Battle of Puebla

Not to be confused with Siege of Puebla (1847) or Siege of Puebla (1863).

Battle of Puebla
Part of the Second French intervention in Mexico
Batalla del 5 de mayo de 1862
Date 5 May 1862 Location Puebla, Puebla, Mexico Result Mexican victory^[1]^[2]
Belligerents
Mexico	France
Commanders and leaders
Ignacio Zaragoza Porfirio Díaz Miguel Negrete Felipe Berriozábal	Charles de Lorencez
Strength
3,791^[3]	5,730^[3]
Casualties and losses
87 killed^[3] 252 wounded^[3] 12 missing Total: 351 men	131 killed^[3] 345 wounded^[3] Total: 476 men

The Battle of Puebla (Spanish: Batalla de Puebla; French: Bataille de Puebla), also known as the Battle of May 5 (Spanish: Batalla del 5 de Mayo) took place on 5 May, Cinco de Mayo, 1862, near Puebla de los Ángeles, during the Second French intervention in Mexico. French troops under the command of Charles de Lorencez repeatedly failed to storm the forts of Loreto and Guadalupe situated on top of the hills overlooking the city of Puebla, and eventually retreated to Orizaba in order to await reinforcements. Lorencez was dismissed from his command, and French troops under Élie Frédéric Forey would eventually take the city, but the Mexican victory at Puebla against a better equipped^[4] force provided patriotic inspiration to the Mexicans.

The anniversary of the victory is primarily celebrated in the Mexican state of Puebla,^[5][6][7][8] where the holiday is celebrated as El Día de la Batalla de Puebla (English: The Day of the Battle of Puebla).^[9][10][11] There is some limited recognition of the holiday in other parts of the country. In the United States, Cinco de Mayo has evolved into a holiday celebration of Mexican heritage.

Background

The Tripartite Expedition

The French intervention in Mexico, initially supported by the United Kingdom and Spain, was a consequence of Mexican President Benito Juárez's imposition of a two-year moratorium of loan-interest payments from July 1861 to French, British, and Spanish creditors.

On December 14, 1861, a Spanish fleet sailed into and took possession of the port of Veracruz. The city was occupied on the 17th.^[12] French and English forces arrived on January 7, 1862. On January 10 a manifesto was issued by Spanish General Juan Prim disavowing rumors that the allies had come to conquer or to impose a new government. It was emphasized that the three powers merely wanted to open negotiations regarding their claims of damages.^[13]

On January 14, 1862, a bill of claims was presented to the government in Mexico City. Foreign Minister Manuel Doblado invited the commissioners to travel to Orizaba with two thousand of their own troops for a conference while requesting that the rest of the tripartite forces disembark from Veracruz.^[14] The proposal to disembark most of the troops was rejected, but negotiations then resulted in an agreement, ratified on January 23, to move the forces inland and hold a conference at Orizaba. The agreement also officially recognized the government of Juarez along with Mexican sovereignty.^[15]

The French invasion begins

On April 9, 1862, agreements at Orizaba between the allies broke down, as France made it increasingly clear that it intended to invade Mexico and interfere in its government in violation of previous treaties. The British informed the Mexican government that they now intended to exit the country, and an arrangement was made with the British government to settle its claims.^[16] Minister Doblado on April 11 made it known to the French government that its intentions would lead to war.

Certain Mexican officers had been sympathetic to the French since the beginning of the intervention. On April 16, 1862, the French issued a proclamation inviting Mexicans to join them in establishing a new government. On April 17, 1862, Mexican general Juan Almonte, who had been a foreign minister of the conservative government during the Reform War, and who was brought back to Mexico by the French, released his own manifesto, assuring the Mexican people of benevolent French intentions.^[17]

The French defeated a small Mexican force at Escamela, and then captured Orizaba. Mexican Generals Porfirio Diaz and Ignacio Zaragoza retreated to El Ingenio, and then headed towards Puebla.^[18]

General Charles de Lorencez led 6,000 French troops to attack Puebla de Los Angeles in May 1862, certain that the French would win the war in Mexico quickly. Juarez assembled a ragged group of faithful soldiers at his new base of operations in the north and dispatched them to Puebla. Britain and Spain bargained with Mexico before withdrawing, but Napoleon III's France opted to take advantage of the available space to create an empire based on Mexico.^[19] A well-armed French warship invaded Veracruz late in 1861, landing a sizable French army and forcing President Juarez and his administration into exile.

