883 pointed to an error in a publication in The Engineer in 1881^[12] where the Swiftsure was listed at built in 1835. He pointed out that Swiftsure was the first locomotive, being built 'early in 1834', and he attended it on trials, etc; he also went to Dublin late in 1834 with the three locomotives for the Dublin and Kingstown Railway ('of the same size and design as the Swiftsure'), and was responsible for their care while under the Forrester's maintenance contract. The confusion may have arisen because Swiftsure worked from the Liverpool end of the L&MR in 1834, before being transferred to the Manchester end of the line in 1835.^[8] Swiftsure had a pair of trailing wheels added in 1836, and was in regular service until 1842.^[13]

Design

The type were the first locomotives to use outside cylinders and also the first outside and inside frames, though the later was not appreciated at the time and only adopted some ten years later.^[14] The combination of outside frames on a short 2-2-0 wheelbase with unbalanced driving wheels led to an oscillating motion and led to the nickname of "Boxers".^{[14][additional citation(s) needed]} Many locomotives eventually were fitted with a trailing axle to become a 2-2-2T to help reduce the problem.

Liverpool and Manchester

Swiftsure entered service on the L&MR as a 2-2-0 in October 1834 with two outside 11 in × 18 in (279 mm × 457 mm) cylinders,^[b] for a price of £860.^[15][c] It was noted as being involved in a collision with at Parkside on 11 November 1934 with the consequence that a labourer was crushed between wagons of the stationary between the wagons of the stationary luggage train.^[d] The labourer was later to die of his injuries and the "occasional engineman" charge of Swiftsure was held responsible for entering a watering stop at more than 6 miles per hour (9.7 km/h) and was sanctioned by losing his turn on the promotion list.^[17] Swiftsure was involved in a further incident in July 1835 whilst descending the incline at Whiston, Merseyside when a train of five silk wagons caught fire; the train took several hundred yards to stop and some wagons were only detached with difficulty. The L&MR was ultimately advised to pay £3,000 damages for the high value load on the basis they had not adequately displayed notices that the owners should have insured it.^[18] Swiftsure was involved in several experiments during its service life. In November 1836 the L&MR performed a coal burning trial involving Swiftsure and several other locomotives, the results being generally unsuccessful with Swiftsure's firebox damaged by excessive heat.^[19] Locomotives at this period were forced to use the more expensive and sometimes problematic coke in order to fulfill the requirement to "consume their own smoke"; it took several years for the technology to use coal successfully in locomotives to evolve.^[20]

Dublin and Kingstown

The Forresters' locomotives for the D&KR became known as Vauxhall, Dublin and Kingstown; the names being those of the manufacturing foundry and the termini of the line.

The first of the D&KR locomotives^[e] ran sufficiently well on tests on the L&MR that it was permitted by their superintendent Manchester to take charge of the first class train to Liverpool on 27 June 1834. The journey was completed in 1 hour 17 minutes with several D&KR people on board including James Pim, Thomas Flemming Bergin, Vignoles and other directors.^[7]

Vauxhall along with Hibernia were transported to Dublin on the same sailing before being hauled through the streets on temporary tracks.^[7] Murray says there is a legend Vauxhall was the first locomotive to reach the D&KR's tracks, making it Ireland's first steam locomotive.^[21]

The first recorded service of the invited members of the public being transported was a special preview trip to Martello Tower and Booterstown by Vauxhall on 4 October 1834. The honour of the first trial run over the entire length of the line fell to Forresters Hibernia on 9 October 1834 with Vauxhall doing a trip later in the day.^{[citation needed]}

The honour of the first scheduled train in Ireland fell to Sharp's locomotive Hibernia at 09:00 17 December 1834; this being the famously celebrated inaugural run. While Forrester's Vauxhall ran the next service and both continued running trips throughout the day. The D&KR commenced its full scheduled service in January 1835.

Maintenance of the class was at the Serpentine Road "engine hospital" with one section reserved for Forrester locomotives with their man Alexander Allan on site for one year per the purchase contract.^[7]

The D&KR began requesting quotes for two more engines in February 1835; Vignoles' earlier suggestion eight locomotives would be required proving more accurate in practice than consuktant Rastrick's suggest only four would be necessary.^[22] On 28 March 1835 the motive power situation became desperate when Forrester locomotive's Vauxhall and Dublin were in collision, with requests to England for spare tenders.^[7] Murray claims the D&KR had begun to consider tank engines carry their own coke and water had begun to be considered from February due to the operational inconvenience of having to separate the locomotive and tender so each could be turned independently on the D&KR's 10 feet (3.0 m) turntables, the latter at least being manually pushed.^[22] The order for two 2-2-0T locomotives's was put in Forrester's, in the event these were named Comet and Victoria, with Murray claiming these were "the first tank engines to work on any public railway".^[23]

All five Forrester D&KR singles were converted to six wheel tank engines by 1841, the conversion being relatively simple with the fitting of water tanks under the boiler and extending the footplate to incorporate a coke stage and the addition of a trailing axle.^[24]

