fbpx
Wikipedia

Brownfield land

Brownfield refers to land that is abandoned or underutilized due to pollution from industrial use.[1] The specific definition of brownfield land varies and is decided by policy makers and/or land developers within different countries.[2][3] The main difference in definitions of whether a piece of land is considered a brownfield or not depends on the presence or absence of pollution.[2][4] Overall, brownfield land is a site previously developed for industrial or commercial purposes and thus requires further development before reuse.[2][5]

Example of brownfield land at a disused gasworks site after excavation, with soil contamination from removed underground storage tanks

Examples of post industrial brownfield sites include abandoned factories, dry cleaning establishments, gas stations, etc.[6][3] Typical contaminants include hydrocarbon spillages, solvents and pesticides, as well as heavy metals like lead, asbestos, petroleum, etc.[7][8]

Many contaminated post-industrial brownfield sites sit unused because the cleaning costs may be more than the land is worth after redevelopment. Previously unknown underground wastes can increase the cost for study and clean-up.[9] Depending on the contaminants and damage present adaptive re-use and disposal of a brownfield can require advanced and specialized appraisal analysis techniques.[9]

Definition edit

Canada edit

The Federal Government of Canada defines brownfields as "abandoned, idle or underutilized commercial or industrial properties [typically located in urban areas] where past actions have caused environmental contamination, but which still have potential for redevelopment or other economic opportunities."[10]

United States edit

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) defined brownfield not simply as a possible improvement site which has been previously improved, but one that may also have impediments, such as "the presence or potential presence of a hazardous substance, pollutant, or contaminant".[11] This comports well with an available general definition of the term, which scopes to "industrial or commercial property".[1]

The term brownfields first came into use on June 28, 1992, at a U.S. congressional field hearing hosted by the Northeast Midwest Congressional Coalition. Also in 1992, the first detailed policy analysis of the issue was convened by the Cuyahoga County, Ohio Planning Commission. EPA selected Cuyahoga County as its first brownfield pilot project in September 1993.[12] The term applies more generally to previously used land or to sections of industrial or commercial facilities that are to be upgraded.[13]

In 2002, President George W. Bush signed the Small Business Liability Relief and Brownfields Revitalization Act (the "Brownfields Law") which provides grants and tools to local governments for the assessment, cleanup, and revitalization of brownfields. The motivation for this act was the success of the EPA's brownfields program, which it started in the 1990s in response to several court cases that caused lenders to redline contaminated property for fear of liability under the Superfund. As of September 2015, the EPA estimates that the Brownfields program has resulted in 56,442 acres of land readied for reuse.[14]

Mothballed brownfields are properties that the owners are not willing to transfer or put to productive reuse.[15]

Brownfield status is a legal designation which places restrictions, conditions or incentives on redevelopment and use on the site.[16]

United Kingdom edit

In the United Kingdom, brownfield land and previously developed land (PDL) have the same definition under the National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF).[17][18] The government of the United Kingdom refers to them both as: "Land which is or was occupied by a permanent structure, including the curtilage of the developed land (although it should not be assumed that the whole of the curtilage should be developed) and any associated fixed surface infrastructure."[18][19]

They exclude land that: "is or has been occupied by agricultural or forestry buildings; has been developed for minerals extraction or waste disposal by landfill purposes where provision for restoration has been made through development control procedures; land in built-up areas such as private residential gardens, parks, recreation grounds and allotments; and land that was previously developed but where the remains of the permanent structure or fixed surface structure have blended into the landscape in the process of time."[18][19]

Locations and contaminants edit

 
An abandoned factory, an example of what may be considered brownfield land

Generally, post industrial brownfield sites exist in a city's or town's industrial section, on locations with abandoned factories or commercial buildings, or other previously polluting operations like steel mills, refineries or landfills.[20]

Small brownfields also may be found in older residential neighborhoods, as for example dry cleaning establishments or gas stations produced high levels of subsurface contaminants.

Typical contaminants found on contaminated brownfield land include hydrocarbon spillages, solvents, pesticides, heavy metals such as lead (e.g., paints), tributyl tins, and asbestos.[20] Old maps may assist in identifying areas to be tested.

Brownfield status by country edit

The primary issue facing all nations involved in attracting and sustaining new uses to brownfield sites is globalization of industry.[citation needed] This directly affects brownfield reuse, such as limiting the effective economic life of the use on the revitalized sites.[citation needed]

Canada edit

Canada has an estimated 200,000 "contaminated sites" across the nation.[citation needed] As of 2016 Canada had about 23,078 federally recognized contamination sites, from abandoned mines, to airports, lighthouse stations, and military bases, which are classified into N 1,2,or 3, depending on a score of contamination, with 5,300 active contaminated sites, 2,300 suspected sites and 15,000 listed as closed because remediated or no action was necessary.[21][22]

The provincial governments have primary responsibility for brownfields.[citation needed] The provinces' legal mechanisms for managing risk are limited, as there are no tools such as "No Further Action" letters to give property owners finality and certainty in the cleanup and reuse process.[citation needed] Yet, Canada has cleaned up sites and attracted investment to contaminated lands such as the Moncton rail yards.[citation needed] A strip of the Texaco lands in Mississauga is slated to be part of the Waterfront Trail.[citation needed] However, Imperial Oil has no plans to sell the 75-acre (30 ha) property which has been vacant since the 1980s.

According to their 2014 report on federally listed contaminated sites, the Parliamentary Budget Officer estimated that the "total liability for remediating Canada's contaminated sites reported in the public accounts [was] $4.9 billion."[23]: 1  The report listed significant sites called the Big Five with a liability of $1.8 billion: Faro mine, Colomac Mine, Giant Mine, Cape Dyer-DEW line and Goose Bay Air Base. The Port Hope, Ontario site has a liability of $1 billion.[23] Port Hope has the largest volume of historic low-level radioactive wastes in Canada, resulting from "radium and uranium processing in Port Hope between 1933 and 1988 by the former Crown corporation Eldorado Nuclear Limited and its private sector predecessors.[24][25] By 2010 it was projected that it would cost well over a billion dollars for the soil remediation project, it was the largest such cleanup in Canadian history. The effort is projected to be complete in 2022.[26] In July 2015 the $86,847,474 contract "to relocate the historic low-level radioactive waste and marginally contaminated soils from an existing waste management facility on the shoreline of Lake Ontario to the new, state-of-the-art facility about a kilometre north of the current site." was undertaken.[24] There is also "$1.8 billion for general inventory sites" and "$200 million for other sites."[23]: 1  The same report claimed the inventory currently lists 24,990 contaminated sites."