Almonte now attempted to consolidate the Mexican pro-French movement. The town of Orizaba joined him and so did the port of Veracruz and Isla del Carmen. Colonel Gonzales, Manuel Castellanos, Desiderio Samaniego, Padre Miranda, and Haro Tamariz, and General Antonio Taboada arrived in Orizaba to support Almonte.^[20] On April 28, 1862, French forces headed towards Puebla.

Prelude

On May 2 the French army and the Mexican troops under Antonio Taboada reached Amozoc, and on the 4th pitched their camp within the sight of Puebla. Lorencez intended on immediately taking the forts of Loreto and Guadalupe, whose possession would assure him control of the city. Juan Almonte and Antonio de Haro y Tamariz had advised Lorencez to attack an orchard of the Convento del Carmen opposite the fortified heights of Guadalupe and Loreto, which was not done. They had also previously advised Lorencez to simply bypass Puebla and march on to the capital.^[21] Mexican historian Francisco Bulnes remarked that Lorencez lacked the men to starve out the city, lacked the artillery to take it by intimidation, lacked the men and artillery to take it by gradual assaults, and could only attempt to storm it in a risky manner that could have scarcely hoped to succeed.^[22]

The Mexican Republican army arrived in Puebla on May 3. On the 4th Arteaga's division now under the command of General Miguel Negrete, occupied the Guadalupe and Loreto Forts. The remainder of the forces took up quarters in the city.^[23]

Battle

 

Map of the battle terrain

At half past eleven Lorencez arranged an attack column made up of two battalions of zouaves, one battery commanded by Captain Bernard, and four pieces of Captain Mallat's marine artillery. ^[24] The regiment of marine infantry and marine riflemen formed the reserve along with a mountain gun. They were meant to protect the rear of the attack columns, which was threatened by the Mexican cavalry on the right. To contain a Mexican force which was threatening the left, he charged L’Heriller to protect with four battalions of marine infantry the convoy which he placed at a convenient location. Cavalry was assigned to place itself between the convoy and the attack columns, which now awaited orders to attack.^[25]

The two battalions of zouaves now set their backpacks on the foot of the hill and began their ascent marching in columns by division and between them carrying ten pieces of horse artillery. They headed to their right towards the Fort of Guadalupe.^[26] According to a report telegraphed by General Zaragoza to the central government, the fighting broke out at noon.^[27] The strategy of attacking the most difficult, fortified, and heavily armed point caught the attention of General Zaragoza, as it now seemed that the French had tossed aside the military maxim of achieving a victory with the least amount of losses possible in favor of bravado.^[28] Zaragoza upon noticing that the attack was going to come via a direct assault on the forts, and who had a large body of this troops on standby for attack now changed his strategy. He gave orders for the forts of Loreto and Guadalupe to be reinforced.^[28] The French division advanced and when opposite the Guadalupe fort, halted and planted its artillery to fire upon the Guadalupe and the Loreto forts. After shelling them for two hours, a strong column preceded by sharpshooters advanced upon Fort Guadalupe by the northern side. Felipe Berriozábal was then ordered to reinforce the two hills.^[29] A portion of the cavalry was divided into two bodies, one of which was placed under Colonel Alvarez and the other under Colonel Trujano. The rest were to be commanded by Colonel Felix Diaz.^[30]

France's army was extremely advanced compared to Mexico's during the time of the battle. French soldiers were equipped with long rifles that could easily outgun the Mexicans' antiquated muskets when they arrived at Puebla on May 4.^[19] At the onset of battle, French soldiers underestimated the defensive capacity of the Mexican positions, to the point that many didn't bother to properly assemble their weaponry. The French attempted to intimidate the civilian population on the morning of May 5 with loud bugle cries and complex bayonet drills. They were forced to retire, however, as a result of significant casualties, following a full day of warfare that included three miserably failed uphill attacks.

