1856 Toronto municipal election

The 1856 City of Toronto Municipal Election was the city's 22nd municipal election. Polling occurred on the first Monday and Tuesday of the year, January 7th and 8th. Elections for Aldermen and Councilmen were held in seven wards and for the Municipal License Inspector.

City of Toronto 1856 Municipal Election

← 1855 January 7, 1856 (1856-01-07) 1857 →
All 28 members of Toronto City Council Mayor appointed by majority of City Council
Nominees for Mayor Candidate John Beverley Robinson (elected 15 - 11) John Hutchison

After the election, John Beverley Robinson a member of the family compact and strong supporter of the railroads, was elected Mayor by City Council, beating John Hutchison a Toronto merchant, who had a reputation for opposing corruption.

Background

By the standards of 1850s civic politics, where riots disrupted voting in 1855 and 1857, the election of the Council for 1856 was quiet.^[1] The issues that animated the campaign included awarding a major public works contract to complete The Esplanade, the controversy around establishing Separate Schools for Roman Catholics, and taverns licenses.^[2]

The Esplanade Contract

In 1853, the City of Toronto passed the Esplanade Act to fill in land along the city's waterfront to provide a route for railways to cross the city and a public promenade along the waterfront. The contract was awarded to Gzowski and Company to construct the Esplanade, but multiple issues created a scandal, and in April 1855, City Council voted to annul the contract. However, the decision to cancel the contract led the Grand Trunk Railway, depending on the waterfront route, to threaten to place its track along Queen Street. This led to numerous public meetings and tremendous public pressure to finish the Esplanade.^[3]

City Council negotiated with the Grand Trunk Railway during the election campaign to construct the Esplanade. A primary concern was who was obligated to pay for crossings over the rail corridor, the city, or the railway.^[4] A special meeting was called on January 13, 1856, after the election but before the new City Council was sworn in to approve the contract, with the modification that the city was responsible for paying for and building any ramps or bridges over the railway tracks, instead of the Grand Trunk Railway. Despite the previous controversies, the outgoing City Council approved the contract unanimously.^[5]

Election of the Mayor

After the municipal election, City Council convened on January 21, 1856, to elect a Mayor. The proceedings were well-attended, with the gallery filled with spectators eager to witness a contest between John Beverley Robinson, who represented the Family Compact and John Hutchison, supported by the city's burgeoning mercantile community.^[6]

Alderman Dunn nominated Robinson for the position of Mayor, with the motion seconded by Councilman Davis. Alderman Dunn argued in favor of Robinson. He was the most qualified candidate and the only St. Patrick's Ward nominee not represented in the mayoral office for some time. Alderman Crooks nominated John Hutchison for Mayor, challenging Robinson's competency and criticizing him for not taking an interest in Council business when he was Alderman in 1854 and for not running for Council in 1855. Crooks also accused Robinson of arranging Councilman Moodie's absence from Council for the vote.^[7]

In an attempt to influence the mayoral election, Councilman Moodie, an employee of the Grand Trunk Railway and a vocal supporter of Hutchison, was dispatched by his employer to Montreal three days before the election of the Mayor by City Council, despite his objections.^[8] Notwithstanding the controversy, Robinson was elected Mayor by a majority of 4, with the motion carried 15 to 11.^[7]

City Council Results

Each ward elected 2 Aldermen and 2 Councilmen. There were ten open seats in the 1856 election, and 15 members of the City Council stood for re-election. Two incumbents lost, Angus Morrison (elected to the Provincial assembly in the summer of 1854) and William Graham.^[9]