The federal government exercises some control over environmental protection, the "provincial and territorial governments issue the bulk of legislation regarding contaminated sites."[23]: 4–5  Under the Shared-Responsibility Contaminated Sites Policy Framework (2005), the government may provide funding for the remediation of nonfederal sites, if the contamination is related to federal government activities or national security. See Natural Resources Canada (2012)

Denmark edit

While Denmark lacks the large land base which creates the magnitude of brownfield issues facing countries such as Germany and the U.S., brownfield sites in areas critical to the local economies of Denmark's cities require sophisticated solutions and careful interaction with affected communities. Examples include the cleanup and redevelopment of former and current ship building facilities along Copenhagen's historic waterfront. Laws in Denmark require a higher degree of coordination of planning and reuse than is found in many other countries.

France edit

In France, brownfields are called friches industrielles and the Ministère de l'Écologie, du Développement Durable et de l'Énergie (MEDDE) maintains a database of polluted sites named BASOL, with "more than 4000 sites".[27] of about 300,000 to 400,000 potentially polluted sites total (around 100,000 ha),[28] in a historical inventory named BASIAS, maintained by the Agence de l'Environnement et de la Maitrise de l'Energie (ADEME).

Hong Kong edit

Developing brownfield land is considered by the public as one of the most popular ways to increase housing in Hong Kong.[29] The Liber Research Community has found 1,521 hectares of brownfield land in Hong Kong, and has found that almost 90% of existing uses of the land could easily be moved into multi-story buildings, freeing up land that could be used efficiently for housing.[30] In June 2021, Liber Research Community and Greenpeace East Asia collaborated and found a new total of 1,950 hectares of brownfield sites, 379 more hectares than the government was previously able to locate.[31]

Germany edit

Germany loses greenfields at a rate of about 1.2 square kilometres per day for settlement and transportation infrastructure. Each of the approximately 14,700 local municipalities is empowered to allocate lands for industrial and commercial use. Local control over reuse decisions of German brownfield sites (Industriebrache) is a critical factor. Industrial sites tend to be remote due to zoning laws, and incur costly overhead for providing infrastructure such as utilities, disposal services and transportation.[citation needed] In 1989, a brownfield of the Ruhrgebiet became Emscher Park.[32]

United Kingdom edit

In the UK centuries of industrial use of lands which once formed the birthplace of the industrial revolution have left entire regions in a brownfield status. There are legal and fiscal incentives for brownfield redevelopment. Remediation laws are centered on the premise that the remediation should leave land safe and suitable for its current or intended use. In 2018, the Campaign to Protect Rural England (CPRE) reported that the 17,656 sites (covering over 28,000 hectares of land) identified by English local planning authorities on their Brownfield Land Registers would provide enough land for a minimum of 1 million homes, which could rise to over 1.1 million once all registers are published. The registers contain land that is available for redevelopment so is a small subset of all land that would be considered brownfield. There is also brownfield capacity in areas in which the green belt is in danger, for example in Northwest England , where local authorities have identified enough brownfield land to provide for 12 years of housing demand.[33]

The UK government has recognised the ecological importance of brownfield sites and has afforded some protection to such habitats through the United Kingdom Biodiversity Action Plan.[34] The Creekside Discovery Centre in Deptford, London is an urban wildlife centre encompassing brownfield habitats.[35]

United States edit

United States estimates suggest there are over 500,000 brownfield sites contaminated at levels below the Superfund caliber (the most contaminated) in the country.[citation needed] While historic land use patterns created contaminated sites, the Superfund law has been criticized as creating the brownfield phenomenon where investment moves to greenfields for new development due to severe, no-fault liability schemes and other disincentives.[citation needed] The Clinton-Gore administration and US EPA launched a series of brownfield policies and programs in 1993 to tackle this problem.[citation needed]

Redevelopment edit

Valuation and financing edit

Acquisition, adaptive re-use, and disposal of a brownfield site requires advanced and specialized appraisal analysis techniques. For example, the highest and best use of the brownfield site may be affected by the contamination, both before and after remediation. Additionally, the value should take into account residual stigma and potential for third-party liability. Normal appraisal techniques frequently fail, and appraisers must rely on more advanced techniques, such as contingent valuation, case studies, or statistical analyses.[36][failed verification] A 2011 University of Delaware study has suggested a 17.5:1 return on dollars invested on brownfield redevelopment.[37] A 2014 study of EPA brownfield cleanup grants from 2002 through 2008 found an average benefit value of almost $4 million per brownfield site (with a median of $2,117,982).[38] To expedite the cleanup of brownfield sites in the US, some environmental firms have teamed up with insurance companies to underwrite the cleanup and provide a guaranteed cleanup cost to limit land developers' exposure to environmental remediation costs and pollution lawsuits. The environmental firm first performs an extensive investigation generally in the form of desk studies and potentially further intrusive investigation.[39]

Remediation strategies edit

 
In Situ bioremediation, a method used to remove pollution from the soil located on brownfield land. This method is done on site instead of taking it elsewhere for processing.

Innovative remediation techniques used at distressed brownfields in recent years include in situ thermal remediation, bioremediation and in situ oxidation. Often, these strategies are used in conjunction with each other or with other remedial strategies such as soil vapor extraction. In this process, vapor from the soil phase is extracted from soils and treated, which has the effect of removing contaminants from the soils and groundwater beneath a site. Binders can be added to contaminated soil to prevent chemical leaching.[40] Some brownfields with heavy metal contamination have even been cleaned up through an innovative approach called phytoremediation, which uses deep-rooted plants to soak up metals in soils into the plant structure as the plant grows. After they reach maturity, the plants – which now contain the heavy metal contaminants in their tissues – are removed and disposed of as hazardous waste.[citation needed]

 
Phytoremediation, a method that can be used to remove pollutants from brownfield land. It uses plants to take up pollutants from the soil.