The French in their ascent towards Fort Guadalupe experienced little opposition and only a few casualties from the fort's guns. They had completed half of the ascent when they were met by two battalions of Mexican infantry, which after exchanging shots with French sharpshooters, returned to their position. The French troops continued their ascent while Mexican cavalry under the cover of a maguey field remained still. The Mexican infantry also under the same cover kept firing upon the French. The ascending column now turned diagonally towards the right, as if going between the two forts, and the two forts now took advantage of the opportunity to fire upon the French troops. Finding themselves assailed from all quarters by infantry and cavalry, the French retreated and were pursued by Mexican forces, but the pursuit was given up when another French column came to the support of the retreating troops.^[31]

The two French columns now pushed on together towards the Guadalupe and Resurrection chapel. The two columns combined and split into three. This second attack on the east and the north of the city was much more vigorous. The two columns which attempted an assault on the hill from the north again were completely routed.^[32] General Diaz with portions of his brigade and other troops and two pieces of artillery checked and drove away the French columns which were marching against the Mexican positions.^[33] The third French column which reached the east side just as the others were repulsed was also defeated. The Mexican cavalry then charged upon the remaining French and prevented their reorganization for further assaults.^[34]

The French and the Mexicans continue to face each other until seven in the evening when the French returned to their camp at Los Alamos and then to Orizaba on the 8th to await reinforcements which were on their way from France.^[35]

Aftermath

The Battle of Puebla was an inspirational event for Mexico during the war, and it proved a stunning revelation to the rest of the world which had largely expected a rapid victory for French arms.^[36] The victory filled the government of Benito Juarez with high hopes. Zaragoza received the thanks of congress, and was awarded a sword. The city name of Puebla de los Ángeles was changed to Puebla de Zaragoza. Honors and rewards were decreed to the officers and men who took part in the action. Zaragoza sent the government the medals and decorations taken on the battlefield as well of those from prisoners, but President Juarez returned them along with the French prisoners of war.^[37] General Zaragoza would not live long after the victory as he died four months later due to typhoid fever. A decree issued by Benito Juárez established the major annual event cinco de mayo.

Despite already having some collaborators, the French attributed their defeat at Puebla to a wider lack of Conservative Party support.^[38] Only two days after the battle the Mexican General Taboada who had collaborated with the French during the battle wrote to his liberal friend, Tomás O'Horán, inviting him to join the French, arguing that they wished to establish a stable government and would bring order to the country.^[39][40] O'Horan would reject the offer, even fighting against the ultimately triumphant Siege of Puebla that the French carried out the following year, but O'Horan eventually would defect to join the forces of the Second Mexican Empire.

Slowed by their loss at Puebla, the French forces retreated and regrouped, and the invasion continued after Napoleon III determinedly sent additional troops to Mexico and dismissed General Lorencez. The French were eventually victorious, winning the Second Battle of Puebla on 17 May 1863 and pushing on to Mexico City. When the capital fell, Juárez's government was forced into exile in the remote northern parts of Mexico.

With the backing of France, the Second Empire of Mexico was established, with the Habsburg Archduke Maximilian as Emperor of Mexico.

General Porfirio Diaz who had played a notable role during the battle would continue to distinguish himself as one of the most important liberal commanders throughout the Second French intervention, and even escaped after being captured by the French. After the end of the Intervention and the fall of the Empire, he would attempt to overthrow the government of Benito Juarez before eventually becoming the President of Mexico in 1876.