London and Greenwich

The London and Greenwich Railway began a public service on the 2+1⁄2 miles (4.0 km) section between Spa Road and Deptford in February 1836.^[25] Locomotives in use at this point were two Planet type of the 2-2-0 configuration. Royal William was supplied by William Marshall & Sons.^[f] Lowe also finds alternative sources indicating No. 1 was supplied by Charles Tayleur and Company which had links to Stephenson and this was as a set of parts and assembled on site. That source also indicates Marshalls were previously Braithwaites until 1839, (Whishaw 1842) and Venus supplied by the L&MR possibly as a hire to replace an esoteric 0-2-0 rotary steam engine supplied by Earl Dundonald. Victoria from Forresters became the third operational engine in May 1836 for the sum of £1,010 10s 0d.^[26] The L&GR had initially ordered locomotives from Stephenson's and Burys however neither actually supplied.^[g] Forrester's second engine Walter^[h] arrived in December 1836 in time for the extension to London Bridge station, becoming the sixth operational engine, Royal William having acquired three sister locomotives in the interim.^[26] Victoria and Walter with their 2-2-0WT configuration and acquired the nickname "Boxers" for the typical yawing motion of type. Trials in 1837 revealed that Walter was more powerful than Royal William. Both were converted to tender locomotives, possibly in an effort to reduce the yawing. They were painted green, acquiring the numbers five and six respectively and possibly losing their names from the 1840s.^{[citation needed]}

Victoria had a trailing axle added in 1841 to become a 2-2-0, before becoming a pumping engine at Bricklayers Arms from December 1845 and was finally acquired by C. Tomkins at Reading for scrap for £110. Walter was never fitted with a trailing axle. It saw service at Redhill repair shops from January 1846 followed by an assignment to the Gomshall sandpits from 1853 until it was scrapped along with Victoria.^[27]

Birmingham and Gloucester

The Birmingham and Gloucester Railway possessed four Forrester 2-2-2s:^[28] the Cheltenham, the Worcester, the Bromsgrove and the Tewkesbury.^[29] They had been ordered by Edward Bury soon after his appointment as locomotive advisor and agent and two arrived in November 1838 and were used on construction.^[30] They proved more reliable than the American Norris engines and were allocated to the important mail services.^[31] With their 2-2-2 wheel arrangement they were totally unsuited and never intended for climbing the steep Lickey Incline and for this ascent they were assisted by the Norris Type A Extra bank engines.^[31]

Other railways

Parliamentary papers published in 1842 seem to yield examples of other railways using 2-2-0 and 2-2-2 Forrester engines.^[32] The Preston and Wyre Railway (P&WR) had a Forrester 2-2-0 it sued for light goods, ballasting work, and occasional special passenger trains. Its other engine was a 2-2-2 goods and its passenger services were generally worked by another railway. The P&WR was aware their six-wheeled locomotive seemed to cause far less track wear than several other four wheel locomotives used on the railway, but that there 4 wheel Forrester could negotiate some curves the six wheel could not.^[33][i] The Grand Junction Railway had between one and three Forrester engines 2-2-2 engines based on the information they had three locomotives with outside cylinders with one different from the other two.^[34] The Manchester, Bolton & Bury Canal Navigation and Railway (MB&CNR) had two Forrester 2-2-0s and eight 0-4-0s from Edward Bury and William Fairbairn with a preference to go for Bury's engine if more were needed.^[35]

Legacy

The class was to form the basis for later locomotives built by the D&KR for itself starting with the Princess in 1939.^[36] The locomotives Alexander Allan went on design for the Grand Junction Railway and London and North Western Railway (including the Crewe type (locomotive)) showed influences from Forrester practice.^[37]

Notes

1. Outside cylinders means the cylinders were placed outside of the wheels. It is possible some earlier engines may have had outside cylinders. Dodd's Star of 1833 and possibly one other may have a claim.
2. The date seems surprisingly late in the year if (Thomas 1980, pp. 162–163) is correct.
3. Dawson states the L&MR ordered Swiftsure in November 1834 for £860 as a replacement for Milo. and was delivered in spring 1834, with a Forrester D&KR engine running trials earlier in July 1834 on the L&MR.^[16]
4. Freight or goods trains were termed luggage trains in this period.
5. It would probably be reasonably assumed this was Vauxhall but it is not named as such in the source.
6. (Thomas 1986) locates Marshall & Sons at Tipton while (Lowe 2014, pp. 458–459) indicates Gravesend.
7. (Lowe 2014, pp. 458–459) says Bury subcontracted to Forrester (both factories were in the Liverpool docks area) while Stephenson had links to Charles Tayleur.^{[citation needed]}
8. Forrester's had named the locomotive William but the L&GR renamed it Walter to avoid a clash, presumably after their director George Walter.
9. The P&WR included docks where sharp curves might be found.