Research is under way to see if some brownfields can be used to grow crops, specifically for the production of biofuels.[41] Michigan State University, in collaboration with DaimlerChrysler and NextEnergy, has small plots of soybean, corn, canola, and switchgrass growing in a former industrial dump site in Oakland County, Michigan. The intent is to see if the plants can serve two purposes simultaneously: assist with phytoremediation, and contribute to the economical production of biodiesel and/or ethanol fuel.[citation needed]

The regeneration of brownfields in the United Kingdom and in other European countries has gained prominence due to greenfield land restrictions as well as their potential to promote the urban renaissance.[13] Development of brownfield sites also presents an opportunity to reduce the environmental impact on communities, and considerable assessments need to take place in order to evaluate the size of this opportunity.[42]

Barriers edit

Many contaminated brownfield sites sit unused for decades because the cost of cleaning them to safe standards is more than the land would be worth after redevelopment, in the process becoming involuntary parks as they grow over. However, redevelopment has become more common in the first decade of the 21st century, as developable land has become less available in highly populated areas, and brownfields contribute to environmental stigma which can delay redevelopment.[43] Also, the methods of studying contaminated land have become more sophisticated and costly.[citation needed]

Some states and localities have spent considerable money assessing the contamination on local brownfield sites, to quantify the cleanup costs in an effort to move the redevelopment process forward. Therefore, federal and state programs have been developed to help developers interested in cleaning up brownfield sites and restoring them to practical uses.[citation needed]

In the process of cleaning contaminated brownfield sites, previously unknown underground storage tanks, buried drums or buried railroad tank cars containing wastes are sometimes encountered. Unexpected circumstances increase the cost for study and clean-up. As a result, the cleanup work may be delayed or stopped entirely. To avoid unexpected contamination and increased costs, many developers insist that a site be thoroughly investigated (via a Phase II Site Investigation or Remedial Investigation) prior to commencing remedial cleanup activities.[citation needed]

Post-redevelopment uses edit

 
Brownfield relic serves as monument in a new park in Atlantic Station area of Atlanta, Georgia, U.S.
 
Residential development at former brownfield site in New Jersey
 
Pedestrians walking along hillside path in Seonyudo Park, Seoul, South Korea which was developed from a former brownfield site

Commercial and residential edit

As of 2006 the Atlantic Station project in Atlanta, was the largest brownfield redevelopment in the United States.[44] Dayton, like many other cities in the region, is developing Tech Town in order to attract technology-based firms to Dayton and revitalize the downtown area.[citation needed] In Homestead, Pennsylvania, the site once occupied by Carnegie Steel has been converted into a successful commercial center, The Waterfront.[citation needed]

Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, has successfully converted[when?] numerous former steel mill sites into high-end residential, shopping, and offices. Examples of brownfield redevelopment in Pittsburgh include:

Solar landfill edit

 
Solar arrays on a full landfill in Rehoboth, MA

A Solar landfill is a repurposed used landfill that is converted to a solar array solar farm.[45]

Regulation edit

United States edit

In the United States, Brownfield regulation and development is largely governed by state environmental agencies in cooperation with the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). In 1995, the EPA launched the Brownfields Program, which was expanded in 2002 with the Brownfields Law.[38] The EPA, together with local and national government, can provide technical help and some funding for assessment and cleanup.[38] From 2002 through 2013, the EPA awarded nearly 1,000 grants for clean up, for a total of almost $190 million. It can also provide tax incentives for cleanup that is not paid for outright; specifically, cleanup costs are fully tax-deductible in the year they are incurred.[46] Many of the most important provisions on liability relief are contained in state codes that can differ significantly from state to state.[47]

United Kingdom edit

In the United Kingdom, regulation of contaminated land comes from Part IIA of the Environmental Protection Act 1990; responsibility falls on local authorities to create a "contaminated land register". For sites with dubious past and present uses the Local Planning Authority may ask for a desktop study,[48] which is sometimes implemented as a condition in planning applications.[49] However by definition land that is derelict or underused is highly unlikely to be determined as contaminated land – especially due to risks to human health.

The key regulation of brownfield land is through the land use planning system when a new land use is being considered.