The political decision taken by President Franklin D. Roosevelt to implement the "Good Neighbor Policy," which was intended to promote links with Latin American nations and people, was one of the key factors in the popularization of "Cinco de Mayo" in the United States. As a result of the Roosevelt administration's promotion of the holiday, Cinco de Mayo gained popularity in the 1950s and 1960s and eventually became a recognized national holiday. While the original celebrations in the United States were localized among Mexican immigrants from the state of Puebla commemorating the battle, over time, the origins of the holiday have become less emphasized and the date has evolved into a general celebration of Mexican culture by immigrants and their descendants from all parts of Mexico.^[41] A comparable phenomenon can be found in the evolution of St. Patrick's Day from an ecclesiastical holiday marking the arrival of Christianity in Ireland to a largely secularized celebration of Irish-American culture.

 

An image of Fort Guadalupe

Celebration

On 9 May 1862, President Juárez declared that the anniversary of the Battle of Puebla would be a national holiday,^{[42][43][44][45][46]} regarded as "Battle of Puebla Day" or "Battle of Cinco de Mayo".^[47]

Cinco de Mayo is not the national day of Mexico, as is sometimes misunderstood.^[48] The most important national patriotic holiday in Mexico is Independence Day, on 16 September,^[49] commemorating the 1810 "Cry of Dolores" call-to-arms, that began the War of Independence.^[50] Mexico also observes the culmination of the war of Independence, which lasted 11 years, on 27 September.

Cinco de Mayo is day of celebration for the Hispanics is a tradition that takes place on May 5 to mark the date that Mexico defeated the Second French Empire in the Battle of Puebla in 1862, under the command of General Ignacio Zaragoza, a Texas native. The Mexicans' morale was boosted by their win over the bigger and better armed French army with a smaller, less well-equipped Mexican force, which included 500 other Tejanos.^{[51][citation needed]}

Since the 1930s, a re-enactment of the Battle of Puebla has been held each year at Peñón de los Baños, a rocky outcrop close to Mexico City International Airport.^[52]

What most do not realize is that the “Battle of Puebla” is celebrated just as much if not more in America than it is in Mexico, some say it is a way that Mexican Americans can show patriotism towards their roots and traditions, but it has also always been overshadowed by occasions like September 16 Independence Day, which marks the beginning of hostilities against Spanish control in 1810.^[45] Contrarily, Cinco de Mayo became popular in the United States in the 1960s when Chicano activists started seeking for a means to celebrate their heritage. The largest Cinco de Mayo festivities currently take place in American cities with sizable Hispanic populations, such Los Angeles, Houston, and San Antonio. It is a common misconception among non-Mexicans that Cinco de Mayo commemorates the declaration of Mexican independence, which occurred around 50 years before the Battle of Puebla.^[45] On Cinco de Mayo there are multiple different ways that they celebrate this event, some of these being parades, speeches, and recreations of the 1862 fight. In the middle of the 20th century, Mexican immigrants in the United States began to take pride in their Mexican ancestry by celebrating Cinco de Mayo. The main cause for rejoicing in Mexico is a win in war.

The American celebration of Cinco de Mayo is more about honoring Mexican culture in general. In 1863, Americans started celebrating as a show of support for Mexico against the French.^[45] Critics noted that many American celebrations tended to both perpetuate negative stereotypes of Mexicans and promote excessive drinking, and that enthusiasm for the holiday celebration did not catch on with a wider demographic until it was associated with the promotion of Mexican alcoholic beverages. Commercial interests from both Mexico and the United States have contributed to the promotion of the event with goods and services that highlight Mexican cruises, drinks, and celebrations, with music taking on a more prominent role. Since parades and concerts are held in many American towns the week before May 5, Cinco de Mayo has grown in popularity both north and south of the border and is now included in the calendars of more and more people.^[53]

See also

• List of battles of the French intervention in Mexico
• Monument for the 150th Anniversary of the Battle of Puebla

