Ethical eating

Ethical eating or food ethics refers to the moral consequences^[1][2] of food choices, both those made by humans and animals. Common concerns are damage to the environment,^[3] exploitive labor practices, food shortages for others, inhumane treatment of food animals, and the unintended effects of food policy.^[4] Ethical eating is a type of ethical consumerism.

Concerns

Environmental

See also: Environmental impact of agriculture, Environmental impact of meat production, Environmental impact of fishing, and Sustainable diet

 

Cattle grazing in Texas

The extent of environmental impacts depends on the methods of food production and types of food. The Union of Concerned Scientists advises that avoiding eating beef may potentially help the environment,^[5] because of the large amounts of water needed to produce beef, the pollution from fecal, ammonia, carbon dioxide and methane waste associated with raising cows, the physical damage from grazing, and the destruction of wildlife habitat and rainforests to produce land for grazing.^[5] Industrially produced meat, such as that from animals raised in concentrated animal feeding operations (CAFOs), has "the greatest impact of any food product on the environment".^[3] Livestock production takes up the majority of agricultural land use, which ultimately results in the increase of methane and nitrous oxide emissions. These two gases are known for being harmful and damaging to the environment. It also takes 7 kilograms of grain to produce 1 kilogram of beef, and the process to convert this requires even more energy and water usage.^[6] This poses another ethical dilemma, which is choosing to feed the cattle over people in poverty. The latter is what brings in the most revenue, so that is where the attention and resources go towards.

Packaging of commercially produced foods is also an area of concern,^[3] because of the environmental impact of both the production of the packaging and the disposal of the packaging.

Transportation of commercially produced goods can influence the environmental impact of the food products.^[3]

Labor practices

See also: Fair Trade

Within the food system there are many low-paid occupations. Many farm workers are paid below-minimum wages^[7] or work in substandard conditions, especially farm workers in developing countries and migrant workers in industrialized nations. Through the H-2A guest worker program, farms are able to hire for seasonal work or sometimes grant visas to workers. Due to the cost of this program, the administration of the program has been delayed. Year-round food and farm industries have become reliant on undocumented labor because they are unable to use the H-2 guest worker program. More recently, the topic of concern has been over labor shortages. The solution is investing into automation; new technologies have developed to the point where robots can now perform the tasks of an employee. Jobs within food processing^[8] catering^[9] and food retailing^[10] are also often poorly paid and sometimes hazardous. The conditions in the fields require repetition of the same movements-with little to no breaks, and the workers are oftentimes exposed to toxic chemicals used on the crops. Factory farms are just as dangerous, as workers inhale gas from manure pits. The hydrogen sulfide in the manure has been known to cause bronchitis in the lungs, among other threatening health conditions. Although meat packing plant workers receive better pay, they risk their well-being on the job. The work is presented like an assembly line, and the employees each have to go through the same motions at a fast pace. Many employees have been sent to the hospital from incidents related to the knives and machinery they use.^[11]

Distribution of wealth

Since the 1980s, policies promoting global free trade have increased the amount of food exported from poorer countries, which may adversely affect the food available for their own populations.^[12] Campaign to reduce levels of food imports, however, may reduce the incomes of farmers in poorer countries, who rely on export sales.^[13]

Food availability

Since the 1970s, the food system has become increasingly global and a small number of multi-national corporations now dominate trade in many food products.^[14] One result is that the proportion of industrially processed foods in diets is increasing globally.^[15]

Animal welfare

The welfare of animals who are farmed for food is considered a major source of concern, especially when they are farmed intensively, which can lead to negative welfare outcomes.^{[citation needed]}

Specific food choices

 

Take a Bite Out Of Climate Change flashcards

Meat

 

Free-range pigs grazing at Polyface Farm, which promotes 'more sustainable' methods of animal husbandry

Main article: Ethics of eating meat

Some ethicists argue that the keeping and killing of animals for human consumption is in itself unethical.^[16][17] Others point out that animal husbandry is "essential to sustainable farms, which don't rely on fossil fuels and chemicals," rather using animal waste as fertilizer and animal activity as weed and pest control and using animals to "convert vegetation that's inedible to humans, and growing on marginal, uncultivated land, into food."^[1][18]

The method in which food animals are raised and the type of food animal affect the ethics of eating that animal. Farm-raising is a method of raising food animals with lesser environmental impacts.^[19]

Dairy and eggs

Dairy and egg production have ethical consequences, in particular in large-scale industrialized production. Chickens and milk-animals raised in industrial operations are often treated less fairly for commercial purposes.

Male chicks serve no use in the egg industry because they can't lay eggs or be used for meat production. Shortly after hatching they are separated and placed onto a conveyor belt to be killed. Sick and weak female chicks are also inspected and grouped together with the males to be terminated. The two ways of doing this involve either being thrown into a grinder or being gassed to death. The healthy females are transported to another facility where they grow until they are able to lay eggs. Once those chickens are unable to produce more eggs, they are then killed. This usually happens around 18 months, which is premature for their typical lifespan.^[20] This is due to the unnatural conditions for the chickens, such as confinement in battery cages, surgical beak procedures, forced molting, and genetic mutations that lead to health complications.^[21]

Small-scale production of eggs, such as by backyard chicken raisers and small diversified farms raising pastured birds or milk-animals, are less ethically fraught but still create some issues for ethicists.