See also edit

References edit

  1. ^ a b . Brownfields Center. Washington, D.C.: Environmental Law Institute. Archived from the original on February 26, 2015.
  2. ^ a b c Jacek, Guillaume; Rozan, Anne; Desrousseaux, Maylis; Combroux, Isabelle (May 18, 2021). "Brownfields over the years: from definition to sustainable reuse". Environmental Reviews. 30: 50–60. doi:10.1139/er-2021-0017. S2CID 236348006.
  3. ^ a b Loures, Luis; Vaz, Eric (February 1, 2018). "Exploring expert perception towards brownfield redevelopment benefits according to their typology". Habitat International. Regional Intelligence: A new kind of GIScience. 72: 66–76. doi:10.1016/j.habitatint.2016.11.003. ISSN 0197-3975.
  4. ^ Tang, Yu-Ting; Nathanail, C. Paul (May 3, 2012). "Sticks and Stones: The Impact of the Definitions of Brownfield in Policies on Socio-Economic Sustainability". Sustainability. 4 (5): 840–862. doi:10.3390/su4050840. ISSN 2071-1050.
  5. ^ Alker, Sandra; Joy, Victoria; Roberts, Peter; Smith, Nathan (January 1, 2000). "The Definition of Brownfield". Journal of Environmental Planning and Management. 43 (1): 49–69. doi:10.1080/09640560010766. ISSN 0964-0568. S2CID 153395212.
  6. ^ Trouw, Michael; Weiler, Stephan; Silverstein, Jesse (March 6, 2020). "Brownfield Development: Uncertainty, Asymmetric Information, and Risk Premia". Sustainability. 12 (5): 2046. doi:10.3390/su12052046. ISSN 2071-1050.
  7. ^ Trouw, Michael; Weiler, Stephan; Silverstein, Jesse (January 2020). "Brownfield Development: Uncertainty, Asymmetric Information, and Risk Premia". Sustainability. 12 (5): 2046. doi:10.3390/su12052046. ISSN 2071-1050.
  8. ^ Green, T. L. (April 1, 2018). "Evaluating predictors for brownfield redevelopment". Land Use Policy. 73: 299–319. doi:10.1016/j.landusepol.2018.01.008. ISSN 0264-8377.
  9. ^ a b Chen, I-Chun; Chuo, Yu-Yu; Ma, Hwong-wen (April 1, 2019). "Uncertainty analysis of remediation cost and damaged land value for brownfield investment". Chemosphere. 220: 371–380. Bibcode:2019Chmsp.220..371C. doi:10.1016/j.chemosphere.2018.12.116. ISSN 0045-6535. PMID 30590303. S2CID 58557619.
  10. ^ "About contaminated sites". Federal Contaminated Sites Portal. Environment and Climate Change Canada. November 10, 2018. from the original on November 10, 2018.
  11. ^ "Overview of EPA's Brownfields Program". Washington, D.C.: United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). July 26, 2021.
  12. ^ "Brownfields Program Achievements Linked to Early Success" (PDF). EPA. October 2006. Fact sheet. EPA 560-F-06-267.
  13. ^ a b Maliene V, Wignall L, Malys N (2012). "Brownfield Regeneration: Waterfront Site Developments in Liverpool and Cologne". Journal of Environmental Engineering and Landscape Management. 20 (1): 5–16. doi:10.3846/16486897.2012.659030.
  14. ^ Thomas Voltaggio and John Adams. "Superfund: A Half Century of Progress." EPA Alumni Association. March 2016.
  15. ^ "Revitalizing Mothballed Properties: Challenges, Success Stories and Solutions". EPA. 2008. EPA 560-R-08-003.
  16. ^ US EPA, OLEM (July 24, 2014). "Summary of the Small Business Liability Relief and Brownfields Revitalization Act". www.epa.gov. Retrieved June 1, 2022.
  17. ^ "Brownfield land registers". GOV.UK. Retrieved February 20, 2023.
  18. ^ a b c "National Planning Policy Framework" (PDF). GOV.UK. Retrieved February 9, 2023.
  19. ^ a b "National Planning Policy Framework - Annex 2: Glossary - Guidance - GOV.UK". www.gov.uk. Retrieved February 20, 2023.
  20. ^ a b "Contaminated land -Overview". UK: Crown Copyright. November 10, 2016.
  21. ^ . Federal Contaminated Sites Portal, Environment Canada. October 3, 2016. Archived from the original on April 19, 2017. Retrieved February 16, 2017.
  22. ^ Environment and Climate Change Canada (December 7, 2022). "Action plan for contaminated sites". www.canada.ca. Retrieved March 24, 2023.
  23. ^ a b c d Rod Story, Tolga Yalkin (April 10, 2014). "Federal Contaminated Sites Cost" (PDF). Parliamentary Budget Officer (PBO). Ottawa, Ontario. p. 41. Retrieved September 5, 2015.
  24. ^ a b "Contracts Awarded for Port Hope Area Initiative". Natural Resources Canada. Ottawa, Ontario. July 30, 2015. Retrieved September 5, 2015.
  25. ^ . Archived from the original on August 20, 2009. Retrieved January 13, 2009.
  26. ^ Carola Vyhnak (November 9, 2010). "Port Hope properties tested for radiation". Toronto Star. Retrieved January 14, 2013.
  27. ^ "9. Combien y a-t-il de sites pollués ?". Ministère de l'Écologie, du Développement Durable et de l'Énergie (MEDDE). n.d.
  28. ^ "Les friches urbaines dans les SCoT et les PLU". ADEME. August 28, 2014.
  29. ^ "Brownfield site use and reclamation 'most popular' land supply options". South China Morning Post. September 2, 2018. Retrieved May 24, 2021.
  30. ^ "Government 'exaggerated constraints' in freeing up brownfield sites". South China Morning Post. December 20, 2018. Retrieved May 24, 2021.
  31. ^ "Hong Kong NGOs find enough unidentified brownfield sites to build 95,000 homes". South China Morning Post. June 10, 2021. Retrieved June 23, 2021.
  32. ^ "Emscher Park: From dereliction to scenic landscapes". Kopenhagen: Danish Architecture Centre. n.d.
  33. ^ "What are the barriers to brownfield development?".
  34. ^ https://cdn.buglife.org.uk/2019/08/Planning-for-Brownfield-Biodiversity.pdf
  35. ^ https://www.creeksidecentre.org.uk/about/
  36. ^ (PDF). Greenfield Advisors. Archived from the original (PDF) on July 11, 2011. Retrieved November 29, 2009. Article Author of "Valuation of Brownfields", Chapter 29 in Lexis-Nexis Matthew Bender's Brownfield Law and Practice, 2007.
  37. ^ Montgomery, Jeff (May 14, 2011). "Cleaning up contamination". The News Journal. New Castle, Delaware: Gannett. DelawareOnline. Archived from the original on May 14, 2011. Retrieved May 14, 2011. The first online page is archived; the page containing information related here is not in the archived version.
  38. ^ a b c Kriston Capps (July 29, 2014). "How Much Cleaning Up Brownfields Is Really Worth". The Atlantic Monthly.
  39. ^ Environmental, Oakshire. "Commercial development on contaminated land". Oakshire Environmental. from the original on March 17, 2021. Retrieved May 24, 2021.
  40. ^ "ASLA 2011 Professional Awards | The Steel Yard". www.asla.org. Retrieved June 22, 2019.
  41. ^ University, Michigan State. "Brownfields may turn green with help from Michigan State research". MSUToday. Retrieved June 22, 2019.
  42. ^ "Brownfield Sites". www.sustainablebuild.co.uk. September 11, 2006. Retrieved June 22, 2019.
  43. ^ Coming Back from Economic Despair. Henry Mayer and Micheal Greenburg. Economic Development Quarterly, August 2001.
  44. ^ "Building a City Within the City of Atlanta". The New York Times. May 24, 2006. Retrieved June 16, 2014.
  45. ^ https://time.com/6183376/landfills-becoming-solar-farms/
  46. ^ "Brownfields Tax Incentive" (URL). Environmental Protection Agency. Retrieved November 29, 2009.
  47. ^ "Brownfields Overview Page". National Conference of State Legislatures. Retrieved November 29, 2009.
  48. ^ Environmental, Oakshire. "What is a Phase 1 Preliminary Risk Assessment?". Oakshire Environmental. Retrieved November 25, 2019.
  49. ^ "Desktop Study Reports - London, Bristol & Exeter". Southwest Environmental Limited. n.d. Retrieved June 16, 2014.

Further reading edit

  • (PDF). Concerted Action on Brownfield and Economic Regeneration Network (Report). University of Nottingham. 2006. p. 3. ISBN 0-9547474-5-3. Archived from the original (PDF) on April 2, 2015.