References

1. Christopher Minster (2011). . About.com. Archived from the original on 4 March 2016. Retrieved 17 November 2017.
2. Booth, William (5 May 2011). "In Mexico, Cinco de Mayo a more sober affair". The Washington Post. Retrieved 17 November 2011.
3. Clodfelter, M. (2017). Warfare and Armed Conflicts: A Statistical Encyclopedia of Casualty and Other Figures, 1492-2015 (4th ed.). Jefferson, North Carolina: McFarland. p. 304. ISBN 978-0-7864-7470-7.
4. The following sources are mentioning that Zaragoza was heading 12,000 troops : see The Cinco de Mayo and French Imperialism – Hicks, Peter, Fondation Napoléon, and General Gustave Léon Niox book, Expédition du Mexique : 1861–1867, published in 1874 by Librairie militaire de J. Dumaine, p. 162 Read online
5. "Cinco de Mayo". Mexico Online: The Oldest and most trusted online guide to Mexico.
6. Lovgren, Stefan (2006-05-05). . National Geographic News. Archived from the original on September 8, 2006.
7. List of Public and Bank Holidays in Mexico 2009-04-16 at the Wayback Machine April 14, 2008. This list indicates that Cinco de Mayo is not a día feriado obligatorio ("obligatory holiday"), but is instead a holiday that can be voluntarily observed.
8. Cinco de Mayo is not a federal holiday in México Accessed May 5, 2009
9. Día de la Batalla de Puebla. 5 May 2011. "Dia de la Batalla de Puebla: 5 de Mayo de 1862." 24 March 2012 at the Wayback Machine Colegio Rex: Marina, Mazatlan. Retrieved 25 May 2011.
10. Día de la Batalla de Puebla (5 de Mayo). Guia de San Miguel. 2012-05-12 at the Wayback Machine Retrieved 25 May 2011.
11. Retrieved 25 May 2011.
12. Bancroft, Hubert Howe. History of Mexico VI: 1861–1887. New York: The Bancroft Company. p. 29.
13. Bancroft, Hubert Howe. History of Mexico VI: 1861–1887. New York: The Bancroft Company. p. 35.
14. Bancroft, Hubert Howe. History of Mexico VI: 1861–1887. New York: The Bancroft Company. p. 38.
15. Bancroft, Hubert Howe. History of Mexico VI: 1861–1887. New York: The Bancroft Company. p. 40.
16. Bancroft, Hubert Howe. History of Mexico VI: 1861–1887. New York: The Bancroft Company. p. 42.
17. Bancroft, Hubert Howe. History of Mexico VI: 1861–1887. New York: The Bancroft Company. p. 44.
18. Bancroft, Hubert Howe. History of Mexico VI: 1861–1887. New York: The Bancroft Company. p. 46.
19. "Outnumbered Mexican army defeats French at Battle of Puebla". History.com. Retrieved 2022-11-10.
20. Bancroft, Hubert Howe. History of Mexico VI: 1861–1887. New York: The Bancroft Company. p. 46.
21. Bancroft, Hubert Howe (1888). History of Mexico volume VI: 1861–1867. p. 47.
22. Bulnes, Francisco (1904). El Verdadero Juarez y la Verdad Sobre La Intervencion Y El Imperio (in Spanish). p. 117.
23. Bancroft, Hubert Howe (1888). History of Mexico volume VI: 1861–1867. p. 47.
24. Zamacois, Niceto (1880). Historia de Mexico Tomo XI (in Spanish). JF Parres. p. 184.
25. Zamacois, Niceto (1880). Historia de Mexico Tomo XVI (in Spanish). JF Parres. p. 185.
26. Zamacois, Niceto (1880). Historia de Mexico Tomo XI (in Spanish). JF Parres. p. 185.
27. Zamacois, Niceto (1880). Historia de Mexico Tomo XVI (in Spanish). JF Parres. pp. 185–186.
28. Zamacois, Niceto (1880). Historia de Mexico Tomo XI (in Spanish). JF Parres. p. 186.