Seafood

See also: Sustainable seafood advisory lists and certification

Industrial fishing has broad effects with ethical consequences. An example is nutrient and chemical pollution. The seafood industry has also been criticized due to issues with forced labor. Much of the seafood in the United States is imported from overseas, which means that certain regulations are out of jurisdiction and no longer apply. The standards aren't as high in other countries, which has led to problems with extortion. For example, Thailand has been known to participate in illegal, unregulated, and unreported fishing. Ships and vessels depend on third parties for recruitment, meaning U.S. companies that get seafood from international locations are unable to keep track of supply chains. It's common for these third party agencies to hire migrants, who are easier to take advantage because of their vulnerability. Human trafficking has been another issue in some regions.^[22]

Crops

Some foods produced in developing countries are exported in quantities that threaten the ability of local residents to affordably obtain their traditional foods. Western demand for quinoa, a traditional food in Bolivia Peru and Ecuador, has become so high that producers are eating significantly less of the grain, preferring to sell it for import instead and sparking concerns about malnutrition.^[23]

Criticism

See also: Fair trade debate

Some critics of the food ethics movement argue that parsing the various concerns is futile.^[1]

Fairtrade International, the certifying body for Fair Trade products, has been accused of "misleading consumers about its ability to monitor production practices"^[7] and giving Fairtrade certification to at least one coffee association despite the fact they were "illegally growing some 20 per cent of its coffee in protected national forest land."^[7]

References

1. "Put Your Ethics Where Your Mouth Is". New York Times. Retrieved August 13, 2015.
2. "ETHICAL EATING: FOOD AND ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE". Unitarian Universalist Association. 2014-10-30. Retrieved August 13, 2015.
3. Newcomer, Laura (August 24, 2012). "33 Ways to Eat Environmentally Friendly". Time. Retrieved August 15, 2015.
4. "2011 Statement of Conscience". Unitarian Universalist Association. 2011-08-24. Retrieved August 13, 2015.
5. Boyan, Steve. "How Our Food Choices can Help Save the Environment". EarthSave. Retrieved August 15, 2015.
6. "Food and climate change". David Suzuki Foundation. Retrieved 2021-12-02.
7. Weitzman, Hal (2006-09-08). "The bitter cost of 'fair trade' coffee". Financial Times. Retrieved August 15, 2015.
8. Broadway, Michael J.; Stull, Donald D. (2010-04-26). "The Wages of Food Factories". Food and Foodways. 18 (1–2): 43–65. doi:10.1080/07409711003708413. ISSN 0740-9710. S2CID 146528219.
9. Woolever, Laurie (2012-03-22). "High-End Food, Low-Wage Labor". Dissent. 59 (2): 26–32. doi:10.1353/dss.2012.0036. ISSN 1946-0910. PMID 22834046. S2CID 37118259.
10. Lichtenstein, Nelson (2005-01-01). "Wal-Mart and the New World Order: A Template for Twenty-First Century Capitalism?". New Labor Forum. 14 (1): 20–30. doi:10.1080/1095760590901063. JSTOR 40342518.
11. "Labor and Workers in the Food System". FoodPrint. Retrieved 2021-12-02.
12. Brigham, Anne Margrethe (2011-11-01). "Agricultural Exports and Food Insecurity in Sub-Saharan Africa: A Qualititative Configurational Analysis". Development Policy Review. 29 (6): 729–748. doi:10.1111/j.1467-7679.2011.00554.x. ISSN 1467-7679. S2CID 154819179.
13. Vidal, John; editor, environment (2007-10-25). "Air-freight food must pass fair trade test to retain organic label in future". The Guardian. ISSN 0261-3077. Retrieved 2017-02-21. {{cite news}}: |last2= has generic name (help)
14. Lang, Tim (2003-09-01). "Food Industrialisation and Food Power: Implications for Food Governance". Development Policy Review. 21 (5–6): 555–568. doi:10.1111/j.1467-8659.2003.00223.x. hdl:10535/6192. ISSN 1467-7679. S2CID 63385285.
15. Kearney, John (2010-09-27). "Food consumption trends and drivers". Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences. 365 (1554): 2793–2807. doi:10.1098/rstb.2010.0149. ISSN 0962-8436. PMC 2935122. PMID 20713385.
16. Zevnik, Neil (January 26, 2015). "The Humane Omnivore: An Oxymoron?". The Huffington Post. Retrieved August 13, 2015.
17. Pilgrim, Karyn (2013-05-01). "'Happy Cows,' 'Happy Beef': A Critique of the Rationales for Ethical Meat". Environmental Humanities. 3 (1): 111–127. doi:10.1215/22011919-3611257. ISSN 2201-1919.
18. Niman, Nicolette Hahn (December 20, 2011). "Eating Animals". The Atlantic. Retrieved August 13, 2015.
19. Cox, Christopher (April 7, 2010). "It's Okay for Vegans to Eat Oysters". Slate. Retrieved August 13, 2015.
20. "What the egg industry does to millions of day-old chicks will horrify you". www.animalsaustralia.org. Retrieved 2021-12-02.
21. thehumaneleague.org https://thehumaneleague.org/article/factory-farmed-chickens. Retrieved 2021-12-02. {{cite web}}: Missing or empty |title= (help)
22. Thiry, Marissa; RDN (20 April 2021). "The Complexities of Ethical Eating | Food & Nutrition Magazine | Volume 10, Issue 2". foodandnutrition.org. Retrieved 2021-12-02.
23. Collyns, Dan (January 14, 2013). "Quinoa brings riches to the Andes". The Guardian. Retrieved August 13, 2015.

Further reading

• Kaplan, David M. (ed.). The Philosophy of Food, University of California Press, 2012.
• Hardy, Anne, (2016). "Food Poisoning: An On-going Saga". History & Policy.