External links edit

  • United States EPA Brownfields Homepage
  • Photographies of French Brownfields.
  • Photographies of German Brownfields.
  • cosponsored by the U.S. EPA and ICMA
  • From Industrial Wasteland to Community Park
  • From Brownfield to Greenfield: A New Working Landscape for Wellesley College Wrenched from its Toxic Past
  • The Brownfields Center at Carnegie Mellon University
  • Browninfo Methodology and Software for Development of Interactive Brownfield Databases
  • Brownfield Land at Curlie

brownfield, land, brownfield, redirects, here, other, uses, brownfield, disambiguation, brownfield, refers, land, that, abandoned, underutilized, pollution, from, industrial, specific, definition, brownfield, land, varies, decided, policy, makers, land, develo. Brownfield redirects here For other uses see Brownfield disambiguation Brownfield refers to land that is abandoned or underutilized due to pollution from industrial use 1 The specific definition of brownfield land varies and is decided by policy makers and or land developers within different countries 2 3 The main difference in definitions of whether a piece of land is considered a brownfield or not depends on the presence or absence of pollution 2 4 Overall brownfield land is a site previously developed for industrial or commercial purposes and thus requires further development before reuse 2 5 Example of brownfield land at a disused gasworks site after excavation with soil contamination from removed underground storage tanksExamples of post industrial brownfield sites include abandoned factories dry cleaning establishments gas stations etc 6 3 Typical contaminants include hydrocarbon spillages solvents and pesticides as well as heavy metals like lead asbestos petroleum etc 7 8 Many contaminated post industrial brownfield sites sit unused because the cleaning costs may be more than the land is worth after redevelopment Previously unknown underground wastes can increase the cost for study and clean up 9 Depending on the contaminants and damage present adaptive re use and disposal of a brownfield can require advanced and specialized appraisal analysis techniques 9 Contents 1 Definition 1 1 Canada 1 2 United States 1 3 United Kingdom 2 Locations and contaminants 3 Brownfield status by country 3 1 Canada 3 2 Denmark 3 3 France 3 4 Hong Kong 3 5 Germany 3 6 United Kingdom 3 7 United States 4 Redevelopment 4 1 Valuation and financing 4 2 Remediation strategies 4 3 Barriers 5 Post redevelopment uses 5 1 Commercial and residential 5 2 Solar landfill 6 Regulation 6 1 United States 6 2 United Kingdom 7 See also 8 References 9 Further reading 10 External linksDefinition editCanada edit The Federal Government of Canada defines brownfields as abandoned idle or underutilized commercial or industrial properties typically located in urban areas where past actions have caused environmental contamination but which still have potential for redevelopment or other economic opportunities 10 United States edit The U S Environmental Protection Agency EPA defined brownfield not simply as a possible improvement site which has been previously improved but one that may also have impediments such as the presence or potential presence of a hazardous substance pollutant or contaminant 11 This comports well with an available general definition of the term which scopes to industrial or commercial property 1 The term brownfields first came into use on June 28 1992 at a U S congressional field hearing hosted by the Northeast Midwest Congressional Coalition Also in 1992 the first detailed policy analysis of the issue was convened by the Cuyahoga County Ohio Planning Commission EPA selected Cuyahoga County as its first brownfield pilot project in September 1993 12 The term applies more generally to previously used land or to sections of industrial or commercial facilities that are to be upgraded 13 In 2002 President George W Bush signed the Small Business Liability Relief and Brownfields Revitalization Act the Brownfields Law which provides grants and tools to local governments for the assessment cleanup and revitalization of brownfields The motivation for this act was the success of the EPA s brownfields program which it started in the 1990s in response to several court cases that caused lenders to redline contaminated property for fear of liability under the Superfund As of September 2015 the EPA estimates that the Brownfields program has resulted in 56 442 acres of land readied for reuse 14 Mothballed brownfields are properties that the owners are not willing to transfer or put to productive reuse 15 Brownfield status is a legal designation which places restrictions conditions or incentives on redevelopment and use on the site 16 United Kingdom edit In the United Kingdom brownfield land and previously developed land PDL have the same definition under the National Planning Policy Framework NPPF 17 18 The government of the United Kingdom refers to them both as Land which is or was occupied by a permanent structure including the curtilage of the developed land although it should not be assumed that the whole of the curtilage should be developed and any associated fixed surface infrastructure 18 19 They exclude land that is or has been occupied by agricultural or forestry buildings has been developed for minerals extraction or waste disposal by landfill purposes where provision for restoration has been made through development control procedures land in built up areas such as private residential gardens parks recreation grounds and allotments and land that was previously developed but where the remains of the permanent structure or fixed surface structure have blended into the landscape in the process of time 18 19 Locations and contaminants edit nbsp An abandoned factory an example of what may be considered brownfield landGenerally post industrial brownfield sites exist in a city s or town s industrial section on locations with abandoned factories or commercial buildings or other previously polluting operations like steel mills refineries or landfills 20 Small brownfields also may be found in older residential neighborhoods as for example dry cleaning establishments or gas stations produced high levels of subsurface contaminants Typical contaminants found on contaminated brownfield land include hydrocarbon spillages solvents pesticides heavy metals such as lead e g paints tributyl tins and asbestos 20 Old maps may assist in identifying areas to be tested Brownfield status by country editThis article needs additional citations for verification Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources Unsourced material may be challenged and removed Find sources Brownfield land news newspapers books scholar JSTOR June 2022 Learn how and when to remove this template message The primary issue facing all nations involved in attracting and sustaining new uses to brownfield sites is globalization of industry citation needed This directly affects brownfield reuse such as limiting the effective economic life of the use on the revitalized sites citation needed Canada edit Canada has an estimated 200 000 contaminated sites across the nation citation needed As of 2016 update Canada had about 23 078 federally recognized contamination sites from abandoned mines to airports lighthouse stations and military bases which are classified into N 1 2 or 3 depending on a score of contamination with 5 300 active contaminated sites 2 300 suspected sites and 15 000 listed as closed because remediated or no action was necessary 21 22 The provincial governments have primary responsibility for brownfields citation needed The provinces legal mechanisms for managing risk are limited as there are no tools such as No Further Action letters to give property owners finality and