St. James' Ward
Position	Candidate		Votes	%	±	Vote for Mayor
Aldermen	John Harrington	Elected	427	40.9%	N/A	Yea
	John Hutchison	Elected	346	33.1%	N/A	Nay
	Hewitt	Lost	272	26.0%	N/A	N/A
Councilmen	John Wilson(X)	Elected	317	32.4%	+2.3%	Yea
	John Cameron	Elected	244	25.0%	N/A	Nay
	Thompson	Lost	174	17.8%	N/A	N/A
	Mitchell	Lost	158	16.2%	N/A	N/A
	A.H. St. Germain	Lost	84	8.6%	N/A	N/A
St. Andrew's Ward
Position	Candidate		Votes	%	±	Vote for Mayor
Aldermen	John Worthington	Elected	279	41.9%	N/A	Yea
	R.P. Crooks (X)	Elected	205	30.8%	-4.9%	Nay
	Ritchey	Lost	182	27.3%	N/A	N/A
Councilmen	Henry Prettie (X)	Elected	276	42.9%	+15.2%	Yea
	Henry Sproat	Elected	229	35.6%	N/A	Yea
	Charles Fisher	Lost	138	21.5%	+3.7%	N/A
St. John's Ward
Position	Candidate		Votes	%	±	Vote for Mayor
Aldermen	John Bugg (X)	Elected	347	52.1%	+16.3%	Nay
	Richard Dempsey	Elected	319	47.9%	+15.8%	Yea
Councilmen	Robert Moodie	Elected	336	46.8%	+12.6%	Absent
	Joseph Rowell (X)	Elected	241	33.6%	+3.6%	Nay
	Carnegie	Lost	141	19.6%	N/A	N/A
St. David's Ward
Position	Candidate		Votes	%	±	Vote for Mayor
Aldermen	William Henderson (X)	Elected	340	37.0%	-3.2%	Nay
	John George Bowes	Elected	318	34.6%	N/A	Yea
	Brooke	Lost	261	28.4%	N/A	N/A
Councilmen	Adam Beatty (X)	Elected	328	32.8%	-10.1%	Yea
	John Carruthers (X)	Elected	235	23.5%	-13.8%	Nay
	James Mallon	Lost	221	22.1%	N/A	N/A
	William Ramsey	Lost	215	21.5%	N/A	N/A
St. Lawrence Ward
Position	Candidate		Votes	%	±	Vote for Mayor
Aldermen	Alexander Manning	Elected	204	39.1%	+12.0%	Nay
	William Strachan	Elected	180	34.5%	N/A	Nay
	D.K. Feehan	Lost	138	26.4%	N/A	N/A
Councilmen	William Davis	Elected	199	36.2%	N/A	Yea
	William Murphy (X)	Elected	176	32.0%	-5.7%	Yea
	Ernest	Lost	175	31.9%	N/A	N/A
St. George's Ward
Position	Candidate		Votes	%	±	Vote for Mayor
Aldermen	John Duggan (X)	Elected	172	42.1%	-5.5%	Nay
	G.A. Philpotts(X)	Elected	122	29.8%	-5.9%	Yea
	Brunel	Lost	115	28.1%	N/A	N/A
Councilmen	Geo. Neeting	Elected	127	35.4%	N/A	Nay
	Edward Wright (X)	Elected	131	36.5%	+5%	Absent
	James Myers	Lost	101	28.1%	+4.4%	N/A
St. Patrick's Ward
Position	Candidate		Votes	%	±	Vote for Mayor
Aldermen	John Beverley Robinson	Elected	279	47.3%	Candidate
	Johnathan Dunn (X)	Elected	171	29.0%	-21.7%	Yea
	Adam Wilson (X)	Lost	140	23.7%	-25.6%	N/A
Councilmen	T. Shortis	Elected	231	40.4%	N/A	Yea
	Theophilus Earls (X)	Elected	206	36.0%	-6.9%	Yea
	Reeves	Lost	135	23.6%	N/A	N/A

References

1. Russell, Victor Loring, ed. (1984). Forging a consensus : historical essays on Toronto. Victor Loring Russell, Toronto. Sesquicentennial Board. Toronto: Published for the Toronto Sesquicentennial Board by University of Toronto Press. p. 100. ISBN 978-1-4875-8021-6. OCLC 988215315.
2. "Mr St. Germain's Address: To the Electors of St. James' Ward". The Globe (1844-1936). December 28, 1855. p. 3.
3. Goheen, Peter G. (2000). "The Struggle for Urban Public Space: Disposing of the Toronto Waterfront in the Nineteenth Century". In Murphy, Alexander B.; Johnson, Douglas L.; Haarman, Viola (eds.). Cultural Encounters with the Environment : Enduring and Evolving Geographic Themes. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc. pp. 60–66. ISBN 0-7425-0105-1.
4. "The Grand Trunk Railway Entering the City". The Globe (1844-1936). November 21, 1855. p. 1108.
5. "Special Meeting of City Council: Settlement of the Esplanade Difficulty". The Globe (1844-1936). January 14, 1856. p. 2.
6. "The Mayoralty". The Globe. January 16, 1856. p. 2.
7. "City Council Proceedings - Election of Mayor". The Globe. January 22, 1856. p. 2.
8. "The Mayoralty: Infamous Conduct of the Grand Trunk Company". The Globe. January 19, 1856. p. 2.
9. "The City Election". The Globe (1844-1936). January 7, 1856. p. 2.