Actor's and Sin
Actors and Sin is a 1952 American comedy film written, produced and directed by Ben Hecht.[2] The film marks Edward G. Robinson's second film with actress Marsha Hunt.[3][4][5] It is also known by its section names of Actor's Blood and Woman of Sin. Lee Garmes was codirector and cinematographer, as he was on most of the films that Hecht directed.
| Actors and Sin | |
|---|---|
| Directed by | Ben Hecht Lee Garmes (co-director) |
| Written by | Ben Hecht |
| Produced by | Ben Hecht |
| Starring | Edward G. Robinson Eddie Albert Marsha Hunt |
| Narrated by | Dan O'Herlihy Ben Hecht |
| Cinematography | Lee Garmes |
| Edited by | Otto Ludwig |
| Music by | George Antheil |
| Color process | Black and white |
Production company | |
| Distributed by | United Artists |
Release date |
|
Running time | 86 minutes |
| Country | United States |
| Language | English |
Plot
The film lampoons the Hollywood motion picture industry and is separated into two sections. The first section is Actor's Blood, a morality play about legitimate theater. The second section is Woman of Sin, a send-up of Hollywood greed.
Actor's Blood takes place in New York City. Broadway star Marcia Tillayou has been found shot dead in her apartment. Her father Maurice is himself an actor, and had watched her theater career rise as his own declined. She had let success overcome her, and had thus alienated critics, fans, producers and her playwright husband. She had a few recent stage flops before being murdered.
Woman of Sin takes place in Hollywood. Dishonest writers' agent Orlando Higgens has been receiving frantic calls from Daisy Marcher about a screenplay that she had written titled Woman of Sin. Thinking they are crank calls, Higgens tells her to never again call his office. He then learns that because of a mail mixup, her screenplay had been received by film mogul J.B. Cobb, a man who had once passed on Gone With the Wind based on Higgins' advice. Cobb thinks that Higgins sent the script and offers him a lucrative sum for the rights. However, Higgins does not know where Daisy is or that she is actually a nine-year-old child.
Cast
Actor's Blood sequence:
- Dan O'Herlihy as Alfred O'Shea, Narrator
- Edward G. Robinson as Maurice Tillayou
- Marsha Hunt as Marcia Tillayou
- Rudolph Anders as Otto Lachsley
- Peter Brocco as Frederick Herbert
- Robert Carson as Thomas Hayne
- Herb Bernard as Emile
- Alice Key as Miss Thompson, Tommy
- Irene Martin as Mrs. Murray
- Joseph Mell as George Murray
- Ric Roman as Clyde Veering
- Elizabeth Root as Mrs. Herbert
Woman of Sin sequence:
- Ben Hecht as Narrator
- Eddie Albert as Orlando Higgens
- Alan Reed as Jerome (J.B.) Cobb
- Jenny Hecht as Millicent Egelhofer, Daisy Marcher
- George Baxter as Vincent Brown
- John Crawford as Gilbert, Movie Actor
- Douglas Evans as Mr. Devlin
- Paul Guilfoyle as Mr. Blue
- Sam Rosen as Danello
- Tracey Roberts as Miss Flanagan
- Toni Carroll as Millicent, Movie Star
- Jody Gilbert as Mrs. Egelhofer
- George Keymas as Bill Sweitzer, Producer
- Alan Mendez as Captain Moriarity
- Kathleen Mulqueen as Miss Wright
- Cameo appearances by:
- Betty Field, Louis B. Mayer, and Jack L. Warner
Reception
In a contemporary review for The New York Times, critic Howard Thompson characterized the film as "an almost reverential close-up of a stage actor's senile egomania and an atomically conceived blast at front-office intellectuality in the film factories." Thompson called Actor's Blood a "stiff, glum and narcissistic tale ... the whole episode flounders midway between a conversational seance and a straight farce" and Woman of Sin "straight farce, with an idea so devastatingly impudent that only Mr. Hecht could claim it."[1]
In reference to the film's two sections, DVD Talk writes "Both are light, breezy, and inconsequential, though admittedly written with an expert's ear for dialogue and a knack for clever story twists." They write that both sections "move at an efficient pace", and praise Ben Hecht for the dialog and rhythm of his scripts. They also note that the actors were well chosen, finding flaw only in the child actors used in the Woman of Sin segment. They did have critique about the material itself, noting that while Hecht knew his way around both Hollywood and Broadway, the subject matter comes off as a little "too inside". They were also disappointed in the two stories, finding the plotlines "fairly hokey and predictable". However, and despite the "hackneyed narrative", they found the film overall to be "very watchable", in that Hecht's sense of timing kept the project from being boring.[6]
DVD Verdict wrote that "the most intriguing element" of the film, and not properly promoted by the film's trailer, is that "it is actually two brief films combined in one package." In analyzing Actor's Blood, they wrote that there was "an opportunity for insight and depth in this story, but it would seem that Mr. Hecht wrote the screenplay while in a blind rage." They offered that the material might even have been comedic but for it being "preposterously heavy-handed". They felt that the actors generally spoke each line over-dramatically and floundered, with only Edward G. Robinson "able to make this work within the context of his character". In their analysis of Woman of Sin, they found it to be "reasonably engaging early on as a breezy satire", despite the concept of a story written by a nine-year-old "earning words of praise and adoration from the likes of Jack Warner and Louis B. Mayer". They noted that the cameos by the studio heads were amusing, but that the story was derailed by the use of Ben Hecht's daughter Jenny in the role of child screenwriter Daisy Marcher. They felt that she was "fingernails-on-a-blackboard grating" in this role, in that she "dials up every aspect of precociousness that can afflict a child actor as high as it can possibly go, and her presence effectively destroys any sense of comic momentum that the film had built up to that point," making her use a clear example of the problems inherent in nepotism.[7] They concluded that the film would stand as "an interesting curiosity for Hollywood history buffs, but fails as a cinematic experience."[7]
Controversy
Upon original release, several theater chains refused to screen the film because it lampoons of stage and screen. This resulted in a lawsuit by United Artists and Sid Kuller Productions against the A. B. C. Theatres Company.[8]
References
- ^ a b Thompson, Howard (1952-05-30). "The Screen: Three Films in Premieres Here". The New York Times. p. 11.
- ^ Debut of a Sinner. Time. Vol. 32. Life magazine. Jun 23, 1952. pp. 121–122, 124. ISSN 0024-3019.
- ^ Robert Beck (2002). The Edward G. Robinson encyclopedia. McFarland. p. 21. ISBN 0-7864-1230-5.
- ^ Society of Arts and Crafts (Detroit, Mich.) (1952). Theatre arts, Volume 36. Theatre Arts, Inc. pp. 42, 85.
- ^ Laurie Scheer (2002). Creative careers in Hollywood. Allworth Communications, Inc. pp. 46–47. ISBN 1-58115-243-4.
- ^ Jamie S. Rich (October 17, 2009). "review: Actors And Sin: Actor's Blood, Woman of Sin ". DVD Talk. Retrieved May 22, 2011.
- ^ a b Clark Douglas (September 25, 2009). "review: Actors And Sin". DVD Verdict. from the original on 18 May 2011. Retrieved May 22, 2011.
- ^ "HECHT'S NEW FILM IN A LEGAL BATTLE; Coast Theatre Refuses to Show 'Actors and Sin' – Producer Seeks Injunction in Court". The New York Times. July 16, 1952. Retrieved May 22, 2011.