certainty in the cleanup and reuse process citation needed Yet Canada has cleaned up sites and attracted investment to contaminated lands such as the Moncton rail yards citation needed A strip of the Texaco lands in Mississauga is slated to be part of the Waterfront Trail citation needed However Imperial Oil has no plans to sell the 75 acre 30 ha property which has been vacant since the 1980s According to their 2014 report on federally listed contaminated sites the Parliamentary Budget Officer estimated that the total liability for remediating Canada s contaminated sites reported in the public accounts was 4 9 billion 23 1 The report listed significant sites called the Big Five with a liability of 1 8 billion Faro mine Colomac Mine Giant Mine Cape Dyer DEW line and Goose Bay Air Base The Port Hope Ontario site has a liability of 1 billion 23 Port Hope has the largest volume of historic low level radioactive wastes in Canada resulting from radium and uranium processing in Port Hope between 1933 and 1988 by the former Crown corporation Eldorado Nuclear Limited and its private sector predecessors 24 25 By 2010 it was projected that it would cost well over a billion dollars for the soil remediation project it was the largest such cleanup in Canadian history The effort is projected to be complete in 2022 26 In July 2015 the 86 847 474 contract to relocate the historic low level radioactive waste and marginally contaminated soils from an existing waste management facility on the shoreline of Lake Ontario to the new state of the art facility about a kilometre north of the current site was undertaken 24 There is also 1 8 billion for general inventory sites and 200 million for other sites 23 1 The same report claimed the inventory currently lists 24 990 contaminated sites The federal government exercises some control over environmental protection the provincial and territorial governments issue the bulk of legislation regarding contaminated sites 23 4 5 Under the Shared Responsibility Contaminated Sites Policy Framework 2005 the government may provide funding for the remediation of nonfederal sites if the contamination is related to federal government activities or national security See Natural Resources Canada 2012 Denmark edit While Denmark lacks the large land base which creates the magnitude of brownfield issues facing countries such as Germany and the U S brownfield sites in areas critical to the local economies of Denmark s cities require sophisticated solutions and careful interaction with affected communities Examples include the cleanup and redevelopment of former and current ship building facilities along Copenhagen s historic waterfront Laws in Denmark require a higher degree of coordination of planning and reuse than is found in many other countries France edit In France brownfields are called friches industrielles and the Ministere de l Ecologie du Developpement Durable et de l Energie MEDDE maintains a database of polluted sites named BASOL with more than 4000 sites 27 of about 300 000 to 400 000 potentially polluted sites total around 100 000 ha 28 in a historical inventory named BASIAS maintained by the Agence de l Environnement et de la Maitrise de l Energie ADEME Hong Kong edit Developing brownfield land is considered by the public as one of the most popular ways to increase housing in Hong Kong 29 The Liber Research Community has found 1 521 hectares of brownfield land in Hong Kong and has found that almost 90 of existing uses of the land could easily be moved into multi story buildings freeing up land that could be used efficiently for housing 30 In June 2021 Liber Research Community and Greenpeace East Asia collaborated and found a new total of 1 950 hectares of brownfield sites 379 more hectares than the government was previously able to locate 31 Germany edit Germany loses greenfields at a rate of about 1 2 square kilometres per day for settlement and transportation infrastructure Each of the approximately 14 700 local municipalities is empowered to allocate lands for industrial and commercial use Local control over reuse decisions of German brownfield sites Industriebrache is a critical factor Industrial sites tend to be remote due to zoning laws and incur costly overhead for providing infrastructure such as utilities disposal services and transportation citation needed In 1989 a brownfield of the Ruhrgebiet became Emscher Park 32 United Kingdom edit In the UK centuries of industrial use of lands which once formed the birthplace of the industrial revolution have left entire regions in a brownfield status There are legal and fiscal incentives for brownfield redevelopment Remediation laws are centered on the premise that the remediation should leave land safe and suitable for its current or intended use In 2018 the Campaign to Protect Rural England CPRE reported that the 17 656 sites covering over 28 000 hectares of land identified by English local planning authorities on their Brownfield Land Registers would provide enough land for a minimum of 1 million homes which could rise to over 1 1 million once all registers are published The registers contain land that is available for redevelopment so is a small subset of all land that would be considered brownfield There is also brownfield capacity in areas in which the green belt is in danger for example in Northwest England where local authorities have identified enough brownfield land to provide for 12 years of housing demand 33 The UK government has recognised the ecological importance of brownfield sites and has afforded some protection to such habitats through the United Kingdom Biodiversity Action Plan 34 The Creekside Discovery Centre in Deptford London is an urban wildlife centre encompassing brownfield habitats 35 United States edit United States estimates suggest there are over 500 000 brownfield sites contaminated at levels below the Superfund caliber the most contaminated in the country citation needed While historic land use patterns created contaminated sites the Superfund law has been criticized as creating the brownfield phenomenon where investment moves to greenfields for new development due to severe no fault liability schemes and other disincentives citation needed The Clinton Gore administration and US EPA launched a series of brownfield policies and programs in 1993 to tackle this problem citation needed Redevelopment editValuation and financing edit Acquisition adaptive re use and disposal of a brownfield site requires advanced and specialized appraisal analysis techniques For example the highest and best use of the brownfield site may be affected by the contamination both before and after remediation Additionally the value should take into account residual stigma and potential for third party liability Normal appraisal techniques frequently fail and appraisers must rely on more advanced techniques such as contingent valuation case studies or statistical analyses 36 failed verification A 2011 University of Delaware study has suggested a 17 5 1 return on dollars invested on brownfield redevelopment 37 A 2014 study of EPA brownfield cleanup grants from 2002 through 2008 found an average benefit value of almost 4 million per brownfield site with a median of 2 117 982 38 To expedite the cleanup of brownfield sites in the US some environmental firms have teamed up with insurance companies to underwrite the cleanup and provide a guaranteed cleanup cost to limit land developers exposure to environmental remediation costs and pollution lawsuits The environmental firm first performs an extensive investigation generally in the form of desk studies and potentially further intrusive investigation 39 Remediation strategies edit This section needs additional citations for verification Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources