New York City Board of Aldermen

For the modern legislature, see New York City Council.

The New York City Board of Aldermen was a body that was the upper house of New York City's Common Council from 1824 to 1875, the lower house of its Municipal Assembly upon consolidation in 1898 until the charter was amended in 1901 to abolish the Municipal Assembly and its upper house, and its unicameral legislature from 1875 to 1897 and 1902 to 1937. The corresponding lower house was known as the Board of Assistants or the Board of Assistant Aldermen from 1824 to 1875, while the upper house was known as the Council^[b] from 1898 to 1901. In 1938 a new charter came into effect that replaced the Board of Aldermen with the New York City Council.

Board of Aldermen of the City of New York
The seal of New York City depicted in 1915
Type
Type	Upper house (1824–1875) Lower house (1898–1901) Unicameral (1875–1897, 1902–1937)
History
Established	1824
Disbanded	1937
Leadership
President	William F. Brunner^[a]
Meeting place
New York City Hall

Upper house (1824–1875)

Municipal legislators had been known as "aldermen" since at least April 1686,^[1] and had historically sat in the "Common Council" alongside so-called "assistant aldermen". In 1824 an Act of the New York State Legislature made the Common Council bicameral by dividing it into a Board of Aldermen and a Board of Assistants. Under the Act the City was divided into wards which each elected one member to the Board of Aldermen and two to the Board of Assistants.^[2] Aldermen served two-year terms which were staggered such that half of the Board was elected every year while assistants were elected annually.^[2] This made the Common Council bicameral as both Boards were separate bodies who possessed veto power over each other's proceedings.^[2] The Mayor was made the presiding officer of the Board of Aldermen, and in his absence the City Recorder, either person possessing only a casting vote in the Board.^[2] In an 1897 retrospective the Board of Assistant Aldermen would be known as the "lower branch" of the Common Council.^[3]

The New York State Legislature passed a bill in 1872 abolishing bicameralism in the fallout of Boss Tweed's corruption, which lavished on the assistant aldermen.^[3] At the time fifteen aldermen were elected at-large and one assistant alderman was elected from each Assembly district.^[3] The Senate had introduced an amendment to the new Charter that would have retained the Board of Assistant Aldermen but the amendment was dropped.^[4] Under the bill the Board of Aldermen would have comprised 45 members with 9 elected from each Senate district^[5] via cumulative voting.^[6] The Board would have elected its President from its own membership.^[7] The Mayor would have had veto power over each ordinance, which the Board could override with a two-thirds vote.^[8] Governor John T. Hoffman vetoed the bill, claiming that New York City was too important for the experimental nature of the bill's provisions.^[9]

An act was definitively passed in 1873, abolishing the Board of Assistant Aldermen as of the first Monday of January 1875 (January 4), and thereby making the Common Council unicameral and coterminous with the Board of Aldermen.^[10] This was not uncontroversial, supporters of bicameralism arguing that the Board of Assistant Aldermen better represented local interests and served as a check against the at-large Board of Aldermen. A body claiming to be the Board of Assistant Aldermen composed mainly of former members met in January 1875 and argued that the 1873 Act was unconstitutional, although only two new members were elected thereto. Mayor William H. Wickham prohibited them from meeting and refused to recognize them, but they nevertheless held a meeting on January 20, entering the chamber clandestinely to avoid arrest.^[11]

Unicameral council (1875–1897)

The Board of Aldermen under the 1873 act comprised 27 members elected annually, 6 elected at-large and 21 elected from State Senate districts with three from each district.^[12] Cumulative voting was limited, with a voter being entitled to vote for up to two aldermen in the district races and up to four aldermen in the at-large race.^[12] The Board elected its President from among its membership.^[13]

Lower house (1898–1901)

When New York City annexed much of its surroundings and assumed its modern form in 1898, a new city charter was passed that reintroduced a bicameral legislature, this time known as the "Municipal Assembly".^[14] This was not uncontroversial; The New York Times noted the corruption associated with the City's previous attempt at bicameralism.^[3] Under this system the Council was elected from special districts that each elected three members except for the districts representing Queens and Staten Island, which elected two members.^[15] Each member of the Board of Aldermen was elected from an Assembly district except for those representing Queens, where one member was elected from the former Long Island City and Newtown and one member from the remainder.^[16] The President of the Council was directly elected by citizens of the City^[17] while the President of the Board of Aldermen was selected from among its membership.^[18] This bicameralism invited comparisons to the state legislature, with The Brooklyn Eagle comparing the Council to "the State Senate ... [as] a superior body."^[19]