29. Bancroft, Hubert Howe (1888). History of Mexico volume VI: 1861–1867. p. 48.
30. Bancroft, Hubert Howe (1888). History of Mexico volume VI: 1861–1867. p. 49.
31. Bancroft, Hubert Howe (1888). History of Mexico volume VI: 1861–1867. p. 49.
32. Bancroft, Hubert Howe (1888). History of Mexico volume VI: 1861–1867. p. 49.
33. Bancroft, Hubert Howe (1888). History of Mexico volume VI: 1861–1867. p. 50.
34. Bancroft, Hubert Howe (1888). History of Mexico volume VI: 1861–1867. p. 49.
35. Bancroft, Hubert Howe (1888). History of Mexico volume VI: 1861–1867. p. 50.
36. Beezley, William H. (2011). Mexico in World History. Oxford: Oxford University Press. p. 71. ISBN 978-0-19-515381-1. Retrieved 17 November 2011.
37. Bancroft, Hubert Howe (1888). History of Mexico volume VI: 1861–1867. pp. 50–51.
38. Bancroft, Hubert Howe (1888). History of Mexico volume VI: 1861–1867. p. 51.
39. Shawcross, Edward (2018). "Towards Pan-Latinism". France, Mexico and Informal Empire in Latin America, 1820-1867. pp. 119–155 [136]. doi:10.1007/978-3-319-70464-7_4. ISBN 978-3-319-70463-0.
40. Taboada, Antonio (May 8, 1862). "Carta de Antonio Taboada al Gral. Tomás O'Horan" (in Spanish). Letter to Tomás O'Horan.
41. Redd, Kandace (5 May 2021). "A brief history of Cinco de Mayo, from the Battle of Puebla to growing celebrations in California". ABC10.
42. Burton, Tony (16 July 2020). "Cinco de Mayo is more widely celebrated in USA than Mexico". MexConnect.
43. Burton, Tony (2 May 2011). "Cultural adaptation: the Cinco de Mayo holiday is far more widely celebrated in the USA than in Mexico". Geo-Mexico.^{[self-published source?]}
44. Pavon, Ana-Elba; Borrego, Diana (2003). "Benito Juárez Silhouette". 25 Latino Craft Projects: Celebrating Culture in Your Library Series. American Library Association. p. 14. ISBN 978-0-8389-0833-4.^{[better source needed]}
45. Greenspan, Jesse (3 May 2023). "7 Things You May Not Know About Cinco de Mayo". History.
46. Congressional Record – House. p. 7488. May 9, 2001. Retrieved 29 April 2013. Note that contrary to most other sources, this source states the date Juarez declared Cinco de Mayo to be a national holiday was 8 September 1862.
47. Statement by Mexican Consular official 2007-09-30 at the Wayback Machine Accessed May 8, 2007.^{[failed verification]}
48. Ray, Michael (4 May 2022). "Is Cinco de Mayo Mexico's Independence Day?". Encyclopedia Britannica.
49. . Alpine Avalanche. Archived from the original on 26 April 2009.^{[unreliable source?]}
50. Central Intelligence Agency (2011). "The World Factbook: Mexico". CIA. Retrieved 17 November 2011.
51. "History of Cinco de Mayo and Tejanos role in the battle of Puebla". 5 May 2023.
52. Burton, Tony (5 May 2011). "The Battle of Puebla is re-enacted each year on Cinco de Mayo (May 5), but in Mexico City".^{[self-published source?]}
53. Purvis, John (2017-05-04). "Why is Cinco de Mayo more popular in the U.S. than Mexico?". KFOX. Retrieved 2022-11-10.

External links

 

Wikimedia Commons has media related to Battle of Puebla.

• French Intervention in Mexico: Battle of Puebla 2017-02-18 at the Wayback Machine
• Phil's Findings: Did Battle of Puebla change the course of U.S. history? by Philip A. Rue

19°03′N 98°12′W / 19.05°N 98.20°W / 19.05; -98.20