in this section Unsourced material may be challenged and removed May 2011 Learn how and when to remove this template message nbsp In Situ bioremediation a method used to remove pollution from the soil located on brownfield land This method is done on site instead of taking it elsewhere for processing Innovative remediation techniques used at distressed brownfields in recent years include in situ thermal remediation bioremediation and in situ oxidation Often these strategies are used in conjunction with each other or with other remedial strategies such as soil vapor extraction In this process vapor from the soil phase is extracted from soils and treated which has the effect of removing contaminants from the soils and groundwater beneath a site Binders can be added to contaminated soil to prevent chemical leaching 40 Some brownfields with heavy metal contamination have even been cleaned up through an innovative approach called phytoremediation which uses deep rooted plants to soak up metals in soils into the plant structure as the plant grows After they reach maturity the plants which now contain the heavy metal contaminants in their tissues are removed and disposed of as hazardous waste citation needed nbsp Phytoremediation a method that can be used to remove pollutants from brownfield land It uses plants to take up pollutants from the soil Research is under way to see if some brownfields can be used to grow crops specifically for the production of biofuels 41 Michigan State University in collaboration with DaimlerChrysler and NextEnergy has small plots of soybean corn canola and switchgrass growing in a former industrial dump site in Oakland County Michigan The intent is to see if the plants can serve two purposes simultaneously assist with phytoremediation and contribute to the economical production of biodiesel and or ethanol fuel citation needed The regeneration of brownfields in the United Kingdom and in other European countries has gained prominence due to greenfield land restrictions as well as their potential to promote the urban renaissance 13 Development of brownfield sites also presents an opportunity to reduce the environmental impact on communities and considerable assessments need to take place in order to evaluate the size of this opportunity 42 Barriers edit This section needs additional citations for verification Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources in this section Unsourced material may be challenged and removed May 2011 Learn how and when to remove this template message Many contaminated brownfield sites sit unused for decades because the cost of cleaning them to safe standards is more than the land would be worth after redevelopment in the process becoming involuntary parks as they grow over However redevelopment has become more common in the first decade of the 21st century as developable land has become less available in highly populated areas and brownfields contribute to environmental stigma which can delay redevelopment 43 Also the methods of studying contaminated land have become more sophisticated and costly citation needed Some states and localities have spent considerable money assessing the contamination on local brownfield sites to quantify the cleanup costs in an effort to move the redevelopment process forward Therefore federal and state programs have been developed to help developers interested in cleaning up brownfield sites and restoring them to practical uses citation needed In the process of cleaning contaminated brownfield sites previously unknown underground storage tanks buried drums or buried railroad tank cars containing wastes are sometimes encountered Unexpected circumstances increase the cost for study and clean up As a result the cleanup work may be delayed or stopped entirely To avoid unexpected contamination and increased costs many developers insist that a site be thoroughly investigated via a Phase II Site Investigation or Remedial Investigation prior to commencing remedial cleanup activities citation needed Post redevelopment uses edit nbsp Brownfield relic serves as monument in a new park in Atlantic Station area of Atlanta Georgia U S nbsp Residential development at former brownfield site in New Jersey nbsp Pedestrians walking along hillside path in Seonyudo Park Seoul South Korea which was developed from a former brownfield siteCommercial and residential edit As of 2006 update the Atlantic Station project in Atlanta was the largest brownfield redevelopment in the United States 44 Dayton like many other cities in the region is developing Tech Town in order to attract technology based firms to Dayton and revitalize the downtown area citation needed In Homestead Pennsylvania the site once occupied by Carnegie Steel has been converted into a successful commercial center The Waterfront citation needed Pittsburgh Pennsylvania has successfully converted when numerous former steel mill sites into high end residential shopping and offices Examples of brownfield redevelopment in Pittsburgh include In Pittsburgh s Squirrel Hill neighborhood a former slag dump for steel mills was turned into a 243 million residential development called Summerset at Frick Park In Pittsburgh s South Side neighborhood a former LTV Steel mill site was transformed into Southside Works a mixed use development that includes high end entertainment retail offices and housing In the Hazelwood Pittsburgh neighborhood a former Jones and Laughlin steel mill site was transformed into a 104 million office park called Pittsburgh Technology Center In Herr s Island a 17 hectare 42 acre island on the western bank of the Allegheny River a former rail stop for livestock and meatpacking was transformed into Washington s Landing a waterfront center for commerce manufacturing recreation and upscale housingSolar landfill edit nbsp Solar arrays on a full landfill in Rehoboth MAA Solar landfill is a repurposed used landfill that is converted to a solar array solar farm 45 Regulation editFurther information Brownfield regulation and development United States edit In the United States Brownfield regulation and development is largely governed by state environmental agencies in cooperation with the Environmental Protection Agency EPA In 1995 the EPA launched the Brownfields Program which was expanded in 2002 with the Brownfields Law 38 The EPA together with local and national government can provide technical help and some funding for assessment and cleanup 38 From 2002 through 2013 the EPA awarded nearly 1 000 grants for clean up for a total of almost 190 million It can also provide tax incentives for cleanup that is not paid for outright specifically cleanup costs are fully tax deductible in the year they are incurred 46 Many of the most important provisions on liability relief are contained in state codes that can differ significantly from state to state 47 United Kingdom edit In the United Kingdom regulation of contaminated land comes from Part IIA of the Environmental Protection Act 1990 responsibility falls on local authorities to create a contaminated land register For sites with dubious past and present uses the Local Planning Authority may ask for a desktop study 48 which is sometimes implemented as a condition in planning applications 49 However by definition land that is derelict or underused is highly unlikely to be determined as contaminated land especially due to risks to human health The key regulation of brownfield land is through the land use planning system when a new land use is being considered See also editGreenfield project Brockton Brightfield brownfield turned into a solar power plant Greyfield land HUD USER Industrial nature Love Canal Redevelopment of Mumbai mills unused mills being re developed Regulatory Barriers Clearinghouse