Abolition

The return to bicameralism proved to be short-lived, however, when a new charter passed in 1901 entailed removing the Council and making the President of the Board of Aldermen directly elected by City citizens.^[20] This charter entered into effect in January 1902, making the municipal legislature once again unicameral.

Return to unicameralism (1902–1937)

The new unicameral Board comprised aldermen elected from special districts at one per district, the President of the Board of Aldermen, who was elected citywide, and the Borough presidents. There were initially 73 districts, although in later years this was reduced to 65. The term of the President was four years while aldermen served two-year terms. Heads of administrative departments had seats in the Board and could be compelled to answer questions of it and participate in debate, but were not entitled to vote.

New charter

Plans were made in the 1930s to introduce a new city charter that would replace the Board of Aldermen with a smaller City Council that would be elected from each borough via proportional representation. This was in large part due to the large Democratic majorities in the Board of Aldermen.^[21] The Board convened for the last time on December 21, 1937.^[21]

Proportional representation was abolished in 1947 due in large part to its opening up the possibility of Communist council members being elected.^[22]

Notes

1. As of December 21, 1937.
2. Without any such preceding modifier as "Common" or "City"

References

1. "New York City at last to have an official flag and regain her ancient seal". The Sun. Vol. 132, no. 237. April 25, 1915. Retrieved December 7, 2018 – via Newspapers.com.
2. "AN ACT to alter the Organization of the Common Council of the city of New York". The Evening Post. May 26, 1824. p. 4. Retrieved May 2, 2019 – via Newspapers.com.
3. "Former Experiments Failed". The New York Times. March 7, 1897. Retrieved December 7, 2018 – via Newspapers.com.
4. "The Charter". New York Daily News. No. 13, 025. April 19, 1872. p. 3. Retrieved May 2, 2019 – via Newspapers.com.
5. 1872 Bill §2
6. 1872 Bill §4
7. 1872 Bill §7
8. 1872 Bill §10
9. "The Charter Vetoed". The New York Times. May 1, 1872. Retrieved May 2, 2019 – via Newspapers.com.
10. 1873 Act §2
11. "Another move by the Assistant Aldermen". The New York Times. January 21, 1875. Retrieved May 2, 2019 – via Newspapers.com.
12. 1873 Act §4
13. 1873 Act §6
14. 1898 Charter §17
15. 1898 Charter §19
16. 1898 Charter §24
17. 1898 Charter §18
18. 1898 Charter §26
19. "The Municipal Assembly". The Brooklyn Eagle. April 17, 1898. Retrieved April 25, 2019 – via Newspapers.com.
20. "New Charter's effect on City affairs". The Brooklyn Daily Eagle. August 1, 1901. Retrieved December 9, 2018 – via Newspapers.com.
21. "The Board of Aldermen sang its Swan song". The Brooklyn Citizen. December 22, 1937. Retrieved April 24, 2019.
22. Lee, Dick (October 27, 1947). "PR Called Costly to City; Voters to Decide Its Fate". New York Daily News. Retrieved April 24, 2019.

Bibliography

• "An Act to reorganize the local government of the city of New York". New York Daily Herald. No. 13, 025. April 19, 1872. pp. 3–4. Retrieved May 2, 2019 – via Newspapers.com.
• "An Act to Reorganize the Local Government of the City of New York". New York Daily Herald. No. 13, 388. April 17, 1873. pp. 6–7. Retrieved May 2, 2019 – via Newspapers.com.
• The Charter of the City of New York, Chapter 378 of the Laws of 1897, With amendments passed in 1898 and 1899, and a complete index, and maps of boroughs. Eagle library. Vol. Xiv, no. 6, serialno. 35. Eagle Building, Brooklyn: Office of Publication. September 1899. Retrieved December 9, 2018.