References

Footnotes

1. Lyons 2015, p. 81.
2. Thomas 1980, p. 157.
3. Thomas 1980, p. 162.
4. Murray 1981, pp. 173–174.
5. Murray 1981, pp. 172–174.
6. Lowe 2014, pp. 176–177.
7. Murray 1981, p. 177.
8. "Links in the History of the Locomotive No. XIII". The Engineer: 150. 23 February 1883.
9. Stretton 1892, pp. 54–56.
10. Stretton 1903, pp. 62–63.
11. Pangborn 1894, pp. n105–n106.
12. "Links in the History of the Locomotive No. X". The Engineer. 18 March 1881.
13. "Links in the History of the Locomotive No. XIV". The Engineer: 160. 2 March 1883.
14. Nock 1975, pp. 7–9.
15. Thomas 1980, pp. 162–163.
16. Dawson 2021, p. 150.
17. Thomas 1980, pp. 210.
18. Thomas 1980, p. 206.
19. Thomas 1980, pp. 175–176.
20. Thomas 1980, p. 175.
21. Murray 1981, p. 182.
22. Murray 1981, p. 178.
23. Murray 1981, p. 179.
24. Murray 1981, p. 183.
25. Thomas 1986, p. 50.
26. Thomas 1986, pp. 176−177.
27. Thomas 1986, p. 191.
28. Various 1842, p. 202.
29. Whishaw 1842, p. 30.
30. Long & Awdry 1987, p. 131.
31. Long & Awdry 1987, p. 169–170.
32. Various 1842.
33. Various 1842, pp. 219–220.
34. Various 1842, pp. 211–212.
35. Various 1842, pp. 205–206.
36. Murray 1981, pp. 181, 190.
37. Lowe 2014, p. 177.

Sources

• Barlow, Peter (1837). A Treatise on the Strength of Timber, Cast Iron, Malleable Iron, and Other Materials with Rules for Application in Architecture, Construction of Suspension Bridges, Railways, Etc. London: John Weale. OCLC 258491612.
• Bergin, T. F. (27 October 1841). "Dublin and Kingstown Railway No. 29". Letter to Lords of the Privy Council for Trade. pp. 213–214.
• Dawson, Anthony (2021). Locomotives of the Liverpool and Manchester Railway. Yorkshire: Pen & Sword Transport. ISBN 9781526763983. OCLC 1190858980.
• Lowe, James W. (2014) [1975]. British Steam Locomotives Builders. Pen & Sword Transport. pp. 245–259. ISBN 978-1-47382-289-4. OCLC 889509628.
• Long, P. J.; Awdry, W. V. (1987). The Birmingham and Gloucester Railway. Gloucester: Alan Sutton. ISBN 0862993296. OCLC 18588406. OL 2468738M.
• Lyons, Garrett (15 October 2015). Steaming to Kingstown and Sucking Up to Dalkey: The Story of the Dublin and Kingstown Railway. Dublin: Londubh Books. ISBN 978-1907535772.
• Murray, Kevin (1981). Ireland's First Railway. Dublin: Irish Railway Record Society. ISBN 0-904078-07-8.
• Nock, O. S. (August 1975). Locomotion. Routledge & Kegan Paul PLC. ISBN 978-0710082220. OCLC 21980980. OL 5253681M.
• Pangborn, Joseph Gladding (1894). The world's rail way, historical, descriptive, illustrative. New York: Winchell Printing Company. OCLC 983256626.
• Patterson, Edward Mervyn (2003) [1962]. The Great Northern Railway (Ireland). Railway History. Vol. OL67. Usk: Oakwood. ISBN 9780853616023. OCLC 53393781.
• Saunders (18 October 1834). "The Dublin and Kingstown Railway". Mechanics Magazine. London: J. Cunningham. 22 (584): 47 – via googlebooks.{{cite journal}}: CS1 maint: url-status (link)
• Snell, S (1921). A Story of Railway Pioneers — being an account of the inventions and works of Isaac Dodds and his son Thomas Weatherburn Dodds. London: Selwyn & Blount, Ltd. OCLC 1085335383. OL 7035758M.
• Stretton, Clement Edwin (1892). The Locomotive Engine and Its Development: A popular treatise on the gradual improvements made in railway engines between 1803 and 1892 (1 ed.). London: Crosby Lockwood. OCLC 503789724.
• Stretton, Clement Edwin (1903). The Locomotive Engine and Its Development: A popular treatise on the gradual improvements made in railway engines between 1803 and 1903 (6 ed.). London: Crosby Lockwood. OCLC 265878314. OL 20443807M.
• Thomas, Ronald H. G. (1980). The Liverpool & Manchester Railway. London: Batsford. ISBN 0-7134-0537-6.
• Thomas, Ronald H. G. (1986) [1972]. London's First Railway: The London and Greenwich. Batsford. ISBN 9780713454147. OCLC 915881410. OL 6395959W.
• Various (1842). "Railway Correspondence". Letter to Lords of the Privy Council for Trade.
• Whishaw, Francis (1842) [1840]. The Railways of Great Britain and Ireland practically described and illustrated (2nd ed.). London: John Weale (1840 publisher - Simpkin, Marshall & Co.). OCLC 36383414.