Small Business Liability Relief and Brownfields Revitalization Act Waste law Urban renewal Vapor IntrusionReferences edit a b Glossary of Brownfields Terms Brownfields Center Washington D C Environmental Law Institute Archived from the original on February 26 2015 a b c Jacek Guillaume Rozan Anne Desrousseaux Maylis Combroux Isabelle May 18 2021 Brownfields over the years from definition to sustainable reuse Environmental Reviews 30 50 60 doi 10 1139 er 2021 0017 S2CID 236348006 a b Loures Luis Vaz Eric February 1 2018 Exploring expert perception towards brownfield redevelopment benefits according to their typology Habitat International Regional Intelligence A new kind of GIScience 72 66 76 doi 10 1016 j habitatint 2016 11 003 ISSN 0197 3975 Tang Yu Ting Nathanail C Paul May 3 2012 Sticks and Stones The Impact of the Definitions of Brownfield in Policies on Socio Economic Sustainability Sustainability 4 5 840 862 doi 10 3390 su4050840 ISSN 2071 1050 Alker Sandra Joy Victoria Roberts Peter Smith Nathan January 1 2000 The Definition of Brownfield Journal of Environmental Planning and Management 43 1 49 69 doi 10 1080 09640560010766 ISSN 0964 0568 S2CID 153395212 Trouw Michael Weiler Stephan Silverstein Jesse March 6 2020 Brownfield Development Uncertainty Asymmetric Information and Risk Premia Sustainability 12 5 2046 doi 10 3390 su12052046 ISSN 2071 1050 Trouw Michael Weiler Stephan Silverstein Jesse January 2020 Brownfield Development Uncertainty Asymmetric Information and Risk Premia Sustainability 12 5 2046 doi 10 3390 su12052046 ISSN 2071 1050 Green T L April 1 2018 Evaluating predictors for brownfield redevelopment Land Use Policy 73 299 319 doi 10 1016 j landusepol 2018 01 008 ISSN 0264 8377 a b Chen I Chun Chuo Yu Yu Ma Hwong wen April 1 2019 Uncertainty analysis of remediation cost and damaged land value for brownfield investment Chemosphere 220 371 380 Bibcode 2019Chmsp 220 371C doi 10 1016 j chemosphere 2018 12 116 ISSN 0045 6535 PMID 30590303 S2CID 58557619 About contaminated sites Federal Contaminated Sites Portal Environment and Climate Change Canada November 10 2018 Archived from the original on November 10 2018 Overview of EPA s Brownfields Program Washington D C United States Environmental Protection Agency EPA July 26 2021 Brownfields Program Achievements Linked to Early Success PDF EPA October 2006 Fact sheet EPA 560 F 06 267 a b Maliene V Wignall L Malys N 2012 Brownfield Regeneration Waterfront Site Developments in Liverpool and Cologne Journal of Environmental Engineering and Landscape Management 20 1 5 16 doi 10 3846 16486897 2012 659030 Thomas Voltaggio and John Adams Superfund A Half Century of Progress EPA Alumni Association March 2016 Revitalizing Mothballed Properties Challenges Success Stories and Solutions EPA 2008 EPA 560 R 08 003 US EPA OLEM July 24 2014 Summary of the Small Business Liability Relief and Brownfields Revitalization Act www epa gov Retrieved June 1 2022 Brownfield land registers GOV UK Retrieved February 20 2023 a b c National Planning Policy Framework PDF GOV UK Retrieved February 9 2023 a b National Planning Policy Framework Annex 2 Glossary Guidance GOV UK www gov uk Retrieved February 20 2023 a b Contaminated land Overview UK Crown Copyright November 10 2016 Inventory of Sites How many federal contaminated sites are there in Canada Federal Contaminated Sites Portal Environment Canada October 3 2016 Archived from the original on April 19 2017 Retrieved February 16 2017 Environment and Climate Change Canada December 7 2022 Action plan for contaminated sites www canada ca Retrieved March 24 2023 a b c d Rod Story Tolga Yalkin April 10 2014 Federal Contaminated Sites Cost PDF Parliamentary Budget Officer PBO Ottawa Ontario p 41 Retrieved September 5 2015 a b Contracts Awarded for Port Hope Area Initiative Natural Resources Canada Ottawa Ontario July 30 2015 Retrieved September 5 2015 Port Hope Area Initiative Archived from the original on August 20 2009 Retrieved January 13 2009 Carola Vyhnak November 9 2010 Port Hope properties tested for radiation Toronto Star Retrieved January 14 2013 9 Combien y a t il de sites pollues Ministere de l Ecologie du Developpement Durable et de l Energie MEDDE n d Les friches urbaines dans les SCoT et les PLU ADEME August 28 2014 Brownfield site use and reclamation most popular land supply options South China Morning Post September 2 2018 Retrieved May 24 2021 Government exaggerated constraints in freeing up brownfield sites South China Morning Post December 20 2018 Retrieved May 24 2021 Hong Kong NGOs find enough unidentified brownfield sites to build 95 000 homes South China Morning Post June 10 2021 Retrieved June 23 2021 Emscher Park From dereliction to scenic landscapes Kopenhagen Danish Architecture Centre n d What are the barriers to brownfield development https cdn buglife org uk 2019 08 Planning for Brownfield Biodiversity pdf https www creeksidecentre org uk about John A Kilpatrick Resume PDF Greenfield Advisors Archived from the original PDF on July 11 2011 Retrieved November 29 2009 Article Author of Valuation of Brownfields Chapter 29 in Lexis Nexis Matthew Bender s Brownfield Law and Practice 2007 Montgomery Jeff May 14 2011 Cleaning up contamination The News Journal New Castle Delaware Gannett DelawareOnline Archived from the original on May 14 2011 Retrieved May 14 2011 The first online page is archived the page containing information related here is not in the archived version a b c Kriston Capps July 29 2014 How Much Cleaning Up Brownfields Is Really Worth The Atlantic Monthly Environmental Oakshire Commercial development on contaminated land Oakshire Environmental Archived from the original on March 17 2021 Retrieved May 24 2021 ASLA 2011 Professional Awards The Steel Yard www asla org Retrieved June 22 2019 University Michigan State Brownfields may turn green with help from Michigan State research MSUToday Retrieved June 22 2019 Brownfield Sites www sustainablebuild co uk September 11 2006 Retrieved June 22 2019 Coming Back from Economic Despair Henry Mayer and Micheal Greenburg Economic Development Quarterly August 2001 Building a City Within the City of Atlanta The New York Times May 24 2006 Retrieved June 16 2014 https time com 6183376 landfills becoming solar farms Brownfields Tax Incentive URL Environmental Protection Agency Retrieved November 29 2009 Brownfields Overview Page National Conference of State Legislatures Retrieved November 29 2009 Environmental Oakshire What is a Phase 1 Preliminary Risk Assessment Oakshire Environmental Retrieved November 25 2019 Desktop Study Reports London Bristol amp Exeter Southwest Environmental Limited n d Retrieved June 16 2014 Further reading editSustainable Brownfield Regeneration PDF Concerted Action on Brownfield and Economic Regeneration Network Report University of Nottingham 2006 p 3 ISBN 0 9547474 5 3 Archived from the original PDF on April 2 2015 External links edit nbsp Wikimedia Commons has media related to Brownfields United States EPA Brownfields Homepage Parents Demand Curbs on Schools Built on Contaminated Land Photographies of French Brownfields Photographies of German Brownfields National Brownfields Conference cosponsored by the U S EPA and ICMA From Industrial Wasteland to Community Park From Brownfield to Greenfield A New Working Landscape for Wellesley College Wrenched from its Toxic Past The Brownfields Center at Carnegie Mellon University Browninfo Methodology and Software for Development of Interactive Brownfield Databases Brownfield Land at Curlie Retrieved from https en wikipedia org w index php title Brownfield land amp oldid 1193515430, wikipedia, wiki, book, books, library,

article

, read, download, free, free download, mp3, video, mp4, 3gp, jpg, jpeg, gif, png, picture, music, song, movie, book, game, games.